Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 678
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 396 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • IPC (Penal Code, 1860)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 678
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 396 of the Penal Code, 1860
  • IPC (Penal Code, 1860)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The prosecution alleged that in the night between 5-7-1981 and 6-7-1981 about 14–15 armed dacoits entered the house of the informant, Shrishti Narain Jha (PW-7). During the incident the informant’s father was killed with sharp-edged weapons and property worth approximately Rs 40,000 was looted. Two of the informant’s brothers (PW-4 and PW-6) sustained injuries allegedly caused by gun-shot and lathi blows. A fardbeyan was recorded on 6-7-1981 at 6:30 a.m., leading to a formal FIR under Section 396 IPC. After investigation, the police filed a charge-sheet under several sections, but the Sessions Court framed a single charge under Section 396 IPC. The IInd Additional Sessions Judge, Muzaffarpur, convicted all nine accused and imposed life sentences. On appeal, the Patna High Court found the prosecution evidence unreliable—particularly identification by lantern light, inconsistencies about weapons, the absence of medical evidence for some claimed injuries, and doubts about the presence of very young and very old accused at the scene—and consequently acquitted all respondents. The informant (not the State) appealed to the Supreme Court challenging that acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Patna High Court erred in reversing the trial court’s conviction of the respondents under Section 396 IPC.
  2. Whether the prosecution evidence—especially eyewitness identification and medical testimony—was sufficiently cogent and credible to sustain convictions for dacoity-cum-murder.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The High Court improperly discarded the testimony of the eyewitnesses (PWs 1, 2, 4, 6, 7).
  • The lantern light was adequate for identification, and minor inconsistencies should not overshadow injured-witness testimony.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The prosecution case was false and motivated by longstanding neighborhood enmity.
  • The High Court’s assessment of evidentiary infirmities was sound and free from perversity, warranting no interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reviewed the High Court’s detailed critique of the prosecution case and found no perversity:

  • Identification Doubts: The High Court considered it highly improbable that 14–15 assailants could be correctly identified solely by lantern light; the investigating officer found no lantern or evidence of one at the scene.
  • Weapon Inconsistencies: Medical evidence (PW-8) reported numerous incised wounds incompatible with the garasa and tengari said to have been used; the trial court itself noted the mismatch but downplayed it.
  • Missing or Delayed Statements: PWs 1 and 2—claimed eyewitnesses—did not give statements to police on the first opportunity, undermining their credibility.
  • Lack of Medical Proof for Certain Injuries: Though PWs 1 and 2 alleged assault, no injury certificates or doctor’s examination supported their claims.
  • Inclusion of Minors and an Elderly Accused: The presence of a 13-year-old, a 16-year-old, and a 74-year-old among alleged dacoits appeared implausible.
  • Possibility of False Implication: Given longstanding neighborhood disputes, the High Court considered false implication a realistic possibility.

Finding these factors cumulatively destructive of the prosecution narrative, the Supreme Court concluded that the High Court’s acquittal was justified and not amenable to interference on appeal.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The judgment of the Patna High Court acquitting all respondents stands affirmed.

Implications: The decision leaves the respondents acquitted and underscores the Supreme Court’s reluctance to overturn an acquittal absent demonstrable perversity or gross misappreciation of evidence. No new legal precedent was articulated; the ruling primarily affects the parties by finalizing their acquittal.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shrishti Narain Jha v. Bindeshwar Jha And Others

    Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— The challenge in these appeals is to the judgment of a Division Bench of the Patna High Court directing acquittal of Respondents 1 to 9 who faced trial for alleged commission of the offence punishable under Section 396 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”). Questioning their acquittal the complainant has filed the appeal. The learned IInd Addl. Sessions Judge, Muzaffarpur, had directed conviction of Respondents 1 to 9 and sentenced each to undergo imprisonment for life. On appeal the High Court directed acquittal.

    2. The background facts in a nutshell as projected by the prosecution are as follows:

    The case of the prosecution, as disclosed in the fardbeyan (Ext. 6) of informant, Shrishti Narain Jha (PW 7), in short, is that on the night between 5-7-1981 and 6-7-1981, the informant was sleeping along with his two brothers in the baithka of his house. On one bed, he was sleeping alone and on the other bed near his bed, his younger brothers, Gopal Narain Jha (PW 4) and Naresh Narain Jha (PW 6) were sleeping. At 12 o'clock about fourteen to fifteen dacoits came to the house of the informant, entered the baithka and started hurling lathis and when their lathis struck against tatti of baithka, the informant woke up on hearing the strikings and he stood on his bed. One of the dacoits ordered him to remain standing otherwise he would be shot dead. The informant, among the dacoits, identified all the appellants and Dahaur Jha (since dead).

