AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “CrPC”)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”)
  • Sections 120-B/302 IPC, and Sections 25(1-B)(a)/27 of the Arms Act, 1959
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “CrPC”)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”)
  • Sections 120-B/302 IPC, and Sections 25(1-B)(a)/27 of the Arms Act, 1959
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On the night of 11-2-2001, Md. Jahangir alias “Mughal” was shot at the junction of Iron Gate Road and Risaldar Gate Road in Calcutta. An FIR was lodged at 10.18 p.m. by Md. Rashid Khan (PW-3) naming the present appellant, Sayed Darain, as one of the assailants. The deceased was taken to Hannan Nursing Home where he was declared dead. Police registered a case under Sections 120-B/302 IPC and Sections 25(1-B)(a)/27 of the Arms Act. After investigation, a charge-sheet was filed against the appellant and one Abuzar Hossain under Sections 302/34 IPC and the matter was committed to the Sessions Court.

The trial court examined 24 witnesses, including four eyewitnesses (PW-3, PW-4, PW-5, PW-7), and convicted both accused under Sections 302/34 IPC, sentencing them to life imprisonment and a fine. The Calcutta High Court dismissed the appellant’s criminal appeal (CRA No. 244 of 2003) on 12-5-2006, affirming the conviction and sentence. The present judgment decides the appellant’s further challenge by special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether alleged inconsistencies between ocular testimony and medical / forensic evidence rendered the eyewitness account unreliable, thereby vitiating the conviction.
  2. Whether failure to conduct a test-identification parade undermined the eyewitness identification of the appellant.
  3. Whether the prosecution’s reliance on a forensic science laboratory (FSL) report that was allegedly not put to the accused under Section 313 CrPC violated fair-trial requirements.
  4. Whether the eyewitnesses were “interested” witnesses acting at the behest of the deceased’s brother, thus creating reasonable doubt.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Ocular evidence of PW-3, PW-4, PW-5 and PW-7 conflicted with medical evidence because only one bullet injury was found despite their account of multiple shots.
  • The FSL report indicated use of a .303″ rifle, whereas witnesses spoke of revolvers; a rifle implies long-distance firing inconsistent with eyewitness claims of close-range attack.
  • The deceased’s brother, Raju, allegedly had a property motive and orchestrated false testimony through witnesses who were his friends or neighbours; hence they were “interested” witnesses.
  • No test-identification parade was held, making in-court identification unsafe.
  • The FSL report dated 4-6-2001 was not put to the appellant under Section 313 CrPC; relying on it violates the ratio in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda.
  • Cited precedents: Mani Ram v. State of U.P. (direct evidence unsupported by expert evidence), State of Punjab v. Rajinder Singh (ocular–medical inconsistency), and Sharad Birdhichand Sarda (Section 313 requirements).

State's Arguments

  • All four eyewitnesses consistently named the appellant as an assailant at close range and described multiple shots.
  • The FSL report showed bullets were fired from an improvised firearm, and an empty cartridge plus another bullet were recovered at the scene, corroborating the eyewitness version.
  • The Section 313 CrPC questionnaire did refer to sending seized articles to the FSL; the appellant suffered no prejudice.
  • Medical evidence (PW-12) affirmed death by gunshot and did not contradict ocular evidence; reliance placed on Gamini Bala Koteswara Rao where ocular evidence prevailed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mani Ram v. State of U.P., 1994 Supp (2) SCC 289 Where direct (ocular) evidence is not supported by expert evidence, conviction becomes difficult. Distinguished; the Court found medical and forensic evidence did not negate the ocular testimony in this case.
State of Punjab v. Rajinder Singh, (2009) 15 SCC 612 Prosecution story doubtful when medical and ocular evidence clearly diverge. Held inapplicable because medical evidence here was consistent with eyewitness accounts.
Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 Circumstances not put to the accused under Section 313 CrPC must be excluded. Court found the appellant not prejudiced; evidence was recorded in his presence and broadly put to him.
Gamini Bala Koteswara Rao v. State of A.P., (2009) 10 SCC 636 Medical evidence did not contradict ocular evidence on facts. Cited by State; Court approved the approach and applied it to uphold ocular evidence.
Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P., (2010) 10 SCC 259 Ocular evidence prevails unless medical evidence makes it improbable or impossible. Relied on to affirm that medical findings did not rule out eyewitness version; hence ocular evidence accepted.
Ram Narain Singh v. State of Punjab, (1975) 4 SCC 497; State of Haryana v. Bhagirath, (1999) 5 SCC 96; Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat, (1983) 2 SCC 174; Khambam Raja Reddy v. Public Prosecutor, (2006) 11 SCC 239; State of U.P. v. Dinesh, (2009) 11 SCC 566; State of U.P. v. Hari Chand, (2009) 13 SCC 542 Series of decisions on the interplay between medical and ocular evidence. Referenced within Abdul Sayeed; collectively reinforce that ocular testimony is not discarded unless medical evidence makes it impossible.
State of Punjab v. Swaran Singh, (2005) 6 SCC 101 Evidence not specifically put to the accused can still be considered if no prejudice is caused. Court used this authority to reject the appellant’s Section 313 argument regarding the FSL report.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Consistency of eyewitness evidence with medical findings: The Court reproduced key excerpts of PW-3, PW-4, PW-5 and PW-7, noting their uniform description that the appellant and 8-10 associates fired at the deceased at close range. Post-mortem evidence (PW-12) recorded a fatal gunshot wound (Injury 7) and a possible grazing bullet injury (Injury 6), thereby corroborating the occurrence of gunfire rather than contradicting it.

