Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Article 46 (b) of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp Act
  • Article 19 of the Schedule I-A of the Madras Stamp Act.
  • Section 2(10) read with Article 20 of Schedule I-A
  • Article 46 (b) of Schedule I-A of the Stamp Act
  • Stamp Act Section 46 (1895) 18 Mad 233 (FB).
  • Article 46 (b) of the Andhra Pradesh Act
  • Article 44 of the Madras Stamp Act.11.
  • Article 44 (b) of the Stamp Act
  • SECTION 57 STAMP ACT
  • Stamp Act, Section 46 (1895) 18
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Article 46 (b) of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp Act
  • Article 19 of the Schedule I-A of the Madras Stamp Act.
  • Section 2(10) read with Article 20 of Schedule I-A
  • Article 46 (b) of Schedule I-A of the Stamp Act
  • Stamp Act Section 46 (1895) 18 Mad 233 (FB).
  • Article 46 (b) of the Andhra Pradesh Act
  • Article 44 of the Madras Stamp Act.11.
  • Article 44 (b) of the Stamp Act
  • SECTION 57 STAMP ACT
  • Stamp Act, Section 46 (1895) 18
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Krishna Rao, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises from a dispute over the proper classification (and hence the stamp duty payable) of a document executed on 5 December 1967 by Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry in favour of Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah concerning jointly purchased house property. Ramakrishnaiah and Seetharama Sastry had jointly purchased the property by a registered sale deed on 30 November 1965. The 1967 document was presented for registration on 16 December 1967 and stamped by the executant on the footing that it was a release deed with stamp duty Rs. 22.50 paid under Article 46(b) of Schedule I-A of the Indian Stamp Act as applicable in Andhra Pradesh.

The Sub-Registrar doubted the sufficiency of the stamp and referred the matter to the District Registrar, Machilipatnam. On 2 April 1948 the District Registrar held the document to be a conveyance on sale (Article 20 of Schedule I-A) and directed a demand for stamp duty of Rs. 2,946.75 plus a penalty of Rs. 25. A revision petition to the Board of Revenue was rejected on 23 August 1968. Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah filed Writ Petition No. 4168 of 1968 before the High Court challenging the Board's order. The High Court directed the Board of Revenue (the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority under the Act) to refer the question to the Supreme Court under Section 57 of the Stamp Act. The Board submitted the reference to this Court under Section 57.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the document No. P. 50/67 executed by Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry in favour of Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah is a release deed and whether the stamp duty of Rs. 22.50 under Article 46(b) of Schedule I-A is sufficient?
  2. Whether the document is a deed of "conveyance or sale" within Section 2(10) read with Article 20 of Schedule I-A and whether the levy of stamp duty of Rs. 2,921.25 and a penalty of Rs. 25/- is correct?

Arguments of the Parties

Government Pleader / Revenue Position

  • The Government Pleader stressed a particular passage of the document that uses words such as "transfer", "consideration" and "I hereby transfer to you my joint interest... hence you shall from now onwards enjoy the schedule property with absolute rights." The implication advanced was that such language supported treating the instrument as a conveyance liable to the higher stamp duty under Article 20.
  • Earlier administrative action (Sub-Registrar and District Registrar) treated the document as a conveyance and levied the higher stamp duty and penalty on that basis.

The opinion does not contain a detailed, point-by-point account of the arguments advanced by the executant (Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry) or by Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah in the reference; the text records the instrument's character as presented (styled a release and stamped as such) and the administrative positions described above.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Board of Revenue v. Murugesa, AIR 1955 Mad 641 (Full Bench) Held that an instrument executed by co-owners styled as a release was not a conveyance; Article 44(b) (Madras) applied to such instruments — emphasis on absence of partition or new interest creation. The Court relied on the Full Bench's reasoning to support that a document executed by co-owners relinquishing one co-owner's share for a stated sum is a release and not a conveyance.
Reference under Stamp Act Section 46 (1895) 18 Mad 233 (Full Bench) Established principle in relation to Hindu joint family and relinquishment: a relinquishment by a co-parcener in consideration of a benefit constitutes a release (stamped as such). The Full Bench principle was cited to show that a renunciation/relinquishment by a co-owner in consideration of benefit is correctly characterised as a release, and this principle was applied analogously to co-owners.
Chief Controlling Revenue Authority v. Patel, AIR 1968 Mad 159 (Full Bench) Considered essential ingredients of a release and held an instrument to be a release rather than a conveyance; quoted and applied Murugesa. The Court referred to this decision as further support that instruments transferring one co-owner's interest by way of release (even with stated consideration) are releases and not conveyances.
Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Arumuga Chettiar, AIR 1967 SC 1395 (Supreme Court) Observed that a release deed "could only feed title, but could not transfer title" and that renouncement must be in favour of a person who already had title — the effect is enlargement of an existing right. The Court relied on this Supreme Court observation to emphasize that a release enlarges the rights of an existing co-owner and does not create a new proprietary title transferrable as a conveyance for stamp purposes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from a close construction of the document itself and the legal distinction between a release by a co-owner and a conveyance creating or transferring a new title.

