Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 319
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Chapter 6 and Chapter 7 of the Bihar Education Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 INSC 319
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Chapter 6 and Chapter 7 of the Bihar Education Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The contempt petition arises out of an alleged breach of an undertaking given by the State of Bihar on 18-01-2006, and an order of the Supreme Court dated 23-01-2006 in SLP (C) Nos. 22882-88 of 2004. The undertaking promised that vacant posts of primary-school teachers would be filled with trained teachers and that fresh recruitment rules would be framed after the Patna High Court had quashed the 2003 Rules.

When the State did not act on its promises, Contempt Petition No. 297 of 2006 was filed and disposed of on 19-03-2007 with a direction to implement the undertaking. Continued non-compliance led to the present contempt proceedings.

On 09-12-2009 the Court, seeking a “one-time measure,” treated the 34,540 vacancies advertised in 2003 as the definitive number of posts to be filled by trained teachers and adjourned the matter for compliance. An affidavit dated 06-05-2010 stated that:

  • 34,540 posts of Assistant Teachers had been created; and
  • The Bihar Special Elementary Teachers' Recruitment Rules, 2010 (“2010 Rules”) had been approved to facilitate recruitment.

Objections to the 2010 Rules were then argued, leading to the present order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State of Bihar had complied with its undertakings and the Court’s earlier directions to appoint trained teachers to all vacant primary-school posts.
  2. Whether the Bihar Special Elementary Teachers' Recruitment Rules, 2010 were consistent with, or in breach of, those undertakings and directions—particularly regarding eligibility cut-off dates, inclusion of physical-education training, reservation policy, and conditions on payment of salary.

Arguments of the Parties

State of Bihar (represented by Advocate General P.K. Shahi)

  • 34,540 posts have been formally created as a one-time measure.
  • The 2010 Rules were framed specifically to implement the Court’s earlier orders.
  • Accordingly, the State has complied and the contempt petition should be dropped.

Petitioners and Intervenors (represented inter alia by R.P. Bhatt, L. Nageswara Rao)

  • Rule 4 restricts eligibility to candidates trained up to 01-12-2003, unlawfully excluding later-trained teachers who should be covered.
  • Rule 2(iv) excludes teachers with physical-education training from the definition of “training.”
  • Rule 6 (reservation) will leave posts unfilled because sufficient trained teachers from reserved categories may not exist; all 34,540 posts must nevertheless be filled.
  • Rule 9 withholds salaries until certificate verification, risking indefinite non-payment.
  • The Court’s orders require that all 34,540 posts be filled in order of seniority, leaving no vacancy on the ground of reservation shortfall.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(2010) 6 SCC 653 (Order dated 09-12-2009 in the same matter) Established that 34,540 vacancies must be filled by trained teachers as a one-time measure. Re-affirmed; the Court clarified that the reference to the 2003 advertisement was only to ascertain the number of vacancies, not to adopt its conditions.
(2007) 13 SCC 349 (Order dated 19-03-2007 in Contempt Petition No. 297 of 2006) Directed the State to implement its undertaking “in letter and spirit.” Relied on as an earlier, still-binding direction that trained teachers be appointed on priority.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged the creation of 34,540 posts but held that:

  • Its earlier reference to the 2003 advertisement was solely to determine the number of vacancies; none of the advertisement’s conditions could be revived.
  • The intent of the orders was that every one of the 34,540 posts be filled with trained teachers waiting for appointment in order of seniority, after accommodating reserved-category candidates.
  • Leaving any post vacant on the ground that a reserved-category candidate is unavailable would defeat that intent.
  • Consequently, any Rule—such as those fixing a cut-off training date, excluding physical-education training, or potentially causing unfilled vacancies—that frustrates full appointment of trained teachers conflicts with prior Court orders.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: The Court again directs that all 34,540 created posts be filled with trained teachers, in order of seniority, after providing for reservation, as a one-time measure. Compliance must be achieved by 31-08-2010, and the matter is adjourned to 08-09-2010 for a compliance report.

Implications: The State of Bihar must complete the appointment process without further delay or face continuing contempt proceedings. The decision enforces existing undertakings rather than setting a new legal precedent, but it underscores the binding nature of commitments made to the Supreme Court.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Nand Kishore Ojha v. Anjani Kumar Singh .

