Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)
  • The Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)
  • The Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 938 of 2001 before the Delhi High Court seeking transfer of investigation in RC No. S19.E0006/99 (dated 7-12-1999) from Respondents 3, 4 and 5 to another senior CBI officer, alleging abuse of investigative powers. On 4-4-2002, Respondent 5’s counsel told the High Court that investigation was complete; the Court therefore directed that an affidavit be filed by 5-4-2002. Respondent 5, the Investigating Officer (IO), filed the affidavit stating that investigation had concluded and a final report (Part I) had been submitted on 11-1-2002 to the Superintendent of Police.

Subsequently, the appellant learned that additional witnesses were examined after the affidavit. Contending that Respondent 5 had misled the Court, the appellant moved an application under Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking perjury proceedings against Respondent 5. The Delhi High Court dismissed that application on 16-4-2010. The present appeal challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Respondent 5’s statement and affidavit that the investigation had concluded constituted a deliberate and conscious falsehood warranting prosecution for perjury under Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) CrPC.
  2. Whether the Delhi High Court erred in holding that it was not “expedient in the interests of justice” to initiate such prosecution.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Respondent 5 expressly stated and swore on affidavit that investigation was complete and no further steps were required; subsequent examination of witnesses shows the affidavit was false.
  • The false affidavit was intended to mislead the Court and therefore attracted Section 340 CrPC; the High Court ought to have ordered prosecution.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The affidavit was factually correct when made: the IO had completed his part of the investigation and submitted the report.
  • Under the CBI Manual, superior officers may direct the IO to examine additional witnesses to “tie loose ends”; compliance with such directions after filing the affidavit does not render the earlier statement false.
  • No deliberate or conscious attempt was made to mislead the Court; hence the prerequisites for initiating perjury proceedings were absent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandra Shashi v. Anil Kumar Verma (1995) 1 SCC 421 Court must curb perjury, prevarication and motivated falsehoods in judicial proceedings. Cited to emphasise the seriousness of perjury but also to underline that only deliberate falsehoods warrant prosecution.
K. Karunakaran v. T.V. Eachara Warrier (1978) 1 SCC 18; AIR 1978 SC 290 Conditions precedent for lodging a complaint under Section 340 CrPC—prima facie case and expediency in the interests of justice. Invoked to frame the test that the Court applied in assessing the appellant’s application.
K.T.M.S. Mohd. v. Union of India (1992) 3 SCC 178 Reiterates the necessity of a prima facie case before initiating prosecution for perjury. Used to support the conclusion that no such prima facie case existed.
Chajoo Ram v. Radhey Shyam (1971) 1 SCC 774 Perjury prosecution should be sanctioned only when deliberate falsehood is reasonably probable; minor inaccuracies are insufficient. Relied on to hold that the alleged discrepancy did not justify prosecution.
Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi Marwah (2005) 4 SCC 370 Court’s discretion under Section 340 CrPC is guided by whether prosecution is “expedient in the interests of justice.” Applied to affirm that prosecution was not expedient in the present facts.
R.S. Sujatha v. State of Karnataka (2011) 5 SCC 689 Follows Iqbal Singh Marwah on the threshold for initiating perjury proceedings. Cited as additional authority for the legal standard employed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reviewed the affidavit of Respondent 5, the subsequent directions issued by the Director, CBI on 23-4-2002, and the fact that additional witness examination was limited to “tightening the loose ends.” It noted that:

  • The IO had indeed completed his investigation when the affidavit was filed; any later steps were undertaken on superior officers’ instructions, a recognised procedure under the CBI Manual.
  • The Director’s 23-4-2002 order directing further steps was never challenged by the appellant.
  • The application under Section 340 CrPC was filed after a delay of approximately three and a half years, weakening any claim of urgency or deliberate deception.
  • Applying the principles in Chajoo Ram, Iqbal Singh Marwah and related cases, the Court held that prosecution for perjury is warranted only where there is a prima facie, deliberate and conscious falsehood, and where such prosecution is expedient in the interests of justice.
  • The High Court had examined the original and confidential records and concluded there was no intent to mislead; the Supreme Court found no reason to disturb that finding.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Consequences: The High Court’s refusal to initiate perjury proceedings against Respondent 5 stands affirmed. The decision reiterates established principles governing Section 340 CrPC, emphasizing that prosecution for perjury requires clear evidence of deliberate falsehood and that courts must consider whether such action is expedient in the interest of justice. No new legal precedent is set; the ruling principally affects the parties to this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ashok Kumar Aggarwal v. Union Of India And Others

    Dr B.S Chauhan, J.— This appeal has been preferred against the impugned judgment and final order dated 16-4-2010 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in Ashok Kumar Aggarwal v. Union of India, by which the application filed by the appellant to proceed against Respondent 5 under Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”) has been dismissed.

