AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section VII of the [no specific year mentioned] Act
  • [no specific act/article title mentioned], RC No. 140.B2-1/2005
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the [no specific act/article title mentioned]
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section VII of the [no specific year mentioned] Act
  • [no specific act/article title mentioned], RC No. 140.B2-1/2005
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the [no specific act/article title mentioned]
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Andhra Pradesh, through Memo No. 1280.COSE/A2/2004-4 dated 20-10-2004 (“the ban memo”), imposed a blanket ban on filling existing vacancies in aided posts of teachers. Several private aided schools had, prior to the memo, already obtained permission from the competent authorities and initiated recruitment processes—including advertising posts, collecting names from employment exchanges and scheduling interviews.

When the ban was enforced mid-process, the schools filed writ petitions before the Andhra Pradesh High Court. A learned Single Judge held that the ban could not operate retrospectively and permitted the schools to complete the recruitments. The State filed multiple writ appeals; a Division Bench, by judgment dated 29-12-2006, affirmed the Single Judge, quashed the ban’s application to already-initiated recruitments, and set aside a contemporaneous “rationalisation” exercise that attempted to redistribute surplus teachers.

The State of Andhra Pradesh sought special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in SLP (C) Nos. 9541 & 10945 of 2007 (lead matter: Govt. of A.P. v. Sri Sevadas Vidyamandir High School). Two other sets of SLPs were tagged: (i) SLP (C) Nos. 15231-32 of 2011 concerning conversion of contingent staff to Class IV posts in Asafia High School, and (ii) SLP (C) No. 469 of 2011 challenging a High Court order refusing to condone 366 days’ delay in filing a writ appeal that raised the same ban-memo issue. All petitions were heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Memo dated 20-10-2004 banning recruitment to aided teacher posts could retrospectively nullify recruitment processes that had already been commenced with official permission.
  2. Whether the State’s “rationalisation” policy could override earlier approvals granted to private aided schools for filling sanctioned posts.
  3. In the connected Asafia High School matter, whether G.O. Ms. No. 259 dated 18-6-1993 entitled two contingent employees (sweeper and gardener-cum-watchman) to conversion of their posts into Class IV posts and corresponding salary benefits.
  4. Whether delay of 366 days (and 107 days before the Supreme Court) in filing an appeal against a ban-memo judgment should be condoned.

Arguments of the Parties

State of Andhra Pradesh (Petitioners)

  • Contended that the Government, being the grant-in-aid authority, possessed incidental power to adjust posts and transfer personnel, including declaring staff surplus.
  • Argued that the High-Power Committee’s decision to impose the ban and undertake rationalisation was final and not amenable to judicial scrutiny.
  • Submitted that rationalisation on a need-based basis was essential and that permitting recruitment would defeat that exercise.

Respondent Schools and Employees

  • Maintained that the ban memo, issued after permission was granted, was prospective and could not invalidate ongoing recruitment processes.
  • Asserted that Rule 10(17) of the A.P. Educational Institutions Rules, 1993 required surplus determination based on two years’ enrolment figures; the State’s rationalisation ignored this criterion and was arbitrary.
  • Highlighted that interviews had already been conducted on 14-12-2004 and the State’s refusal to approve appointments was unreasonable.
  • In the Asafia High School matter, argued that G.O. Ms. No. 259 mandatorily converted long-serving full-time contingent staff into last-grade service employees, a finding accepted by the Single Judge and unchallenged by the State.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that:

  • The ban memo was issued after the competent authority had granted permission to the schools to fill vacant aided posts; it was indisputably not expressed to operate retrospectively.
  • Administrative orders are presumed prospective unless explicitly given retrospective effect. Hence, the memo could not nullify recruitment steps already lawfully begun.
  • The State’s rationalisation exercise could not override earlier permissions: its legal basis was not shown to trump the statutory framework governing aided schools (specifically Rule 10(17) of the 1993 Rules).
  • Since approvals for recruitment were granted only after the authorities scrutinised student strength and institutional need, there was no basis to deny final approval to selected candidates.
  • In SLPs 15231-32/2011, the Court observed that the Single Judge’s application of G.O. Ms. No. 259 to convert the contingent posts had attained finality because the State had not earlier appealed. The Division Bench rightly dismissed the State’s appeal, and no ground for Supreme Court interference existed.
  • In SLP (C) No. 469/2011, the Court found no sufficient cause to excuse a 366-day delay in the High Court and an additional 107-day delay before the Supreme Court, especially when the substantive issue (the ban memo) had already been resolved against the State.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court dismissed all the special leave petitions.

