AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not mentioned, but 'the official records' and 'disciplinary proceedings' are mentioned which could be related to some act or article
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not mentioned, but 'the official records' and 'disciplinary proceedings' are mentioned which could be related to some act or article
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a Member of the U.P. Higher Judicial Service and then Additional District & Sessions Judge, Moradabad, sought expungement of severe strictures recorded against him by the High Court of Allahabad in Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 (U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Lajja Ram). The High Court had:

  • Allowed the second appeal, reversed the decrees of the courts below, and imposed exemplary costs.
  • Directed that “severe strictures” against the trial and first appellate judges be placed on their service records and sent to the Hon’ble Chief Justice for consideration of disciplinary proceedings.

The appellant contended that he had not decided the suit or first appeal on merits; he had only adjudicated twelve additional issues on remand. After the High Court refused to modify its judgment (except to say it had no intention of recommending disciplinary proceedings against him), he filed the present appeals by special leave limited to expunging the adverse remarks.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in making severe strictures against the appellant in its judgment dated 1-3-2012.
  2. Whether the direction to forward the judgment to the Chief Justice for possible disciplinary action was legally sustainable.
  3. Whether disposing of the appellant’s modification application without expunging the offending remarks, and without affording him an opportunity of explanation, was proper.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • He neither decided the suit as the trial judge nor decided the first appeal; he only determined twelve additional issues on remand.
  • The High Court furnished no independent findings identifying any fault in his limited adjudication.
  • The strictures were passed without notice or opportunity to explain, contrary to settled law protecting judicial officers.
  • Retention of the remarks would irreparably damage his 30-year unblemished service record and future career prospects.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Parkash Singh Teji v. Northern India Goods Transport Co. (P) Ltd. (2009) 12 SCC 577 No adverse remarks should be made against a judicial officer without giving the officer an opportunity to be heard; such remarks may be expunged on appeal. Relied upon as a factually similar case to justify expunging the High Court’s strictures against the appellant.
Amar Pal Singh v. State of U.P. (2012) 6 SCC 491 High Courts must avoid harsh or disparaging observations against subordinate judges unless essential for deciding the case; unjustified remarks should be deleted. Cited to reinforce the principle that higher courts should refrain from unnecessary strictures and to support removal of the remarks entered in the appellant’s service record.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reiterated the “settled legal position” that no adverse remark can be made against a judicial officer without first offering an opportunity to explain. Drawing on the principles from Parkash Singh Teji and Amar Pal Singh, the Court reasoned as follows:

  • The High Court’s judgment used the expression “severe strictures” yet provided no logical reasoning or factual basis identifying the appellant’s fault.
  • The appellant had not rendered the original decision or the first appellate judgment; he merely decided additional issues on remand, reducing any possible basis for criticism.
  • Harsh or disparaging remarks that are irrelevant to the decision and potentially career-damaging should be avoided and, where recorded without due process, expunged.
  • Expunging the remarks would not affect the High Court’s ultimate decision on the merits of the civil dispute; therefore, removal was appropriate.

On this analysis, the Court concluded that the strictures were “neither justified nor called for” and violated the protective standards accorded to judicial officers.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The adverse remarks and directions against the appellant contained in the High Court’s judgments dated 1-3-2012 and 23-4-2012 are set aside; the appeals are allowed to that extent. No order as to costs.

Implications: The appellant’s service record remains unblemished, and no disciplinary proceedings will stem from the impugned High Court order. The decision reaffirms existing Supreme Court jurisprudence that higher courts must exercise restraint in criticising subordinate judiciary and must afford them an opportunity to be heard before recording adverse remarks; however, it establishes no new legal doctrine beyond that reinforcement.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Awani Kumar Upadhyay v. High Court Of Judicature Of Allahabad And Others

    P. Sathasivam, J.— Leave granted. These appeals arise from the judgment and final orders dated 1-3-2012 and 23-4-2012 passed by the High Court of Judicature of Allahabad in U.P Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Lajja Ram Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 and U.P Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Lajja Ram respectively, whereby the High Court, while allowing the second appeal, passed severe strictures against the appellant herein and forwarded a copy of its judgment to the Hon'ble Chief Justice of the High Court to consider as to whether disciplinary proceedings are warranted against him?

    2. The case of the appellant, in brief, is as under: The appellant, who is a Member of the U.P Higher Judicial Service, is posted as the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Moradabad and, according to him, he is having unblemished service career and has successfully completed 30 years of service. The High Court, while allowing Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 titled U.P Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Lajja Ram Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000, passed severe strictures against the appellant herein in the judgment which, according to him, are ultimately going to affect permanently not only his reputation but also his entire service career.

