AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Babu, a resident of Kullaveeranpatti, Mettur (Tamil Nadu), was killed on 18-4-2001 after being attacked with sickles by Saravanan (A-1), Raja alias Sasikumar (A-2) and Natesan alias Natarajan (A-3) among others. The incident was rooted in animosity stemming from a love triangle involving Chitra (PW 6), Arumugam alias Arupaiyan, and Palanichami. Immediately after the assault, Radhakrishnan (PW 2) lodged a written complaint that was registered as FIR No. 402/2001 under Section 302 IPC.

Upon investigation, the police charged A-1 to A-7 under Sections 302 read with 34, 120-B and 342 IPC. The Additional District Sessions Judge, Salem (Sessions Case No. 254/2004), convicted A-1 to A-6 of murder and wrongful confinement, sentencing them to life imprisonment and six months’ RI respectively, while acquitting A-7 and all accused of conspiracy. On appeal, the Madras High Court (Criminal Appeal No. 963/2005) acquitted A-4 to A-6 but confirmed conviction and sentence of A-1 to A-3. A-2 and A-3 then preferred the present appeal by special leave to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of A-2 and A-3 for murder under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC could be sustained on the basis of the testimonies of PWs 2 and 3 despite alleged inconsistencies.
  2. Whether contradictions regarding the place of occurrence, recording of the complaint, and identification of weapons generated reasonable doubt warranting acquittal.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (A-2 & A-3)

  • The evidence of eyewitnesses PWs 2 and 3 was unreliable due to contradictions about the place of occurrence and investigation details.
  • PW 3 stated that he was never examined by police, contradicting the investigating officer (PW 14).
  • PWs 2 and 3 failed to identify the weapons allegedly used.
  • Discrepancies existed between the oral complaint described by PW 2 and the written complaint relied upon by the police.
  • The prosecution failed to prove motive because neither Arumugam alias Arupaiyan nor Palanichami was examined.

Respondent State’s Arguments

  • The motive, arising from prior enmity linked to the love affair, was firmly established.
  • PWs 2 and 3 were natural, consistent eyewitnesses whose presence was corroborated by contemporaneous documents, including Ext. P-18 (accident register).
  • Minor inconsistencies did not undermine the core prosecution case.
  • The prompt lodging of FIR (Ext. P-19) and specific attribution of roles to A-1 to A-3 fortified the prosecution narrative.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court confined its analysis to the involvement of A-2 and A-3. Noting that the High Court had already rejected the testimonies of PWs 4 and 5, the Court scrutinised whether the evidence of PWs 2 and 3, together with the earliest document (complaint Ext. P-1/FIR Ext. P-19), was sufficient:

  • Prompt FIR & Specific Attribution: The complaint was lodged within 1 hour 40 minutes of the occurrence, explicitly naming A-1 to A-3 as assailants and describing the injuries inflicted.
  • Credibility of PWs 2 & 3: Both eyewitnesses were present at the scene and took the victim to hospital. PW 3’s presence was corroborated by his name in the accident register (Ext. P-18).
  • Minor Discrepancies: Variations regarding weapon identification, examination dates, and peripheral details were deemed negligible and insufficient to discard otherwise credible testimony.
  • Motive: The prior altercation stemming from rival affections for Chitra provided a rational motive, supporting the prosecution narrative.
  • Principle of Separating Truth from Falsehood: Endorsing the High Court’s approach, the Supreme Court held that even if some parts of the prosecution case failed against co-accused (A-4 to A-6), the credible portion implicating A-2 and A-3 could be safely relied upon.

Having found the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 trustworthy and consistent with contemporaneous records, the Court rejected all defence contentions and upheld the findings of the High Court.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The convictions and sentences of life imprisonment and six months’ RI imposed on Raja alias Sasikumar (A-2) and Natesan alias Natarajan (A-3) are affirmed.

Implications: The judgment maintains the High Court’s decision and leaves intact the life sentences of A-2 and A-3. It sets no new legal precedent but reinforces the principle that convictions may rest on credible eyewitness testimony despite minor inconsistencies and partial acquittal of co-accused.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Raja Alias Sasikumar And Another v. State Through Inspector Of Police .