    3. The accused, Navo Nath Mishra was carrying a country-made pistol, Bindeshwar Jha was armed with tengari (axe) and Jeev Nath Mishra was armed with a garasa. Rest of the accused persons were carrying lathis, ropes and torches. Accused Navo Nath Mishra fired two shots from his country-made pistol causing injuries on the thigh and body of Naresh Narain Jha (PW 6) and when Gopal Narain Jha (PW 4) went running out of the baithka, dacoits, after surrounding him, assaulted him with lathis.

    4. The informant also ran out of the house and went to the darwaza of one Krishna Kant Jha (not examined) and raised hulla. While leaving baithka, he had heard the dacoits saying that “sala ghar mein hoga” and some dacoits entered the house and when on hearing the cry of help of the informant, nobody from his locality came, he again returned to his house and found that dacoits were running away through the back door of his house towards south. Mother of the informant raised hulla from the house that dacoits had killed the father of the informant and when the informant went inside his house; he found his father lying dead beneath a chowki with injuries on his neck caused by sharp-edged weapons.

    5. From his mother, the informant came to know that accused Bindeshwar Jha with tengari and Jeev Nath Mishra with garasa had inflicted injuries on the neck and body of the father of the informant when he had tried to hide beneath his chowki and at that time accused Daya Nath Mishra, Bhai Lal Jha, Navo Nath Mishra and three to four others had surrounded his mother and had demanded keys from her. (Sic When she tried) to prevent the dacoits from assaulting her husband, she was also assaulted with lathis by dacoits. The dacoits took away steel boxes carrying clothes, ornaments of silver and gold and a cash amount of rupees seven thousand. The dacoits also snatched an earring and a necklace from the body of mother of the informant. About his wife, the informant stated that she was also assaulted by dacoits with lathis. The amount of articles, taken away in dacoity, was about rupees forty thousand.

    6. The fardbeyan (Ext. 6) of the informant was recorded at his house on 6-7-1981 at about 6.30 a.m by Sub-Inspector, Radhika Raman Singh (PW 12). On the basis of fardbeyan (Ext. 6) of the informant, formal first information report (Ext. 4) was drawn against all the appellants and co-accused Dahaur Jha under Section 396 IPC. After investigation, police submitted charge-sheet under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302, 323, 324, 380, 452 and 307 IPC against all the accused persons. Taking cognizance, the case was committed to the Court of Session where charge under Section 396 IPC was framed against all the appellants and they were put on trial because they denied the charge.

    7. After investigation police submitted charge-sheet in respect of the offences punishable under Sections 147, 148, 149, 392, 323, 324, 380, 452 and 307 IPC. However, the Sessions Court framed charges under Section 396 against the accused persons. The accused persons pleaded innocence, therefore, the trial was held. After trial, all the accused persons were found guilty under Section 396 IPC and were accordingly convicted and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life.

    8. The High Court directed acquittal which is questioned by the informant. The prosecution witnesses stated that they identified the appellants by a lantern. The High Court found it highly improbable that they could identify such a large number of accused persons with the light of a lantern. Though the investigating officer during investigation did not find any lantern or sign of any lantern. The High Court ultimately concluded that the case of the prosecution is not established by cogent evidence and therefore, it would not be desirable to place reliance on the prosecution evidence and accordingly directed acquittal.

    9. The trial court noted that Naresh Narain Jha (PW 6) and Gopal Narain Jha (PW 4) were injured witnesses. It was the prosecution case that apart from the present appellant, the informant; Amod Devi (PW 1), Veena Devi (PW 2), Gopal Narain Jha (PW 4) and Naresh Narain Jha (PW 6) were the eyewitnesses. PW 1 is the mother of the PW 2. PW 2 is the wife of the informant and two others are his brothers. PW 1 and PW 2 claim to have seen injuries on the deceased. They stated that the accused persons assaulted with garasa and accused Bindeshwar Jha assaulted the deceased with tengari.

    10. The High Court noted that the evidence of the doctor (PW 8) was that there were a large number of incised wounds found on the dead body of the deceased which are caused by sharp-edged weapon. It was found that the injuries were not possible by garasa and tengari. Though the trial court noted that the prosecution version was not acceptable as regards the weapons used, much importance was not attached except the statement that no explanation is available in evidence of PWs 1 and 2 regarding such injury. There was another aspect which the High Court noted to hold that the prosecution case was not believable. It was the prosecution case that the appellant Shrishti Narain Jha fired at PW 4. The doctor did not find any firearm injury.

    11. It is to be noted that the State has not questioned the acquittal and the informant has filed the present appeal. The only stand taken by the appellant is that the eyewitnesses' version should not have been discarded. Learned counsel for respondent, on the other hand, supported the judgment of acquittal submitting that the false case has been foisted because of previous enmity. It is further submitted that the judgment of the High Court does not suffer from any perversity to warrant any interference.