    3. It is the claim of the appellant that in Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000, he has not rendered any judgment as the trial court Judge or as the first appellate court Judge. According to him, a suit bearing No. 418 of 1997 was filed by Shri Lajja Ram against the U.P Avas Evam Vikas Parishad, Lucknow and another and the said suit was decided by one learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Ghaziabad presided over by Shri Chaturbhuj by a judgment and order dated 2-5-1997. Aggrieved by the said judgment, a first appeal was filed being First Appeal No. 105 of 1997 in the Court of Shri A.K Aggarwal, Second Additional District & Sessions Judge, Ghaziabad. The first appellate court framed 12 additional issues and on those additional issues, the matter was remanded to the Court of the appellant as he was working as the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Ghaziabad. Thereafter, in compliance with the order of the first appellate court, after recording the evidence of the parties, the appellant recorded the evidence of the parties and gave his findings on 31-5-1999.

    4. It is the case of the appellant that in the impugned judgment and order, the High Court has neither furnished any independent finding on the issues which were determined by the appellant herein nor anything about his ultimate decision. The present appeal is confined only to the portion wherein the High Court has made certain strictures. The appellant has also asserted that the High Court has not considered that the appellant has not rendered any decision as the trial Judge or as the Judge of the first appellate court. On the direction by the first appellate court, only 12 additional issues were adjudicated by the appellant. Inasmuch as “severe strictures”, if allowed to stand, would affect his entire future prospects of service, he approached this Court by filing this appeal by way of special leave.

    5. While answering the substantial questions of law, namely, 3, 4, 5 and 6, the High Court decided the same in favour of the appellants therein and against the respondents. Ultimately, both the second appeals were allowed with exemplary costs of Rs 5 lakhs in Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 and Rs 1 lakh in Second Appeal No. 1445 of 2000. The High Court ultimately set aside the decrees passed by the courts below and dismissed both the suits. The High Court also directed that an FIR be lodged immediately against the plaintiffs for malicious prosecution and manipulation in the official records. After issuing such directions the High Court passed the following order Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000, with which we are concerned in these appeals:

    “Severe stricture is passed against the Judge of the trial court as well as of the lower appellate court for passing extremely illegal and unjust judgments and decrees. A copy of this judgment shall be placed in their service records and be also sent to the Hon'ble the Chief Justice to consider as to whether disciplinary proceedings are warranted against them.”

    6. On coming to know of the strictures and the ultimate direction of the High Court, the appellant filed a Civil Misc. Modification Application No. 122702 of 2012 in Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 for expunging the remarks made in the judgment dated 1-3-2012 Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000. The High Court, after hearing the counsel for the judicial officer without modifying the judgment, observed that “I did not intend to make any suggestion for initiating disciplinary proceedings against the Judge who had decided the remitted issues only”, and by saying so disposed of the said application, however, permitted the appellant to make representation on the administrative side of the High Court. Not satisfied with the same, the appellant has filed the above appeal for a limited purpose of expunging those adverse remarks.

    7. Heard Mr Harshvir Pratap Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr Ravi Prakash Mehrotra, learned counsel for the Registrar General, High Court of Allahabad. In the present appeals, the other parties have been shown only as pro forma respondents.

    8. The questions which arise for consideration are:

    8.1 Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the High Court was justified in making severe strictures and directions against the appellant in its judgment dated 1-3-2012 Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000?

    8.2 Whether the direction to send the impugned judgment Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 to the Hon'ble Chief Justice of the High Court with a request to consider whether disciplinary proceedings are warranted against the appellant herein was justified?

    8.3 Whether the High Court is justified in disposing of the application for modification without expunging the offending portion which was made without affording opportunity to the appellant?

    9. It is settled legal position that no adverse remarks can be made against any judicial officer without giving an opportunity to explain the conduct. It is useful to refer a decision of this Court in Parkash Singh Teji v. Northern India Goods Transport Co. (P) Ltd. (2009) 12 SCC 577 which is identical to the case on hand. In the above decision, the directions of the High Court in its order dated 6-7-2006 read as under:

    “10. … ‘Before parting, we wish to make it clear that the learned Judge who passed the impugned judgment and decree need be careful in future, rather than adopting a hasty, slipshod and perfunctory approach as is manifest from the judgment delivered by him in this case. We further direct that a copy of this order shall be placed on the personal/service record of the officer, while another copy be placed before the Hon'ble Inspecting Judge of the officer for His Lordship's perusal.’”

    According to the appellant, by making such remarks and that too behind his back, are not warranted. Here again, after adverting to the earlier decisions and principles enunciated therein, this Court expunged the offending remarks made against the appellant and allowed the appeal filed by him.