  1. Characterisation depends on substance, not merely the label: the document is styled a "Deed of release" but that designation alone is not conclusive (paragraph 6 and 8).
  2. Factual matrix marshalled from the instrument: the property was acquired jointly; the parties were co-owners; one occupier was upstairs and the other downstairs; a vendor's lien and unpaid purchase money existed; one co-owner (Seetharama Sastry) had contributed only a small share and was leaving to adopt a religious life (paragraphs 6 and 16).
  3. On construction of the instrument, the Court finds the payment of Rs. 9,475 was essentially reimbursement/settlement for amounts the executant had contributed and an agreed sum to effect his withdrawal from co-ownership (paragraphs 7 and 16–17).
  4. The Court emphasises that the instrument does not show any attempt to determine the then existing market value of the share and then create a conveyance. There was no evidence of partition, creation of a new right in favour of the transferee, or division of the property by metes and bounds; the effect was one co-owner's renunciation of his co-ownership with a resultant enlargement of the other co-owner's share (paragraphs 7 and 18).
  5. Words such as "transfer" and "consideration" in the text are not decisive. The Court explains that a release may validly recite a consideration or benefit to the executant without being thereby converted into a conveyance. The Court rejects the submission that a release is only valid if gratuitous (paragraph 8).
  6. The Court supports its construction by relying on prior decisions (Madras Full Bench decisions and a Supreme Court decision) which established that a relinquishment/release by a co-owner or co-parcener in consideration of payment is a release, not a conveyance, and that a release merely enlarges an existing title (paragraphs 9–12).
  7. On the combined factual and legal analysis, the Court concludes the instrument is a release deed: it effectuates Seetharama Sastry's withdrawal from co-ownership and enlarges Ramakrishnaiah's pre-existing rights, rather than constituting a conveyance creating or transferring a new title for Article 20 purposes (paragraphs 13 and 17–18).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court holds that the document No. P. 50/67 is a release deed and that the stamp duty of Rs. 22.50 paid under Article 46(b) of Schedule I-A is sufficient; accordingly the document is not a deed of conveyance or sale within the meaning of Section 2(10) read with Article 20 of Schedule I-A, and the levy of stamp duty of Rs. 2,921.25 and penalty of Rs. 25/- is incorrect and unsustainable. (See paragraphs 13, 24–26.)

Implications:

  • The direct consequence is that the classification of the instrument as a release is upheld and the higher assessment of stamp duty and the penalty imposed by the District Registrar (and sustained administratively) are invalidated.
  • The Registry's impounding and demand under Article 20 and the penalty are held to be incorrect; the reference is answered in favour of the party who had stamped the document as a release.
  • The opinion applies established principles from prior Full Bench and Supreme Court decisions; it does not purport to create a new legal principle but applies existing authorities to the facts. The Court framed its decision as an application of precedent to the facts rather than as laying down novel law.

Answer to the reference: The reference is answered accordingly (paragraphs 15–16, 27–28).

    Board Of Revenue v. Valivety Rama Krishnaiah

    Krishna Rao, J.:— The above case is posted before us for a decision on a reference made by the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority (Board of Revenue in this case) under Section 57 of the Stamp Act.

    2. The facts giving rise to the reference may be stated. One Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah and another Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry, both residents of Vijayawada, purchased certain house property jointly under a registered sale deed on 30-11-1965. Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry purported to execute a deed of release on 5-12-1967 in favour of Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah. The consideration recited was Rs. 9475/-. The document was presented for registration before the Sub-registrar, Vijayawada, on 16-12-1967. A Stamp Duty of Rs. 22.50 was paid on the document on the footing that it was a release deed under the provisions of Article 46 (b) of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp Act (II of 1899) as applicable in Andhra Pradesh. The Sub-Registrar thought that the stamp duty paid was not sufficient, as the document in question was a conveyance and not a release. The matter was referred to the District Registrar at Machilipatnam. After notice to the parties and hearing their objections, the District Registrar passed an order on 2-4-1948 holding that the document was a conveyance on sale and came under Article 20 of Schedule I.A of the Act and directed the respondent to pay a sum of Rs. 2,946.75. A penalty of Rs. 25/- also was levied. There was a revision petition preferred to the Board of Revenue challenging the correctness of that order. The Board of Revenue had rejected the petition on 23-8-1968. Thereupon Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah had filed Writ Petition No. 4168 of 1968 before the High Court challenging the order of the Board of Revenue, which was the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority under the Act. In the said Writ Petition, the High Court directed the respondent (Board of Revenue) to refer the matter under Section 57 of the Stamp Act. The reference was accordingly submitted by the Board of Revenue to this Court under Section 57 of the Stamp Act.