Implications: The Division Bench judgments of the Andhra Pradesh High Court stand affirmed. Private aided schools that commenced recruitment prior to 20-10-2004 may complete appointments and obtain approval; the State’s rationalisation exercise, as then structured, cannot impede those processes. In the Asafia High School matter, the contingent employees’ posts are to be converted to Class IV posts with attendant salary benefits. The decision does not establish a new precedent on broader constitutional or statutory interpretation but reinforces the principle that administrative orders are prospective unless expressly retrospective, and that unchallenged findings attain finality.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Government Of Andhra Pradesh And Others v. Sri Sevadas Vidyamandir High School And Others

    Altamas Kabir, J.— Two special leave petitions, being SLPs (C) Nos. 9541 and 10945 of 2007, arising out of the judgment and final order dated 29-12-2006, passed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court have been taken up for consideration together, along with SLP (C) No. 469 of 2011, which is directed against the judgment and order dated 9-7-2009, passed by the said High Court in School Education Deptt., A.P v. IMS School and SLPs (C) Nos. 15231-32 of 2011, which are directed against the judgment and order dated 17-8-2010, passed by the said High Court in Asafia High School v. Sk. Lal Mohammed. Inasmuch as, SLPs (C) Nos. 469 and 15231-32 of 2011 arise out of different orders of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, the same will be dealt with separately, although, they have been taken up for hearing along with the other special leave petitions.

    2. For the sake of convenience, we shall refer to the facts in SLP (C) No. 9541 of 2007 (Govt. of A.P v. Sri Sevadas Vidyamandir High School) in deciding the matters.

    3. The subject-matter of the various writ petitions, which were disposed of by the learned Single Judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, culminating in the various appeals, which were disposed of by the common judgment dated 29-12-2006, is the effect of the ban order imposed by the State Government vide Memo No. 1280.COSE/A2/2004-4 dated 20-10-2004, on the filling up of existing vacancies in the aided posts of teachers where the recruitment process had already been initiated by the management of the private schools.

    4. The learned Single Judge, who had heard the writ petitions, had declared that the said ban would not be applicable to the recruitment process already initiated by the management of the private schools for filling up the vacant aided posts of teachers prior to the coming into effect of the aforesaid memo. The learned Judge had given a further direction to the said authorities to allow the writ petitioners to complete the process of selection. In some cases, a further prayer was made that the authorities concerned be also restrained from transferring teachers from one school to another by declaring them surplus and to release the amount of salaries payable to the teachers appointed against the aided posts.

    5. For the sake of convenience, the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh noted the facts from the paper book of WA (SR) No. 121938 of 2005, filed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh and others against an order dated 9-3-2005, passed by the learned Single Judge in C.A.M High School v. Govt. of A.P, wherein, pursuant to leave granted, a prayer had been made for quashing the impugned Memo dated 20-10-2004, along with RC No. 140.B2-1/2005 dated 3-11-2005, issued by the Director of School Education, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad.

    6. C.A.M High School, Nellore, is a private aided school established by Samavesam of Telugu Baptist Churches, wherein all the posts of teachers sanctioned for the School are aided posts. In 2004, the management of the School approached the District Education Officer, Nellore, for grant of permission to fill up the existing vacant posts. The said officer, by his letter dated 17-9-2004, to the Regional Joint Director, School Education, Guntur, recommended grant of sanction to the management of the School to fill up the vacant aided posts. Such permission was duly granted by letter dated 22-9-2004, which has been reproduced in full in the judgment of the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court. Pursuant to such permission being granted by the Regional Director of School Education, Guntur, the management of the School initiated the recruitment process by requesting the District Employment Officer, Nellore, to forward the names of eligible candidates and also by publishing advertisements in two daily newspapers inviting applications for filling up the vacant posts.

    7. While the recruitment process was underway, the School was informed that the Government had issued the abovementioned Memo dated 20-10-2004, imposing a ban on the filling up of the vacant posts and, therefore, the selection process could not be completed. The management thereupon filed Writ Petition No. 22804 of 2004 for a declaration that the decision contained in the said Memo dated 20-10-2004, was not retrospective and the same could not, therefore, be applied to the ongoing process of recruitment initiated for the purpose of filling up the vacant aided posts for which permission had already been granted by the competent authority.

