Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (2).5. After careful consideration of sub-rule 2 of R. 11 of O. 20 of the CPC
  • 14 of the Chitaley's Code of Civil Procedure (Act V of 1908) under O. 20, R. 11 (1951
  • sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43 of our Code referred
  • sub-rule (2), of R. 11 of O. 20 of Act 5 of 1908
  • sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20 of our Code
  • India. Sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43
  • sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20
  • sub-rule (1) of R. 11 of O. 20
  • sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43
  • sub-rule 2, R. 11 of Order
  • sub-rule (2), R. 11 of O. 20
  • sub-rule (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (2).5. After careful consideration of sub-rule 2 of R. 11 of O. 20 of the CPC
  • 14 of the Chitaley's Code of Civil Procedure (Act V of 1908) under O. 20, R. 11 (1951
  • sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43 of our Code referred
  • sub-rule (2), of R. 11 of O. 20 of Act 5 of 1908
  • sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20 of our Code
  • India. Sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43
  • sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20
  • sub-rule (1) of R. 11 of O. 20
  • sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43
  • sub-rule 2, R. 11 of Order
  • sub-rule (2), R. 11 of O. 20
  • sub-rule (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a revision application challenging an order of the District Judge, Jammu, which dismissed the judgment-debtor applicant's appeal against an order of the City Judge, Jammu. The City Judge had refused to allow the payment of the decretal amount in instalments. The dismissal was on the ground that such an appeal was not competent under Order 43, Rule 1(ii) read with Order 20, Rule 11(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal by the judgment-debtor against an order rejecting his application to pay the decretal amount in instalments is competent under Order 43, Rule 1(ii) of the CPC.
  2. Whether an order refusing to fix instalments for payment of the decretal amount falls within the scope of sub-rule (2) of Rule 11 of Order 20, making it appealable.
  3. The interpretation of the phrase "passed without the consent of the parties" in Order 43, Rule 1(ii) in relation to orders under Order 20, Rule 11(2).

Arguments of the Parties

Decree-Holder (Non-Applicant) Arguments

  • Appeal by the judgment-debtor against an order rejecting instalment payment is not competent under Order 43, Rule 1(ii) of the CPC.
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 11 of Order 20 applies only when the executing court fixes instalments with or without the consent of the decree-holder.
  • An order refusing to exercise the discretion to fix instalments does not constitute an order under sub-rule (2) and hence is not appealable.

Judgment-Debtor (Applicant) Arguments

  • Both orders fixing instalments and refusing to fix instalments fall under sub-rule (2) of Rule 11 of Order 20.
  • Orders passed without the consent of the parties are appealable under Order 43, Rule 1(ii), and refusal to fix instalments is such an order against the judgment-debtor's consent.
  • The language of Order 43, Rule 1(ii) is broad and includes orders rejecting applications for instalments.
  • If the legislature intended to restrict appeals only to orders granting instalments, it would have done so explicitly, as seen in other clauses of Order 43.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the relevant provisions of the CPC, particularly Order 43, Rule 1(ii) and Order 20, Rule 11(2). It noted that the District Judge had erred in holding that an appeal against an order refusing instalments was not competent. The court found that both orders granting and refusing instalments are made under sub-rule (2) of Rule 11 of Order 20 and are appealable if passed without the consent of the parties.

The court emphasized the wide language of Order 43, Rule 1(ii), which includes any order under sub-rule (2) of Rule 11 of Order 20 passed without consent, encompassing refusal orders. It rejected the contention that only orders granting instalments are appealable, noting that if such restriction was intended, the legislature would have specified it explicitly.

The court also referred to the distinction in other jurisdictions and prior versions of the Code but found those not determinative for the present case. Ultimately, it concluded that the appeal was competent and that the order of the District Judge dismissing the appeal was incorrect.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed the revision application, set aside the District Judge's order, and directed restoration of the appeal to its original number for disposal on merits and according to law. Costs were left to abide the result.

The decision directly affects the parties by permitting the judgment-debtor's appeal against the refusal to allow payment in instalments. No new precedent beyond the interpretation of the relevant CPC provisions was established.

