Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 27 of the Evidence Act, 1872
  • Section 27 of the Evidence Act, (year not specified)
  • Section 8 of the Evidence Act, (year not specified)
  • FIR, discovery panchnama, panchnama of the seized articles, the FSL report and the serology report and panchnama of the test identification parade
  • Section 342, Section 346, Section 302, Section 120-B, Section 201 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 27 of the Evidence Act, 1872
  • Section 27 of the Evidence Act, (year not specified)
  • Section 8 of the Evidence Act, (year not specified)
  • FIR, discovery panchnama, panchnama of the seized articles, the FSL report and the serology report and panchnama of the test identification parade
  • Section 342, Section 346, Section 302, Section 120-B, Section 201 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 23-1-2006, Ashokbhai Nanubhai disappeared after being taken from Zanda Chowk, Udwada Railway Station, in a Maruti Zen allegedly owned by the appellant (A-1) and driven by persons later identified as A-1 to A-4. Two days of fruitless search by family members prompted the lodging of FIR No. 1-12/2006 at Pardi Police Station on 25-1-2006. Police investigation led to the arrest of the accused, recovery of the deceased’s buried body, and seizure of related articles at the instance of A-1.

Sessions Case No. 28/2006 in the Court of the Sessions Judge, Valsad, resulted in acquittal of A-3 and A-4, but conviction of A-1 and A-2 under Sections 342, 346, 302, 120-B and 201 read with Section 34 IPC, with life imprisonment for murder. In Criminal Appeal No. 860/2007, the High Court of Gujarat (judgment dated 20-4-2009) acquitted A-2 but affirmed all convictions against A-1. A-1 appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a two-day delay in lodging the FIR fatally undermines the prosecution case.
  2. Admissibility and legal effect of recovery of the dead body and articles pursuant to information supplied by the accused when panch witnesses turned hostile.
  3. Reliability of the “last seen together” circumstance given the alleged time-gap between abduction and death.
  4. Effect of prosecution’s failure to examine a purported material witness (Gulia).
  5. Whether conviction for criminal conspiracy (Section 120-B IPC) can stand when all alleged co-conspirators have been acquitted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Unexplained delay in filing the FIR renders the prosecution version doubtful.
  • Confessional portions are inadmissible; hostile panch witnesses vitiate the alleged discovery and recovery.
  • The “last seen” theory is unreliable because of a substantial time gap between disappearance and estimated time of death.
  • Non-examination of Gulia, at whose house the deceased was allegedly taken, is a serious lacuna.
  • A-2 having been acquitted, parity requires acquittal of A-1, especially on the conspiracy charge.

