Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Case Summary — Opinion by Gangadhara Menon, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit is for redemption of mortgaged properties described in the plaint as Survey Nos. 556/4A (31 cents) and 556/4B (1 acre and 40 cents). The plaint pleads that these properties originally belonged to the Thuruthiyil Tarwad and were mortgaged on 9-9-1080 by Exhibit A. The plaintiff's father, Kiriyan Kochu Cheriyan, purchased the equity of redemption under Exhibit B from the Thuruthiyil Tarwad; by Exhibit C (partition) and Exhibit D (sale-deed) the equity of redemption devolved on the plaintiff. The defendants are in possession under the Exhibit A mortgage and the plaintiff sued for redemption on payment of the mortgage money due.

At trial the learned Munsif held that Survey No. 556/4A was included in Ex. A and that, notwithstanding that the registry stood in the name of Chirutha Idikali (the first defendant's mother), it was merely an accession to the mortgage holding; the Munsif also held that the defendants, having obtained assignment of Ex. A, were estopped from denying that S. No. 556/4A was redeemable, and awarded mesne profits to the plaintiff at a stated rate until delivery through court.

The present opinion is delivered on appeal by Gangadhara Menon, J., resolving contested questions about (a) whether S. No. 556/4A is an accession to the mortgage holding and thus redeemable, (b) whether the defendants are estopped from denying mortgagor title by reason of assignment, and (c) the mortgage amount and mesne profits recoverable.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Survey No. 556/4A (the 31-cent puthuval registry in favour of Chirutha Idikali) is an accession to the mortgage holding and therefore redeemable by the mortgagor or the plaintiff who holds the equity of redemption.
  2. Whether the defendants, having obtained an assignment of the Exhibit A mortgage/right, are estopped from denying the title of the mortgagor (and hence bound to surrender S. No. 556/4A).
  3. What amount of mortgage money is chargeable on the plaint properties (other than S. No. 556/4A) and what mesne profits should be awarded to the plaintiff pending delivery of those properties.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaint alleges purchase of the equity of redemption (Ex. B) and that the equity of redemption devolved on the plaintiff under Exhibits C and D, entitling the plaintiff to redeem the properties comprised in Ex. A.
  • The plaintiff contended that S. No. 556/4A, though registered in the name of Chirutha Idikali, is an accession to the mortgage holding and therefore the registry benefit enures to the mortgagor (i.e., is redeemable).
  • The plaintiff also argued that the defendants, having obtained an assignment of Ex. A mortgage, are estopped from denying the mortgagor's title and must surrender S. No. 556/4A.

Defendants' Arguments

  • Defendants 1 and 4 contended S. No. 556/4A is a puthuval registry in favour of defendant's mother Chirutha Idikali and that the plaintiff is not entitled to redeem that property.
  • They relied on the documents of registry and the assignment to show that the registry in the name of Chirutha Idikali was independent and that the assignment obtained by them did not include S. No. 556/4A (i.e., the assignment did not transfer any right to S. No. 556/4A under Ex. A).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
30 T.L.R. 105 The principle that a benefit or interest acquired by a mortgagee over mortgaged property is not automatically held in trust for the mortgagor in all circumstances; if the mortgagee obtained the advantage by fraud, unfair practice or behind the mortgagor's back, equity requires surrender to the mortgagor, but if the advantage was acquired after an open contest, by consent, or fairly, the mortgagee may keep it. The court treated this reported ruling as a near-parallel and applied its principle: because the registry in favour of Chirutha Idikali was obtained after an open and fair contest (and the mortgagor's tarwad finally withdrew their contest), the registry did not enure to the mortgagor and therefore was not an accretion to the mortgage holding.
19 T.L.J. 435 (Cited parenthetically in the opinion to support the quoted principle) — the question in such cases is whether circumstances make the mortgagee liable in equity to surrender the advantage to the mortgagor. The court invoked this authority (by reference) to reinforce that no such equitable circumstances (fraud, sharp practice, or unfair dealing) were present, and therefore the mortgagee was not liable to surrender the registry to the mortgagor.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise factual and legal analysis, applying documentary evidence and the cited authorities to the contested issues.

