AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • villages) rules, 1994 (for short 'the rules'). (7) Rules 9 to 12
  • act 2 of 1964 (for short 'the act of 1964) (3)
  • clause (f) of sub - section (2) of section 3
  • a. P. District (formation) act (7 of 1974)
  • act, 1924 (central act 2 of 1924). (2)
  • sub - section (1) of section 3
  • sub - section (5) of section 3
  • sub - section (2) of section 3
  • section 3 (1) or 3 (2)
  • sub - section (1). (6)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • villages) rules, 1994 (for short 'the rules'). (7) Rules 9 to 12
  • act 2 of 1964 (for short 'the act of 1964) (3)
  • clause (f) of sub - section (2) of section 3
  • a. P. District (formation) act (7 of 1974)
  • act, 1924 (central act 2 of 1924). (2)
  • sub - section (1) of section 3
  • sub - section (5) of section 3
  • sub - section (2) of section 3
  • section 3 (1) or 3 (2)
  • sub - section (1). (6)
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — N.Y. Hanumanthappa, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition challenges an order of the District Collector dated 12-05-1995 (ROC No. 1091/95-A6 (PTS)) which bifurcated Venkatapuram Gram Panchayat and formed a separate gram panchayat for Dayyalakuntapalle village. The order also appointed an extension officer (PTS), Singanamala, as the special officer to the newly constituted Dayyalakuntapalle Gram Panchayat, with the special officer exercising the powers and performing the functions of the gram panchayat and its sarpanch until elected members assume office.

The petitioner is a resident of Venkatapuram village and filed the writ petition seeking a writ (in the nature of mandamus) declaring the bifurcation order illegal, irregular, arbitrary and unsustainable, and seeking to set aside the same so that Venkatapuram Gram Panchayat would continue with Dayyalakuntapalle as its hamlet.

The opinion sets out the statutory framework under the Andhra Pradesh Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 (notably section 3(1) and 3(2)) and the Andhra Pradesh Gram Panchayats (Declaration of Villages) Rules, 1994 (in particular Rules 9–12), which provide for issuing notifications to declare, form, alter, or cancel villages and prescribe show-cause/opportunity to affected gram panchayats and revision to the government through the commissioner.

The writ petition was heard by the court and ultimately disposed of by directing procedural steps: the petitioner (or any aggrieved gram panchayat) may approach the District Collector (or the government through the Commissioner, as applicable) within thirty days; the concerned authority is directed to issue notices, receive objections and other material, consider them in accordance with law and relevant provisions and case law, and pass appropriate orders within sixty days.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a villager (an individual resident) can challenge a notification issued under section 3(1) or section 3(2) of the Andhra Pradesh Panchayat Raj Act, 1994.
  2. Whether the specific bifurcation order under challenge is arbitrary, mala fide, or otherwise bad so as to warrant judicial interference (i.e., whether the administrative action can be quashed by the court).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Sri Veera Reddy)

  • The bifurcation and formation of Dayyalakuntapalli Gram Panchayat is illegal and not in conformity with the Act and the Rules because there was no prior notice to the gram panchayat inviting its objections.
  • The distance between the bifurcated villages is less than two kilometers, whereas Rule 6 in G.O. Ms. No. 232 (dated 18-04-1995) requires a distance of more than two kilometers.
  • The bifurcation is arbitrary and not in the interest of the villagers.
  • The bifurcation deprives villagers of their right to effectively rule themselves (i.e., impacts local self-government).
  • Accordingly, the petitioner sought quashing of the collector's order and continuation of the pre-existing gram panchayat arrangement.

Respondent's Arguments (Sri Krishna Koundinya)

