Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8 of the Evidence Act, 1872
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8 of the Evidence Act, 1872
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 8 June 1997, Lal Singh, a tea-shop owner, lodged an FIR at Police Station Adarsh Nagar, Ajmer, reporting that a 13–14-year-old boy was found dead in a pool of blood near a culvert on Bypass Road, Sedariya Tiraha. The police registered a case under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and, after investigation, filed a charge-sheet against the appellant, Vivek Kalra.

The trial court convicted the appellant of murder on the basis of circumstantial evidence and sentenced him to life imprisonment with a fine of ₹1,000. The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, affirmed the conviction and sentence in Criminal Appeal No. 602 of 2002 on 25 October 2004. The present appeal before the Supreme Court challenges that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the chain of circumstantial evidence established by the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant alone committed the murder of Ankit Kalra.
  2. Whether the absence of a proven motive and the alleged possibility of another assailant (one “Munna”) created reasonable doubt necessitating acquittal.
  3. Whether discrepancies between the medical evidence (Injuries 8 and 9) and the alleged weapon (a dantli) undermined the prosecution case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The High Court wrongly inferred motive from PW 11’s testimony regarding an ₹80,000 fixed deposit; revenge was not proved.
  • PW 5 testified that the appellant had “good behaviour” and “no bad habit,” suggesting improbability of his involvement.
  • According to PW 5, the appellant stated that “Munna and his 2–4 associates” had assaulted the deceased, raising an alternative hypothesis of another perpetrator.
  • Medical witness PW 22 (Dr B.K. Mathur) opined that Injuries 8 and 9 could not have been caused by a dantli, creating doubt about the weapon and, by extension, the assailant.

State's Arguments

  • PW 6 (brother of the deceased) stated the appellant took the deceased on a scooter on 7 June 1997 to “get a cassette,” after which the boy never returned.
  • PW 5 corroborated PW 6, confirming both the appellant’s visit and the child’s disappearance.
  • PW 28, an employee of V.K. Video Movies, testified that the appellant rented a “Judwaa” cassette between 8:00 p.m. and 8:30 p.m. on 7 June 1997 and never returned it.
  • PW 7 witnessed recovery of a blood-stained dantli at the scene.
  • PW 13, a blacksmith, identified the recovered dantli as the one he sold to the appellant for ₹110 the previous day.
  • PW 22 stated that Injuries 1–7, which were sufficient to cause death, could be inflicted by the seized dantli.
  • Taken together, these circumstances form a complete chain pointing only to the appellant’s guilt.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ujjagar Singh v. State of Punjab (2007) 13 SCC 90 Absence of motive does not necessarily vitiate conviction based on a complete chain of circumstantial evidence. Relied upon to hold that, even though motive was not firmly proved, the established circumstances were sufficient to sustain conviction.
Vikramjit Singh @ Vicky v. State of Punjab (2006) 12 SCC 306 Conduct of an accused is relevant under Section 8 of the Evidence Act only if it has nexus with the crime. Used to reject reliance on appellant’s general “good behaviour” as irrelevant to guilt determination.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court agreed that motive was not convincingly established but emphasized that motive is merely a relevant, not indispensable, factor when other circumstances form an unbroken chain pointing to guilt.

Key links in the chain included:

  • Last-seen evidence: PW 6 and PW 5 confirmed the appellant took the deceased on the evening preceding discovery of the body.
  • Rental of the cassette corroborated the appellant’s presence with the deceased around the relevant time.
  • Recovery of a blood-stained dantli at the scene, identified by PW 13 as sold to the appellant the previous day.
  • Medical testimony (PW 22) showing Injuries 1–7, collectively sufficient to cause death, were consistent with the dantli.

The Court held that discrepancies regarding Injuries 8 and 9 did not break the chain because the fatal injuries (1–7) were clearly attributable to the weapon linked to the appellant. The Court further ruled that evidence of “good behaviour” lacked nexus to the crime and was therefore irrelevant. Applying the principles from Ujjagar Singh and Vikramjit Singh, the Court concluded that the circumstantial evidence proved the appellant’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed; conviction and sentence of life imprisonment with ₹1,000 fine affirmed.

Immediate effect: the appellant remains convicted under Section 302 IPC. Broader implication: the judgment reiterates that (1) absence of proved motive is not fatal where circumstantial evidence is compelling, and (2) general good character evidence is immaterial unless it bears direct nexus to the offence. No new legal doctrine was created, but existing principles on circumstantial evidence and relevancy of conduct were reaffirmed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Vivek Kalra v. State Of Rajasthan .

