Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant filed complaint C.C. No. 783 of 1995 before the XI Metropolitan Magistrate, Secunderabad under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The factual matrix as stated in the opinion is:

  • The accused approached the complainant for a bill discounting facility which the complainant accepted. Bills were discounted on 23-12-1994 and after deducting commission the balance was paid to the accused.
  • The facility was for 90 days. The accused gave a post-dated cheque No. 880944 dated 23-3-1995 for Rs. 26,12,742/- drawn on United Western Bank Ltd., Hyderabad.
  • Subsequent to issuance of the cheque, the accused paid Rs. 12,50,000/- on 25-4-1995 and promised to settle the account by end of May 1995.
  • On 9-6-1995 the complainant wrote to the accused to settle by 15-6-1995 or the cheque would be presented on 16-6-1995. The cheque was presented at Canara Bank, M.G. Road, Secunderabad on 16-6-1995 and was dishonoured on 20-6-1995 with endorsement "funds insufficient".
  • On 24-6-1995 the complainant issued a notice requesting payment of the balance amount of Rs. 15,16,329.17 from the date of receipt of the notice. The accused received the notice and replied on 10-7-1995 admitting issuance of the cheque.
  • The complainant filed the complaint under section 138 of the Act. To prove its case the complainant examined a representative as PW1 and marked exhibits P.L to P.11. The accused adduced no oral or documentary evidence.
  • The trial court acquitted the accused under section 255(1) Cr.P.C. after observing (inter alia) that the bank endorsement did not disclose the amount available in the accused's account, the non-examination of the bank official was fatal to the complainant's case, and that the cheque was presented for the entire amount notwithstanding a part-payment.
  • The complainant appealed against the trial court's judgment dated 1-9-1997; that appeal is the subject of the present opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statutory notice required by proviso (b) to section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act must specifically demand payment of the amount covered by the dishonoured cheque (i.e., the exact cheque amount), and whether a notice for a different amount (lesser or greater) satisfies the statutory requirement.
  2. Whether presenting the original cheque for the full amount after receipt of a subsequent part-payment, but issuing the statutory notice only for the balance amount, renders the notice invalid and thereby defeats prosecution under section 138.
  3. Whether the complainant's failure to examine bank officials or to establish the account balance at the time of presentation (as referenced by the trial court) is fatal to maintaining the complaint under section 138.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Complainant)'s Arguments

  • The accused did not dispute issuance of the cheque for Rs. 26,12,742/-. After adjusting the subsequent payment of Rs. 12,50,000/-, the amount legally due was Rs. 15,16,329.17.
  • The cheque was presented and returned with endorsement "funds insufficient". The statutory notice under the Act was issued for the actual amount due (the balance) and therefore the notice is valid.
  • Because the accused failed to pay the amount covered by the notice, he is liable for conviction under section 138.
  • The appellant relied on the decision of Justice K. B. Siddappa in Andhra Engineering Corporation v. TCI Finance Ltd. (1999 (3) ALD 393) in support of the contention that the complaint is maintainable and conviction is warranted.