  • The writ petition is not maintainable because it was filed approximately four and a half months after the order dated 12-05-1995 (delay/latency argument).
  • Under the scheme of the Act and Rules, the aggrieved party when a gram panchayat is reconstituted is the gram panchayat itself; an individual resident lacks locus standi to challenge the bifurcation.
  • The Collector issued notification after satisfying himself that all statutory requirements were complied with.
  • Constitution, bifurcation or changing headquarters of a gram panchayat are administrative acts done for administrative convenience and are not ordinarily open to challenge unless shown to be arbitrary or illegal.
  • Even if the bifurcation were flawed, the aggrieved has the remedy of revision to the government through the Commissioner.
  • Overall, the respondent submitted the petition has no merit and should be rejected.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
J. R. Raghupathy v. State of A.P., (AIR 1988 SC 1681) The High Court should not interfere with location of administrative headquarters (mandal/headquarters) where the decision is an administrative one made after consideration of proposals, local objections and cabinet/sub‑committee recommendations; administrative guidelines are not statutory rights and cannot be enforced by mandamus unless discretion was exercised arbitrarily or mala fide. The court relied on this principle to emphasize that declaration/location/bifurcation decisions are administrative and ordinarily not subject to interference; interference is limited to cases of arbitrariness or mala fide exercise of discretion.
B. N. Shankarappa v. Uthanur Srinivas, (AIR 1992 SC 836) Approved the approach in J. R. Raghupathy: the government's discretion in fixing administrative headquarters must be respected; courts will not interfere unless the discretion was exercised arbitrarily, whimsically, without application of mind, or for ulterior/mala fide purposes. The court applied this authority to reaffirm that the scope of judicial review of administrative decisions about formation/bifurcation/locations is narrow and interference is warranted only on proof of arbitrary/mala fide exercise of discretion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in these main steps (as expressly set out in the opinion):

  1. Statutory and rule framework: Sections 3(1) and 3(2) of the Andhra Pradesh Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 empower the Commissioner (or Collector acting under delegated authority) to declare or alter villages and to form, alter, increase, diminish, or cancel villages by notification. The rules (Gram Panchayats (Declaration of Villages) Rules, 1994) prescribe procedures including show‑cause notices and opportunities for gram panchayats to represent their views (Rules 9–12).
  2. Nature of the action: The court noted that constitution, declaration or change in headquarters of a gram panchayat are primarily administrative acts undertaken for administrative convenience and effective administration. This character of the action means judicial interference is limited.
  3. Who is aggrieved: From the statutory scheme and the rules, the court observed that the aggrieved entity when such notifications are issued is the gram panchayat (as the formal local authority), not an individual resident. The petitioner in this case was an individual resident and not the gram panchayat of Venkatapuram.
  4. Binding precedents: The court relied on the Supreme Court's decisions in J. R. Raghupathy and B. N. Shankarappa to explain that courts should not ordinarily interfere with discretionary administrative decisions about headquarters/formation unless there is a demonstrated arbitrary or mala fide exercise of discretion or absence of proper application of mind.
  5. Procedural compliance and fairness: Despite the limited scope for judicial review, the court emphasized that the authorities must comply with mandatory provisions of the Act and the Rules (notably sections 3 and 4 and Rules 7–12). If objections or petitions are presented, the authority should properly consider them rather than act under political pressure or without dispassionate consideration. The rules require issuing show‑cause notices and considering objections; there is no absolute requirement of a personal hearing, but objections must be considered.
  6. Practical remedy: Because the petitioner contended that political pressure influenced the notification and because objections had been raised, the court determined that justice required an opportunity for the aggrieved gram panchayat or the petitioner (in this case) to submit explanations/objections to the District Collector or, on adverse order, to the government through the Commissioner. The court directed procedural steps and timeframes for reconsideration and decision.

Holding and Implications

The court's core rulings are:

Holding: The point whether a villager can challenge a notification under section 3(1) or 3(2) was answered negatively in principle: formation, declaration, bifurcation or change of headquarters of a gram panchayat are administrative acts and ordinarily the aggrieved party is the gram panchayat, not an individual; judicial intervention under Article 226 is limited and is permissible only where the administrative discretion has been exercised arbitrarily or mala fide.

At the same time, because objections had been raised and there were allegations of political pressure, the court disposed of the petition with a direction providing a remedial and procedural route:

  • The petitioner may, if he so desires, approach the District Collector (if not already approached) or the government through the Commissioner (if the Collector has already given adverse orders) by way of a revision petition within thirty days from the date of receipt of the court's order.
  • If any gram panchayat (not before the court) wishes to ventilate its grievance it may file objections before the concerned authority within thirty days from receipt of this order.
  • On receipt of such representations or objections the concerned authority (District Collector or the government) shall issue notice to the gram panchayat and the writ petitioner, receive objections and other material, apply its mind in accordance with the provisions of the Act, the Rules (including Rules 7–12), regulations and relevant G.O.s, and the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in the cited cases, and pass appropriate orders within sixty days from receipt of the objections/representations/revision petitions.