    P. Sathasivam, C.J— This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 15-3-2007 passed by the High Court of Judicature of Madras in Saravanan v. Inspector of Police Criminal Appeal No. 963 of 2005 whereby the Division Bench of the High Court disposed of the appeal by acquitting A-4 to A-6 and confirmed the order of conviction and sentence dated 27-10-2005 in respect of A-1 to A-3 passed by the Additional District Sessions Judge, Salem in Sessions Case No. 254 of 2004.

    2. The facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are as under: this case relates to the death of one person by name Babu, resident of Kullaveeranpatti, Mettur, Tamil Nadu. One Arumugam alias Arupaiyan, who was working as a car driver at Sadurangadi, Mettur, was having an affair with one Chitra (PW 6), who, at the relevant time, was working at Krishna Medicals. One Palanichami, who was working as a car cleaner, too was in love with her.

    3. When Chitra informed Arumugam alias Arupaiyan about Palanichami, he confronted the cleaner and when the driver of the car, Senthil (A-7) asked him as to why he confronted him, Arumugam alias Arupaiyan started beating Senthil which resulted in enmity between A-7 and Arumugam alias Arupaiyan. A-7 also developed grudge against one Babu, the deceased, friend of Arumugam alias Arupaiyan, who also helped him during the abovesaid incident and even at one point of time, when both the groups were fighting, A-7 shouted at him that he (A-7) will not spare him at any cost.

    4. On 18-4-2001 when Babu was trying to start his motorcycle, the accused persons viz. Saravanan (A-1), Raja alias Sasikumar (A-2), Natesan alias Natarajan (A-3), Karthik (A-4), Chandran alias Chandramohan (A-5) and Sakthivel (A-6), intercepted him and prevented him from going further from that spot and A-1 inflicted a sickle-blow on his hand. In order to escape, Babu went inside the shed of one Sengodan (PW 3), but A-1, A-2 and A-3 also went inside that shed and inflicted cuts on him indiscriminately as a result of which he fell down and the accused persons fled away assuming that he was dead.

    5. Babu was immediately taken to Government Hospital, Mettur for treatment by one Radhakrishnan (PW 2) and Sengodan (PW 3) but he succumbed to his injuries. Radhakrishnan (PW 2) lodged a complaint against the accused persons with Police Station Mettur which was registered as FIR No. 402 of 2001 under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”).

    6. After the investigation, charges were framed against all the abovenamed accused persons including Senthil (A-7) under Section 302 read with Section 34, Section 120-B and Section 342 IPC and the case was committed to the Court of the Additional District Sessions Judge, Salem and was numbered as Sessions Case No. 254 of 2004. The Additional District Sessions Judge, by order dated 27-10-2005, sentenced A-1 to A-6 to suffer rigorous imprisonment (RI) for 6 months for the offence punishable under Section 342 IPC and imprisonment for life for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC along with a fine of Rs 1000 each, in default, to further undergo RI for 3 months. However, A-1 to A-7 were acquitted under Section 120-B IPC and A-7 was acquitted of all the charges.

    7. Being aggrieved of the order dated 27-10-2005, A-1 to A-6 filed Criminal Appeal No. 963 of 2005 before the High Court. The Division Bench of the High Court, by order dated 15-3-2007 Criminal Appeal No. 963 of 2005, disposed of the appeal by acquitting A-4 to A-6 while sustaining the conviction and sentence of A-1 to A-3. Being aggrieved by the order of the High Court, A-2 and A-3 have preferred this appeal by way of special leave before this Court.

    8. Heard Mr V. Kanagaraj, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant-accused and Mr M. Yogesh Kanna, learned counsel for the respondent State.

