AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Twelve company petitions were filed by various creditors of Satya Steel Strips Ltd. (referred to in the opinion as "SSSL" or "the respondent company") seeking winding up, mainly on the ground of inability to pay debts despite statutory notices under section 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 (except company petition no. 27 of 1990). The Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) declared SSSL a "sick industrial company" under section 3(1)(o) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 ("the Act"). As a result, BIFR initiated inquiries and proceedings under the Act.

Relevant BIFR actions included an order dated 9-1-1990 fixing 5-4-1990 for hearing suggestions and objections, directing notices to institutions and publication in newspapers. A subsequent order dated 15-5-1990 directed Canara Bank to submit a report within two months assessing whether the company was technically, economically and commercially viable and called for an inter-institutional meeting to try to reach agreement in principle before the next BIFR hearing.

The company petitions were pending before the High Court while BIFR was in seisin of the matter and attempting to prepare a rehabilitation scheme under the Act. The High Court considered whether, and to what extent, it could proceed with winding up proceedings in light of the pending BIFR proceedings and the statutory bar in section 22 of the Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in view of the declaration of SSSL as a sick industrial company and the pendency of inquiries and scheme-preparation before BIFR, the High Court may proceed with or continue winding up proceedings under the Companies Act without the consent of BIFR.
  2. Whether the statutory bar in section 22 of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 prevents continuation of the pending company petitions for winding up in the absence of BIFR's consent.
  3. What procedural disposition should the High Court make of the pending company petitions while BIFR proceedings remain in progress?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners (creditors) argued that BIFR's order dated 15-5-1990 had given Canara Bank two months to submit its viability report and that the two-month period had expired without BIFR having prepared or sanctioned any revival scheme; hence, the High Court should proceed with enquiries in the company petitions and order winding up of SSSL.
  • At least one petitioner (company petition no. 62 of 1987) sought that the company petitions be adjourned from time to time until BIFR concluded its proceedings; this request was made to the court but not acceded to.

Respondent Company's Arguments

  • The respondent company (SSSL) noted that BIFR had declared the company sick and that a scheme was under preparation (including a report by Canara Bank). The respondent also emphasised that BIFR had issued notices and that creditors had appeared before BIFR and were parties to BIFR proceedings — a fact not disputed by petitioners' counsel.
  • The respondent contended, implicitly through submissions recorded by the court, that BIFR remained seized of the matter and was taking steps towards preparing a rehabilitation scheme; therefore statutory processes under the Act should be allowed to run their course.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Testels Limited v. Radhaben Ranchhodlal Charitable Trust (Gujarat High Court, Division Bench decision) Held that under section 22 of the Act, winding up proceedings already started against an industrial company can be dismissed and need not be kept in abeyance indefinitely without further action. The Court cited and relied on this decision to support the conclusion that the company petitions could be dismissed rather than kept pending indefinitely while BIFR proceedings continued.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded from statutory interpretation of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 and the admitted facts that BIFR had declared SSSL to be a sick industrial company and had initiated statutory processes.

Key steps in the court's analysis:

  • The Act is a self-contained code for companies declared sick. Its object is timely detection of sickness and expeditious expert determination of remedial measures, including preparation and sanction of revival/rehabilitation schemes and provision of financial assistance where appropriate.
  • Under the Act, after an inquiry under section 16, BIFR can either (a) decide revival/rehabilitation is practicable and prepare and sanction a scheme (as contemplated by section 17 and related provisions), or (b) decide revival is not practicable, record an opinion that it is just and equitable that the company be wound up and forward that opinion to the High Court so that the court may proceed under the Companies Act.
  • Section 22 of the Act provides that where an inquiry is pending or a scheme is under preparation or consideration, or a sanctioned scheme is under implementation, no proceedings for winding up the industrial company shall lie or be proceeded further except with the consent of BIFR (or the appellate authority). This provision, the court held, operates as a statutory bar to the High Court entertaining or continuing winding up proceedings without BIFR's consent while BIFR proceedings remain in progress.
  • The petitioners had not obtained BIFR's consent to proceed with winding up before the High Court. Meanwhile, BIFR had taken steps (orders dated 9-1-1990 and 15-5-1990) seeking reports and convening inter-institutional discussions, and was attempting to prepare a scheme under section 18 of the Act.
  • The court therefore concluded that it was barred by section 22 from inquiring into or proceeding with the company petitions in the absence of BIFR's consent. Keeping the petitions pending indefinitely would serve no useful purpose; an earlier order appointing a receiver (dated 23-12-1988) had been passed before BIFR proceedings were initiated and did not bind the parties in view of the subsequent BIFR action.
  • The court noted judicial support for this approach in the cited Gujarat High Court division bench decision and applied that principle to dismiss the petitions subject to specific revival conditions described below.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court dismissed the company petitions listed in the order.

Specific disposition:

  • Company petition nos. 44 and 62 of 1987; 16, 23, 26, 34, 39, 43 and 57 of 1988; 1 and 2 of 1989; and 27 of 1990 are dismissed.
  • The dismissal is conditional: if BIFR records an opinion that it is just and equitable that SSSL should be wound up and forwards that opinion to the High Court, the dismissed company petitions will be revived and further proceedings will be continued.
  • Each party was directed to bear its own costs.