Implications: The decision reaffirms the narrow scope of judicial review of administrative decisions concerning formation and alteration of gram panchayats and emphasizes procedural fairness (show-cause and consideration of objections). The direct practical effect is to provide the petitioner (and any affected gram panchayat) an opportunity to seek reconsideration/revision before the administrative authorities within prescribed time limits; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying existing Supreme Court principles.

    D. Venkata Rushi Reddy v. The Divisional Panchayat Officer, Anantapur And Ors.

    N.Y.Hanumanthappa, J.:-

    (1) The point that arises for consideration in this writ petition is, whether a villager can challenge the notification issued under section 3 (1) or 3 (2) of the andhra pradesh panchayat raj act, 1994 (act no. 13 of 1994) ?

    (2) In obedience to article 40 of the constitution of india, wherein it is envisaged that the state shall take steps to organise village panchayats and endow them with such powers and authority as may be necessary to enable them to function as units of self - government in the state of andhra pradesh, several acts relating to self - governance of the villages were enacted. Amongst them the latest is the andhra pradesh panchayat raj act, 1994 (for short 'the act of 1994) , which was promulgated by replacing the earlier act i. E. , the andhra pradesh gram panchayats act, 1964 i. E. , act 2 of 1964 (for short 'the act of 1964)

    (3) In the state of andhra pradesh, the panchayat raj has got a three - tier system. At village level, it is called grampanchayat; at mandal level it is called mandal praja parishad; and at district level it is called zilla praja parishad.

    (4) Here, we are concerned with gram panchayat, which was earlier governed by the act of 1964, replaced by the act or 1994. The object of passing the constitution (seventy - third amendment) act, 1992 by the parliament was with a view to strengthen and revitalise the panchayat raj bodies so that they can serve the needs of the teeming millions that live in the rural areas. The seventy - third amendment gave certain broad guidelines in regard to the constitution, composition and powers and functions of a three - tier panchayat raj set up, apart from providing for reservation of seats for scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, backward classes and women, including powers and functions of the members of the panchayats, audit and accounts etc. , along with other functions. The object of the act is to have gram - panchayat at the village level composed of members elected from the wards carved out on territorial basis and two nominated members, and the sarpanch will be elected by the members of the grampanchayat, including nominated members. There will be a gram sabha consisting of all electors in the village, which will meet twise an year.

    (5) Section 3 of the act of 1994, which deals with declaration of a village for the purpose of the act, reads as follows : -

    3. Declaration of a village for the purpose of this act : - (1) the commissioner may, by notification and in accordance with the rules made by the government in this behalf, declare any revenue village or hamlet thereof or any part of a mandal to be village for the purpose of this act and specify the name of the village. Explanation : - for the purposes of this sub - section the expressions 'mandal' and 'revenue village' shall mean respectively any local area which is recognised as a mandal or village in the revenue accounts of government after excluding therefrom the area, if any, included in (a) a municipal corporation governed by the relevant law relating to municipal corporations for the time being in force in the state; (b) a municipality governed by the law relating to municipalities for the time being in force in the state; (c) a mining settlement governed by the andhra pradesh (telengana area.) mining settlements act, 1956 (act xliv of 1956) ; (d) a cantonment governed by the cantonments act, 1924 (central act 2 of 1924). (2) the commissioner may, by notification and in accordance with such rules as may be prescribed in this behalf (a) form a new village by separation of local area from any village or by uniting two or more villages or parts of villages or by uniting any local area to a part of any village; (b) increase the local area of any village; (c) diminish the local area of any village; (d) alter the boundaries of any village; (e) alter the name of any village; (f) cancel a notification issued under sub - section (1).

    (6) To give effect to section 3 of the act, by g. O. Ms. No. 515, panchayati raj, rural development and relief (mandal - i) , dated 17 - 8 - 1994, the state of andhra pradesh promulgated the rules known as the andhra pradesh grampanchayats (declaration of villages) rules, 1994 (for short 'the rules').