    3. Two questions were referred for opinion by this court and they are:

    “(1) Whether the document No. P. 50/67 of the Sub-Registrar's Office, Vijayawada, executed by Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry in favour of Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah is a release deed and the stamp duty of Rs. 22.50 under Article 46 (b) of Schedule I-A is sufficient?

    (2) Whether the document in question is a deed of “conveyance or sale” within Section 2(10) read with Article 20 of Schedule I-A and the levy of stamp duty of Rs. 2921.25 and penalty of Rs. 25/- is correct?”

    4. In order to decide the points referred to us for decision, it is necessary to reproduce the document in question, which is as follows:—

    “1. Deed of release of joint right in the property described in the schedule below for the consideration of Rs. 9,475/-.

    2. Executed on fifth December, 1967 equivalent to 14th Margasira of 1989 of Salivahana Saka.

    3. In favour of Valiveti Sadasiva Parabrahmam's son Rama Krishnaiah, resident of Vijayawada, Vijayawada Sub-Registry, Kriskna district, by.

    4. Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry, son of Pasumarthi Parvatheesam, Hindu, Brahmin, resident of Vijayawada Sub-Registry, Krishna Dt.

    5. Nature of Deed:— You and I purchased jointly and as our self-acquired property the immoveable property described in Schedule below under a registered sale deed on 30-11-1965. I have been residing on the upstairs portion of the said property. You have been realising all the rents for the downstairs portion and paying all the taxes as Rs. 43,000/- out of the sale consideration for the said property remained unpaid purchase money by the date of the sale deed. Yourself and myself jointly executed a promissory note therefor in favour of the vendors. You paid Rs. 7,800/- from time to time towards the said promissory note debt. The rest of the debt has to be paid together with interest according to law there is a statutory charge for the said promissory note debt on the property mentioned in the schedule below. I intended to adopt Yati-Ashram and therefore to give up my practice as Pleader and I am leaving this town. My sons are employed in Hyderabad and Warangal. Hence I have no necessity to discharge the statutory charge debt and retain some portion of the schedule property you have joint right. Adjacent to it on the eastern side there is your own property also. You represented that you require the entire schedule property for your own residence and for your own business. Further, even though you and I purchased the schedule property jointly, I invested only a small amount for the purchase and the subsequent repairs. On looking into the account in regard to the amount invested by me, interest, rent etc., it is ascertained that you have to pay me Rs. 9,475/-. I felt that it is in your interest to receive the said amount and execute a release deed in respect of my joint right in the schedule property vested in me under the sale deed without demanding any profits. Hence I agree to transfer to you my joint interest in the schedule property receiving Rs. 9,475/- as consideration as fixed by you and me subject to the condition that you yourself shall discharge the entire unpaid purchase money which is a charge on the schedule property without my concern and I received in all Rs. 8,500/- from you from time to time the balance of Rs. 975/- is agreed to be paid before the Sub-Registrar, Vijayawada, at the time of registration of this deed and thus I received the entire consideration of Rs. 9475/-., I hereby transfer to you my joint interest in the Schedule Property which vested in me under the sale deed and I delivered the possession of the same. Hence you shall from now onwards enjoy the schedule property with absolute rights. I or my heirs or representatives shall not raise any disputes in enjoyment thereof by yourself, your heirs or representatives. I have no ancestral property. All my properties are self-acquired. Hence my sons need not join in this deed. I transferred my joint interest hereby assuring you that I did not alienate the schedule; property to anybody in any way. I vacated the upstairs portion and I delivered possession of the same to you. You and I have no disputes as regards rent for the said upstairs. The downstair portions are in the possession of subtenants and we both filed jointly H.R.C Nos. 524, 525, 526, 527 and 528 of 1966 in the Rent Controller's Court, Vijayawada, for evicting them. The said petitions are pending. As the said petitions were filed by us having joint interest, you shall contest the said petitions having obtained my joint interest, realising damages (for use and occupation) evict the tenants and enjoy the result thereof. Transfer forms for mutations of the schedule property in your name in the Municipal and Government accounts are filed herewith. An application for transfer of the electric service No. 5707 for the schedule property in your name is given to you herewith. The details of property are given below.