  1. Identification of the documents and properties:
    • Exhibit A (mortgage dated 9-9-1080) is the instrument sought to be redeemed and on its face includes the properties in the two survey numbers (556/4A and 556/4B).
    • Exhibit F (a purakkadam dated 9-12-1065) and the pleading show that the prior mortgage of 1050 covered 10 paras of paddy in lekkoms 1–10 corresponding to Survey No. 556/4B; the parties admitted that S. No. 556/4B is that property.
    • It was admitted that S. No. 556/4A is a puthuval registry in favour of Chirutha Idikali.
  2. On the contention that S. No. 556/4A is an accession to the mortgage holding:
    • The court examined Exhibit III (the revenue authorities' proceedings regarding registry of S. No. 556/4A). Those proceedings showed an application by Chirutha Idikali (filed circa 1072) and a near-10-year contest with Narayanan Aiyappan (mortgagor acting for his tarwad). On 21-2-1080 Narayanan Aiyappan withdrew his contest and thereafter the land was registered in favour of Chirutha Idikali on payment of dues.
    • The court concluded that the registry was obtained after open and fair contest, and there was no evidence of fraud, unfair use of position, or sharp practice by Chirutha Idikali. The mortgagor's withdrawal amounted to consent by the mortgagor's tarwad to the registry in her independent right.
    • Applying the principle from 30 T.L.R. 105 (and as supported by 19 T.L.J. 435), the court held that when the mortgagee secured registry openly and fairly after contest, the registry does not enure to the benefit of the mortgagor; thus S. No. 556/4A was not an accession to the mortgage holding.
  3. On the estoppel/assignment point:
    • The court considered the document by which the Exhibit A mortgage right was assigned in favour of the defendants (the assignment document was produced and marked as an exhibit in the record). That assignment document, as produced, clearly excluded Survey No. 556/4A from the description of transferred rights.
    • The court noted that Exhibit VIII (described as taking in the superior mortgage right created under Ex. A in respect of property originally mortgaged to Chirutha Idikali) corresponds in description to Ex. F (the purakkaddam). Conversely, the additional property 556/4A that was included as an additional property in Ex. A is not included in the assignment document.
    • Because the assignment did not purport to transfer any interest in S. No. 556/4A, the court could not infer that the defendants, by acquiring the superior mortgage right, had admitted any title or interest of the plaintiff or their predecessors in respect of 556/4A. Accordingly, no estoppel arose from the assignment to bar the defendants from asserting ownership of 556/4A.
  4. Consequences for redemption and mesne profits:
    • The court found that the mortgage money chargeable on the plaint items other than S. No. 556/4A is 5,750 fanams (a figure that the respondents stated and which the appellants did not dispute).
    • The court addressed mesne profits: the trial court had awarded 112 paras of paddy and 5 fanams per annum inclusive of S. No. 556/4A. Because the plaintiff was not entitled to recover S. No. 556/4A, the mesne profits had to be reduced proportionately. The court calculated the proportion attributable to S. No. 556/4A as 20 paras and 3 edangalies of paddy per annum, leaving 90 paras and 7 edangalies of paddy and 5 fanams per annum for the remaining plaint properties (as an intermediate calculation in the opinion).
    • In the decretal part the court specified that the plaintiff will recover mesne profits at the rate stated in the order (see Holding below) from the date of deposit of the mortgage money until the date of recovery of the allowed plaint properties; such mesne profits are permitted to be set off against the mortgage money due to the defendants, and only the balance (if any) will be paid to the defendants. The court also fixed valuation of paddy at Rs. 1½ per para as stated by the lower court.
  5. Final directions:
    • In modification of the decree below the court allowed redemption of the plaint items except S. No. 556/4A upon deposit of the mortgage amount of Rs. 5,750 for payment to the defendants and directed the mesne profits adjustment and set-off described above.
    • The court ordered that the parties shall suffer their costs throughout.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART: The court modified the decree below and held that the plaintiff is entitled to redeem the plaint items except the property comprised in Survey No. 556/4A. The plaintiff must deposit the mortgage amount of Rs. 5,750 for payment to the defendants to effect redemption of the allowed properties. The plaintiff's prayer to redeem S. No. 556/4A is disallowed.