Respondent State’s Arguments

  • Search efforts by relatives adequately explain the brief delay in lodging the FIR; no prejudice was caused.
  • Recovery of the body and articles, though panch witnesses turned hostile, is admissible under Sections 8 and 27 of the Evidence Act because the facts discovered were within the exclusive knowledge of A-1.
  • Medical evidence fixes time of death within four days, matching the time the deceased was last seen with A-1, thereby validating the “last seen” link.
  • Even without Gulia’s testimony, the chain of circumstantial evidence is complete.
  • Conspiracy charge cannot survive, but convictions under substantive sections are fully proved against A-1.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of H.P. v. Gian Chand (2001) 6 SCC 71 Delay in lodging FIR is not fatal if satisfactorily explained. Used to reject the defence challenge based on the two-day delay.
Ramdas v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 2 SCC 170 Delay must be evaluated in the totality of circumstances. Reinforced acceptance of prosecution explanation for delay.
Kilakkatha Parambath Sasi v. State of Kerala (2011) 4 SCC 552 Effect of FIR timing: neither strengthens nor weakens case per se. Cited to show that timely FIR is not the sole determinant of credibility.
Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan (2013) 5 SCC 655 Similar principle on FIR delay. Further bolstered dismissal of delay argument.
A.N. Venkatesh v. State of Karnataka (2005) 7 SCC 714 Accused’s conduct in pointing out place of concealment is relevant under Section 8 Evidence Act. Made discovery of body admissible despite hostile panchas.
Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1979) 3 SCC 90 Discovery of a dead body pointed out by accused is admissible. Relied upon for the same proposition as Venkatesh.
State of Maharashtra v. Damu (2000) 6 SCC 269 “Fact discovered” includes place and knowledge of accused under Section 27. Supported admissibility of recovery evidence.
State of Maharashtra v. Suresh (2000) 1 SCC 471 a) Scope of Section 27 recovery; b) False/absent explanation under Section 313 CrPC can fill missing link. Used both for recovery and for adverse inference against A-1’s bald denial.
State of Punjab v. Gurnam Kaur (2009) 11 SCC 225 Validity of discovery evidence. Cited with other authorities on recovery.
Aftab Ahmad Ansari v. State of Uttaranchal (2010) 2 SCC 583 Recovery jurisprudence reaffirmed. Part of series of authorities validating discovery.
Bhagwan Dass v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2011) 6 SCC 396 Recovery and circumstantial evidence principles. Added weight to admissibility of discovery.
Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2010) 6 SCC 1 Recovery under Section 27 and evaluation of circumstantial evidence. Cited similarly.
Rumi Bora Dutta v. State of Assam (2013) 7 SCC 417 Confirmation by subsequent events doctrine. Applied to uphold relevance of discoveries.
Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra (1984) 4 SCC 116 Five “panchsheel” principles governing circumstantial evidence. Bench used as standard to test chain of circumstances.
State v. Saravanan (2008) 17 SCC 587 Circumstantial evidence requirements. Part of cumulative circumstantial analysis.
Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta v. State of Maharashtra (2010) 13 SCC 657 Circumstantial evidence evaluation. Cited for same purpose.
Jagroop Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 11 SCC 768 Circumstantial evidence standards. Affirmed completeness of chain.
Takhaji Hiraji v. Thakore Kubersing Chamansing (2001) 6 SCC 145 When non-examination of a witness warrants adverse inference. Used to hold that failure to examine Gulia was not fatal.
Dahari v. State of U.P. (2012) 10 SCC 256 Adverse inference for non-examining witness not automatic when other evidence is overwhelming. Reinforced the view that Gulia’s absence was immaterial.
Fakhruddin v. State of M.P. AIR 1967 SC 1326 Conviction for conspiracy cannot stand if co-conspirators are acquitted. Ground for setting aside A-1’s conviction under Section 120-B IPC.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Delay in FIR: The Court, applying Gian Chand line of cases, accepted the relatives’ explanation that they first searched for the deceased and had no immediate apprehension of murder; hence the two-day delay did not taint the prosecution.

Discovery and Recovery: Although panch witnesses turned hostile, the Court invoked Sections 8 and 27 of the Evidence Act and precedents such as A.N. Venkatesh and Damu to hold that A-1’s act of leading police to the buried body and seized items was admissible and a strong incriminating circumstance.

Last Seen Theory: Eye-witnesses PW 13 and PW 15 placed the deceased in A-1’s Maruti car on 23-1-2006; medical evidence fixed injuries at approximately four days old, aligning the time of death with the abduction. The Court found the temporal proximity sufficient and rejected the argument of a fatal time gap.

Non-Examination of Gulia: Relying on Takhaji Hiraji and related cases, the Bench reasoned that since other evidence was cogent, failure to call Gulia did not vitiate the case, especially when the defence did not cross-examine the IO on this point.

Section 313 CrPC Silence: A-1’s bald denial to all incriminating questions allowed the Court to treat his failure to explain circumstances as an additional link per Suresh.

Conspiracy Charge: Referring to Fakhruddin, the Court held that conviction under Section 120-B could not survive once all other alleged conspirators had been acquitted.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is DISMISSED except that the conviction and sentence under Section 120-B IPC are set aside. Convictions and concurrent sentences, including life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC, stand affirmed.

Implications: A-1 continues to serve life imprisonment. The judgment re-asserts (a) that brief, explained delay in FIR filing does not defeat prosecution; (b) that discovery of facts within an accused’s exclusive knowledge remains admissible even when panch witnesses turn hostile; and (c) that a conspiracy conviction cannot stand alone once co-accused are acquitted. No new legal doctrine is created, but existing principles are reinforced.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Harivadan Babubhai Patel v. State Of Gujarat .

    Dipak Misra, J.— The appellant, A-1, along with Dipakbhai Zinabhai Patel, A-2; Raghubhai Chaganbhai Patel, A-3; and Babubhai Khushalbhai Patel, A-4, faced trial in Sessions Case No. 28 of 2006 in the Court of the learned Sessions Judge, Valsad, for the offences punishable under Sections 342, 346, 302, 120-B and 201 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”). The learned trial Judge acquitted A-3 and A-4 as he found them innocent and convicted A-1 and A-2 for all the offences and imposed rigorous imprisonment for life and a fine of Rs 1000, in default of payment of fine, to undergo further imprisonment for one month under Section 302 and separate sentences for the other offences with the stipulation that all the sentences shall run concurrently.