    6. Schedule of property released:—

    xx xx xx

    This is the release deed in respect of joint right in immovable property executed by me with my consent.

    Sd/- P. Seetharama Sastri.”

    5. Our answer to the questions referred depend upon a construction of the above document. If it is a release deed, the stamp duty already paid is sufficient. If, on the other hand, the document is a conveyance or sale, then the impounding of the document and the levy of stamp duty of Rupees 2,921.25 and the penalty of Rs. 25/- would be correct. If a document is a releasedeed, it is covered by Article 46 (b) of Schedule I-A of the Act. If the document is a conveyance or sale within the meaning of Section 2(10) of the Act, then the stamp duty is leviable under Article 20 of Schedule I-A of the Act.

    6. From a reading of the document above extracted the following facts emerge; The document is styled as a release deed, though by itself it cannot be said to be conclusive of the character or nature of the document. Ramakrishnaiah and Seetharama Sastry jointly purchased the immovable property referred to in the document. It would appear that Ramakrishnaiah contributed a major portion of the consideration for the sale. There was the unpaid purchase money of Rs. 43,000/- still outstanding and there was a vendor's lien on the property purchased by them. After purchase and having been put in possession, they owned and enjoyed the property jointly as co-owners, though for purposes of convenience in the matter of enjoyment one was occupying the upstairs portion and the other the downstair portion of the house property. Seetharama Sastry, with a view to take Sanyasa Asramam desired to give up the joint interest in the property as a co-owner in favour of the other co-owner. He had contributed only a small amount for the joint purchase. On looking into the accounts, it was found that Rama krishnayya had to pay a sum of Rs. 9,475/- and it was agreed that the said sum of Rs. 9,475/- should be paid by Ramakrishnaiah to Seetharama Sastry for the purpose of releasing the joint interest which Seetharama Sastri had in the property.

    7. From the document, it is clear that there was no attempt by the parties to determine the then existing value of the share of Seetharama Sastry on the date of execution of the document and then make a conveyance of the property for a proper consideration. It was merely a case of a release by Seetharama Sastry of his rights in the property after taking back the amounts which he had originally contributed for the purchase. The document does not disclose any intention of the parties either to sell or purchase the same. The property was owned jointly until the date of the execution of the document and it cannot be said that a new interest or right was created in favour of Ramakrishnaiah for the first time. It is really a case of withdrawal of the executant Seetharama Sastry which operated as his effacement from co-ownership and thus resulting in an enlargement of the interest of the other co-owner Ramakrishnaiah.

    8. The word ‘release’ is not defined in the Stamp Act. There is already a legal right in the property in Ramakrishnaiah who is a co-owner. The incidents of co-ownership are well established. Each co-owner in theory is entitled to enjoy the joint property either in part or in its entirety and when one co-owner releases his interest or walks out, it cannot be said that there is any conveyance of his interest to the other co-owner. No doubt in the document, the language is employed which if not properly understood in the context of the document and the character of the ownership of the property, may lead to an argument that the transaction evidenced by the document was a conveyance. In fact stress was laid by the Government Pleader on the sentence in the document. “Hence I agree to transfer to you my joint right in the Schedule Property receiving Rs. 9,475/- I received the entire consideration of Rs. 9,475/-. I hereby transfer to you my joint interest………… Hence you shall from now onwards enjoy the schedule property with absolute rights.” The word ‘transfer’ employed in the document cannot be understood to mean a conveyance or sale. There is no warrant for the view that it is only in a case where the release deed is gratuitous it operates as a valid release deed. A document of release may be validly executed even if it recites some benefit to the executant simultaneously with the act of release. In our view, the fact that the document contained words like ‘consideration’ and ‘transfer’ do not affect the substantial or true character of the transaction. The designation given to the document is that it is a release leed, though by itself is not decisive of the character of the transaction. The contents of the document, the intendment of the parties as can be seen from the document and the joint nature of acquisition by both the parties and the mode of enjoyment are all decisive of the fact that the document in question evidences a transaction by way of a release of the interest of the executant in favour of the releasee, the parties to the transaction being co-owners.

