AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 120-B read with Sections 409, 420, 467, 468, 471 and 477-A of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 120-B read with Sections 409, 420, 467, 468, 471 and 477-A of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 7-1-2009, B. Ramalinga Raju (A-1), Chairman of Satyam Computer Services Ltd. (SCSL), sent a confessional letter to the Board of Directors revealing massive financial irregularities, including inflated cash balances of Rs. 5040 crores and other falsified figures. Following a complaint by an investor, the Andhra Pradesh CID registered an FIR on 9-1-2009 against the Company’s management and auditors under multiple IPC provisions. Given the magnitude of the fraud, investigation was transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) on 20-2-2009.

Chargesheets were later filed alleging a conspiracy by various accused, including external statutory auditor S. Gopalakrishnan (A-4) and internal audit head V.S. Prabhakara Gupta (A-10). After several unsuccessful bail applications, the Andhra Pradesh High Court, by order dated 25-6-2010, enlarged A-4 (on his eighth attempt) and A-10 (on his sixth attempt) on bail. The CBI filed special leave petitions challenging that order. The present Supreme Court judgment addresses those appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in granting bail to A-4 and A-10 in light of the seriousness and magnitude of the Satyam corporate fraud.
  2. Whether the bail order in favour of Talluri Srinivas (A-5) could be invoked to claim parity for A-4 and A-10.
  3. Whether subsequent Supreme Court directions of 26-10-2010 setting a strict trial timetable and cancelling bail for other principal accused altered the bail considerations for A-4 and A-10.

Arguments of the Parties

CBI (Appellant)

  • Release of A-4 and A-10 would jeopardise the ongoing trial because, as external and internal auditors, they could influence key employee-witnesses.
  • The gravity, scale, and public impact of the fraud warrant continued custody.
  • The parity argument is misplaced: A-5 audited for only one year, whereas A-4 did so for seven; circumstances have changed since A-5’s bail on 4-2-2010.
  • The Supreme Court’s later order dated 26-10-2010 cancelling bail of A-1, A-2, A-3, A-7, A-8 and A-9, and directing a speedy trial, makes the High Court’s reliance on A-5’s bail inappropriate.

Respondents (A-4 and A-10)

  • A-4: Claimed identical role to A-5; had already spent 1 year 5 months in custody before bail; was not an SCSL employee but a partner at Price Waterhouse.
  • A-10: Asserted he had no statutory audit role, was added only in the second chargesheet, and had spent 222 days in custody before bail.
  • Both criticised CBI’s delay in challenging the High Court order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order dated 4-2-2010 in Criminal Appeal No. 257 of 2010 (bail granted to Talluri Srinivas, A-5) Factors justifying bail: voluminous chargesheet, 470 witnesses, long prospective trial, and over-one-year custody Held not comparable; A-4’s longer audit tenure and changed trial circumstances made parity inapplicable
Order dated 26-10-2010, (2011) 5 SCC 340 (cancellation of bail for A-1, A-2, A-3, A-7, A-8, A-9) Set strict day-to-day trial schedule and emphasised seriousness of the scam Relied upon to show that granting bail to A-4 and A-10 was inconsistent with the Court’s later directions and the scam’s gravity

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasised the unprecedented magnitude of the Satyam scam and the pivotal roles played by A-4 (statutory auditor for seven years) and A-10 (global head of internal audit). It distinguished their positions from that of A-5, noting material differences in duration and responsibility. Further, after the Court’s order of 26-10-2010 cancelling bail for principal accused and mandating an expedited trial (now proceeding day-to-day, with most witnesses already examined), the considerations that supported A-5’s bail no longer applied.

The Court observed that employees of the reconstituted company, particularly those in accounts and finance, would likely be reluctant to testify freely if the respondents remained at liberty. It concluded that the High Court overlooked these factors and the subsequent Supreme Court directions, thereby erring in granting bail.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed – High Court order dated 25-6-2010 granting bail to A-4 and A-10 is set aside.