    2. Grieved by the aforesaid conviction and sentence, the appellant-accused and A-2 preferred Criminal Appeal No. 860 of 2007 and the High Court, by the impugned judgment dated 20-4-2009 Criminal Appeal No. 860 of 2007, acquitted A-2 but sustained the conviction of the appellant for all the offences. Hence, the present appeal by the appellant-accused A-1.

    3. Filtering the unnecessary details, the prosecution case is that on 23-1-2006, deceased, Ashokbhai Nanubhai, accompanied by his brother-in-law, Kantibhai Manilal Patel, PW 13, had gone to Udwada Railway Station, Zanda Chowk on his scooter and went to a tea stall where the deceased was engaged in a conversation with one Durlabhbhai Kikubhai Bhandari, PW 15. Durlabhbhai took the deceased near the railway crossing where 3-4 persons were waiting in a Maruti car. As the prosecution story further gets unfurled, the deceased had discussion with them and, thereafter, those persons informed that they would take the deceased to the house of Gulia at Valsad and, accordingly, they took him in the Maruti car bearing No. GJ 15 K 9263. They had provided one mobile number stating that if there would be any delay in the return of the deceased, they could be contacted on that mobile number. The brother-in-law of the deceased supplied that mobile number to his sister Madhuben, PW 14, and went to Daman for his work and came back in the evening at about 5.00 p.m Thereafter, he enquired from his sister whether she had talked with the deceased on the given number or not and he was informed by her that the mobile phone was picked up by different persons who spoke differently and, at a later stage, it was switched off. Someone speaking on the mobile had also enquired from Madhuben whether she had gone to the police station. Coming to know about the situation, Kantibhai made enquiry and searched about the deceased for two days and when the deceased did not return, he lodged a complaint at Pardi Police Station on 25-1-2006 which was registered as CR No. 1-12 of 2006.

    4. After the criminal law was set in motion, the investigating agency examined the witnesses and after coming to know about the place where the accused persons had hidden themselves, the investigating officer arrested them and they confessed before the police that they had wrongfully confined the deceased and assaulted him. They also confessed that they had pressurised the deceased for returning the money as the money was paid to the passport agent, namely, Bharatbhai, who was introduced by the deceased, in the presence of one Ashokbhai alias Amratbhai. They also stated that they had assaulted the deceased on 23-1-2006 and when the deceased succumbed to the injuries, they buried the dead body in an agricultural farm.

    5. At the instance of the accused, the dead body of the deceased was taken out in the presence of the panch witnesses. Discovery panchnama was prepared in presence of the Executive Magistrate. After carrying out the seizure of footwear, clothes and an old jute blanket, samples of the same were sent for forensic examination and thereafter, the dead body, after being identified by wife Madhuben, was initially sent to Dungri Primary Health Centre for post-mortem, but as the medical officer opined that it was to be done by a forensic expert, it was sent to Surat Civil Hospital Forensic Department. The identification of the accused persons was carried out by the Executive Magistrate. The Maruti car which was used for the offence was taken into possession. The investigating agency examined a number of witnesses and, after completing the investigation, placed the charge-sheet before the competent court for all the offences in respect of A-1 to A-3 and as far as A-4 was concerned, he was charge-sheeted for the offence punishable under Section 201 IPC.

    6. The accused persons pleaded innocence and false implication and claimed to be tried.

    7. The prosecution, in support of its case, examined 19 witnesses and got a number of documents including the FIR, discovery panchnama, panchnama of the seized articles, the FSL report and the serology report and panchnama of the test identification parade exhibited. In the statement under Section 313 CrPC, the accused persons made a bald denial of every aspect and did not offer any explanation and chose not to adduce any evidence.

    8. The learned trial Judge, on the basis of the material brought on record, found A-1 and A-2 guilty of all the offences and the High Court affirmed the conviction and sentence in respect of A-1 only as stated hereinbefore.

    9. We have heard Mr Rauf Rahim, learned counsel for the appellant and Ms Hemantika Wahi, learned counsel for the respondent State.

    10. It is the undisputed position that the death was homicidal in nature and the case of the prosecution rests on the circumstantial evidence. The learned counsel for the appellant has assiduously endeavoured to point out certain loopholes and contended that because of the said dents, the prosecution version deserves to be discarded. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent would support the analysis made in the judgment Criminal Appeal No. 860 of 2007 of the High Court and stand for its sustenance.