    Altamas Kabir, J.— As indicated in our order dated 9-12-2009 (2010) 6 SCC 653, this contempt petition has a background of alleged breach of an undertaking given on 18-1-2006 and the order passed on the basis thereof on 23-1-2006 in SLPs (C) Nos. 22882-88 of 2004. The said undertaking related to the commitment made by the State of Bihar to recruit and fill in the vacant posts of teachers in primary schools with trained teachers.

    2. The undertaking given by the State of Bihar is in that context and reads as follows:

    “That in the meantime, it has been decided that trained teachers be recruited on the vacant posts available in the State of Bihar. The Bihar Elementary Teachers Appointment Rules, 2003 having been quashed by the Patna High Court, new recruitment rules are contemplated to facilitate recruitment of trained teachers in a decentralised manner, by giving them age relaxation as ordered by the High Court.
    That Chapters 6 and 7 of the Bihar Education Code relating to oriental education and hostels and messes will be kept in mind, as directed by the Patna High Court, while making recruitment of teachers.
    That it is respectfully submitted that since the number of available trained teachers in the State is expected to be less than the available vacancies, no test for selection is required to that extent, a reference to this to the Bihar Public Service Commission for initiating the process of recruitment of trained teachers may not be necessary, and the orders of this Hon'ble Court and of the Patna High Court in this regard may be modified.”

    3. The said application made for withdrawal of the special leave petition was disposed of by this Court on 23-1-2006 on the basis of the submissions made therein.

    4. Subsequently, when the State of Bihar failed to abide by its commitments and assurances, the petitioner herein, Nand Kishore Ojha, filed Contempt Petition No. 297 of 2006, which was disposed of on 19-3-2007 (2007) 13 SCC 349 by the following order:

    “5. In view of the categorical statement now made that the priority will be given to the trained teachers in appointment and also the clarification made in Paras 19 to 22 of the aforesaid affidavit dated 7-2-2007, we direct the State of Bihar to implement the undertaking given by the State of Bihar earlier and also now by the present affidavit dated 7-2-2007 in letter and spirit by appointing the trained teachers on priority basis.”

    5. Once again on the failure of the State Government to appoint trained teachers as Assistant Teachers in the vacant sanctioned posts carrying a pay scale, in breach of the undertaking and the assurances given by the Government, the present contempt petition was filed. Many applications were made in the contempt petition by the trained teachers similarly situated, for being impleaded as parties to the proceedings.

    6. Ultimately, the learned Attorney General appeared before us on 25-8-2009 and assured us that it was not the intention of the State of Bihar to resile from the undertaking given on its behalf, but that the situation had changed over the years, since the undertaking had been given and had become much more complex than was thought of at that point of time.

    7. Since no workable solution could be suggested which could satisfy the undertaking given by the State Government and, at the same time, to cause minimum amount of disruption in implementing the same, this Court took note of an advertisement for appointment of Primary Teachers, which was published in December 2003 and had been struck down by the High Court for the limited purpose of determining the total number of vacancies which were shown as 34,540. In order to put a quietus to the entire issue, we accepted the figure relating to the vacancies to the posts shown in the advertisement to meet the claims of the trained teachers who were, at the relevant point of time, available for being appointed on a regular basis.

    8. Accordingly, notwithstanding the number of trained teachers available, this Court directed that the available 34,540 vacancies shown in the advertisement for appointment of Primary Teachers be filled up with the said number of trained teachers as a one-time measure to give effect to the undertaking which had been given on 18-1-2006 and 23-1-2006.

    9. This Court also adjourned the contempt petition for implementation of the said order passed by us and for a report to be submitted on the next date as to the result of the discussions held between the petitioner and the authorities concerned.

    10. Pursuant to the above directions, the matter was taken up on 6-5-2010, when an additional affidavit affirmed by the contemnor, Shri Anjani Kumar Singh, was shown to us. The deponent indicated that he was the Principal Secretary, Human Resource Development Department, Government of Bihar, and it was mentioned in Para 4 of the said affidavit that 34,540 posts of Assistant Teachers had been created as a one-time measure for appointment in elementary schools of the State of Bihar and to facilitate the process of recruitment, the Bihar Special Elementary Teachers' Recruitment Rules, 2010 had been prepared and had been approved by the State Cabinet on 2-2-2010. On the said basis, it was averred that by creating 34,540 posts of Assistant Teachers, the State of Bihar had complied with the directions given by this Court on 9-12-2009 (2010) 6 SCC 653 as a one-time measure.