Both respondents must surrender by 30-4-2011, failing which the CBI may take legal steps to secure their custody. All directions issued in the Supreme Court’s order of 26-10-2010 remain applicable. The decision reinstates custody of the external and internal auditors, ensuring witness protection and reinforcing the Court’s earlier mandate for a swift conclusion of the trial. No new legal precedent was created; the ruling applies the Court’s existing bail principles to the facts of this high-profile corporate fraud.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Central Bureau Of Investigation, Hyderabad v. Subramani Gopalakrishnan And Another

    P. Sathasivam, J.— Leave granted. These appeals, at the instance of the Central Bureau of Investigation (in short “CBI”), Hyderabad are directed against the order dated 25-6-2010 passed by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in Criminal Petitions Nos. 4972 and 4913 of 2010, in and by which, the High Court enlarged the respondents herein, namely, S. Gopalakrishnan (A-4) and V.S Prabhakara Gupta (A-10) on bail by imposing certain conditions.

    2. Since CBI has challenged the order of the High Court granting bail in respect of the two accused, namely, A-4 and A-10, we are constrained to refer only the facts which are necessary for the disposal of these appeals.

    Brief Facts

    3. On 7-1-2009, B. Ramalinga Raju (A-1), the then Chairman of M/s Satyam Computer Services Ltd. (in short “M/s SCSL”) addressed a confessional letter to the Board of Directors revealing certain financial irregularities in M/s SCSL. As per this letter, the balance sheet as on 30-9-2008 showed inflated (non-existent) cash and bank balances of Rs. 5040 crores, an accrued interest of Rs. 376 crores which is non-existent and an understated liability of Rs. 1230 crores on account of funds arranged by him and an overstated debtors' position of Rs. 490 crores (as against Rs. 2651 crores reflected in the books). He also revealed several other factual details which resulted an increase in artificial cash and bank balances. He also revealed several frauds and cooking of books of accounts that ever happened in India's corporate history.

    4. Due to the fraud on the part of the persons in management including the financial advisors, auditors, etc., many investors suffered loss and on the complaint of one of such investors, a first information report (in short “FIR”) was registered on 9-1-2009 by the Andhra Pradesh State Crime Investigation Department against the then Chairman, Directors and auditors of M/s SCSL and others under Section 120-B read with Sections 409, 420, 467, 468, 471 and 477-A of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”). Considering the magnitude of the offence, investigation was entrusted to CBI and a regular case being RC No. 4(S) of 2009 was registered by CBI, Anti-Corruption Branch, Hyderabad, on 20-2-2009.

    5. Due to fudging of the company accounts and manipulation of records by showing incorrect and inflated figures in the balance sheets by the Chairman, MD and other Directors of the Company which were certified by the auditors, the value of the shares of the Company suddenly dropped causing huge financial loss to the shareholders. The drop in the value of the shares was due to dishonest and fraudulent acts committed by the aforesaid functionaries, who were managing the affairs of the Company and were associated with its functioning and day-to-day affairs.

    6. With the above brief facts, let us consider the allegations levelled against the respondents herein (A-4 and A-10) and the role played by them.

    The role of S. Gopalakrishnan (A-4), Partner and In charge of M/s Price Waterhouse in CC No. 1 of 2010

    6.1 (a) He affixed his signature on the financial statements as partner of M/s Price Waterhouse, the statutory auditors for M/s SCSL from Financial Year 2001 till 2007.
    (b) He was a partner in the firm “M/s Price Waterhouse, Bangalore” and not in “M/s Price Waterhouse”.
    (c) In the agreement entered into between M/s SCSL and M/s Price Waterhouse, instead of affixing his signature, he signed as “M/s Price Waterhouse” which is contrary to the established practice and procedure.
    (d) By virtue of his status as a statutory auditor, it is incumbent on his part to verify the bank balances and FDRs claimed to be held by M/s SCSL besides other investments, liabilities and sales of the Company before certifying the statutory audit report which forms the basis of the annual financial statement of the Company.
    (e) The presentations made by him to the Audit Committee about the health of the Company were misleading.
    (f) As a consideration for his acts in accommodating the accused persons, he received an exorbitant audit fee from M/s SCSL over and above the market rate which reflects a quid pro quo arrangement.
    (g) Letters generated on the letterheads of M/s Price Waterhouse were recovered from the computer systems of M/s SCSL. These letters were supposed to be written by the auditors addressed to the banks seeking confirmations about the balances.
    (h) Though deficiencies were found in information technology general check, no substantial and elaborate examination of the financial accounts was conducted by him.
    (i) Control deficiencies identified in the integrated audit were not brought to the notice of the Audit Committee.
    (j) The above overt acts of A-4 reveal the offences punishable under Section 120-B read with Sections 420, 419, 467, 471 and 477-A IPC.

