Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant (Respondent 1) alleged that the appellant borrowed Rs 1,50,000 and issued a cheque dated 20-6-2001 drawn on Indian Overseas Bank, Plankamon Branch. Upon presentation through the Pathanamthitta District Co-operative Bank, the cheque was returned with the endorsement “insufficient funds in the account”. After the statutory notice dated 14-7-2001—admittedly received on 16-7-2001—went unanswered, the complainant lodged a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pathanamthitta.

At trial, the complainant testified as PW 1 and produced Exhibits P-1 to P-6. The appellant led no evidence. In his Section 313 CrPC statement, the appellant claimed his son had taken the cheque and that any liability lay with the son. The Chief Judicial Magistrate identified multiple deficiencies in the complainant’s evidence—particularly on the date and source of the alleged loan and on authorship of the cheque entries—and acquitted the appellant under Section 255(1) CrPC.

The complainant appealed. The High Court of Kerala (Criminal Appeal No. 452 of 2004) reversed the acquittal, invoked the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act, convicted the appellant, and directed him to pay Rs 1,50,000 as compensation, with three months’ simple imprisonment in default. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges that reversal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in reversing the trial court’s acquittal of the appellant under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  2. Whether, on the evidence adduced, the statutory presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act could be validly invoked against the appellant.
  3. Whether the complainant had discharged his burden of proving the existence of a legally enforceable debt and the authenticity of the cheque.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised the evidentiary record accepted by the trial court and identified “vital defects” in the complainant’s case:

  • The complainant could not recall the date on which the alleged loan was advanced.
  • No documentary proof of the funds—purportedly from sale of family property and a co-operative society loan—was produced despite an undertaking to do so.
  • His testimony on who filled in the cheque was internally contradictory; at different points he asserted that the appellant wrote it, that he himself wrote it, and that only the amount in words was in his handwriting.
  • There was no evidence that the appellant consented to any alteration or filling in of the cheque.

The trial court had relied on these deficiencies to acquit. The Supreme Court held that the High Court overlooked these material contradictions and relied solely on two factors: (i) the appellant’s failure to assert in Section 313 CrPC questioning that he had given a blank cheque to his son, and (ii) his failure to reply to the statutory notice. According to the Supreme Court, these considerations were insufficient to override the trial court’s detailed evaluation of evidence.

The Court emphasised that, before the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act can assist the complainant, he must first establish factual foundations: possession of funds, actual advancement of the loan, and issuance of the cheque in discharge of that liability. On the record, those foundational facts were not proved. Consequently, the High Court’s finding that the appellant failed to rebut the presumptions was characterised as “perverse”.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgment set aside; conviction and sentence against the appellant quashed.

Direct consequence: the appellant stands acquitted and need not pay the Rs 1,50,000 compensation, nor face the default imprisonment. The decision reinstates the trial court’s acquittal but sets no new legal precedent beyond reaffirming that appellate courts must critically evaluate evidentiary shortcomings before invoking presumptions under the Negotiable Instruments Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    John K. Abraham v. Simon C. Abraham And Another

    F.M Ibrahim Kalifulla, J.— Leave granted. This appeal is directed against the judgment of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam dated 15-12-2010 passed in Simon C. Abraham v. State of Kerala Criminal Appeal No. 452 of 2004.

    2. The issue involved in this appeal arises under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The complaint was preferred by Respondent 1 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pathanamthitta alleging that the appellant borrowed a sum of Rs 1,50,000 from him and issued a cheque for the said sum on 20-6-2001 drawn on Indian Overseas Bank, Plankamon Branch in discharge of the debt. It is the further case of the respondent complainant that when the cheque was presented for encashment through Pathanamthitta District Co-operative Bank, Kozhencherry Branch, the same was returned by the bankers with the endorsement “insufficient funds in the account” of the accused. The respondent complainant stated to have issued a lawyer's notice on 14-7-2001, which was received by the appellant on 16-7-2001, but yet there was no reply from the appellant. Based on the above averments alleged in the complaint, the case was tried by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate.

    3. The respondent herein was examined as PW 1 and Exts. P-1 to P-6 were marked. None was examined on the side of the appellant. In the questioning of the appellant made under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant took the stand that his son took the cheque from him and that if at all anything was to be recovered, it had to be made from the son of the appellant, since the appellant had not borrowed any money.