Direct Consequences for the Parties

  • The plaintiff may redeem all plaint properties other than S. No. 556/4A on deposit of Rs. 5,750 (this amount being the mortgage money chargeable on those items).
  • The plaintiff is entitled to recover mesne profits for the allowed properties from the date of deposit of the mortgage money until delivery; the mesne profits awarded by the court are to be set off against the mortgage money due to the defendants, and only any balance will be paid to the defendants.
  • Valuation of paddy for computation of mesne profits is fixed at Rs. 1½ per para (as stated by the lower court).
  • The plaintiff's claim to redeem Survey No. 556/4A is rejected and that item remains with the defendants.
  • Each party is to bear their costs throughout (the parties "to suffer their costs throughout").

Broader Implications

The opinion applies established equitable principles (as cited in 30 T.L.R. 105 and 19 T.L.J. 435) to distinguish circumstances where a mortgagee's gain must be held for the mortgagor from circumstances where the mortgagee may retain a registry obtained openly and fairly after contest. The court found no evidence of fraud or sharp practice and therefore refused to convert the registry in the mortgagee's favour into an accretion for the mortgagor. The judgment does not announce a novel legal principle; it applies the cited authorities to the facts and confines relief to the properties and amounts established by the record.

Disposition: Appeal allowed to the extent indicated above; parties to bear costs.

    Parvathi Amma And Another v. Cheriyan Cheriyan .

    Gangadhara Menon, J.:— Defendants 1 and 4 are the appellants. The Suit is for redemption. The properties mentioned in the plaint are comprised in two survey nos. 556/4A measuring 31 cents and 556/4B measuring 1 acre and 40 cents. It is alleged that these properties belonged to the Thuruthiyil Tarwad and they mortgaged them on 9-9-1080 under Ex. A. Kiriyan Kochu Cheriyan, the plaintiff's father, purchased the equity of redemption of the properties under Ex. B from the Thuruthiyil Tarwad. By virtue of Ex. C partition among the children of Kiriyan Koohu Cheriyan and Ex. D sale-deed the equity of redemption devolved on the plaintiff. The defendants are in possession of the plaint schedule properties under Ex. A mortgage. Plaintiff, therefore, sued for redemption of the properties on payment of the mortgage money due.

    2. Defendants 1 and 4 contended that the property comprised in S. No. 556/4A is a puthuval registry in favour of defendant's 1st mother Chirutha Idikali and that the plaintiff is not entitled to redeem this property. The learned Munsif founl that S. No. 556/4A is included in Ex. A mortgage, that even though the property was registered in the name of Chiruha Idikali it is only an accession to the mortgage holding and that the defendants having obtained an assignment of Bx. A mortgage are estopped from contending that S. No. 556/4A is not redeemable. It was also held that the plaintiff is entitled to get mesne profits from the property at the rate of 112 paras of paddy and 5 fanams per annum till delivery of the property through Court.