Respondent (Accused)'s Arguments

  • Although the cheque was for Rs. 26,12,742/-, the accused made a subsequent payment of Rs. 12,50,000/-. The complainant after adjustment should have returned the cheque and sought a fresh cheque for the balance, rather than presenting the original cheque for the entire amount.
  • The statutory notice must demand payment of the amount covered by the cheque. Because the notice in this case was issued only for the balance (after accounting for the subsequent payment), it cannot be treated as a valid notice under section 138.
  • The respondent also argued that the complainant included interest at 24% in the demand without furnishing details; the omission of separate particulars about principal and interest allegedly makes it difficult for the accused to ascertain what was paid and hence renders the notice illegal.
  • The respondent relied on the decision of R. Ramanujam, J. (M/s. Yankay Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. M/s. Citi Bank & Another, 2001 (2) LS 71) and earlier Supreme Court authority (Suman Sethi v. Ajay K. Churiwal) to contend that a notice demanding a lesser or greater amount than the cheque amount fails the statutory requirement and the prosecution must fail.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Andhra Engineering Corporation v. TCI Finance Ltd., 1999 (3) ALD 393 (Justice K. B. Siddappa) Authority holding that when a subsequent payment is made and the cheque is presented after issuing notice for the balance amount (after deducting the payment), the notice may be valid depending on circumstances. The appellant relied on this decision to argue maintainability of the complaint. The opinion notes the decision and its facts, but also observes that that judge considered surrounding circumstances and referred to other cases where excess claims rendered notices insufficient.
M/s. Yankay Drugs & Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. M/s. Citi Bank & Another, 2001 (2) LS 71 (R. Ramanujam, J.) Held that under proviso (b) to section 138 the demand in the statutory notice must be for the amount covered by the dishonoured cheque; a demand for lesser or greater amount not covered by the cheque will invalidate the notice and defeat prosecution. The respondent relied on this decision; the court cited it as supporting the proposition that a notice for an amount other than the cheque amount fails to fulfill statutory formalities and prevents prosecution under section 138.
Suman Sethi v. Ajay K. Churiwal, JT 2000 (1) SC 493 = (2000) 2 SCC 380 (Supreme Court) Supreme Court authority referred to in the reasoning that supports the necessity that the statutory notice demand the cheque amount. Cited within the discussion of R. Ramanujam's decision; the opinion refers to this Supreme Court authority as part of the legal background supporting the requirement that the statutory notice specifically demand the cheque amount.
K. R. Indira v. Dr. G. Adinarayana, 2003 SCC (Crl.) 2002 (Supreme Court) Held that the statutory notice under proviso (b) must contain a specific demand for payment of the sum covered by the dishonoured cheque. If the notice provides sufficient information and contains the specific demand, other consolidated demands may not invalidate it; but absence of a specific demand for the cheque amount renders the notice invalid. The court relied on this Supreme Court decision as authoritative: it applied the principle that absence of a specific demand for the cheque amount makes the notice invalid, and used it to conclude the notice in the present case was deficient.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court's analysis proceeded from the statutory text of section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and from the precedents cited by the parties. The court noted the following points, based only on the material in the opinion:

  1. Statutory framework: The court reproduced the language of section 138 including the provisos that (a) the cheque must be presented within time, (b) the payee must give written notice to the drawer within 30 days of receiving information of dishonour from the bank, and (c) the drawer must fail to make payment within 15 days of the notice.
  2. Evidence before trial court: The complainant adduced evidence by way of its representative (PW1) and exhibits; the accused led no evidence. The trial court nevertheless acquitted, observing absence of bank official evidence and that the bank's endorsement did not show the amount available in the accused's account on presentation.
  3. Precedential guidance: The court considered competing authorities. It acknowledged Justice Siddappa's decision (Andhra Engineering) where a notice for the balance after part-payment was upheld in that case's circumstances. It contrasted that with decisions (including Ramanujam, J.'s decision and the Supreme Court in K. R. Indira) which emphasize that the statutory notice must specifically demand payment of the exact cheque amount — and that a notice demanding a lesser or a greater amount than the cheque amount will be deficient.
  4. Application to present facts: The court found as an undisputed fact that the notice in the present case was not issued for the amount covered by the cheque (i.e., the complainant issued notice for the balance after accounting for the part-payment rather than demanding the cheque amount itself). The court held that this failure means the notice did not satisfy the requirements of proviso (b) to section 138.
  5. Legal conclusion: Relying on the cited precedents (particularly the principle in K. R. Indira and the Ramanujam decision), the court concluded that because there was no specific demand in the legal notice for the cheque amount, the notice was invalid. In the absence of a valid statutory notice, prosecution under section 138 could not be maintained.
  6. Consistency with trial court: Given the invalidity of the notice, the appellate court found no reason to interfere with the trial court's conclusion that the accused was entitled to acquittal, and therefore upheld the acquittal.

Holding and Implications

Final Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The appellate court upheld the trial court's acquittal of the accused in the complaint under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

Implications and Direct Consequences:

  • The accused's acquittal in the trial court is affirmed; prosecution under section 138 could not be maintained because the statutory notice did not specifically demand the amount covered by the dishonoured cheque.
  • As applied in this opinion, the court followed precedent emphasizing that the statutory notice must contain a specific demand for the cheque amount; where that requirement is not met the prosecution fails.
  • The opinion does not expound or announce any broader new legal principle beyond application of the existing authorities on the statutory notice requirement; its direct effect is to dismiss the appeal and affirm acquittal in the facts of this case.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the provided opinion. No information beyond that opinion has been added.

    Tci Finance Limited v. State Of A.P.

    (1) This appeal is preferred by the complainant in c. C. No. 783 of 1995 on the file of the xi metropolitan magistrate, secunderabad taken on file for the offence under section 138 of the negotiable instruments act, 1881 (for short 'the act').