    (7) Rules 9 to 12 of the above rules are extracted hereunder: -

    9. Where it becomes necessary to take action under sub - section (2) of section 3 of the act, to exclude from a village any local area or include in village any local area or unite two or more villages or parts of villages or to alter the boundaries of any villages or to alter the name of any village in giving effect to these rules, the commissioner shall, before issuing a notification therefor, give the gram panchayat which will be affected by the issue of such notification an opportunity of showing cause against the proposal to indicate its decision within a period often days from the date of receipt of the show cause notice and consider the objections, if any, of such gram panchayat: provided that where a special officer has been appointed to exercise the powers and perform the functions of the gram panchayats and its sarpanch and executive authority, such special officer shall be given the aforesaid opportunity and the special officer shall make his representation within a period of ten days from the date of receipt of the show - cause notice after taking into consideration the views expressed by the members of the gram sabha at a special meeting convened for the purpose; provided, further that if no reply to the show cause notice from the gram panchayat or the special officer is received within the period aforesaid, the commissioner shall pass such orders as deemed fit to give effect to the proposal.

    10. Where a notification for the declaration of a village has been issued by the commissioner, it shall be open to any gram panchayat affected to prefer revision petition to the government through the commissioner, within fifteen days from the date of publication of such notification and the government, may pass such orders thereon as they may deem fit.

    11. The name of the village to be specified under sub - section (1) of section 3 of the act, shall be the name of revenue village or hamlet or any part of revenue mandal comprising the village having the largest population.

    12. (1) it shall be competent for the commissioner to cancel a notification under clause (f) of sub - section (2) of section 3, in the following circumstances namely: - (i) where it is proposed to constitute a municipality or a notified area under section 389 - a of the andhra pradesh municipalities act, 1965, or a municipal corporation for a village or group of villages or part thereof declared as village under sub - section (1) of section 3 of the act; (ii) where a village declared under sub - section (1) of section 3 or part thereof is proposed to be merged in a neighbouring municipality or municipal corporation or a notified area constituted under section 389 - a of the andhra pradesh municipalities act, 1965, and the residuary area is not, in the opinion of the commissioner, a viable unit for continuing as a gram panchayat; (iii) where the revenue village or part thereof declared as a village under sub - section (1) of section 3 of the said act ceases to be a revenue village due to submersion or depopulation and the necessity for a gram panchayat ceases; (iv) where it is found in the actual working that the gram panchayat for the village declared under sub - section (1) of section 3 cannot function efficiently as a viable unit of local self - govemment; (2) the commissioner shall, before issuing a notification under clause (f) of sub - section (2) of section 3 of the act, give to the gram - panchayat, which will be affected by the issue of such notification, an opportunity of showing cause against the proposal to indicate its decision within a period of ten days from the date of receipt of the show cause notice and consider the objections, if any, of such gram panchayat: provided that if no reply to the show cause notice from the gram panchayat is received within the period aforesaid, the commissioner shall pass such orders as deemed fit, to give effect to the proposal. Powers shall be vested with government for relaxation of rules contained in this order.

    (8) From the above provisions, it is clear that in case of issuing of any notification either by the district collector or by the commissioner, who will have powers to declare a particular area as a gram panchayat or to include or exclude to or from thereof, any village or a part thereof, the aggrieved person, if any, shall be the gram - panchayat only. In case if any gram panchayat feels that it is affected by any such declaration or notification, it has to challenge the same by way of revision to the government through the commissioner. Further, these rules are not permanent in nature, subject to relaxation by the government, as and when the exigencies demand.

    (9) In the case on hand, the petitioner is a resident of venkatapuram village of b. K. Samudram mandal of anantapur district he filed this writ petition challenging the proceedings of the district collector dated 12 - 5 - 1995 in roc. No. 1091/95 - a6 (pts) bifurcating the venkatapuram gram panchayat and forming a separate panchayat for dayy lakuntapalle village and appointing the extension officer (pts.) , singanmala as the special officer to the newly constituted dayylakuntapalle gram panchayat. In the said order, it is mentioned that the special officer will exercise the powers and perform the functions of the gram panchayat and its sarpanch and executive authority until the members and sarpanch thereof who are duly elected, assume office. Feeling the said orders as incorrect, the petitioner has filed this writ petition, seeking for the following relief: -

    ". To issue an appropriate writ order or direction mostly one which is in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the 2nd respondent in issuing proceedings roc. No. 1901/95 - a6 (pts) , dated 12 - 5 - 1995, in bifurcating the dayyalakunta palli village from venkatapuram gram panchayat and formation of separate gram panchayat for dayyalakuntapalli village as illegal, irregular, arbitrary, unjustified, contrary to rules and unsustainable and set aside the same holding that the venkajapuram gram panchayat should continue with dayyalakuntapalli as its hamlet and pass such other order or orders as it may deem fit."