    11. We shall deal with the challenges and the stance in oppugnation one by one. The first ground of attack is that there is delay in lodging of the FIR and in the absence of explanation, the case of the prosecution should be thrown overboard. On a perusal of the judgments, it is noticeable that the said aspect has been dealt with in great detail and the plea of delay has been negatived. It is urged before us that though the occurrence, as alleged, had taken place on 23-1-2006, yet the FIR was lodged only on 25-1-2006 indicating that efforts were being made to search for the deceased and the said effort is based on some kind of surmises which do not inspire confidence. On a close scrutiny, it is evident that as per the FIR and the evidence of the informant, PW 13, and Madhuben, PW 14, they had searched for the deceased and realising that it was an exercise in futility, they went to the police station. It has been deposed by them that they had never apprehended that the deceased would be done to death though there was a previous quarrel pertaining to demand of money from the deceased as he had introduced the passport agent to A-1 who had paid more than rupees one lakh to obtain the necessary documents to go to the United States of America. It has been clearly proven that the informant was engaged in search and he had not apprehended that the life spark of the deceased would be extinct. The issue is whether such an explanation is to be believed.

    12. In this context, we may refer with profit to the authority in State of H.P v. Gian Chand (2001) 6 SCC 71 wherein a three-Judge Bench has opined that the delay in lodging the FIR cannot be used as a ritualistic formula for doubting the prosecution case and discarding the same solely on the ground of delay. If the explanation offered is satisfactory and there is no possibility of embellishment, the delay should not be treated as fatal to the case of the prosecution.

    13. In Ramdas v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 2 SCC 170 it has been ruled that when an FIR is lodged belatedly, it is a relevant fact of which the court must take notice of, but the said fact has to be considered in the light of other facts and circumstances of the case. It is obligatory on the part of the court to consider whether the delay in lodging the report adversely affects the case of the prosecution and it would depend upon the matter of appreciation of evidence in totality.

    14. In Kilakkatha Parambath Sasi v. State of Kerala (2011) 4 SCC 552, AIR 2011 SC 1064 it has been laid down that when an FIR has been lodged in a belated manner, inference can rightly follow that the prosecution story may not be true but equally on the other side, if it is found that there is no delay in the recording of the FIR, it does not mean that the prosecution story stands immeasurably strengthened. Similar view has also been expressed in Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan (2013) 5 SCC 655, (2013) 6 Scale 242.

    15. Scrutinised on the anvil of the aforesaid enunciation of law, we are disposed to think that there had been no embellishment in the FIR and, in fact, there could not have been any possibility of embellishment. As we find, the case at hand does not reveal that the absence of spontaneity in the lodgment of the FIR has created a coloured version. On the contrary, from the other circumstances which lend support to the prosecution story, it is difficult to disbelieve and discard the prosecution case solely on the ground that the FIR was lodged on 25-1-2006 though the deceased was taken by the accused persons sometime on 23-1-2006. The explanation offered pertaining to the search of the deceased by the informant has been given credence to by the learned trial Judge as well as by the High Court and, in our considered opinion, adjudging the entire scenario of the prosecution case, the same deserves acceptation. Hence, the said submission is sans substance.

    16. The next limb of attack relates to the confessions made by the accused persons and the issue of leading to discovery of articles. It is submitted that the confession part is absolutely inadmissible and that apart, when the panch witnesses had not supported the panchnama, the recovery or discovery of the seized articles cannot be utilised against the appellant. There can be no shadow of doubt that the confession part is inadmissible in evidence. It is also not in dispute that the panch witnesses have turned hostile but the fact remains that the place from where the dead body of the deceased and other items were recovered was within the special knowledge of the appellant.

    17. In this context, we may usefully refer to A.N Venkatesh v. State of Karnataka (2005) 7 SCC 714 wherein it has been ruled that:

    “9. By virtue of Section 8 of the Evidence Act, the conduct of the accused person is relevant, if such conduct influences or is influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact. The evidence of the circumstance, simpliciter, that the accused pointed out to the police officer, the place where the dead body of the kidnapped boy was found … would be admissible as conduct under Section 8 irrespective of the fact whether the statement made by the accused contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct falls within the purview of Section 27 [of the Evidence Act] or not….”