    10. Apart from the above decision, in an identical circumstance, this Court has expunged adverse remarks made against a judicial officer in Amar Pal Singh v. State of U.P (2012) 6 SCC 491:

    10.1 The appellant therein, a judicial officer, being aggrieved by the comments and observations passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Judicature of Allahabad in Sunil Solanki v. State of U.P Criminal Revision No. 1541 of 2007 had preferred an appeal before this Court. In that case, one Sunil Solanki had filed an application under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bulandshahar with the allegation that on 11-2-2007 at 9.30 p.m when he was standing outside the front door of his house along with some others, a marriage procession passed from in front of the door of his house and at that juncture, one Mauzzim Ali accosted him and eventually fired at him from his country-made pistol which caused injuries in the abdomen area of Shafeeque, one of his friends. However, he escaped unhurt. Because of the said occurrence, Sunil Solanki endeavoured hard to get the FIR registered at the police station concerned but the entire effort became an exercise in futility as a consequence of which he was compelled to knock at the doors of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate by filing an application under Section 156(3) of the Code for issuance of a direction to the police to register an FIR and investigate the matter. While dealing with the application, the Chief Judicial Magistrate, the appellant in that appeal, ascribed certain reasons and dismissed the same.

    10.2 Being dissatisfied, the complainant therein (Sunil Solanki) preferred a revision before the High Court and the learned Single Judge, taking note of the allegations made in the application, found that it was a fit case where the learned Magistrate should have directed the registration of FIR and investigation into the alleged offences. While recording such a conclusion, the learned Single Judge has made certain observations which are reproduced below:

    “This conduct of the Chief Judicial Magistrate is deplorable and wholly mala fide and illegal.”

    Thereafter, the learned Single Judge treated the order to be wholly hypothetical and commented it was:

    “Vexatiously illegal.”

    After stating so the learned Single Judge further stated that the Chief Judicial Magistrate has committed a blatant error of law. Thereafter, he further commented:

    “… and has done unpardonable injustice to the injured and the informant. His lack of sensitivity and utter callous attitude has left the accused of murderous assault to go scot-free to this day.”

    10.3 After making the aforesaid observations, the learned Single Judge set aside the order and remitted the matter to the Chief Judicial Magistrate to decide the application afresh in accordance with law. Thereafter, he directed as follows:

    “Let a copy of this order be sent to the Administrative Judge, Bulandshahar to take appropriate action against the Chief Judicial Magistrate concerned as he deems fit.”

    Aggrieved by the said direction, the appellant in Amar Pal Singh case (2012) 6 SCC 491 approached this Court by way of a special leave petition to delete the aforesaid comments, observations and the ultimate direction.

    10.4 After referring to all the various earlier decisions of this Court on this point, this Court in Amar Pal Singh case (2012) 6 SCC 491 expunged the remarks and set aside the said observation/comments and the direction made against the judicial officer. This Court also directed that if the said remarks have been entered into the annual confidential roll of the judicial officer, the same shall stand expunged and also marked a copy of the judgment to the Registrar General of the High Court, Allahabad to be placed on the personal file of the judicial officer concerned.

    11. It is made clear that we are not undermining the ultimate decision of the High Court on merits. However, we are constrained to observe that the higher courts every day come across orders of the lower courts which are not justified either in law or in fact and modify them or set them aside. Our legal system acknowledges the fallibility of the Judges, hence it provides appeals and revisions. Inasmuch as the lower judicial officers mostly work under a charged atmosphere and are constantly under psychological pressure and they do not have the facilities which are available in the higher courts, we are of the view that the remarks/observations and strictures are to be avoided particularly if the officer has no occasion to put forth his reasonings. Further, if the passage complained of is wholly irrelevant and unjustifiable and its retention on the records will cause serious harm to the persons to whom it refers and its expunction will not affect the reasons for the judgment or order, request for expunging those remarks are to be allowed. We, once again, reiterate that harsh or disparaging remarks are not to be made against judicial officers and authorities whose conduct comes into consideration before the courts of law unless it is really for the decision of the case as an integral part thereof.

    12. We hold that the adverse remarks made against the appellant were neither justified nor called for. The perusal of the impugned judgment would show that the word “severe strictures” is mentioned whereas no logical reasoning has been given as to what is the fault of the appellant and the High Court has not adduced any finding as to why it has disagreed with the reasoning given by the appellant particularly when the appellant asserted that neither he has rendered any decision as the trial court Judge nor as the first appellate court Judge except deciding 12 additional issues on the directions issued by his predecessor. The strictures passed against the appellant are neither warranted nor are in conformity with the settled law as propounded by this Court.

    13. Under these circumstances, the adverse remarks passed in the impugned judgment and the final orders dated 1-3-2012 Second Appeal No. 1444 of 2000 and 23-4-2012 insofar as the appellant is concerned are set aside. Since these appeals are confined only for expunging the strictures, the same are allowed as pointed above. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Awani Kumar Upadhyay v. High Court Of Judicature Of Allahabad And Others
    (Feb 13, 2013)