Implications: The immediate consequence is the dismissal of the listed winding-up petitions subject to revival if BIFR forwards an opinion in favour of winding up. The court relied on the statutory bar in section 22 and on precedent to justify dismissal rather than keeping proceedings in abeyance. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new binding precedent beyond its application to the facts before the court.

    M/S Hightemp Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., A Company Incorporated Under The Provisions Of The Indian Companies Act Having Its Registered Office At Bangalore v. M/S Satya Steel Strips (P) Ltd. Satya Krishna Bhavan Larsvin Corporate Complex Panjagutta, Hyderabad 500482 .

    (1) These twelve company petitions have been filed by the various creditors of satya steel strips ltd. , (hereinafter referred to as 'sssl' or the respondent company) seeking the relief of winding up of the respondent company mainly on the ground of its inability to pay debts in spite of the statutory notices issued under section 434 of the companies act of 1956 except in the case of company petition no. 27 of 1990.

    (2) The various contentions put forth in all the company petitions and the allegations urged in the counters filed by the respondent company need not be set out in detail because admittedly the board for industrial and financial reconstruction (hereinafter referred to as the bifr or the board) passed an order declaring the respondent company as a sick industrial company as defined under section 3 (1) (o) of the sick industrial companies (special provisions) act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as 'the act'.)

    (3) The central legislature considering the imperative need to enact a legislation to provide for the timely detection of sickness in industrial units and for expeditious determination by a body of experts of the preventive, ameliorative, remedial and other measures that would be needed for enforcement of the appropriate measures has enacted the act. The main object of the act is to establish, a board consisting of persons who are considered as experts in various fields to enquire into and determine the incidence of sickness in industrial companies and to devise suitable remedial measures through appropriate schemes and for implementation thereof. The main intention of the legislature seems to be that not merely the promoters and share - holders of an industrial unit have concern with the proper functioning of the industrial unit but also the central and the state governments, their undertakings, financial institutions and banks which provide the initial finance for the industrial unit are also equally interested in the proper functioning of the industrial unit thereby promoting the national output. That is the reason why the act provides the scheme of enquiring into the working of sick industrial companies, for preparation and sanction of schemes with the idea of rehabilitation of the sick industrial companies by providing financial and other assistance. The bifr, after making an inquiry under section 16 of the act, is empowered to decide whether it is practicable for the company to make its net worth positive within a reasonable time and to give an opportunity to the company to make its net worth positive. If, on the other hand, the board decides that it is not practicable for the sick industrial company to make its net worth positive within a reasonable time, the board can direct any operating agency to prepare a scheme providing for the measures for the revival of the company in any of the methods provided under sect ion 17 of the act. The scheme may also provide for financial assistance by way of loans, advances or guarantees or reliefs or concessions or sacrifices from the central government, a state government, any scheduled bank or other bank, a public financial institution or state level institution or any institution or other authority to the sick industrial company. The board is thus, authorised to explore all possible means at its command to prepare and sanction schemes for the revival and rehabilitation of a sick industrial company.

    (4) If the board, after making inquiry under section 16 of the act and after consideration of all the relevant facts and circumstances and after giving an opportunity of being heard to all the concerned parties, is of the opinion that it is just and equitable that the sick industrial company should be wound up, it may record and forward its opinion to the concerned high court. Thereupon, the high court, shall, on the basis of the opinion of the board, order winding up of the sick industrial company in accordance with the provisions of the companies act.

    (5) The act, thus, operates as a self - contained code for various steps to be taken in respect of a company which is declared as a sick industrial company under section 3 (1) (o) of the act. Section 22 of the act provides that where in respect of an industrial company, an enquiry under section 16 of the act is pending or, any scheme referred to under section 17 of the act is under preparation or consideration, or a sanctioned scheme is under implementation or where an appeal under section 25 of the act relating to an industrial company is pending, notwithstanding anything contained in the companies act of 1956 or any other law, or the memorandum and articles of association of the industrial company or any other instrument having effect under the companies act or other law, no proceedings, for the winding up of the industrial company shall lie or be proceeded further except with the consent of the board or the appellate authority. It is an admitted fact that in this case, sssl has been declared as a sick industrial company under section 3 (1) (o) of the act and the board is finding out the ways and means of reviving the respondent company. Thus, the b1fr is in seisin of the affairs of the respondent company.

    (6) The learned counsel for the petitioner in company petition no. 62 of 1987 submitted that the board by its order dated 9 - 1 - 1990 has fixed the date as 5 - 4 - 1990 for hearing the suggestions and objections against the proposed winding up of the respondent company and also directed issue of notice of hearing to the various institutions mentioned in the order as well as general notice in one english newspaper and one telugu newspaper having circulation in andhra pradesh for the information of share - holders, creditors, employees: of the respondent company and other interested persons. He further submitted that on 15 - 5 - 1990, the board directed the canara bank to submit its report within two months for circulating the copies thereof to all the parties concerned and also directed that an interinstitutional meeting should be held in order to arrive at an agreement in principle to the proposals to the extent possible before the next hearing of the bench. Since the period of two months mentioned in the order dated 15 - 5 - 1990 has expired, the learned counsel for the petitioner in company petition no. 62 of 1987 argued that the board did not prepare or sanction any scheme for the revival or rehabilitation of sssl and hence the only other option left for this court is to proceed with the enquiry in the various company petitions and to order winding up of the respondent company.