    Contentions

    9. Mr V. Kanagaraj, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants submitted that the evidence of the eyewitnesses viz. PWs 2 and 3, read with the evidence of other prosecution witnesses, creates a doubt about the case of the prosecution, hence, the conviction based on such evidence cannot be sustained. He also submitted that inasmuch as Kasinathan (PW 14), the investigating officer has stated in his evidence that he examined PW 3 on 20-4-2001 and PW 3 in his evidence before the court contradicted his statement that the police never examined him, the evidence of PW 3 has to be disbelieved in toto. He also pointed out that with regard to the actual place of occurrence, the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 contradicts each other, therefore, it is not safe to rely upon their evidence. He further pointed out that both PWs 2 and 3 could not identify the weapon and this aspect was also not considered by the High Court. He also submitted that as per the evidence of PW 2, he had given only oral complaint which was reduced into writing by the police and was attested by one Maheswaran whereas as per the investigating officer (PW 14), PW 2 had given a written complaint and the same was registered and not attested by the aforesaid person. In such circumstance, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that it is not safe to rely upon the case of the prosecution. He also submitted that the prosecution failed to establish the motive i.e the love affair by examining Arumugam alias Arupaiyan and Palanichami. The said two persons having enmity between them and the deceased alleged to have died on supporting Arumugam alias Arupaiyan and the accused persons alleged to have supported Palanichami.

    10. On the other hand, Mr Yogesh Kanna, learned counsel for the respondent State submitted that the prosecution has fully established the motive for the crime. He also pointed out that the courts below, particularly, the High Court, rightly relied on the evidence of PWs 2 and 3, who witnessed the incident and convicted the appellants herein. He also pointed out that PW 2, being the author of the complaint (Ext. P-1), there is no reason to disbelieve his statement. He further highlighted that PWs 2 and 3 were the persons who brought the injured to the hospital within 20 minutes after the occurrence and the presence of PW 3 was also proved by marking a copy of the accident register dated 18-4-2001 as Ext. P-18. He finally submitted that due to minor contradictions in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, the entire prosecution case cannot be thrown out.

    11. We have carefully considered the rival contentions and perused the relevant materials.

    Discussion

    12. It is not in dispute that out of the 7 accused, the conviction relating to A-1 to A-3 was confirmed by the High Court and A-2 and A-3 alone preferred this appeal, therefore, we are concerned about the role and involvement of A-2 and A-3 in the commission of the crime as projected by the prosecution. Though the prosecution has examined PWs 2 to 5 as eyewitnesses to the crime, the High Court itself has disbelieved the evidence of PWs 4 and 5 and the entire prosecution case rests upon the evidence of PWs 2 and 3. We are conscious of the fact that relying upon the prosecution witnesses, the High Court set aside the conviction of A-4 to A-6 in toto and acquitted them. It is also relevant to point out that the High Court took note of the general principle that if the prosecution case is the same against all the accused or with regard to some of the accused on the same set of evidence available on record with reference to any of the accused, then the Court would not be committing any mistake in acquitting all the accused and conversely, if it is possible to do so, namely, to remove the chaff from the grain, the Court would not be committing any mistake in sustaining the prosecution case against whom the evidence is shown to be intact.

    13. It is true that in the earliest information, there was no reference to the presence of PWs 2 to 5. In other words, their names did not find place in the complaint (Ext. P-1). As rightly observed by the High Court, there is no need to mention all the details graphically in the complaint and it depends upon so many factors such as condition of the injured, etc. It is also not in dispute that the incident occurred on 18-4-2001 at 8.20 p.m Inasmuch as PWs 4 and 5 were examined by the investigating officer only on 20-4-2001, there were vast inconsistencies in noting the presence of the accused at the scene of occurrence as well as in the number of assailants at the earliest point of time and the High Court has rightly disbelieved the version of PWs 4 and 5. If there is any tangible and acceptable material from the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 in the earliest information i.e the complaint (Ext. P-1), which is believable, there is no reason to reject the case of the prosecution insofar as the appellants are concerned.