    11. Mr P.K Shahi, learned Advocate General for the State of Bihar, took us to the Bihar Special Elementary Teachers' Recruitment Rules, 2010 (hereinafter referred to as “the 2010 Rules”) and pointed out that the same had been framed to give effect to the undertakings given by the State of Bihar and the orders passed by this Court from time to time. The learned Advocate General, therefore, submitted that in view of such compliance, the contempt proceedings were liable to be dropped.

    12. Appearing for the petitioners in Contempt Petition No. 297 of 2007, Mr R.P Bhatt, learned Senior Advocate, submitted that although apparently it would appear that by the creation of 34,540 posts, the undertakings given on behalf of the State of Bihar and the orders passed by this Court had been duly complied with, in real fact, the same did not reflect the true state of affairs in view of the framing of the 2010 Rules which were in breach and not in compliance with the said undertakings. In particular, it was pointed out that Rule 4 of the said Rules provided that only those candidates who had passed training up to 1-12-2003 could apply which effectively debarred those trained teachers who passed training thereafter and were intended to be covered by the order dated 6-5-2010 for appointment as Primary Teachers. It was also submitted by Mr Bhatt that teachers who had completed physical education training had not been included in the definition of the expression “training”, as provided in Rule 2(iv), although they too were to be covered by the order passed on 6-5-2010 and the earlier orders.

    13. Mr L. Nageswara Rao, learned advocate, who appeared for some of the special leave petitioners, submitted that the provision for reservation in Rule 6 of the aforesaid Rules would also result in the exclusion of a large number of trained teachers from the general category, since it was not expected that the total number of posts reserved would be filled from amongst trained teachers belonging to the reserved category. Mr Rao also pointed out that the provisions of Rule 9 were also prejudicial to the petitioners, who even after their appointment would not be paid their salaries unless their certificates were found to be correct. Mr Rao submitted that such a condition could result in an indefinite delay in paying the salaries of the persons appointed.

    14. Some of the other learned advocates appearing for the other petitioners and those candidates who had been permitted to intervene in these proceedings on the basis of their various applications echoed the submissions made by Mr Bhatt and Mr Rao. All of them in one voice have reiterated the submission that all the 34,540 posts which have been created would have to be filled up without leaving any vacancies on the plea of reservation, as had been undertaken by the learned Advocate General for the State of Bihar, Mr Shahi.

    15. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties with regard to the affidavit of compliance filed on behalf of the State of Bihar and have also considered the submissions of the learned Advocate General for the State of Bihar with regard to the 2010 Rules.

    16. While we appreciate the fact that the number of posts shown in the advertisement published in 2003 amounting to 34,540 have been created to be filled up by trained teachers, it must be said that it was never our intention that the conditions of the advertisement itself, which had been struck down by the High Court, were to be followed by the Bihar State Government. We had made it very clear in our order that we had referred to the advertisement only for the purpose of determining the number of vacancies which would be required to be filled up from amongst the trained teachers. It was very clearly our intention that all the 34,540 posts were to be filled up with trained teachers who were waiting for appointment in order of seniority.

    17. The question of keeping some of the posts vacant on account of non-availability of reserved candidates was never the criterion in the order passed by us on 9-12-2009 (2010) 6 SCC 653. We must add that we are not for a moment suggesting that candidates from the reserved category should not be accommodated as per the reservation policy. What we intended was that after the number of candidates from the reserved category had been accommodated, the rest of the posts were to be filled up from amongst the candidates from the general category.

    18. Having regard to the above, we once again direct that the said 34,540 posts which have been created be filled up from amongst the trained teachers in order of seniority after providing for appointment of candidates belonging to the reserved category as a one-time measure as indicated in our earlier orders and as also mentioned in the additional affidavit affirmed on behalf of the State of Bihar. We would like it to be appreciated by the State of Bihar that these directions should be complied with within 31-8-2010 without further delay.

    19. Let this matter stand adjourned till 8-9-2010 at 3.30 p.m for filing of compliance report.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nand Kishore Ojha v. Anjani Kumar Singh .
    (May 12, 2010)