    2. The facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are that: the appellant had filed Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 938 of 2001 before the High Court of Delhi seeking transfer of investigation from Respondents 3, 4 and 5 to any other senior officer of Central Bureau of Investigation (hereinafter referred to as “CBI”), as the said respondents had been abusing their investigating powers and adopted unfair and improper means in RC No. S19.E0006/99 dated 7-12-1999. The Court made order dated 4-4-2002, on the submission of counsel for Respondent 5 that the investigation report had been finalised in the said RC case and no further investigation was required to be done, directed the competent authority of CBI to file an affidavit in this regard by 5-4-2002.

    3. An affidavit was filed by Respondent 5 on 5-4-2002, being the investigating officer, wherein it had been stated that the investigation was complete and that no further investigation was required to be done and a final report Part 1 (FR 1) was submitted by him on 11-1-2002 to the Superintendent of Police (in short “SP”). However, coming to know that certain witnesses had been examined by CBI subsequent thereto, the appellant preferred an application under Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) CrPC, which has been dismissed by the High Court vide impugned judgment and order. Hence, this appeal.

    4. Shri Ram Jethmalani, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, has submitted that not only was a statement made, but even an affidavit had been filed by Respondent 5 before the High Court that the investigation was complete and an investigation report had been finalised by him and no further investigation was required. Therefore, if further witnesses had been examined and certain evidence had been collected, it is evident that the statement so given and affidavit filed by Respondent 5 was just to mislead the court and therefore, the court ought to have proceeded against him allowing the application filed by the appellant.

    5. Per contra, Shri Ranjit Kumar, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent 5 and Ms Indira Jaising, learned ASG for Respondents 1 and 2, have vehemently opposed this appeal contending that the submission made before the Court and affidavit filed by Respondent 5 that investigation stood concluded, was factually correct. However, as per the procedure prescribed under the CBI manual, the investigation report submitted by the IO goes to the superior officers for their comments, approval and directions, and ultimately, it goes to the Director, CBI. In case the superior authorities have some query in respect of any matter in that report of the investigating officer, they are competent to issue directions to examine a particular witness on a particular point. The investigating officer is bound to do so in order to tie the loose ends of investigation. Such examination of witness or further investigation does not amount to the statement made by the IO in the affidavit before the court being false or having been made deliberately and mischievously to misguide the court. As per the requirement of the procedure prescribed under the CBI manual, the IO, even after filing such an affidavit, was bound to carry out such directions issued by the superior authorities.

    6. We have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

    7. In Chandra Shashi v. Anil Kumar Verma (1995) 1 SCC 421, this Court held that nobody should be permitted to indulge in immoral acts like perjury, prevarication and motivated falsehoods in the judicial proceedings and if someone does so, it must be dealt with appropriately. In case recourse to a false plea is taken with an oblique motive, it would definitely hinder, hamper or impede the flow of justice and prevent the courts from performing their legal duties.

    8. In this context, reference may be made of Section 340 under Chapter XXVI of the CrPC, under the heading of “Provisions as to Offences Affecting the Administration of Justice”. This Chapter deals with offences committed in or in relation to a proceeding in the court, or in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in the court and enables the court to make a complaint in respect of such offences if that court is of the view that it is expedient in the interest of justice that an inquiry should be made into an offence. Clause (b) of Section 195(1) CrPC authorises such court to examine prima facie as it thinks necessary and then make a complaint thereof in writing after having recorded a finding to that effect as contemplated under Section 340(1) CrPC. In such a case, the question remains as to whether a prima facie case is made out which, if unrebutted, may have a reasonable likelihood to establish the specified offences and whether it is also expedient in the interest of justice to take any action. Thus, before lodging a complaint, the condition precedent for the court to be satisfied are that material so produced before the court makes out a prima facie case for a complaint and that it is expedient in the interest of justice to have prosecution under Section 193 IPC. (Vide K. Karunakaran v. T.V Eachara Warrier (1978) 1 SCC 18, AIR 1978 SC 290 and K.T.M.S Mohd. v. Union of India (1992) 3 SCC 178.)