    (7) When once there is a reference to the board with regard to sssl treating it as a sick industrial company, as i mentioned already, the procedure prescribed under the act which is a self - contained code with regard to sick industrial companies should be exhausted. No doubt, the order dated 15 - 5 - 1990 gave two months' time to the canara bank to submit its report as to whether the respondent company is technically, economically and commercially viable. Certain guide lines are indicated in the said order about the scheme which should be proposed by the canara bank. It is not as if the board ceased to continue its jurisdiction after the period of two months given to the canara bank for submitting a report suggesting a scheme for implementation has expired. The learned counsel for the respondent company submitted that the board did not meet so far to consider about the revival of sssl and that a scheme is under preparation by the canara bank, whatever it is, the learned counsel for the petitioners in the various company petitions referred to above have not produced any order passed by the board subsequent to 15 - 5 - 1990. Only two courses are open to the board, after making an inquiry as required under section 16 of the act. They are: (1) if the board is satisfied that it is possible to order revival or rehabilitation of the sick industrial company, to prepare and sanction the scheme and (2) if, on the other hand, the board is of the opinion that it is not possible to order revival or rehabilitation of the sick industrial company or to sanction a scheme in respect of the sick industrial company, the only other option left to the board is to record a finding that it is just and equitable that the sick industrial company should be wound up and forward its opinion to the high coun to enable the high court to proceed with the winding up of the sick industrial company in accordance with the provisions of the companies act.

    (8) In the light of the various provisions contained in the act in respect of a sick industrial company, and especially in view of sec. 22 of the act providing that where an inquiry under section 16 of the act is pending or any scheme referred to under section 17 of the act is under preparation or consideration, no proceedings for the winding up of the sick industrial company shall lie or be proceeded further except with the consent of the board. None of the petitioners have taken steps to obtain the consent of the board for proceeding with the winding up proceedings in respect of sssl pending before the court. On the other hand, the board is making attempts for preparation of a scheme under section 18 of the act.

    (9) Under these circumstances, i hold that section 22 of the act operates as a bar for this court for enquiring into the various company petitions filed for winding up of the respondent company in the absence of the consent of the board.

    (10) The learned counsel for the respondent company submitted that all the creditors who are the parties to the various company petitions have appeared before the bifr and are parties to the proceedings before the bifr. That fact is not disputed by the learned counsel for the petitioners. Even otherwise, by order dated 9 - 1 - 1990, the board has directed issuance of notices of hearing not only to the various institutions mentioned in its order but has also directed a general notice being published in two daily newspapers, one in english and one in telugu having circulation in andhra pradesh, for the information of the share - holders, etc. Thereby, all the interested parties are deemed to have notice of the pioceedings before the bifr. If the board is unable to formulate any scheme for the proper functioning of the respondent - company and is of the opinion that it is just and equitable that sssl should be wound up, the board must have to record its opinion and forward the same to the high court for proceeding with the winding up proceedings.

    (11) The learned counsel for the petitioner in company petition no. 62 of 1987 submitted that in view of the pendency of the proceedings before the bifr, the company petitions might be adjourned from time to time till the proceedings before the bifr are concluded. I cannot accede to that request;

    (12) My learned brother upendralal waghray, j. Passed an order dated 23 - 12 - 1988 in company application nos. 235,300,302,303,309, and 310 of 1988 appointing a receiver. That order is obviously passed before the proceedings were initiated before the bifr under the act. The learned judge observed that there was no material placed before him that any reference has been registered before the bifr. Therefore, that order passed before the proceedings were initiated before the bifr under the act does not bind the parties in view of the admitted subsequent event of initiation of pioceedings under the act and the pendency of the proceedings before the bifr.

    (13) Having regard to the procedure prescribed under the act and in the light of the provisions contained in sections 20 and 22 of the act, 1 hold that no useful purpose would be served in keeping the company petitions pending indefinitely. The only consequence that follows is that the company petitions shoud be dismissed.

    (14) I am supported in the view taken by me above by a division bench decision of gujarat high court in testels limited vs. Radhaben ranchhodlal charitable trust 1 wherein the learned judges held that under section 22 of the act, the winding up proceedings already started against an industrial company can be dismissed and need not be kept in abeyance indefinitely without taking any further action in the matter.

    (15) In the result, company petition nos. 44 and 62, of 1987, 16,23,26, 34,39,43, and 57 of 1988, 1 and 2 of 1989 and 27 of 1990 are dismissed subject to the condition that in the event of the bifr recording its opinion that it is just and equitable that sssl should be wound up and forwarding its opinion to this court, the above company petitions would be revived and further proceedings would be continued. In the circumstances of the case, i direct each party to bear its own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S Hightemp Chemica... v. M/S Satya Steel Stri...
    (Sep 17, 1990)