    In the said decision, reliance was placed on the principle laid down in Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1979) 3 SCC 90, AIR 1979 SC 400. It is worth noting that in the said case, there was material on record that the accused had taken the investigating officer to the spot and pointed out the place where the dead body was buried and this Court treated the same as admissible piece of evidence under Section 8 as the conduct of the accused.

    18. In State of Maharashtra v. Damu (2000) 6 SCC 269 it has been held as follows:

    “35. … It is now well settled that recovery of an object is not discovery of a fact as envisaged in [Section 27 of the Evidence Act, 1872]. The decision of the Privy Council in Pulukuri Kotayya v. King Emperor (1946-47) 74 IA 65, AIR 1947 PC 67 is the most quoted authority for supporting the interpretation that the ‘fact discovered’ envisaged in the section embraces the place from which the object was produced, the knowledge of the accused as to it, but the information given must relate distinctly to that effect.”

    19. The same principle has been laid down in State of Maharashtra v. Suresh (2000) 1 SCC 471, State of Punjab v. Gurnam Kaur (2009) 11 SCC 225, Aftab Ahmad Anasari v. State of Uttaranchal (2010) 2 SCC 583, Bhagwan Dass v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2011) 6 SCC 396, AIR 2011 SC 1863, Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2010) 6 SCC 1, AIR 2010 SC 2352 and Rumi Bora Dutta v. State of Assam (2013) 7 SCC 417.

    20. In the case at hand, the factum of information related to the discovery of the dead body and other articles and the said information was within the special knowledge of the present appellant. Hence, the doctrine of confirmation by subsequent events is attracted and, therefore, we have no hesitation in holding that the recovery or discovery in the case at hand is a relevant fact or material which can be relied upon and has been correctly relied upon.

    21. The next circumstance that has been seriously criticised by Mr Rauf Rahim, learned counsel for the appellant, pertains to the last seen theory. It is submitted by him that as per the testimony of the informant, the appellant along with others had taken the deceased in a Maruti car, but there is no material evidence to suggest that the accused was in the company of the deceased for two days. The learned counsel would further submit that the last seen theory faces a hazard because of the time gap and, hence, should be totally discarded.

    22. It is evident from the material on record that the deceased was taken away from Zanda Chowk in a Maruti car. The appellant has been identified by Kantibhai, PW 13, and Durlabhbhai, PW 15, and their evidence remains totally embedded in all material particulars. It has been proved by the prosecution that the Maruti Zen car belongs to the appellant. There has been no explanation offered by the accused in this regard, though such incriminating materials were put to him. It is also worth noting here that from the testimony of Dr Pandav Vinodchandra Prajapati, PW 16, who had conducted the autopsy on 28-1-2006 at about 10.00 a.m, that the injuries found on the dead body were approximately four days old. Thus, the argument that there is long gap between the last seen and the time of death melts into insignificance inasmuch as the time the deceased was seen in the company of A-1 and the time of death is not long and the said fact has been duly established by the medical evidence and we see no reason to discredit the same. It is apt to note here that A-1 had said that they were taking the deceased to the house of Gulia but during investigation, nothing was found in the house of Gulia. On the contrary, from the testimony of Madhuben, PW 14, wife of the deceased, it is evincible that she had talked on telephone to both the accused persons. Thus, the circumstance pertaining to the theory of last seen deserves acceptance.

    23. The next plank of submission is that Gulia to whose house the deceased was taken to has not been examined by the prosecution and non-examination of such a material witness makes the whole case of the prosecution unacceptable. The learned trial Judge, dealing with the said contention, has opined that during the test identification parade, Shaikh Gulamhussain had not identified the accused persons and that is the reason the prosecution was of the view that the said witness would not support the case of the complainant and, accordingly, chose not to examine him.

    24. In State of H.P v. Gian Chand (2001) 6 SCC 71 it has been opined that:

    “14. … Non-examination of a material witness is again not a mathematical formula for discarding the weight of the testimony available on record howsoever natural, trustworthy and convincing it may be. The charge of withholding a material witness from the court levelled against the prosecution should be examined in the background of the facts and circumstances of each case so as to find whether the witnesses are available for being examined in the court and were yet withheld by the prosecution.”

    The three-Judge Bench further proceeded to observe that the court is required first to assess the trustworthiness of the evidence available on record and if the court finds the evidence adduced worthy of being relied on, then the testimony has to be accepted and acted upon though there may be other witnesses available who could also have been examined but were not examined.