    14. A perusal of the FIR (Ext. P-19) discloses that the incident occurred on 18-4-2001 at 8.20 p.m and the information was received by Police Station Mettur at 10.00 p.m on the same day itself and an FIR being No. 402 of 2001 was registered based on the written complaint by the complainant Radhakrishnan (PW 2). It is stated that one Arumugam alias Arupaiyan was his friend and he was having an affair with one Chitra (PW 6), who at the relevant time was working at Krishna Medicals. Another person, by name Palanichami, who was working as a car cleaner, too was in love with her. It is further stated that Arupaiyan confronted the said cleaner and when the driver of the car viz. Senthil (A-7) questioned the same, Arupaiyan had beaten Senthil. Based on the said incident, the accused persons, including the present appellants, threatened the deceased and his persons. In the said complaint, PW 2 has made a specific reference about the role of A-1, A-2 and A-3. It is also asserted that it was A-1 to A-3 who inflicted cut injuries on Babu (the deceased). The complainant has also stated that with the aid of one Sengodan (PW 3), he admitted Babu in the Government Hospital at Mettur for treatment but in spite of the same, he succumbed to the injuries. The same has been endorsed by the Inspector, Mettur on 18-4-2001 at 2130 hrs at Government Hospital, Mettur and a case was registered in Mettur PS as Crime No. 402 of 2001 under Section 302 IPC on 18-4-2001 at 2200 hrs. It is clear from the complaint that the complainant (PW 2) has implicated A-1 to A-3 (A-2 and A-3 are the appellants herein) and specifically stated that they are the persons who inflicted fatal injuries on Babu (the deceased). There was no delay in making the complaint and the same was duly registered by the police.

    15. Insofar as the evidence of PW 2 is concerned, he is also a resident of Kullaveeranpatti in Mettur. In his evidence, he deposed that he knew all the accused persons and on 18-4-2001 when he and Babu (the deceased) were on election duty, they parked their Bullet motorcycle in front of Sengodan's lathe shed near Navapatti Agricultural Cooperative Bank and, thereafter, they went for the election work. When they returned after completing their work, at that time, suddenly, 5 persons came from the west main road and attacked on the back of Babu. Immediately, in order to escape, Babu ran inside the lathe shed of Sengodan (PW 3). In the open court, PW 2 identified A-2 and A-3 correctly. He further deposed that after inflicting cut injuries to Babu, they ran towards the south of the lathe shed. Thereafter, PWs 2 and 3 went inside the lathe shed and saw that Babu was lying in a pool of blood and struggling for life. They took Babu in an autorickshaw and admitted him in a hospital where the doctor informed them that Babu has died. The injuries of all other aspects have been noted in the accident register and a copy of the same has been marked as Ext. P-18. Though Shri R. Raju, the doctor who issued Ext. P-18 i.e the accident register, has not been examined, all the details have been explained by the doctor who conducted the post-mortem on the body of the deceased. It is also noted that PW 3 was also present in the hospital along with PW 2.

    16. Deposition of Sengodan (PW 3) shows that he was also a native of Kullaveeranpatti in Mettur. He also narrated the entire incident implicating A-1 to A-3. He deposed before the court as to how Radhakrishnan (PW 2) came to the spot along with Babu (the deceased) and how he was attacked by A-1 to A-3. He also mentioned that it was Radhakrishnan (PW 2) who took the deceased to the hospital in an autorickshaw along with him.

    17. As rightly observed by the High Court, inasmuch as in the earliest document, namely, the complaint, there is a specific reference to the involvement and role of the appellants including A-1 supported by the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 and the name of PW 3 has also been mentioned in the accident register (Ext. P-18), there is no valid reason to reject the evidence of the eyewitnesses viz. PWs 2 and 3. No doubt, there were some variations in the statements of PWs 2 and 3 and the investigating officer (PW 14), however, when the variations are negligible about making of the complaint, taking note of the assertion of PWs 2 and 3 and various injuries inflicted on Babu, we concur with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court in accepting their evidence (PWs 2 and 3) on all aspects insofar as A-1 to A-3.

    18. Inasmuch as the prosecution has established the motive for the commission of offence, the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 is acceptable insofar as the involvement of A-2 and A-3 in the crime in question is concerned. In view of the presence of PW 3, which is also noted in the accident register (Ext. P-18) and of the fact that the contradictions are minor in nature, we agree with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court. Consequently, we reject all the arguments advanced by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants.

    19. In the light of the above discussion, we do not find any merit in the appeal, consequently, the same is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raja Alias Sasikumar And Another v. State Through Inspector Of Police .
    (Aug 22, 2013)