    12. The High Court has indicated in great detail the infirmities in the prosecution version and has concluded that the prosecution version is not credible and cogent.

    13. The evidence of investigating officer that he found a plank of door broken and fallen on the floor which is also against the evidence of PW 1 who has clearly said that the appellants had made a hole in the plank of the door of her room by tengari and by inserting hand to that hole, opened the latch of the door. This also does not support the case of prosecution regarding the manner in which door of her room was opened. The investigating officer (PW 12) in his evidence has stated that he recorded the statements of PWs 1 and 2 on 7-7-1981 because on 6-7-1981 when he met them, they were not in a position to give their statements because they were engaged in weeping.

    14. PW 2 has admitted that the police came on the next day of dacoity but on that day, her statement was not recorded because she was weeping on that day and on the next day her statement and statement of her mother-in-law were recorded. This has also created a very strong doubt to accept the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 that they are eyewitnesses to the occurrence. When PW 1 was in a position to give the details of the occurrence to her son who is the informant immediately after the occurrence, there was no reason for her not to give her statement on the next day of occurrence when police had come to her house. PWs 1 and 2, said to be eyewitnesses to the occurrence, in their evidence, have stated that they were also assaulted by dacoits and had received injuries but there is nothing on record that like other injured persons, they were also examined by any doctor.

    15. The investigating officer (PW 12) does not say that on the next day in the morning when he visited the place of occurrence, he found any injury on PWs 1 and 2. Although he has said that he prepared injury certificate but has not made it clear for whom such certificates were prepared by him. He, in his cross-examination, has said that by the time, he reached the place of occurrence, injured Gopal Narain Jha (PW 4) and Naresh Narain Jha (PW 6) had already been sent to the hospital and he, after going to the hospital, saw injuries on their persons. The injuries certificates, prepared by him, may be for these two injured persons and no definite opinion about the injury certificate, said to be prepared by him, can be given in the absence of naming the injured by him or in absence of bringing these injury certificates on record.

    16. Amod Devi (PW 1) has said that later one Bahuran Devi gave her a sum of Rs 320 saying that she found the money thrown on the bank of a river and on the next day, one Ram Master informed that some boxes were lying in katai area which were brought by Budhan Sahni and others. None of the persons, named above, were examined.

    17. The prosecution witnesses have claimed that they identified the appellants in the light of lantern but the investigating officer, during investigation, did not find any lantern or sign of lighting the lantern which usually appear in the surrounding areas. Accused Bharat Lal Jha was not identified by PWs 1 and 2, accused Binod Jha by PW 2 and accused Umesh Jha by PW 6. Besides this, PWs 4 and 6 have added names of Ashok Jha, Somendra Jha and Ram Ballabh Jha who are not among the accused persons.

    18. The medical evidence showing that the death of deceased was homicidal and the evidence of the investigating officer who found bloodstains at the place of occurrence and some marks of violence on a wooden box kept at the place of occurrence may suggest the factum of dacoity in the house of informant but so far as the manner of dacoity and participation of the accused in that dacoity is concerned, that appears quite doubtful. The evidence of prosecution witnesses is that besides the accused, there were some other dacoits also with them who could not be identified. The possibility of false implication of the appellants in this case on account of long-standing enmity utilising the incident of daocity cannot be ruled out.

    19. In this case, accused Vijay Jha and Binod Jha were examined under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure on 31-3-1987 and 20-4-1987 respectively when their ages were estimated by the court below as about nineteen years and twenty-two years respectively. The occurrence is said to have taken place in the night between 5-7-1981 and 6-7-1981. It means that at the time of occurrence the age of accused Vijay Jha was about thirteen years, three months and the age of appellant Binod Jha was about sixteen years two months. They both are brothers and accused Bindeshwar Jha is their another brother. It looks very unnatural that the accused would go to commit dacoity in their neighbourhood taking with them such minor and young boys as Vijay Jha and Binod Jha when they were sufficient in number and accompanied by some other persons also.

    20. Besides this, the age of accused Bhai Lal Jha was estimated by the court on 31-3-1987 when he was examined under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as eighty years. The defence has brought on record a voters' list (Exhibit A) showing that in this voters' list which was received in the year 1983 the age of co-accused Dahaur Jha (since dead) is recorded as seventy-two years, since Dahaur Jha is dead now so this document does not help the case of any one now but then accused Bhai Lal Jha, admittedly at the time of occurrence was aged about seventy-four years. So, we find that the accused included an old man aged about seventy-four years as well as a boy aged about thirteen years and, as stated above, the accused were neighbours of the informant with whom the family of the informant had long-standing dispute.

    21. The judgment of the High Court does not suffer from any infirmity. The appeals fail and are dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shrishti Narain Jha v. Bindeshwar Jha And Others
    (May 5, 2009)