    A.K Patnaik, J.— This is an appeal against the judgment dated 25-10-2004 of the Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, in Vivek Kalra v. State Criminal Appeal No. 602 of 2002, maintaining the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) and the sentence of life imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1000 for the offence.

    2. The facts very briefly are that on 8-6-1997 at about 8.30 a.m, one Lal Singh, who was running a tea shop at Bypass Road, Sedariya Tiraha, lodged an FIR with Police Station Adarsh Nagar, Ajmer. In the FIR, he stated that at about 8.00 a.m on 8-6-1997 one truck driver told him that ahead of Shantinath Dharm Kanta, on the wall of pulia (small bridge) one boy has been murdered and laid down and he went there to see and found that one boy, aged about 13-14 years, was lying dead in a pool of blood and several persons had gathered there. The police registered a case under Section 302 IPC, and after investigation, the police filed a charge-sheet against the appellant under Section 302 IPC.

    3. At the trial, the prosecution did not examine any eyewitness to the murder of the deceased, but produced circumstantial evidence to establish that the appellant had committed the murder of the deceased and the trial court convicted the appellant. On appeal, the High Court held in the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 602 of 2002 that after the death of his father the appellant was living with his uncle, Gurcharan Kalra, and there was a fixed deposit in his name of Rs 80,000, but as Gurcharan Kalra decided to utilise the fixed deposit only at the time of marriage of the appellant, in order to take revenge, the appellant purchased a dantli, took Ankit Kalra, the son of Gurcharan Kalra, on a scooter on the evening of 7-6-1997 to get a cassette, and committed the murder of Ankit Kalra, left the scene of incident, reached Jaipur and got himself admitted to a hospital there on 8-6-1997 for treatment saying that he has met with an accident.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the finding of the High Court in the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 602 of 2002 on the motive of the appellant to commit the offence is based on the evidence of Gurcharan Kalra, PW 11, about the fixed deposit of Rs 80,000 of the appellant, which the appellant used to demand, but from this evidence the High Court could not have come to the conclusion that the motive of the appellant was to take revenge by killing the deceased. He next submitted that PW 5 has admitted in his evidence that the appellant had a good behaviour and had no bad habit and, therefore, it is quite probable that the appellant has not committed the offence. He further submitted that PW 5 has clearly said that when he made the enquiry from the appellant about the deceased Ankit, he had told him that he had been assaulted by Munna and his 2 to 4 associates and caused injuries. He submitted that it is quite possible that Munna may have killed the deceased and that the appellant had not committed the murder. He further submitted that the medical evidence of PW 22, Dr B.K Mathur, is clear that Injuries 8 and 9 could not have been caused by dantli. He submitted that since the prosecution case is that the appellant used a dantli to cause the death of the deceased, this medical evidence creates sufficient doubt on the prosecution case.

    5. The learned counsel appearing for the State, on the other hand, supported the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 602 of 2002 of the High Court by relying on the following circumstances:

    (i) PW 6 has stated that in the evening of 7-6-1997 when his parents had gone to the market and he was playing with the deceased, the appellant came to their house and took the deceased with him saying that they will come back after getting a cassette, but thereafter the deceased did not come back home.
    (ii) PW 5, the father of PW 6, has corroborated the evidence of PW 6 that at about 7.00 p.m in the evening of 7-6-1997, he and his wife had gone to the market for shopping and when they came back home at about 9.00 p.m, PW 6 told them that the appellant took the deceased on a scooter on the pretext of taking a cassette.
    (iii) PW 28 has deposed that he used to work at V.K Video Movies, Plaza Road, and on 7-6-1997 between 8.00 p.m and 8.30 p.m a person by the name of Vivek Kalra (the appellant) came to their shop and took one cassette of picture Judwaa and deposited Rs 100 in advance and his name has been entered in the register of the shop, but the cassette was never received back.
    (iv) PW 7 is a witness to the panchnama of the dead body of the deceased (Ext. P-6) which bears his signatures at Points A to B and he has said that one dantli was lying on the ground near the pulia which had a wooden handle and was taken possession of by the police vide memo, Ext. P-7, which bears his signatures at Points A to B and he has also stated that the dantli was bloodstained.
    (v) PW 13 is a blacksmith and he has said before the court that the appellant had come to purchase a dantli from his shop and he agreed to pay a price of Rs 110 out of which he paid advance of Rs 10 to him and on the next day he came to the shop and took the sharp-edged dantli and he had paid the balance of Rs 100 to him and the seized dantli was produced before PW 13 as Article 1 and PW 13 identified Article 1 as the one that was purchased by the appellant from him.
    (vi) PW 22 Dr B.K Mathur has given his opinion that he conducted the post-mortem on the deceased on 9-6-1997 at 9.30 a.m and that Injuries 1 to 7 could be caused by the dantli.

