AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A contempt petition was filed in WPST No. 47 of 2009 alleging that the West Bengal State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) had failed to comply with a High Court direction to advance the hearing of an application pending before it. The Calcutta High Court issued contempt notices to the SAT Members—former High Court Judges—who responded with explanations and an unconditional apology, undertaking to comply with the direction after the summer vacation.

While disposing of the contempt petition (CPAN No. 50 of 2010) on 19-5-2010, the High Court accepted the apology but recorded disparaging remarks about the Members’ performance. Aggrieved, the Members approached the Supreme Court seeking expungement of those remarks. The present decision is on their civil appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, after accepting an unconditional apology in contempt proceedings, was justified in recording adverse remarks against the SAT Members.
  2. Whether such remarks ought to be expunged to uphold judicial propriety and the restrained use of contempt jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.N. Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik, (2000) 4 SCC 400 Contempt jurisdiction must not be used in abundance or misused; discretion must be exercised to uphold the court’s dignity. Invoked to emphasise that courts should act judiciously and avoid excessive use of contempt powers.
Suresh Chandra Poddar v. Dhani Ram, (2002) 1 SCC 766 Courts should not be oversensitive; after compliance is shown they should exhibit judicial grace in contempt matters. Cited to illustrate that the High Court should have shown magnanimity once the SAT Members complied and apologised.
P.K. Singh v. S.N. Kanungo, (2010) 4 SCC 504 If violation is neither wilful nor deliberate, contempt should be dropped; acceptance of apology should end the matter without additional penalties. Used to support the view that recording further criticism after accepting apology was inappropriate.
Dinabandhu Sahu v. State of Orissa, (1972) 4 SCC 761 Judicial function does not include vindictiveness or personal considerations. Relied on to underscore the need for restraint and avoidance of disparaging remarks.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court acknowledged that the High Court had some justification for initiating contempt proceedings because of the delayed compliance. However, it held that once the unconditional apology was accepted, the High Court should have refrained from making disparaging observations against the SAT Members. Drawing on its own precedents, the Court reiterated that:

  • Contempt powers exist solely to uphold the majesty of law and must be exercised with restraint (R.N. Dey).
  • Courts are expected to show “judicial grace and magnanimity” once compliance is achieved (Suresh Chandra Poddar).
  • After finding no wilful disobedience, proceedings should end without further censure (P.K. Singh).
  • Judges must avoid vindictiveness or personal criticism (Dinabandhu Sahu).

Emphasising that judges “are also mortals,” the Court concluded that the High Court’s remarks were unnecessary and could undermine judicial dignity rather than protect it.

Holding and Implications

Held: The appeal is allowed; all disparaging remarks and observations made by the Calcutta High Court against the SAT Members in CPAN No. 50 of 2010 are expunged.

Implications: The immediate effect is the removal of the critical observations from the High Court’s order, thereby restoring the professional standing of the SAT Members. The decision reinforces the Supreme Court’s consistent message that contempt jurisdiction must be exercised sparingly, with restraint, and without personal criticism once an unconditional apology is accepted. No new legal doctrine is created, but the ruling fortifies existing principles on judicial composure in contempt matters.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Chairman, West Bengal Administrative Tribunal And Another v. Sk. Monobbor Hossain And Another

    Order

    1. Leave granted. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Calcutta in CPAN No. 50 of 2010 arising out of WPST No. 47 of 2009 dated 19-5-2010. By the impugned judgment and order, the learned Judges of the High Court, though having accepted the unconditional apology offered by the contemnors, have passed some remarks against the members of the State Administrative Tribunal. Aggrieved by these observations, the appellants are before us in this civil appeal.

    2. A contempt petition came to be filed by the petitioner in WPST No. 47 of 2009. The allegation in the complaint was that though the High Court had directed the Tribunal to advance the hearing of the application filed before it, the same had not been complied with by the Tribunal and had not passed appropriate orders on merits of the application filed by the petitioner.

    3. On entertaining the contempt petition, the Court had issued notices to the members of the State Administrative Tribunal. They had offered their explanation, explaining the so-called lapses on their part and further, had offered unconditional apology by stating that, if for any reason, the Court comes to the conclusion that there is some disobedience of the directions issued by the Court, the same may be condoned in the light of the unconditional apology offered. They also undertook to follow the directions that they had allegedly flouted as soon as the Tribunal resumes sittings after the summer vacations.

    4. We find that the High Court graciously accepts the unconditional apology offered, but states in its order that the members of the Tribunal, who are former Judges of the High Court, ought not to have disrespected the directions issued by the High Court and while saying so, certain remarks are also made against the performance of the Judges as members of the Tribunal. The appeal is filed before this Court for expunging those remarks and observations.

    5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties to the lis.

    6. This Court in R.N Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik (2000) 4 SCC 400 has observed:

    “7. We may reiterate that the weapon of contempt is not to be used in abundance or misused. … Discretion given to the court is to be exercised for maintenance of the court's dignity and majesty of law.”

    7. In Suresh Chandra Poddar v. Dhani Ram (2002) 1 SCC 766, it is held:

    “1. This is an instance of how a Tribunal vested with the powers to punish for contempt of court became oversensitive in using such powers. Time and again this Court has cautioned as to when and in what circumstances contempt of court jurisdiction is to be exercised. Such a power is not intended to be exercised as a matter of course. Courts should not feel unduly touchy when they are told that the orders have not been implemented forthwith. If the court is told that the direction or the order of the court has been complied with subsequently, albeit after receipt of notice of contempt, we expect the courts to show judicial grace and magnanimity in dealing with the action for contempt.”

    8. In P.K Singh v. S.N Kanungo (2010) 4 SCC 504 this Court opined:

    “21. After reaching the conclusion that the violation is neither wilful nor deliberate, the High Court should have at once dropped the contempt proceedings and could not have accepted the unconditional apology tendered by the appellant nor could have imposed costs on the appellant. In any view of the matter, the High Court, after accepting the unconditional apology tendered by the appellant, should not have imposed costs on the appellant for negligence and reckless manner in which it had allegedly acted in the instant case.”

    9. The tenor of the dicta of this Court on the topic is crystal clear. This Court has, time and again, asserted that the contempt jurisdiction enjoyed by the courts is only for the purpose of upholding the majesty of the judicial system that exists. While exercising this power, the courts must not be hypersensitive or swung by emotions, but must act judiciously. In Dinabandhu Sahu v. State of Orissa (1972) 4 SCC 761, this Court very pertinently observed that:

    “2. … it is no part of the judicial function to be vindictive or allow any personal or other considerations to enter in the discharge of its functions….”

    10. With this background, let us examine the appeal presently before us.

    11. We have perused the orders passed by the High Court while disposing of the contempt petition. In our view, there is some justification for the High Court to have initiated the contempt proceedings against the appellants, but at the same time the High Court, in order to maintain its dignity and majesty of law, could have avoided making some of the remarks and observations against the functioning of the members of the Tribunal. The Judges are also mortals and sometimes, the behaviour of another mortal may not be palatable to them. It is in this type of situation they are expected to rise to the occasion and avoid passing disparaging remarks. This would reflect their learning magnanimity and maturity, particularly when they accept the unconditional apology offered by the contemnors.

    12. Accordingly, we allow this appeal and expunge all those remarks/observations made by the learned Judges in the course of their order. Ordered accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chairman, West Bengal Administrative Tribunal And Another v. Sk. Monobbor Hossain And Another
    (Feb 29, 2012)