2. Forensic report and type of weapon: Although the FSL report mentioned a .303″ cartridge and improvised firearm, expert literature (Dr B.R. Sharma) recognised that improvised handguns can fire .303″ ammunition. The Court concluded that eyewitness references to “guns” or “revolvers” reflected lay terminology for country-made handguns, reconciling the apparent discrepancy.

3. Alleged bias and “interested” witnesses: The Court found no record evidence to suggest the deceased’s brother Raju orchestrated the testimony. All four eyewitnesses were local residents who happened upon the crime scene; cross-examination failed to shake their credibility.

4. Test-identification parade: Because the eyewitnesses and the appellant were residents of the same locality and already acquainted, a TIP was unnecessary; immediate identification at the scene was therefore reliable.

5. Section 313 CrPC complaint: While the detailed contents of the FSL report were not verbatim put to the accused, the fact that seized articles were sent to the FSL was specifically put and the appellant was present when PW-24 proved the report (Exh. 14). Relying on Swaran Singh, the Court held no prejudice was caused and exclusion of the report was unwarranted.

6. Precedential guidance: Applying Abdul Sayeed and related cases, the Court reiterated that ocular evidence outweighs medical evidence unless the latter makes the former impossible—a threshold not met here.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed; Conviction and Sentence Affirmed.

The Supreme Court upheld the life sentence imposed on the appellant. The decision primarily affects the parties, confirming the appellant’s conviction. It does not create new substantive law but reinforces existing principles on evaluating ocular versus medical evidence and the limited impact of procedural omissions where no prejudice is demonstrated.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sayed Darain Ahsan Alias Darain v. State Of West Bengal And Another

    A.K Patnaik, J.— This is an appeal by way of special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution of India against the judgment dated 12-5-2006 of the High Court of Calcutta in Sayed Darain v. State of W.B (2006) 2 Cal LT 547 affirming the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) as well as the sentence of life imprisonment imposed on the appellant by the trial court and dismissing the appeal of the appellant.

    2. The facts briefly are that an FIR was lodged with the officer in charge of Garden Reach Police Station, Calcutta, on 11-2-2001 at about 10.18 p.m by Md. Rashid Khan. In the FIR, Rashid stated that on 11-2-2001 at about 9.45 p.m when he was sitting along with Md. Shamim Ansari at the junction of Iron Gate Road and Risaldar Gate Road and gossiping, Md. Jahangir alias Mughal walked along Iron Gate Road towards Garden Reach Road at about 9.50 p.m Suddenly, they heard a sound of firing from the side of Iron Gate Road and both went there running and saw that eight to ten persons had encircled Mughal and were firing at him again and again. Mughal fell down on the street and the assailants fled away from the spot in different directions and he could recognise the appellant as one of the assailants.

    3. Thereafter, Rashid and Shamim and some people who had gathered from neighbouring areas took Mughal to Hannan Nursing Home at B-79, Iron Gate Road, where Mughal was declared dead. The officer in charge of the police station registered a case under Sections 120-B/302 IPC, and Sections 25(1-B)(a)/27 of the Arms Act, 1959 against the appellant and directed Sub-Inspector B.C Sarkar to take up the investigation of the case. After investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant and Abuzar Hossain under Sections 302/34 IPC, and the case was committed to the Sessions Court for trial.