    25. In Takhaji Hiraji v. Thakore Kubersing Chamansing (2001) 6 SCC 145 the Court has opined thus:

    “19. … It is true that if a material witness, who would unfold the genesis of the incident or an essential part of the prosecution case, not convincingly brought to fore otherwise, or where there is a gap or infirmity in the prosecution case which could have been supplied or made good by examining a witness who though available is not examined, the prosecution case can be termed as suffering from a deficiency and withholding of such a material witness would oblige the court to draw an adverse inference against the prosecution by holding that if the witness would have been examined it would not have supported the prosecution case. On the other hand if already overwhelming evidence is available and examination of other witnesses would only be a repetition or duplication of the evidence already adduced, non-examination of such other witnesses may not be material. In such a case the court ought to scrutinise the worth of the evidence adduced. The court of facts must ask itself—whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, it was necessary to examine such other witness, and if so, whether such witness was available to be examined and yet was being withheld from the court? If the answer be positive then only a question of drawing an adverse inference may arise. If the witnesses already examined are reliable and the testimony coming from their mouth is unimpeachable the court can safely act upon it, uninfluenced by the factum of non-examination of other witnesses.”

    26. In Dahari v. State of U.P (2012) 10 SCC 256 while discussing about the non-examination of material witness, the Court expressed the view that when he was not the only competent witness who would have been fully capable of explaining the factual situation correctly and the prosecution case stood fully corroborated by the medical evidence and the testimony of other reliable witnesses, no adverse inference could be drawn against the prosecution. Be it noted, the Court also took note of the fact that during the cross-examination of the investigating officer, none of the accused persons had voiced their concerns or raised any apprehension regarding the non-examination of the material witness therein.

    27. In the case at hand, it was A-1 who had announced that he was taking the deceased to the house of Gulia. On a search being conducted, nothing has been found from the house of Gulia. There has been no cross-examination of the investigating officer about the non-examination of Gulia. On the contrary, it was A-1 who had led to the discovery of the dead body and other articles. Thus, when the other evidence on record are cogent, credible and meet the test of circumstantial evidence laid down in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra (1984) 4 SCC 116, State v. Saravanan (2008) 17 SCC 587, Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta v. State of Maharashtra (2010) 13 SCC 657 and further reiterated in Jagroop Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 11 SCC 768, there is no justification to come to hold that the prosecution has deliberately withheld a witness that creates a concavity in the concept of fair trial.

    28. Another facet is required to be addressed to. Though all the incriminating circumstances which point to the guilt of the accused had been put to him, yet he chose not to give any explanation under Section 313 CrPC except choosing the mode of denial. It is well settled in law that when the attention of the accused is drawn to the said circumstances that inculpated him in the crime and he fails to offer appropriate explanation or gives a false answer, the same can be counted as providing a missing link for building the chain of circumstances. (See State of Maharashtra v. Suresh (2000) 1 SCC 471.) In the case at hand, though a number of circumstances were put to the accused, yet he has made a bald denial and did not offer any explanation whatsoever. Thus, it is also a circumstance that goes against him.

    29. We will be failing in our duty if we do not note another submission of the learned counsel for the appellant. It is urged by him that A-2 stood on the same footing as the appellant and hence, the High Court should have acquitted him. It is also canvassed by him that A-2 has been acquitted of the charge of criminal conspiracy and, therefore, the appellant deserves to be acquitted. The High Court has taken note of the fact that A-2 was not identified by anyone in the test identification parade. It has also noticed a number of material contradictions and omissions and, accordingly, acquitted A-2. As far as the appellant is concerned, all the circumstances lead towards his guilt. As far as conspiracy under Section 120-B is concerned, we are inclined to think that the High Court erred in not recording an order of acquittal under Section 120-B as no other accused had been found guilty. The conviction under Section 120-B cannot be sustained when the other accused persons have been acquitted, for an offence of conspiracy cannot survive if there is acquittal of the other alleged co-conspirators. It has been so laid down in Fakhruddin v. State of M.P AIR 1967 SC 1326, 1967 Cri LJ 1197 Thus, the conviction of the appellant under Section 120-B is set aside.

    30. Resultantly, the appeal fails except for the acquittal for the offence of conspiracy. However, as we have sustained the conviction under Section 302 IPC and all the sentences are directed to be concurrent, the acquittal for the offence punishable under Section 120-B would not help the appellant. Therefore, the appeal stands dismissed, but the conviction and sentence under Section 120-B IPC is set aside. The other convictions and sentences will stand.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harivadan Babubhai Patel v. State Of Gujarat .
    (Jul 1, 2013)