    (10) Sri veera reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner attacked the order under challenge on various grounds and main amongst them are that, - (i) bifurcation and formation of separate gram - panchayat known as dayyalakuntapalli is illegal and not in conformity with the provisions of the act and the rules, because there was no prior notice to the grampanchayat, inviting its objections, if any; (ii) the distance between the bifurcated villages is less than two kilometers, whereas as per rule 6 in g. O. Ms. No. 232, panchayatraj, rural development and relief (pts. Fv) department, dated 18 - 4 - 1995, the distance must be more than two kms,; (f) bifurcation not only arbitrary and the same is not in the interest of the villagers; and (iv) bifurcation and constitution of dayyalakuntapalli has resulted in depriving the villagers of their right to rule themselves effectively. Thus submitting he sought that the petition be allowed by quashing the order under challenge.

    (11) As an answer to these contentions, sri krishna koundinya submitted that the writ petition is not maintainable for the following reasons: - (1) bifurcation was ordered on 12 - 5 - 1995, whereas the writ petition has been filed in the month of september, 1995, that is nearly after four and half months; (ii) as per the scheme of the act and rules, wherever there is bifurcation or reconstitution of a gram panchayat, the aggrieved, if any, shall only be the gram - panchayat and not any individual: thus the petitioner has no locus - standi to challenge the order of bifurcation; (iii) the collector, after satisfying himself that all the requirements under the provisions of the act and rules are complied with, issued the notification; (iv) the constitution, bifurcation, or changing the headquarters of grampanchayat or deletion or inclusion of areas therefor, are purely administrative acts and the same cannot be challenged, unless it is shown that such an act is arbitrary and illegal; and lastly, even if it is assumed that the bifurcation is bad, the aggrieved person will have an opportunity to challenge the same before the government, through the commissioner, by way of revision petition. According to sri krishna koundinya, there is no merit in any of the contentions raised by sri veera reddy, as such the petition has to be rejected.

    (12) After hearing both the sides and giving our careful thought to the relevant provisions, extracted above, now we have to answer whether the order under challenge is bad?

    (13) Time and again this court and the supreme court stated that constitution or declaration or change in headquarters of a grampanchayat - are all purely administrative acts, made for the purpose of administrative convenience i. E. , to administer effectively. The person who can give information about constitution and declaration of a panchayat is only the gram - panchyat in the present case the grampanchayat of venkatapuram is not before the court, but it is the resident of the panchayat that filed this writ petition. The petitioner in this petition has not chosen to challenge the validity of sections 3 and 4 of the act of 1994 or the rules. On the other hand, he is claiming shelter under them.

    (14) While 'considering the similar provision under the a. P. District (formation) act (7 of 1974) , the supreme court, in j. R. Raghupathy v. State of a. P. (1) air 1988 sc 1681, held as follows: - where the high court interfered with the location of mandal headquarters and quashed the notifications issued under s. 3 (5) on the ground that the government acted in breach of the guidelines in that one place or the other was more centrally located or that location at the other place would promote general public convenience, or that the headquarters should be fixed at a particular place with a view to develop the area surrounded by it, the decision of the high court was liable to be set aside. The location of headequarters by the government by the issue of the final notification under sub - section (5) of section 3 was on a consideration by the cabinet sub - committee of the proposals submitted by the collectors concerned and the objections and suggestions received from the local authorities like the gram - panchayats and the general public. Even assuming that the government while accepting the recommendations of the cabinet sub - committee directed that the mandal headquarters should be at place 'x' rather than place 'y' as recommended by the collector concerned in a particular case, the high court would not have issued a writ in the nature of mandamus to enforce the guidelines which were nothing more than administrative instructions not having any statutory force, which did not give rise to any legal right in favour of the writ petitioners.

    (15) While considering the scope of judicial review in similar situation to the one in the case on hand, in b. N. Shankarappa v. Uthanur srinivas (2) air 1992 sc 836, the supreme court approved the view taken by it in j. R. Raghupathy v. State of a. P. (1 supra) and held as follows: - "in j. R. Raghupathy v. State of a. P. , (air 1988 sc 1681) , this court observed that the ultimate decision as to the place or location of mandal headquarter is left to the government to decide and conferment of discretion upon the concerned authority in that behalf must necessarily leave the choice to the discretion of the said authority and it would not be proper for the courts to interfere with the discretion so exercised. This is not to say that the discretion can be exercised in an arbitratary or whimsical manner without proper application of mind or for ulterior or mala fide purpose. If it is shown that the discretion was so exercised, it would certainly be open to the court to interfere with the discretion but not otherwise.