    8. As was noted by the Division Bench, in the counter filed by the District Education Officer, Nellore, it was not disputed that in furtherance of the sanction granted by the Regional Joint Director, Guntur, the process of recruitment of 8 teachers had been initiated by the management of the School and that Shri M. Ramalingam, Deputy Educational Officer, had been nominated as the departmental representative on the Staff Selection Committee. In fact, the date of interview had been fixed in consultation with Shri Ramalingam, but the same could not be completed on account of the promotion of Shri Ramalingam as the District Education Officer. Thereafter, the management of the school suo motu fixed 14-12-2004, as the date of the interview, but, although the interviews were held, no further steps could be taken up on account of the ban order imposed by the State Government vide Memo dated 20-10-2004.

    9. The Division Bench observed that the learned Single Judge had taken note of the fact that while permission had been given to fill up the vacant posts on 22-9-2004, the Memo in question was issued subsequently on 20-10-2004.

    10. Various appeals had been filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh against the said decision of the learned Single Judge before the Division Bench. While the appeals were pending, the Government began a process of rationalisation for filling up all the vacant posts. Taking note of the same, the Division Bench adjourned the hearing of the appeals with liberty to the counsel for the writ petitioners in one of the cases to comprehensively amend the pleadings and also to challenge the legality of the Memo dated 20-10-2004, if so advised. In furtherance of such leave, the writ petition filed by C.A.M High School, Nellore, was amended to challenge the legality of the said Memo dated 20-10-2004.

    11. Ultimately, the Division Bench dismissed the appeals filed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh and allowed the writ petitions filed by the management of the private Schools and directed that they would be free to appoint selected candidates and seek approval of such appointments from the competent authority. The Division Bench also quashed the exercise of rationalisation undertaken in furtherance of the interim order dated 31-10-2005, together with the directions contained in the letter dated 3-11-2005, issued by the Director of School Education, with liberty to the competent authorities to undertake a fresh exercise of rationalisation, which might lead to certain teachers being declared surplus and for their absorption.

    12. Appearing for the Government of Andhra Pradesh, Mr P. Vishwanatha Shetty, learned Senior Advocate, submitted that the ban order imposed by the State Government, vide Memo dated 20-10-2004, came into operation in respect of appointments of teachers in private aided institutions in the State. Mr Shetty submitted that the Government of Andhra Pradesh, which had the full authority to extend grant-in-aid to educational institutions, also possessed the consequential and incidental power to adjust the posts covered under the grant-in-aid scheme and to transfer personnel from one institution to another. Since a decision had been taken up by a High-Power Committee presided over by the Chief Minister, its decision was final and conclusive and it was not open to the High Court to scrutinise the same.

    13. It was submitted by Mr Shetty that in certain eventualities it could become necessary to declare staff of a school to be surplus and to transfer them to other schools and the power of the Government in such cases could not be curtailed. Mr Shetty submitted that it is to meet such eventualities that a decision had been taken by the State Government to rationalise the staff pattern of the different institutions on a need-based basis.

    14. On the other hand, it was emphatically argued on behalf of the respondent School that the Memo dated 20-10-2004, did not have retrospective effect and could not, therefore, stultify the recruitment process initiated by the management of private aided Schools where permission of the competent authority had been given prior to 20-10-2004. Accordingly, it was incumbent on the part of the competent authority to grant approval for the appointments made pursuant to the permission granted prior to 20-10-2004, to the private aided Schools for filling up the vacant posts in the School.

    15. Holding the brief on behalf of Ms Sunita Rao, learned Advocate, appearing for the respondent Schools, Ms Mahalakshmi Pavani, learned Advocate, submitted that as had been held by the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, the rationalisation process was violative of Rule 10(17) of the A.P Educational Institutions (Establishment, Recognition, Administration and Control of Schools Under Private Managements) Rules, 1993, inasmuch as, although, the said statutory rules stipulated that the strength of students in private aided schools for two consecutive years would be the determining factor for transfer of surplus staff, the State had resorted to a wholly whimsical and arbitrary method to determine such surplus staff.

    16. Ms Pavani submitted that in any event, having permitted the Schools in question to fill up the vacant grant-in-aid posts after taking into account the need and the roll and attendance of students, it was no longer open to the State Government to adopt a different posture on account of the Memo dated 20-10-2004, which was, in any event, prospective and not retrospective.

    17. Ms Pavani submitted that interviews had been duly conducted on 14-12-2004, for filling up the vacant posts in question, but the State Government had quite unreasonably refused to allow the recruitment process to be completed and to grant approval to the candidates who had already been interviewed and had been selected for appointment.