    4. At the trial, the prosecution examined as many as 24 witnesses. Rashid was examined as PW 3 and Shamim was examined as PW 4. Both PW 3 and PW 4 supported the prosecution case as narrated in the FIR. Besides these two eyewitnesses, two more eyewitnesses, who on 11-2-2001 at about 9.00 p.m, were gossiping in front of a shop near the place of occurrence, Yusuf and Jahid, were examined as PW 5 and PW 7 and they also supported the prosecution case as narrated in the FIR.

    5. The trial court, after considering the evidence of the four eyewitnesses as well as the medical and other evidence on record, held that both the accused persons, the appellant and Abuzar Hossain, were guilty of the offences under Sections 302/34 IPC. The trial court also heard the parties on the question of sentence and sentenced each of the two accused persons to suffer life imprisonment and also each of the accused persons to pay a fine of Rs 5000 and in default to suffer RI for one more year.

    6. Aggrieved, the appellant filed CRA No. 244 of 2003 before the High Court but the High Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant by the trial court.

    7. Mr S.B Sanyal, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, submitted that the ocular evidence of PW 3, PW 4, PW 5 and PW 7 ought not to have been believed because it is inconsistent with the medical evidence in the present case. He submitted that these witnesses have said before the court that the appellant and his associates surrounded the deceased and all of them fired at the deceased but the medical evidence reveals that there was only one bullet injury on the deceased.

    8. Mr Sanyal further submitted that as per the forensic science laboratory report dated 4-6-2001, the bullet fired was of a .303″ rifle, but the eyewitnesses have said that the assailants had fired from revolvers. He submitted that if a rifle has been actually used to kill the deceased, the firing must have taken place from a long distance and not from a short distance as alleged by the eyewitnesses.

    9. Mr Sanyal further submitted that the truth is that Raju, who was the younger brother of the deceased, was interested in the property of the deceased, who was a wealthy person, and it is Raju who had killed the deceased and had set up the witnesses against the appellant. He submitted that evidence on record establishes that Raju and PW 3 reside in the same premises and PW 4 is a close friend of PW 3, PW 5 knew Raju since his boyhood and PW 7 was a close friend of both PW 4 as well as Raju and PW 5 and PW 7 are friends. He vehemently argued that all the eyewitnesses were, therefore, interested witnesses and should not have been believed.

    10. Mr Sanyal further argued that no test identification parade was held at the time of investigation and it was not possible for the witnesses to identify the appellant as one of the persons who had fired at the deceased.

    11. Mr Sanyal cited the decision of this Court in Mani Ram v. State of U.P 1994 Supp (2) SCC 289 for the proposition that where the direct evidence was not supported by the expert evidence, it would be difficult to convict the accused on the basis of such evidence. He also relied on State of Punjab v. Rajinder Singh (2009) 15 SCC 612 in which it was held that the prosecution story was doubtful because there was clear inconsistency between medical evidence and ocular evidence.

    12. Mr Sanyal submitted that the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory was not put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “CrPC”). He cited the decision of this Court in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra (1984) 4 SCC 116 in which it has been held that the circumstances, which were not put to the accused in his examination under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, have to be completely excluded from consideration. According to Mr Sanyal, therefore, this is a fit case in which the appellant should be acquitted of the charges under Sections 302/34 IPC, and the judgments of the High Court and the trial court should be set aside.

    13. Mr Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, learned counsel appearing for the State, on the other hand, strongly relied on the evidence of the eyewitnesses, namely, PW 3, PW 4, PW 5, and PW 7 who had all supported the prosecution case. He submitted that all the eyewitnesses have named the appellant as the person who was holding a gun and who shot the deceased. He referred to the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory which clearly revealed that the two bullets (Exts. B and I) were fired through an improvised firearm, one hit the deceased in the occipital region and the other grazed the deceased in the temporal region. He also referred to the seizure list, Ext. 2 to show that an empty cartridge and one bullet head were also found at the place of occurrence.

    14. Mr Ganguli submitted that the contention of Mr Sanyal that the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory was not put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 CrPC, is not correct. He referred to the question put by the trial court to the appellant in which it was brought to the notice of the appellant that the IO sent the seized articles to the forensic science laboratory after completion of the investigation and only thereafter the charge-sheet was filed against the appellant.