    3. Exhibit A is the mortgage dated 9-9-1080 sought to be redeemed in this suit. It is executed by Narayanan Aiyappan of Thuruthiyil house in favour of Aiyappan Sankaran. This document includes the entire property comprised in the two S. Nos. 566/4 a and 556/4B. Exhibit A is for 16 paras of paddy land 10 paras of land out of this is stated to be in the possession of the prior mortgagee Chirutha Idikali under the prior mortagage of 1050 and subsequent purakkadams and redemption thereof is directed from the mortgagees. The remaining 6 paras of land included in Ex. A is stated to be in the possession of the mortgagor Narayanan Aiyappan and possession thereof is stated to have been handed over to the mortgagee under Ex. A. Exhibit a shows that the prior mortgage mentioned therein was one executed by Narayanan Krishnan of Thuruthiyil house in favour of one Krishnan Aiyappan of Kaliyikkal house in the year 1050. This mortgage right was assigned in favour of Chirutha Idikali the mother of defendant in the year 1053. Two purakkadams of the years 1065 and 1074 are stated to have been executed subsequently in favour of Chirutha Idikali in respect of this property. Exhibit F dated 9-12-1065 is one of these purakkadams. It clearly states that the property included in the mortgage of 1050 is 10 paras of paddy land in lekkoms 1 to 10. That this is the property comprised in S. No. 556/4B is admitted by the parties. Therefore the property that was directed to be redeemed from the prior mortgagees in Ex. A is S. No. 555/4B. It is also admitted that S. No. 556/4A is a puthuval registry in favour of Chirutha Idikali.

    4. Survey No. 556/4A is sought to be redeemed not on the basis that it is included in the mortgage of 1050 or the subsequent purakkadams but on two other grounds. The first is that though the registry stands in the name of Chirutha Idikali, it is an accession to the mortgage and the benefit of the registry therefore would enure to the mortgagor. The second ground is that the defendants have obtained an assignment of Ex. A mortgage and therefore they are estopped from denying the title of the mortgagors and are bound to surrender the property to them. Therefore the first question for decision is whether S. No. 556/4A is an accession to the mortgage holding as contended for by the plaintiff. Exhibit III is the copy of the proceedings before the revenue authorities in connection with the registry of S. No. 556/4A measuring 31 cents. It is seen from Ex. III that the application of Chirutha Idikali for the registry of the land which appears to have been filed in 1072 was pending disposal for nearly 10 years due to the contest of Narayanan Aiyappan one of the mortgagers on behalf of his tarwad. Various statements of the contesting parties have been recorded by the revenue authorities. On 21-2-1080 Narayanan Aiyappan gave up contest through a statement recorded before the revenue authorities. Thereafter the land was ordered to be registered in the name of Chirutha Idikali on payment of the tharavila and other amounts due. In pursuance of this order the land was registered in her name. The facts that come out clearly from Ex. 111 proceedings are that the mortgagor's tarwad pressed their claims for the registry of the land in favour of their tarwad as against the mortgagee and that after a keen contest, for nearly 10 years they finally gave up the contest and thereafter the land was registered in favour of Chirutha Idikali in pursuance to the claims put forward by her in her own independent right for the registry of the land. The ruling reported in 30 T.L.R 105 is almost a parallel case. It was held therein that:

    “It is not an absolute rule that a benefit or interest acquired by a mortgagee over the mortgaged property, in all cases and whatever the circumstances be, must be held in trust for the benefit of the mortgagor. If the mortgagee, by fraud or unfair or sharp practice, or behind the back of the mortgagor, obtains an advantage to the prejudice of the right of redemption, which, though not legally due under, has yet its root in, the mortgage, that advantage must be held for the benefit of the mortgagor. But it is open to the mortgagee to show that he acquired the advantage by the mortgagor's consent, or after a contest with him before the grant of the advantage, or otherwise so openly and fairly that he is equitably entitled to keep it.”

    5. It is clear from the facts and circumstances of this case, that the registry in question was obtained after open and fair contest with the mortgagor. There is nothing in this case to show that Chirutha Idikali made any unfair use of her position as mortgagee of S. No. 556/4B. The fact that Narayanan Aiyappan alter ten years of persistent endeavour to get the registry in favour of his reward as against Chirutha Idikali withdrew from the contest evidently allowing the registry to be made in favour of the rival claimant cannot lead to the inference of any sharp practice by Chirutha Idikali. At best it will only amount to a consent given by the mortgagor's tarwad to the claims of Chirutha Idikali for the registry of the land in her favour in her own independent right. As has been held in 30 T.L.R 105 the registry under such circumstances will not enure to the benefit of the mortgagor. The question in each case is

    “whether the circumstances in which the mortgagee secured the registry are such as to make him liable in equity to surrender it in favour of his mortgagor.”