    (2) The factual matrix leading to the filing of this appeal is briefly as under:

    (3) The accused approached the complainant with a proposal for bill discounting facility for which the complainant accepted. The bills were discounted on 23 - 12 - 1994 and after deducting the commission the balance amount was paid to the accused. The facility was given for 90 days. The accused has given postdated cheque bearing no. 880944 dated 23 - 3 - 1995 for rs. 26,12,742/ - drawn on united western bank limited, hyderabad. Subsequent to the date of issuing the cheque, the accused paid rs. 12,50,0007 - on 25 - 4 - 1995 and promised to settle the account by the end of may 1995. On 9 - 6 - 1995 the complainant company wrote a letter to the accused requesting to settle the account before 15 - 6 - 1995, otherwise it will present the cheque on 16 - 6 - 1995. Since there was no effort from the accused to settle the account, on 16 - 6 - 1995 the complainant presented the cheque in canara bank, m. G. Road, secunderabad. The same was dishonoured on 20 - 6 - 1995 with an endorsement "funds insufficient". On 24 - 6 - 1995 the complainant wrote a letter to the accused and requested to pay the balance amount of rs. 15,16,329 - 17 ps. From the date of receipt of the notice. The accused received the notice and gave a reply on 10 - 7 - 1995 admitting the issuing of cheque. The legal debt due to the complainant was rs. 15,16,329 - 17 ps. Subsequently, the complainant filed a complaint before the lower court for the offence under section 138 of the act.

    (4) The complainant in order to prove the guilt of the accused examined its representative as p. W. I and marked exs. P. L to p. I 1.

    (5) No oral or documentary evidence was adduced by the accused.

    (6) The lower court after considering the material available on record acquitted the accused under section 255 (1) crp. C. For the offence under section 138 of the act observing that the bank people might have returned the cheque on the ground that the funds available in the bank are insufficient to honour the cheque for rs. 26,12,7427 -. The lower court further observed that there is no evidence to show as to what is the amount available in the account of the accused as on the date of presentation of the cheque. The non - examination of the bank official is fatal to the complainant's case. The lower court also observed that the complainant instead of getting the cheque for balance amount after deducting the part - payment made by the accused, presented the cheque as it is. Since the endorsement of the bank is not for the amount legally due to the complainant, the complaint is liable to be dismissed.

    (7) The complainant being aggrieved by the judgment of the lower court dated 1 - 9 - 1997 preferred this appeal questioning its validity and legality.

    (8) Section 138 of the negotiable instruments act, 1881 reads as follows: 138. Dishonour of cheque for insufficiency, etc. , of funds in the accounts: where any cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of money to another person from out of that account for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability, is returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit of that account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement made with that bank, such person shall be deemed to have committed an offence and shall without prejudice to any other provisions of this act, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may be extended to two years, or with fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque, or with both: provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply unless

    (a) the cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier. (b) the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque, as the case may be, makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice, in writing, to the drawer of the cheque, within thirty days of the receipt of information by him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid, and (c) the drawer of such cheque fails to make the payment of the said amount of money to the payee or, as the case may be, to the holder in due course of the cheque, within fifteen days of the receipt of the said notice.

    Explanation : for the purpose of this section, "debt or other liability" means a legally enforceable debt or other liability.

    (9) The learned counsel for the appellant - complainant submitted that the accused did not dispute the issuance of cheque for rs. 26,12,742/ - and after adjusting the amount of rs. 12,50,000/ - paid by the respondent - accused, the amount due to the complainant is rs. 15,16,329 - 17 ps. Since the accused did not respond to the notice given by the complainant, the cheque for the entire amount was presented to the bank and the bank returned the cheque with an endorsement "funds insufficient". The learned counsel further submitted that the statutory notice required to be issued under the act was issued only for the actual amount due from the accused, therefore, the notice is valid and as the accused failed to pay the amount covered by the notice, he is liable for conviction for the offence under section 138 of the act.

    (10) The learned counsel for the respondent - accused submitted that though the cheque was issued for rs. 26,12,742/ - , the accused made payment of rs. 12,50,000/ - subsequent to that date, therefore, the complainant after adjusting the amount ought to have returned the cheque demanding the accused to issue another cheque. Instead of resorting to that, the complainant presented the cheque for the entire amount. He further submitted that the statutory notice is supposed to be issued for the amount covered by the cheque, but in view of the subsequent payment made by the accused, the notice was issued only for the balance amount, therefore, it cannot be treated as a valid notice. When once the notice is not valid, the prosecution cannot be maintained and the respondent is not liable for any punishment under section 138 of the act.