    15. Mr Ganguli cited the decision in Gamini Bala Koteswara Rao v. State of A.P (2009) 10 SCC 636 in which this Court has taken a view on facts that the medical evidence did not in any way contradict the ocular evidence. He submitted that there is no inconsistency between the ocular evidence and the medical evidence in this case and this Court should also accept the ocular evidence of the four eyewitnesses who had seen the appellant firing at the deceased.

    16. We may first deal with the arguments of Mr Sanyal that the medical evidence in this case is such as to make the prosecution story as told by PW 3, PW 4, PW 5 and PW 7 improbable. We extract hereinbelow the relevant portions of the evidence of PW 3, PW 4, PW 5 and PW 7:

    “PW 3: I heard a sound of firing in the direction of B-35, Iron Gate Road. On hearing this we ran towards B-35, Iron Gate Road and found Darain with 8-10 others had surrounded Mughal from all sides. Darain and his associates were armed with gun. They uttered in a single voice that Mughal should be finished. Saying this they fired at Mughal, Mughal fell on the ground with bullet injury.
    PW 4: After some time I heard a sound of firing from the direction of B-35, Iron Gate Road. I myself and Rashid ran a few (sic some) distance and found Darain and eight or ten others. Some of them Mughal from behind and no by the side of Mughal (sic). They all uttered in a voice that Mughal should be finished. Saying this Darain and his associates started firing upon Mughal. As a result of such firing Mughal fell at B-35, Iron Gate Road.
    PW 5: I also found Mughal Bhai coming from the side of Bangalee Bazar and when he arrived near the mouth of the lane at B-35, Iron Gate Road at that time Darain, Abuzar Hossain and other associates of Darain detained Mughal Bhai. There were about 8-10 persons armed with revolvers. Darain and his associates surrounded Mughal from his left side and back side. One of those 8-10 persons fired from the revolver and then Darain and Abuzar Hossain said to his associates to kill Jahangir alias Mughal. Immediately all the persons fired upon Jahangir alias Mughal. I could identify only Darain and Abuzar Hossain (identified on the dock). Mughal instantly fell down on the ground.
    PW 7: At about 9.50 p.m I found that Mughal Bhai was coming from the side of Bangalee Bazar towards ourselves and when he reached near B-35, Iron Gate Road at that time Darain and Abuzar Hossain and others encircled Mughal from his behind and side. Out of those persons somebody fired. Then Darain, Abuzar and others abused Mughal filthily and started firing at random and fired about 6-7 times. They also uttered, ‘Sale ko khatam kar do’. (Identified the accused Darain and Abuzar on the dock.)”

    It will be clear from the evidence of PW 3, PW 4, PW 5 and PW 7 that the consistent version of all the four eyewitnesses is that the appellant and his associates fired at the deceased and as a result the deceased fell down.

    17. The medical evidence of this case is of Dr Amitava Das, PW 12, who carried out the post-mortem on the dead body of the deceased. He has stated that on the dead body of the deceased he found the following injuries:

    “1. Injury abrasion 1″ × ½″ over left forehead. 1½″ left to midline and ½″ above left eyebrow.
    2. Abrasion 1″ × ½″ over left side of face just above the monistic and 2″ left to midline.
    3. Abrasion 2″ × 1″ over interior aspect of lower part of right chest wall 9″ below right clavicle and 2½″ right to interior midline.
    4. Graze abrasion 4″ × 1″ over posterior aspect of lower part of right arm and right elbow.
    5. Graze abrasion 1½″ × 1″ over posterior aspect of left elbow.
    6. One lacerated wound ½″ × ¼″ into bone over right side temporal region, 1″ right of outer of canvas of right eye and 4″ above the right angle of mandible and 5.5″ above right heel with evidence of gutter fracture involving outer table of right temporal bone might have been caused by a grazing bullet.
    7. One wound of entrance of gunshot injury of size ½″ to ½″ more or less oval in shape with reddish margin with abrasion 0.2″ surrounding it with brushing underneath with evidence of no protrusion of fat and evidence of turning of body hair was placed over right side of posterior aspect of neck just below the hair border just right to posterior midline 1″ below external occipital pursuance 5′ 2″ above right heel.”

    18. Dr Das, PW 12 has also stated that in his opinion the death was due to the effects of a gunshot injury which was ante-mortem and homicidal in nature. This obviously refers to Injury 7. Regarding Injury 6, he has stated that it was not possible for him to say that the injury was caused by grazing by the bullet or not.