    (16) Thus, it is clear that any bifurcation, declaration, inclusion or deletion etc. , can be made by the authorities concerned by way of appropriate orders. Any interference only when such an order is either arbitrary or mala fide. Further any challenge to such an order cannot be by an individual, as he is not the aggrieved party. Thus the point for consideration is answered negatively.

    (17) When objections were raised objecting the notification under section 3 (1) or 3 (2) of the act, bifurcating or refusing to bifurcate the existing gram panchayats, changing the headquarters, including or excluding or excluding some villages to or from the grampanchayats etc. , the concerned authority should have considered the same properly. Though issuing of such notification is purely an administrative act, but the same shall be done complying with the mandatory provisions of the act, rules, regulations and g. Os. Formation of grampanchayat is not only for mere administrative convenience, but also for the convenience of the villagers. By arbitrary issuance of the notification under section 3 (1) or 3 (2) of the act, bifurcating, or refusing to bifurcate, constituting the grampanchayats, or including or excluding some villages to or from the existing grampanchayats or changing the headquarters etc. , the very avowed object of article 40 of the constitution of india is given a go - by. There is some force in the contention of the petitioner that at least when objections were raised and petitions were presented, either the district collector or the commissioner should have considered the objections and taken a decision in a dispassionate way, in - stead of yielding to the political pressure.

    (18) As mentioned earlier, the petitioner has not challenged the competency or the authority of the district collector or the commissioner to issue notification under section 3 (1) or 3 (2) of the act bifurcating or refusing to bifurcate, including or excluding some villages to or from the grampanchayats or changing the headquarters of the grampanchayat etc. His grievance is that before issuing such a notification an opportunity of hearing should have been given to the gram panchayat, and if wide publicity was given, apart from the aggrieved gram - panchayat, persons interested would have also participated by filing objections. In the matters of bifurcation or refusing to bifurcate the grampanchayats, political considerations should not have been weighed. No doubt neither the act, nor the rules say that there shall be a personal hearing before taking a decision under section 3 or 4 of the act. All that it contemplates is issuing a show cause notice and objections, if any, received to consider the same. Since the main grievance of the petitioner is that the notification under section 3 (1) or 3 (2) of the act bifurcating or refusing to bifurcate, including or excluding some villages to or from the gram panchayats, forming new gram panchayats or changing the headquarters of the grampanchayats etc. , was issued yielding to political pressure, we think justice would be done if either the concerned gram panchayat which is aggrieved by issue of such a notification or the petitioner in the writ petition is given an opportunity of submitting explanation and a final decision is taken, though it is purely an administrative act and scope to interfere with such an act under article 226 of constitution of india is very much limited, since the authorities have to act in accordance with law, particularly as per sections 3 and 4 of the act and rules 7 to 12 of the rules. It is needless to say that there shall be proper application of mind on the part of the authorities before a decision is taken regarding issue of notification, bifurcating or refusing to bifurcate, including or excluding some villages to or from the grampanchayats, shifting of headquarters or forming new grampanchayats etc.

    (19) Hence, the writ petition is disposed of, directing the petitioner to approach, if he so desires, the district collector, if not already approached, or the government through the commissioner in case he has already approached the district collector and obtained adverse orders, by way of revision petition, - within thirty days from the date of receipt of this order. If any grampanchayat is not before this court, yet it feels to avail of the opportunity of ventilating its grievance before the district collector or the government, as the case may be, still it can do so, by filing objections before the concerned authority, within thirty days from the date of receipt of this order. The concerned authority, i. E. , the district collector or the government shall on receipt of such representation or objection petition, issue a notice to the grampanchayat and the writ petitioner concerned and receive objections and other material, if any, and then to apply its mind to the facts and circumstances and to the effect of provisions of the act, rules and regulations and other gos including the principles laid down by the supreme court in the cases cited supra, and pass appropriate orders within sixty days from the date of receipt of objection petitions, or representations or revision petitions, as the case may be, in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D. Venkata Rushi Reddy v. The Divisional Panchayat Officer, Anantapur And Ors.
    (Sep 27, 1995)