    9. In Chajoo Ram v. Radhey Shyam (1971) 1 SCC 774, this Court held:

    “7. The prosecution for perjury should be sanctioned by courts only in those cases where the perjury appears to be deliberate and conscious and the conviction is reasonably probable or likely. No doubt giving of false evidence and filing false affidavits is an evil which must be effectively curbed with a strong hand but to start prosecution for perjury too readily and too frequently without due care and caution and on inconclusive and doubtful material defeats its very purpose. Prosecution should be ordered when it is considered expedient in the interests of justice to punish the delinquent and not merely because there is some inaccuracy in the statement which may be innocent or immaterial. There must be prima facie case of deliberate falsehood on a matter of substance and the court should be satisfied that there is reasonable foundation for the charge.”
    (emphasis added)

    10. In Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi Marwah (2005) 4 SCC 370, this Court observed:

    “23. In view of the language used in Section 340 CrPC the court is not bound to make a complaint regarding commission of an offence referred to in Section 195(1)(b), as the section is conditioned by the words ‘court is of opinion that it is expedient in the interests of justice’. This shows that such a course will be adopted only if the interest of justice requires and not in every case. Before filing of the complaint, the court may hold a preliminary enquiry and record a finding to the effect that it is expedient in the interests of justice that enquiry should be made into any of the offences referred to in Section 195(1)(b). This expediency will normally be judged by the court by weighing not the magnitude of injury suffered by the person affected by such forgery or forged document, but having regard to the effect or impact, such commission of offence has upon administration of justice.”

    (See also R.S Sujatha v. State of Karnataka (2011) 5 SCC 689.)

    11. In view of the above, the law on the issue can be summarised that in order to initiate prosecution for perjury, the court must prima facie reach a conclusion after holding preliminary inquiry that there has been a deliberate and conscious effort to misguide the court and interfere in the administration of justice. More so, it has to be seen whether such a prosecution is necessary in the interest of justice. The case is required to be decided in light of the aforesaid settled legal proposition.

    12. The affidavit filed by Respondent 5 revealed that Respondent 5 had submitted the final report (Part I) in the aforesaid case on 11-1-2002 to the SP. It is also not in dispute as can be seen from the affidavit dated 5-4-2002, that the report submitted by the IO goes to the superior officers for scrutiny and comments. The High Court had passed a consent order dated 9-4-2002 WP (Cri) No. 938 of 2001 wherein certain directions had been issued to the Director, CBI to examine the case. The Director, CBI after examining the record of the case, vide order dated 23-4-2002, asked the IO to tighten the loose ends of the case. The said order has not been challenged till date. It is also evident that charge-sheet was filed on 5-12-2002 and, subsequently, cognizance was taken by the competent court on 10-1-2003. The case was filed under Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b) CrPC by the appellant on 3-5-2006, i.e after three-and-a-half years.

    13. The High Court while dealing with the case has also, after examining the original records as well as the file and particularly the confidential notings therein, came to the conclusion that in view of the directions issued by the superior authority, some other witnesses were examined “to tighten the loose ends of the case” and there was no attempt on the part of the investigating agency to mislead the court.

    14. The order dated 23-4-2002 passed by the Director, CBI has not been challenged by the appellant and the instant complaint had been filed after 3½ years in 2006. The statements were recorded on such directions, however, only to the extent of tightening the loose ends. More so, the provisions of Section 195(1)(b), etc. are also attracted in such a fact situation. After looking into the voluminous record of the case, what has been done after filing the affidavit or making the statement was minimal. The prosecution for perjury is required only where perjury appears to be deliberate and conscious and the conviction is reasonable, probable (sic reasonably probable) or likely. In the circumstances, a mere impression or perception of the appellant would not make the deposition on affidavit by Respondent 5 to be false as being a deliberate and conscious act.

    15. The Court further observed that the complaint had been filed after 4 years on the basis of mere impression of the appellant and under no circumstances, it could be held that there had been some deliberate and conscious attempt to mislead the court which may warrant entertaining the application filed by the appellant.

    16. We have given serious consideration to the material on record. However, we could not convince ourselves to take a view contrary to that of the High Court. The High Court has rightly reached the conclusion that there was no deliberate perjury to misguide the court while making such statement or filing the affidavit. In such a fact situation, the question of allowing application under Section 340 CrPC read with Section 195(1)(b) CrPC was not warranted.

    17. Thus, we do not find any cogent reason to interfere with the impugned judgment and order. The appeal lacks merit and, is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ashok Kumar Aggarwal v. Union Of India And Others
    (Nov 22, 2013)