    19. Thus the medical evidence is also clear that the death of the deceased was caused by a bullet injury. The medical evidence clearly supports and does not contradict the ocular evidence of PW 3, PW 4, PW 5 and PW 7 that the deceased was killed by the gunshots fired by the appellant and his associates.

    20. In a recent judgment in Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P (2010) 10 SCC 259 this Court after considering its earlier decisions in Ram Narain Singh v. State of Punjab (1975) 4 SCC 497, State of Haryana v. Bhagirath (1999) 5 SCC 96, Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat (1983) 2 SCC 174, Mani Ram v. State of U.P 1994 Supp (2) SCC 289, Khambam Raja Reddy v. Public Prosecutor (2006) 11 SCC 239, State of U.P v. Dinesh (2009) 11 SCC 566 and State of U.P v. Hari Chand (2009) 13 SCC 542 has held: (Abdul Sayeed case (2010) 10 SCC 259g-h)

    though the ocular testimony of witness has greater evidentiary value vis-à-vis medical evidence but when medical evidence makes the ocular testimony improbable, that becomes a relevant factor in the process of evaluation of evidence. However, where the medical evidence goes so far that it completely rules out all possibility of the ocular evidence being true, the ocular evidence may be disbelieved.

    In the facts of the present case, as we have seen, the medical evidence does not go so far as to rule out all possibility of the ocular evidence being true. Hence, the ocular evidence cannot be disbelieved.

    21. We now turn to the submission of Mr Sanyal that as per the forensic science laboratory report dated 4-6-2001 the bullet was of .303″ rifle whereas the eyewitnesses have said that the assailants had fired from revolvers. PW 12 who carried out the post-mortem on the dead body of the deceased has stated that eight articles were preserved after the post-mortem and these included skin from wound of entry and foreign body (bullet). PW 24 who took up further investigation of the case has deposed that on 16-2-2001 he received sealed packets collected from CMOH, Alipore during autopsy like blood, foreign body (bullet), hair, etc. and on 16-4-2001 he sent these articles to the forensic science laboratory and thereafter received the reports from the forensic science laboratory on different dates.

    22. The report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory contains the result of examination of some of these articles. These articles are kept in an envelope marked A containing one deformed fired case of a .303″ rifle cartridge (Ext. A), an envelope marked B containing one fired nose bullet of .315″/8 mm calibre (Ext. B), the glass phial marked I containing one fired metal jacketed bullet of improvised make having dark brown bloodstains (Ext. I) and a glass phial J containing semi-solid substance said to be a piece of human skin (Ext. J).

    23. The results of the examination of these articles as given in the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory are as follows:

    “The physical condition of Ext. A suggested that it was used for firing through an improvised firearm capable of firing .303″ rifle cartridges.
    Although Exts. B and I were not of identical calibres but both were found to have been fired through improvised firearm. The scratch mark patterns on B and I were found to match characteristically while compared under microscope. Hence it was revealed that both Exts. B and I were fired through the same improvised firearm.
    No opinion could be given on Ext. J as it was unfit for any examination.”

    The report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory thus is clear that the firearms used by the appellant and his associates were improvised firearms capable of firing .303″ rifle cartridges.

    24. Dr B.R Sharma in his book on Firearms in Criminal Investigation & Trials published by Universal Law Publishing Co., 4th Edn., has in Chapter 11 on “Improvised Firearms” classified country-made firearms with reference to the ammunition used in them: .12 bore firearms and .303 bore firearms. Dr Sharma has also classified country-made firearms according to the manner in which they are fired: shoulder firearms or the handguns.

    25. Dr Sharma has stated that country-made firearms are non-standard firearms and they are not tested or proved for their fire-worthiness and are, therefore, usually imperfect contrivances. He has also stated that the poor construction of the firearms affects the firing process in many respects and sometimes the incomplete combustion inhibits a complete and proper development of pressure and the projectiles do not acquire standard velocities or striking energies.