    9. That the above is the correct position is borne out by the decision of the Madras High Court referred to before us: in Board of Revenue v. Murugesa, AIR 1955 Mad 641 (FB), a similar question was referred to by the Board of Revenue under Section 57 of the Stamp Act. The document in that case was styled as a release deed. It was dated 23-5-1949. The question before the Full Bench was whether Article 44 (b) of the Stamp Act in Madras which is the same as Article 46 (b) of the Andhra Pradesh Act was applicable to the instrument in question. There were five partners of a registered firm known as “Gudiyatham Lungi Company”. Three of the partners executed the deed in question in favour of the other two partners. The executants had ceased to be partners of the firm from and after 12-4-1949. The preamble recited that the executants were co-owners of the immovable property described in the schedule to the document and that the executants who had retired from the firm renounced all interest in the said property by and under the deed receiving the proportionate value of their shares in the property in cash. The deed recited that it was being executed in consideration of a sum of Rs. 9858-9-7 and the: executants had released all their respective rights, claims, interest etc in respect of the property described in the schedule.

    10. The question that fell for determination before the Full Bench was whether the instrument in question fell within the definition of a conveyance under Article 19 of the Schedule I-A of the Madras Stamp Act. Their Lordships were of opinion that it was not a conveyance. It was observed that the property in question was owned by the parties to the instrument as co-owners, the executants being entitled to a 3/5th share and the other two being entitled to the other 2/5th share. They laid stress on the fact that there was no division of the property by metes and bounds at any time anterior in accordance with their respective shares. In such circumstances, the document in question was a release within the meaning of Article 44 of the Madras Stamp Act.

    11. Reference was made by the Full Bench to a decision in ‘Reference under Stamp Act Section 46’ (1895) 18 Mad 233 (FB). The said Full Bench in a reference under Section 46 of the then Stamp Act had to consider the question of a document executed by a Hindu son in favour of his father representing the other members of the family relinquishing his rights in the property of the family in consideration of certain lands being allotted to him for life and also certain debts incurred by him being paid. The learned Judges observed that it was a deed by which one co-owner renounced his claim for partition against the family property in consideration of a certain income to be enjoyed by him for his life out of certain lands over which he had no power of alienation. It was held that the instrument in question was a release and should be stamped as such. The principle enunciated therein was in relation to a Hindu joint family and a relinquishment by one coparcener in favour of the others in consideration of some benefit conferred on the relinquishing coparcener. Such an instrument was held to be a release deed. The principle decided in “Reference under Stamp Act, Section 46” (1895) 18 Mad 233 (FB), was applied by the later Full Bench to the case of Co-owners and a release by one or more of them in favour of the others for a stated consideration. The Full Bench held that the document in question was a release deed and that it was neither a deed of dissolution of partnership nor a conveyance.

    12. In another Full Bench decision of the Madras High Court in Chief Controlling Revenue Authority v. Patel, AIR 1968 Mad 159, a somewhat similar question had arisen. That again was a reference under Section 57 of the Stamp Act and the question was whether the instrument in the case before the Full Bench was a release of conveyance amounting to a transfer of property for value. The Full Bench considered the essential ingredients of a release. They quoted with approval the observations from the Full Bench decision in AIR 1955 Mad 641 (FB) and held that the instrument before them was a release. In support of their conclusion, they referred to a decision of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Arumuga Chettiar, AIR 1967 SC 1395. The Supreme Court was concerned with a document of release. It was observed by the Supreme Court that a release deed could only feed title, but could not transfer title and that renouncement must be in favour of a person who had already title to an estate, the effect of which was only to enlarge the right.

    13. Now adverting to the document in the present case before us we have no manner of doubt that it is a release deed. We, therefore, unhesitatingly hold that the document has been correctly stamped as a release deed.

    14. Our answers therefore to the questions referred to us are as follows:—

    (1) That the document No. P. 50/67 of the Sub-registrar's Office, Vijayawada, executed by Pasumarthi Seetharama Sastry in favour of Valiveti Ramakrishnaiah is a release deed and the stamp duty of Rs. 22.50 paid under Article 46 (b) of Schedule I-A of the Stamp Act is sufficient; and

    (2) That the document in question is not a deed of conveyance or sale within the meaning of Section 2(10) read with Article 20 of Schedule I-A and that the levy of stamp duty of Rs. 2,921.25 and the penalty of Rs. 25/- is incorrect and unsustainable.

    15. The reference is answered accordingly.

    16. Answer accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Board Of Revenue v. Valivety Rama Krishnaiah
    (Oct 6, 1972)