    (11) The learned counsel for the appellant - complainant relied on a decision rendered by justice k - b. Siddappa, a learned single judge of this court, as he then was, in andhra engineering corporation sec 'bad v. Tci finance ltd. , sec'bad, 1999 (3) ald 393, in support of his contention that the complaint is maintainable and that the accused is liable for conviction.

    (12) In the case covered by the above decision, a cheque was issued for an amount of rs. 10,76,000/ - and a sum of rs. 3,50,000/ - was paid subsequent to the issuance of the cheque. When the cheque was subsequently presented after issuing of notice for the balance amount due under the cheque after deducting the amount paid, the learned judge held that the notice is valid and the failure of the accused to pay the said amount renders him punishable for the offence under section 138 of the act.

    (13) The learned judge laid down the above principle taking into consideration the circumstances referred to in the said decision. The learned judge while dealing with the said matter and while referring to certain other decisions rendered by calcutta and kerala high courts observed that when excess amount was claimed than the amount covered by the debt, the difference will create difficulty to the drawee to know how much he has to pay and that makes the notice insufficient and vague and the notice will become illegal.

    (14) In the case on hand, the learned counsel for the respondent - accused submitted that the complainant included the interest at 24% without furnishing the details in the legal notice and unless the details regarding the principal amount and the rate of interest claimed therein are separately mentioned, it becomes difficult for the accused to know as to how much amount he paid and in the light of the above circumstances the notice becomes illegal.

    (15) The learned counsel for the respondent - accused relied on a decision of r. Ramanujam, j. , a learned single judge of this court, as he then was, in m/s. Yankay drugs and pharmaceuticals ltd. V. M/s. Citi bank and another, 2001 (2) ls 71, wherein the learned judge while referring the case of suman sethi v. Ajay k. Churiwal, jt 2000 (1) sc 493 = (2000) 2 scc 380, (decision rendered by the hon'ble supreme court) held that while demanding payment by issuing a notice under section 138 proviso (b) of the act, the payee or the holder in due course must demand payment of the amount covered by the cheque. If the demand is for a lesser amount or for a higher amount not covered by the cheque, which was dishonoured, then the prosecution must fail as the statutory requirement of section 138 proviso (b) is not fulfilled.

    (16) In k. K.R Indira v. Dr. G. Adinarayana., 2003 scc (crl.) 2002, the supreme court while considering the scope of section 138 proviso (b) of the act held that in the notice issued under section 138 proviso (b) , specific demand for payment of the sum covered by the cheque dishonoured has to be made. If the notice provides sufficient information envisaged by the statutory provision and contains the specific demand, the mere fact that it was a consolidated notice, and/or that further demands in addition tc the statutorily envisaged demand were also found to have been made may not invalidate the same. In the absence of specific demand for the cheque amount, the notice was held to be invalid.

    (17) In the case covered by the above decision, the supreme court observed as follows: significantly, not only the cheque amounts were different from the alleged loan amounts, but the demand was made not of the cheque amounts, but only the loan amount as though it is a demand for the loan amount and not the demand for payment of the cheque amount and in addition thereto made further demands as well. What is necessary is making a demand for the amount covered by the bounced cheque, which is conspicuously absent in the notice issued. The notice in question is imperfect in this case, not because it had any further or additional claims as well but it did not specifically contain any demand for payment of the cheque amount, the non - compliance with such a demand only being the incriminating circumstance, which exposes the drawer for being proceeded against under section 138 of the act.

    (18) The decision rendered by ramanujam, j. , makes the position clear that if the notice is either for lesser amount or for more amount than the amount covered by the cheque, it amounts to failure to fulfill all the technical formalities contemplated under section/138 of the act, therefore, the respondent - accused herein cannot be prosecuted. The judgment of the supreme court in k. R. Indira (supra) , is also making the position clear that unless there is a specific demand in the legal notice in respect of the amount covered by the cheque, the appellant - complainant cannot proceed against the accused under section 138 of the act.

    (19) In the case on hand, it is an undisputed fact that the notice under section 138 proviso (b) was not issued for the amount covered by the cheque, therefore, it falls short of the fulfillment of the requirements under section 138 of the act and it cannot be treated as a valid notice. In the absence of a valid notice, the prosecution under section 138 of the act cannot be maintained. In the light of the above circumstances, the lower court was right in coming to the conclusion that the accused is entitled for acquittal.

    (20) In the light of the foregoing discussion, i do not find any grounds to interfere with the judgment of the lower court. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tci Finance Limited v. State Of A.P.
    (Mar 25, 2004)