    Om Prakash v. Jammu And Kashmir Bank Ltd.

    1. This is a revision application directed against an order of the District Judge, Jammu, dismissing the judgment-debtor applicant's appeal from an order of the City Judge, Jammu, refusing to allow the payment of the decretal amount in instalments, on the ground that such an appeal is not competent under O. 43, R. 1(ii) read with O. 20, R. 11(2) of the CPC.

    2. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. There is no such clause as (ii) in the corresponding provisions of O. 43, R. 1 of the CPC as in force in the other States in India. sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43 of our of the CPC runs as follows: “(ii) an order under sub-rule 2, R. 11 of Order passed without the consent of the parties”.

    3. The learned District Judge accepting the contention of the decree-holder non-applicant has held that an appeal by the judgment-debtor from an order rejecting his application to fix instalments for payment of the decretal amount does not fall within this sub-rule.

    4. The main argument of the learned counsel for the non-applicant in support of this order of the learned District Judge is that a reference to sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20, according to him, would show that an order would be made under this sub-rule only if the executing court fixes instalments with or without the consent of the decree-holder as indicated in the sub-rule and that an order refusing to exercise this discretion vested in the executing court under this sub-rule would not be an order under sub-rule (2).

    5. After careful consideration of sub-rule 2 of R. 11 of O. 20 of the CPC and all the other material to which our attention has been drawn by the learned counsel for the non-applicant, we are unable to accept this contention. Both the orders fixing instalments or refusing to fix instalments for the payment of the decretal amount by the executing court would be made under sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20 and an order under this sub-rule would be appealable under O. 43, R. 1(ii) of the CPC if it is passed without the consent of the parties. It would be doing nothing short of violence to the language of sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43 to confine its application to those orders alone by which fixation of instalments for payment of the decretal amount is made.

    6. If the Legislature wanted to confine the right of appeal only to those cases, in which an order granting application for instalments was made, it could have said so specifically to manifest that intention as it has done in so many other clauses of R. 1, O. 43, e.g, sub-clause (d), where an order under R. 13 of O. 9 rejecting an application for an order to set aside a decree passed ex parte has been made appealable. A reference to sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20 of our Code would show that the executing court can fix instalments with, the consent of the decree-holder or without such consent for special reasons which are to be recorded. The words “consent of the parties” appear nowhere in sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20 but in O. 43, R. 1(ii) of the CPC, the words used are “an order under sub-rule (2), R. 11 of O. 20 passed without the consent of the parties”. These words are very wide and include the consent of the judgment-debtor. An order rejecting an application for instalments under the afore-mentioned sub-rule (2) would clearly be against the consent of the judgment-debtor.

    7. A reference to Note 14 of the Chitaley's Code of Civil Procedure (Act V of 1908) under O. 20, R. 11 (1951 Ed at p. 2114) would show that where an order granting a decree for instalments is made under sub-rule (1) of R. 11 of O. 20 it will of course be incorporated in the decree itself and can, therefore, be attacked in an appeal against the decree but where it is not so incorporated the order will not be appealable because that Code as already indicated does not contain provision similar to one incorporated in sub-rule (ii) of R. 1 of O. 43 of our Code referred to above.

    8. In Rangoon and Nagpur, however, sub-rule (2), of R. 11 of O. 20 of Act 5 of 1908 which in other Indian States does not give the executing court power to fix instalments for the payment of the decretal amount without the consent of the decree-holder has been amended and gives the executing court almost similar power as is contained in our sub-rule (2) of R. 11 of O. 20. Some rulings of the Rangoon High Court have been cited before us to show that there both orders allowing an application for instalments or refusing such an application by the executing court have been held to be appealable under Section 47 of the CPC as relating to the execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree within the meaning of that section. But it is not necessary to go into that question as in our view appeal in this case is competent under O. 43, R. 1(ii) of the CPC.

    9. For the foregoing reasons we accept this revision application and setting aside the order of the learned District Judge we direct him to restore the appeal to its original number and dispose of it on its merits and according to law. Costs shall abide the result.

    A/V.B.B

    10. Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Om Prakash v. Jammu And Kashmir Bank Ltd.
    (Dec 8, 1953)