    4. The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate after considering the oral and documentary evidence led on behalf of the respondent complainant, held that the respondent complainant was making a prevaricating statement as regards the issuance of the cheque, that he was not even aware of the date when the amount was said to have been borrowed by the appellant, that there was material alteration in the instrument and, therefore, the respondent failed to establish a case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Consequently, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate found the appellant not guilty and acquitted him under Section 255(1) CrPC. The respondent preferred the appeal in the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam and by the impugned order Criminal Appeal No. 452 of 2004 the High Court reversed the judgment of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, convicted the appellant and imposed the sentence to pay a fine of Rs 1,50,000 as compensation under Section 357(1) CrPC. In default of making the payment of the fine amount, the appellant was directed to suffer simple imprisonment for a period of three months.

    5. We have heard Mr Romy Chacko, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr Jogy Scaria, learned counsel for the second respondent. We have also perused the material papers placed before us, including the judgment of the trial court as well as the High Court. Having considered the above, we are of the view that the High Court was in error in having reversed the judgment of the trial court.

    6. When we examine the case of the respondent complainant as projected before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate and the material evidence placed before the trial court, we find that the trial court had noted certain vital defects in the case of the respondent complainant. Such defects noted by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate were as under:

    6.1 Though the respondent as PW 1 deposed that the accused received the money at his house also stated that he did not remember the date when the said sum of Rs 1,50,000 was paid to him.

    6.2 As regards the source for advancing the sum of Rs 1,50,000, the respondent claimed that the same was from and out of the sale consideration of his share in the family property, apart from a sum of Rs 50,000, which he availed by way of loan from the co-operative society of the college where he was employed. Though the respondent stated before the court below that he would be in a position to produce the documents in support of the said stand, it was noted that no documents were placed before the court below.

    6.3 In the course of cross-examination, the respondent stated that the cheque was signed on the date when the payment was made, nevertheless he stated that he was not aware of the date when he paid the sum of Rs 1,50,000.

    6.4 According to the respondent, the cheque was in the handwriting of the accused himself and the very next moment he made a contradictory statement that the cheque was not in the handwriting of the appellant and that he (complainant) wrote the same.

    6.5 The respondent also stated that the amount in words was written by him.

    6.6 The trial court has also noted that it was not the case of the respondent that the writing in the cheque and filling up of the figures were with the consent of the appellant-accused.

    7. In the light of the above evidence, which was lacking in very many material particulars, apart from the contradictions therein, the trial court held that the appellant was not guilty of the offence alleged against under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and acquitted him.

    8. Keeping the above factors in mind, when we examine the judgment impugned in this appeal, we find that the High Court committed a serious illegality in reversing the judgment of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate. While reversing the judgment of the trial court, what weighed with the learned Judge of the High Court was that in the Section 313 CrPC questioning, it was not the case of the appellant that a blank signed cheque was handed over to his son and that even in the cross-examination it was not suggested to PW 1 that a blank cheque was issued. The High Court was also persuaded by the fact that the appellant failed to send any reply to the lawyer's notice, issued by the respondent. Based on the above conclusions, the High Court held that the presumption under Sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act could be easily drawn and that the appellant failed to rebut the said presumption. On that single factor, the learned Judge of the High Court reversed the judgment of the trial Judge and convicted the appellant.

    9. It has to be stated that in order to draw the presumption under Section 118 read along with Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the burden was heavily upon the complainant to have shown that he had the required funds for having advanced the money to the accused; that the issuance of the cheque in support of the said payment advanced was true and that the accused was bound to make the payment as had been agreed while issuing the cheque in favour of the complainant.

    10. Keeping the said statutory requirements in mind, when we examine the facts as admitted by the respondent complainant, as rightly concluded by the learned trial Judge, the respondent was not even aware of the date when substantial amount of Rs 1,50,000 was advanced by him to the appellant, that he was not sure as to who wrote the cheque, that he was not even aware when exactly and where exactly the transaction took place for which the cheque came to be issued by the appellant. Apart from the said serious lacuna in the evidence of the complainant, he further admitted as PW 1 by stating once in the course of the cross-examination that the cheque was in the handwriting of the accused and the very next moment taking a diametrically opposite stand that it is not in the handwriting of the accused and that it was written by the complainant himself, by further reiterating that the amount in words was written by him.

    11. We find that the various defects in the evidence of the respondent, as noted by the trial court, which we have set out in para 6 of the judgment, were simply brushed aside by the High Court without assigning any valid reason. Such a serious lacuna in the evidence of the complainant, which strikes at the root of a complaint under Section 138, having been noted by the learned trial Judge, which factor was failed to be examined by the High Court while reversing the judgment of the trial court, in our considered opinion would vitiate the ultimate conclusion reached by it. In effect, the conclusion of the learned Judge of the High Court would amount to a perverse one and, therefore, the said judgment of the High Court cannot be sustained.

    12. Having regard to our above conclusion, this appeal stands allowed. The order impugned is set aside, the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant is also set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    John K. Abraham v. Simon C. Abraham And Another
    (Dec 5, 2013)