    The role of S. Gopalakrishnan (A-4) in CC No. 3 of 2010:

    6.2 (a) He failed to comply with the audit and assurance standards while conducting statutory audit in case of M/s SCSL.
    (b) He failed to point out the existence of forged and fabricated invoices in the invoice samples.
    (c) As a quid pro quo for his role he received very high remuneration.
    (d) The above overt acts of A-4 reveal the offences punishable under Section 120-B read with Sections 420, 471 and 477-A IPC.

    The role of V.S Prabhakara Gupta (A-10), Head, Internal Audit, M/s SCSL in the supplementary charge-sheet:

    6.3 (a) He was the Associate In-charge, Internal Audit and was the Global Head of Internal Audit of M/s SCSL during the relevant period of time.
    (b) He had intentionally not included auditing of Oracle Financials (OF) in the internal audit plan of M/s SCSL till 2007 even though the system was operational since 2002.
    (c) He intentionally submitted a prioritisation plan to the Audit Committee for postponing the audit of many items including Oracle Financials citing several irrelevant reasons.
    (d) With regard to anomalies pertaining to the invoices no correctional measures or follow-up action was taken.
    (e) He did not properly follow up for the restoration of the access to the offshore books of accounts for the internal audit team.
    (f) He intentionally flouted the laid-down procedures mentioned in the Internal Audit Manual.
    (g) The above overt acts of A-10 reveal the offences punishable under Section 120-B read with Section 420 IPC.

    7. Apart from the above details, Mr P.P Malhotra, learned ASG has also brought to our notice that prior to the grant of bail by the High Court A-4 had filed seven bail applications and the High Court passed the impugned order only in the eighth bail application. He also pointed out that in the same way, A-10 had filed six bail applications and the High Court passed the impugned order enlarging him on bail only in the sixth bail application.

    8. By pointing out all these details, the learned ASG submitted that at this stage, release of the respondent-accused from judicial custody will jeopardise the trial, particularly, when these two respondents, A-4 and A-10 who were the external and internal auditors of the Company, will influence the witnesses and it would be difficult for the employees to come and depose against them. He also submitted that considering the seriousness of the offence, impact on the society as a whole and magnitude of the offence, the respondents are not entitled for bail and the High Court has committed an error in granting the bail to them.

    9. The learned ASG also submitted that the reliance on the orders of this Court insofar as Talluri Srinivas (A-5) is not comparable because after the order of this Court granting him bail on 4-2-2010 in Criminal Appeal No. 257 of 2010, the entire scenario in the trial has changed, hence the said order cannot be cited as a precedent. He also submitted that though A-4 and A-5 were auditors of M/s SCSL, A-5 was there only for a limited period of one year whereas A-4 worked for a period of seven years i.e from 2000-2007. He also relied on the order of this Court dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340 wherein this Court cancelled the bail granted by the High Court insofar as A-1, A-2, A-3, A-7, A-8 and A-9 are concerned.

    10. On the other hand, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for A-4 highlighted the alleged role between those accused i.e A-1, A-2, A-3, A-7, A-8 and A-9 whose bail has been cancelled by this Court and that of A-4. According to him, the order of this Court dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340 passed in Criminal Appeals Nos. 2068-72 of 2010 is not applicable. A-4 had been in custody for one year and five months before he was enlarged on bail. He also demonstrated that even according to the prosecution the role assigned to A-4 and A-5 is identical and when A-5 was ordered to be released by this Court even as early as on 4-2-2010, the High Court rightly applied parity between them and granted bail. He also contended that A-4 was not an employee of M/s SCSL but was a partner in M/s Price Waterhouse and has nothing to do with the alleged claim in M/s SCSL.

    11. Shri D. Rama Krishna Reddy, learned counsel appearing for A-10 submitted that though he was an internal auditor of M/s SCSL, no statutory function was assigned to him. He also pointed out that only in the second charge-sheet, his name was included as an accused. He further pointed out that before granting bail by the High Court, he was put in jail for 222 days.

    12. We have perused the impugned order of the High Court, various details furnished by both the sides and considered the rival contentions.

    13. As per the complaint and investigation, A-4 and A-10 along with the other accused are involved in one of the greatest corporate scams of the commercial world. It has caused a financial storm not only throughout the country but also worldwide and by their action and conduct, lakhs of shareholders and others have been duped and the corporate credibility of the nation has received a serious setback. It is not in dispute that nobody can underestimate the sufferings of the shareholders and others due to the scam in question.