    6. (Vide, 19 T.L.J 435). We do not see any such circumstances in this case. We are, therefore, unable to accept the plaintiff's case that S. No. 556/4 A is an accretion to the mortgage holding and that the defendants are liable to surrender that property to the mortgagors.

    7. The next ground that is urged is that the defendants have obtained an assignment of Ex. A mortgage and that by virtue of the assignment they are estopped from denying the title of the mortgager. As has already been stated Ex. A undoubtedly covers both S. No. 556/4-A and B. The document under which Ex. A right is said to have been assigned in favour of the defendants has been produced before us and we have marked it as Ex. III in the case. This document clearly shows that S. No. 556/4-A is not included therein. Exhibit Vin takes in only the superior mortgage right created under Ex. A in respect of the property that was originally mortgaged to Chirutha Idikali and was already in her possession. The description of the property in Ex. VIII is the same as that contained in Ex. F purakkaddam taken by Chirutha Idikali, Survey No. 556/4-A which is included as an additional property in Ex. A mortgage and which is stated to have been surrendered to the mortgagee under Ex. A is not included in Ex. III. Exhibit VIII does not purport to transfer any interest that the mortgagees got under Ex. A in respect of S. No. 666/4-A. Therefore, it is not possible to infer on the basis of Ex. VIII that the defendants have in any way admitted that the plaintiff or their predecessor-in-interest had any title to or interest in the property comprised in S. No. 556/4-A. There is, therefore, no bar by estoppel as contended for by the respondents. It follows that plaint Item S. No. 556/4-A belongs to the defendants and that the plaintiff is not entitled to recover that property from the defendants. They can redeem only the other properties in the plaint schedule.

    8. Next the amount chargeable on the properties that the plaintiff can recover has to be determined. The amount covered by the mortgage assigned in favour of Chirutha Idikali and the subsequent purakkadaros in her favour in respect of the properties, i.e, the plaint properties other than S. No. 556/4-A is stated by the respondent to be 5750 fanams. This is not disputed by the appellants. We hold that the mortgage money charged on these items is only 5750 fanams. The question of mesne profits has next to be considered. The Court below has awarded mesne profits to the plaintiff from the date of deposit of the mortgage money till date of recovery of the property at the rate 112 paras of paddy and 5 fanams per annum. This is inclusive of the profits of S. No. 556/4-A which is 31 cents in extent. We have already found that plaintiff is not entitled to recover this property. The mesne profits awarded has, therefore, to be reduced proportionately. The proportionate profits for S. No. 556/4-A will be 20 paras and 3 edangalies of paddy per annum. The mesne profits for the remaining portion of the plaint properties will be 90 paras and 7 edangalies of paddy and 5 fanams per annum. The plaintiff will be entitled to recover mesne profits at this rate from the date of deposit of the mortgage money till the date of recovery of the plaint property other than S. No. 558/4 A.

    9. In the result in modification of the decree of the Court below, the plaintiff is allowed to redeem plaint item except the property comprised in S. No. 556/4-A, on deposit of the mortgage amount of Rs. 5750 for payment to the defendants. Plaintiff will recover from the defendants mesne profits at the rate of 91 paras and 7 edangalies of paddy and 5 fanams per annum from the date of deposit of mortgage money till the date of recovery of the property allowed to be recovered. The mesne profits decreed is allowed to be set off from the mortgage money due to the defendants and the balance of the mortgage mount, it any, will alone be paid to the defendants. The paddy will be valued at Rs. 1½ per para and as stated by the lower Court. The plaintiff's prayer for redemption of plaint Item S. No. 556/4-A is disallowed.

    10. The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated above. In the circumstances of this case we direct, the parties to suffer their costs throughout.

    11. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Parvathi Amma And Another v. Cheriyan Cheriyan .
    (Aug 18, 1950)