    The learned counsel for the State submitted that considering all these circumstances established by the prosecution, there can be no doubt that it is the appellant and the appellant only who has committed the murder of the deceased.

    6. We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and we agree with the learned counsel for the appellant that from the evidence of PW 11 one could not hold that the appellant had committed the murder of the deceased to take revenge on his uncle (PW 11), who had not given him Rs 80,000 kept in the fixed deposit. We are, however, of the opinion that where prosecution relies on circumstantial evidence only, motive is a relevant fact and can be taken into consideration under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, 1872 but where the chain of other circumstances establishes beyond reasonable doubt that it is the accused and the accused alone who has committed the offence, and this is one such case, the Court cannot hold that in the absence of motive of the accused being established by the prosecution, the accused cannot be held guilty of the offence. In Ujjagar Singh v. State of Punjab (2007) 13 SCC 90 this Court observed:

    “17. … It is true that in a case relating to circumstantial evidence motive does assume great importance but to say that the absence of motive would dislodge the entire prosecution story is perhaps giving this one factor an importance which is not due and (to use the cliché) the motive is in the mind of the accused and can seldom be fathomed with any degree of accuracy.”

    7. In the instant case, the dead body of Ankit was found on the morning of 8-6-1997 at around 8.00 a.m and it is clear from the evidence of PW 5 and PW 6 that the appellant had taken Ankit on a scooter between 7.00 p.m and 9.00 p.m on 7-6-1997 on the pretext of getting a cassette. PW 28 has confirmed that between 8.00 p.m and 8.30 p.m the appellant had come to his cassette shop and taken the cassette of the film Judwaa. It is also clear from the evidence of PW 5 and PW 6 that neither the appellant nor the deceased returned on the evening of 7-6-1997. From the evidence of PW 26 and PW 7, we also find that the bloodstained dantli has been recovered from the place of occurrence and the blacksmith, PW 13, has confirmed that he had sold that particular dantli to the appellant at a price of Rs 110.

    8. Dr B.K Mathur, PW 22, has said in his evidence that Injuries 1 to 7 could have been caused by the dantli and that the death of the deceased has been caused from shock and haemorrhage with blood oozing from all the injuries. We find that Injuries 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 are cut wounds on the left of the face, left of the neck, back of the neck, on the left muscles and scapula bone, intestine and on the left of the waist. The number and nature of these injuries together are enough in the ordinary course to cause death and have been caused by the dantli purchased by the appellant. Hence, merely because the prosecution has not been able to prove that Injuries 8 and 9 have been caused by the dantli, we cannot hold that it is not the appellant who has caused the death of the deceased.

    9. It is true that PW 5 has stated that the appellant had a good behaviour and had no bad habit. Section 8 of the Evidence Act, 1872, however, provides that the conduct of any person an offence against whom is the subject of any proceeding, is relevant, if such conduct influences or is influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact, and whether it was previous or subsequent to it. Hence, any behaviour or conduct of the appellant would be relevant if it had nexus with the offence under Section 302 alleged to have been committed by him. This Court has held in Vikramjit Singh v. State of Punjab (2006) 12 SCC 306 at p. 314: (SCC para 17)

    “17. … Conduct of an accused must have nexus with the crime committed. It must form part of the evidence as regards his conduct either preceding, during or after commission of the offence as envisaged under Section 8 of the Evidence Act.”

    The general good behaviour of the appellant and the fact that he had no bad habit have no nexus with the offence alleged against the appellant and are not relevant when other circumstances have established beyond reasonable doubt that it is the appellant and the appellant alone who has committed the murder of the deceased.

    10. In the result, we find no merit in the appeal and we dismiss the same.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vivek Kalra v. State Of Rajasthan .
    (Feb 15, 2013)