    14. Though it was argued that the management of M/s SCSL has been shifted to other corporate entity, it is demonstrated before us that the employees who were working in the erstwhile M/s SCSL are now working under the present management. In view of the same, at least persons working in the accounts section/financial management will not come forward to depose against the respondents herein (A-4 and A-10) who were the external and internal auditors of the Company and who had influence in the Company.

    15. The High Court, while ordering bail for A-4 and A-10, heavily relied on the order of this Court dated 4-2-2010 made in Criminal Appeal No. 257 of 2010. The said appeal relates to one Talluri Srinivas (A-5), who is a chartered accountant, registered with the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). He was working as a partner with M/s Price Waterhouse, Bangalore registered with ICAI. M/s Price Waterhouse is the statutory authorised auditor of M/s SCSL and allegation against A-5 is that while submitting the audit report for the year 2007-2008, some inflated figures were incorporated in the said report and thereby he committed serious breach of faith as a member of the professional body of auditors/accountants. After noting several details and hearing the learned counsel on either side, this Court noted the following circumstances for releasing A-5 on bail:

    “(i) the charge-sheet is running into several thousand pages;
    (ii) CBI proposes to examine 470 witnesses;
    (iii) a very large volume of records have been produced in this case;
    (iv) therefore, it can be easily assumed that the trial of this case will take a long time even to start.”

    Considering these factual details without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case regarding the nature of offence or gravity thereof allegedly committed by A-5 and having regard to the fact that he had been in custody for more than a year, released him on bail on 4-2-2010 by imposing certain conditions.

    16. Now the question is whether the same reasonings are applicable to the respondents herein i.e A-4 and A-10?

    17. We have already pointed out that in view of the appeal filed by Talluri Srinivas (A-5) against the dismissal of his bail application by the High Court, this Court considering the facts stated in the earlier paragraph passed an order on 4-2-2010 releasing A-5 on bail subject to certain conditions. First of all, there is no similarity in respect of the role assigned to A-4 and A-5. Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel, after taking us through several materials, submitted that even as per the prosecution, the role assigned to A-4 and A-5 is identical. After going through the same, prima facie, we are satisfied that the said assumption is incorrect. It is pointed out that though both A-4 and A-5 were auditors of M/s SCSL at the relevant time, admittedly, A-5 had worked only for a period of one year whereas A-4 was in charge of auditing the accounts of M/s SCSL for a period of seven years i.e from 2000 to 2007. In addition to the same, we have also verified the three charge-sheets and the imputations made against both these accused persons. In these factual details available, prima facie, we are satisfied that A-4 and A-5 cannot be put on the same footing in respect of erroneous auditing resulting in inflated cash and bank balances of M/s SCSL.

    18. It is relevant to point out the recent order of this Court dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340 in Criminal Appeals Nos. 2068-72 of 2010 wherein this Court cancelled the bail granted by the High Court in respect of A-1, A-2, A-3, A-7, A-8 and A-9. After passing such order, this Court after recording the fact that the charges have been framed on 25-10-2010 and the trial is scheduled to commence w.e.f 2-11-2010 issued several directions, namely,

    (i) the trial court to take up the case on day-to-day basis and conclude the trial as expeditiously as possible in any event on or before 31-7-2011;
    (ii) the trial court would avoid granting undue adjournments, unless it becomes absolutely imperative;
    (iii) the parties are directed to examine only material and most essential witnesses and fully cooperate with the trial court;
    (iv) the accused shall be produced before the trial court on time, on every date of hearing, unless exempted by orders of the court;
    (v) the trial court is free to decide the case without being influenced by any of the observations made by the High Court or by this Court;
    (vi) if for any reason, the trial is not concluded before 31-7-2011, the accused would be at liberty to approach the trial court for grant of bail.

    19. The recent order dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340 of this Court referred to above makes it clear that this Court cancelled the bail in respect of the prime accused, namely, A-1, A-2, A-3, A-7, A-8 and A-9. It is also brought to our notice that in view of the specific directions of this Court in the said order, the trial has started and according to the learned ASG, it is likely to be concluded by the cut-off date i.e 31-7-2011. It is also brought to our notice that out of 697 witnesses, the prosecution has dropped 470 witnesses and only 227 witnesses are to be examined. Out of this, 193 witnesses have already been examined and some of them are to be cross-examined. According to him, only 30 more witnesses have to be produced and examined.