    18. Having considered the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties, we are of the view that no interference is called for with the judgment and order of the Division Bench of the High Court. There is no dispute that the Memo dated 20-10-2004, imposing a ban on recruitment to grant-in-aid posts was issued after the schools in question had been given permission by the State authorities to fill up the vacant posts in the schools being managed and run by the writ petitioners, who are the respondents in these special leave petitions. There is also no dispute that the said memo was not given retrospective effect so as to negate the approval already given for filling up the grant-in-aid posts. The State Government and its authorities could not, therefore, contend that the rationalisation process which had been introduced, would also apply in respect of the private aided schools, where the process of recruitment had already been commenced pursuant to the approval granted earlier.

    19. Furthermore, as was submitted by Ms Pavani, even the approval which was granted for filling up the vacant aided posts, had been granted after due scrutiny as to the requirements of the schools in question. Since it is well settled that administrative orders are prospective in nature, unless they are expressly or by necessary implication made to have retrospective effect, there is no need to refer to the decisions cited by Ms Pavani, appearing on behalf of the respondent Schools.

    20. As indicated hereinbefore, we, therefore, see no reason to interfere with the judgment and order of the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court impugned in these special leave petitions and the same are accordingly dismissed.

    21. As far as SLPs (C) Nos. 15231-32 of 2011 are concerned, the same have been filed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh, represented by its Principal Secretary, Education Department, Hyderabad against Shaik Lal Mohammed and others. These special leave petitions are directed against the orders in the writ appeals filed by the co-respondent, Asafia High School, Malakpet, Hyderabad against Shaik Lal Mohammed and others. The School was aggrieved by the order of the learned Single Judge in a writ petition filed by two employees of the School for a direction upon the State authorities to convert their posts into Class IV posts with effect from 9-6-1980 and 16-3-1981, respectively, and to pay them their arrears of salaries, which, according to them, were due. The two respondents had worked as sweeper and gardener-cum-watchman from 9-6-1980 and 16-3-1983, respectively. It was their claim that since their posts had been admitted into the grant-in-aid scheme and they had been appointed as full-time contingent employees, they were entitled to claim the benefit of certain government orders under which they were entitled to be converted as employees on the last grade service and the salary attached to such grade. The claims of the said respondents were rejected by the State authorities on the ground that the posts had not been created under the orders of the competent authority and they had not been in service for a period of 10 years as on 1-4-1985. Furthermore, they had not acquired the minimum educational qualification of Class VII as on the day GOMs No. 259 dated 18-6-1993, had been published.

    22. The learned Single Judge held that the said GOMs dated 18-6-1993, was applicable to the said two respondents, who were the writ petitioners, and since the said findings had not been challenged by the Government, they had become final and, accordingly, the said respondents were entitled to have their posts converted into Class IV posts. Consequently, the order of rejection passed by the Regional Joint Director, Hyderabad, dated 6-4-2004, was set aside and the writ appeal filed by the State against the said decision of the learned Single Judge was dismissed and the writ petitions filed by the said Respondents 1 and 2 were allowed.

    23. It is in the light of the finding of the Division Bench of the High Court that the findings of the learned Single Judge had not been challenged, that GOMs No. 259 dated 18-6-1993 was made applicable to the petitioners. As the same had become final as between the writ petitioners and the State and it was no longer open to the State to come to a different conclusion, we see no reason to interfere with the impugned decision of the High Court and the said special leave petitions are, accordingly, dismissed also.

    24. As far as SLP (C) No. 469 of 2011 is concerned, the same has been filed against the judgment and order dated 9-7-2009, passed by the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, rejecting the prayer made on behalf of the State and the State authorities to condone the delay of 366 days in filing the writ appeal. Even the filing of the special leave petition was delayed by 107 days. Since the subject-matter of the writ petition was also with regard to the application of the ban order imposed by the Memo dated 20-10-2004, which we have already considered in SLPs (C) Nos. 9541 and 10945 of 2007 decided in the earlier part of the judgment, we are not inclined to interfere with the order of the Division Bench dismissing the writ appeal on the ground of delay. SLP (C) No. 469 of 2011 is, therefore, dismissed in the light of the decision rendered in the aforesaid special leave petitions and also on the ground of delay.

    25. Having regard to the different circumstances in which the special leave petitions have been filed, the parties will bear their own costs therein.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Government Of Andhra Pradesh And Others v. Sri Sevadas Vidyamandir High School And Others
    (Sep 6, 2011)