    26. Considering the evidence on record and the opinions of experts we have discussed, we have no doubt that the deceased has not been shot by a rifle from a long distance but by improvised or country-made handguns capable of firing .303 rifle cartridges from a short distance. PW 3 has described these as guns, whereas PW 5 has described these as revolvers because he has not been able to distinguish a revolver from a country-made handgun. PW 4 and PW 7 are silent on whether the appellant and his associates have used guns or revolvers. Some of these eyewitnesses have said that all the assailants fired but they could not have known how many projectiles were actually ejected from these defective improvised firearms as a result of firing. One bullet has been recovered from the occipital region of the deceased and another bullet and an empty cartridge have been recovered from the place of occurrence. Hence, in the present case, the fact that the other bullets were not recovered either from the body of the deceased or from the place of occurrence does not belie the prosecution story that the appellant and his associates had fired and killed the deceased.

    27. We may now consider the argument of Mr Sanyal that Raju, who was the younger brother of the deceased had actually killed the deceased and had set up the witnesses against the appellant and that PW 3, PW 4, PW 5 and PW 7 were directly or indirectly connected with Raju and were all interested witnesses. We do not find any material on record to support the contention of Mr Sanyal that Raju was behind the killing of the deceased.

    28. The witnesses PW 3 and PW 4 were chatting at the junction of Risaldar Gate Road and Iron Gate Road and PW 5 and PW 7 were gossiping in front of the shop of PW 6. All the four eyewitnesses were of the locality in which the incident took place and happened to be at the place of occurrence at the time of the incident and their evidence would show that they have stated whatever they have actually observed. Although, during cross-examination the defence has suggested to these witnesses that their evidence implicating the appellant is false, the defence has not been able to create a reasonable doubt about the veracity of their evidence.

    29. We cannot therefore accept the submission of Mr Sanyal that the four eyewitnesses were directly or indirectly connected with Raju and had implicated the appellant for the offence at the instance of Raju, who was the man behind the killing of the deceased.

    30. We also do not find any merit in the submission of Mr Sanyal that as no test identification parade was held at the time of investigation, the eyewitnesses could not have identified the appellant as one of the persons who fired at the deceased. The appellant, PW 3 and PW 4 were residents of Iron Gate Road, which was the part of Garden Reach Police Station. PW 5 and PW 7 were residents of Bichali Ghat Road which is also a part of the same police station, Garden Reach. Hence, the appellant and the four eyewitnesses belonged to the same locality and the four eyewitnesses knew the appellant before the incident and were able to immediately identify the appellant at the time of the incident. It is only if the appellant was a stranger to the eyewitnesses that the test identification parade would have been necessary at the time of investigation.

    31. Coming now to the submission of Mr Sanyal that the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory was not put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 CrPC, we find that PW 24 has stated in his evidence that he has received four forensic science laboratory reports on different dates and PW 4 has been cross-examined on behalf of the appellant. We also find from the examination of the appellant under Section 313 CrPC that the court did put a question to him that PW 24 who took up further investigation of the case sent the seized articles to the forensic science laboratory including articles collected from CMOH, Alipore and after completion of investigation submitted charge-sheet against both the accused persons under Sections 302/34 IPC and sought a reply from the appellant.

    32. The evidence of PW 24 was recorded by the court in the presence of the appellant and the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory was marked as Ext. 14 on 24-2-2003 and the court had also put it to the appellant during his examination on 4-3-2003 that the seized articles were sent to the forensic science laboratory, yet the appellant has stated in his reply before the court that he was not aware. The appellant could have stated on 4-3-2001 if he had anything to say on the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory.

    33. Thus, although the content of the report dated 4-6-2001 of the forensic science laboratory was not put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant was not in any way prejudiced. In State of Punjab v. Swaran Singh (2005) 6 SCC 101, AIR 2005 SC 3114, this Court has held relying on the earlier decisions of this Court that where the accused was not in any way prejudiced by not giving him an opportunity to answer specifically regarding evidence which was recorded in his presence, such evidence cannot be excluded from consideration by the court.

    34. We find that the High Court has rightly held in the impugned judgment that all the eyewitnesses have given a vivid and true account of the incident and had seen the occurrence on close range and as they were residents of the locality they had no problem in identifying the assailants and there was nothing on record suggesting that they nurtured ill feeling and harboured enmity against the appellant and that the evidence of the eyewitnesses was consistent and finds due corroboration from the post-mortem report. In our considered opinion, the High Court has rightly sustained the conviction of the appellant on the evidence of four eyewitnesses as corroborated by the medical evidence.

    35. In the result, we find no merit in the appeal which is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sayed Darain Ahsan Alias Darain v. State Of West Bengal And Another
    (Mar 22, 2012)