    20. In view of the directions of this Court in the subsequent order dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340, the trial is proceeding on day-to-day basis and likely to be concluded by 31-7-2011. We are satisfied that the reasons stated while granting bail for Talluri Srinivas (A-5) by this Court on 4-2-2010 are not applicable to the respondents herein. Accordingly reliance on the basis of the bail order granted in favour of A-5 cannot be applied to these respondents.

    21. Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel, appearing for A-4 and Mr D. Rama Krishna Reddy, learned counsel appearing for A-10 strongly commented on the conduct of CBI in not challenging the order of the High Court granting bail to these persons and failure on their part to place these matters before the Court at the appropriate time. It is not in dispute that the High Court granted bail to these respondents on 25-6-2010 and CBI challenging the said order filed two special leave petitions before this Court on 6-10-2010. No doubt, the matter was listed before the Court only on 1-4-2011 on which date, this Court issued notice to the respondents and on the same day the notice was accepted by the respective counsel for the respondents and they were permitted to file their reply. After filing reply, when the matter again came up for hearing on 4-4-2011 at the request of both sides, the matter was posted for final hearing on 15-4-2011 and was argued at length on the same day. Though the appellant CBI was not so diligent to bring the special leave petitions for orders immediately after filing of the same due to various reasons and compliance with the office report had taken some time, however, on this ground their challenge with regard to the order of the High Court granting bail cannot be rejected without going into the merits.

    22. Though Mr D. Rama Krishna Reddy, learned counsel for A-10, submitted that he being the internal auditor, an employee of M/s SCSL, there is no statutory function and his name does not find place in the first charge-sheet and he was named only in the second charge-sheet, considering the materials available, it is not desirable to go into the correctness or otherwise at this juncture and at the same time in view of the magnitude of the scam and without the assistance and connivance of persons in charge of auditing, we are unable to accept the stand of the learned counsel and hold that the High Court is not justified in granting bail for him.

    23. It is also relevant to note that there is difference between yardsticks for cancellation of bail and appeal against the order granting bail. Very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an order directing the cancellation of bail already granted. Generally speaking, the grounds for cancellation of bail are, interference or attempt to interfere with the due course of administration of justice or evasion or attempt to evade the due course of justice or abuse of the concessions granted to the accused in any manner. These are all only few illustrative materials. The satisfaction of the court on the basis of the materials placed on record of the possibility of the accused absconding is another reason justifying the cancellation of bail. In other words, bail once granted should not be cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering whether any supervening circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during the trial.

    24. We have already pointed out that the issue before us is not for cancellation of bail granted earlier, the question is whether in the facts and circumstances of the magnitude of the scam, the bail granted in favour of all the main accused have been cancelled and Respondents A-4 and A-10 being external and internal auditors respectively, their role being paramount in inflating processing assets and bank balances of M/s SCSL, we are of the view that the High Court is not justified in granting bail.

    25. In view of the specific allegation by the prosecution that A-4 and A-10 were party to the criminal conspiracy showing inflated (non-existent) cash and bank balances reflected in the books, inflated proceeds over a period of last several years, frauds and cooking of books of accounts, we are satisfied that the High Court ought not to have granted bail to these respondents. Considering the subsequent order of this Court dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340 cancelling the bail in respect of other accused and issuing directions based on which the trial has to be concluded within the schedule time viz. 31-7-2011, we hold that the High Court committed an error in granting bail to these Respondents A-4 and A-10.

    26. In the light of the above discussion, the impugned order of the High Court dated 25-6-2010 in Criminal Petitions Nos. 4913 and 4972 of 2010 granting bail in favour of the respondents i.e A-4 and A-10 is set aside. They are directed to surrender on or before 30-4-2011 otherwise the appellant shall take appropriate steps in accordance with law. All the observations and directions, as stated in the earlier order dated 26-10-2010 (2011) 5 SCC 340, are also applicable to the respondents (A-4 and A-10). We also make it clear that the abovesaid conclusion is for considering the grant of bail by the High Court and the trial court is free to decide the case without being influenced by any of the observations made by the High Court and by this Court in this order.

    27. The appeals are allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Central Bureau Of Investigation, Hyderabad v. Subramani Gopalakrishnan And Another
    (Apr 21, 2011)