AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 184
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 319 CrPC, Section 161 CrPC of the Criminal Procedure Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2009 INSC 184
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 319 CrPC, Section 161 CrPC of the Criminal Procedure Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 1 October 2006, Brijesh Kumar Singh alias Bablu Singh and his brother-in-law Manvender Singh were walking through Gupta Colony, Sitapur (U.P.) when they were allegedly attacked “in a planned manner with common intention.” Brijesh died on the spot and Manvender sustained injuries. Kamlesh Singh (PW 1), brother of the deceased, lodged the First Information Report the same day.

Upon investigation, a charge-sheet (challan) dated 22 October 2006 was filed under Sections 307, 302 read with 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, and the case was committed to the Sessions Court.

During trial, PW 1’s deposition was recorded on 19 June 2007. The same day he moved an application under Section 319 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) to summon four additional persons—Ram Pal Singh, Deepak Singh, Ajai Kumar Singh and Anil Kumar Singh—to face trial. The Additional Sessions Judge dismissed this application on 5 July 2007.

On revision, the High Court of Allahabad set aside that dismissal on 29 August 2007 and directed the trial court to reconsider the matter. After rehearing, the trial court again dismissed the Section 319 application on 15 September 2007. A second revision (No. 549/2007) was filed; on 5 October 2007 the High Court quashed the second dismissal, sought an explanation from the trial judge for non-compliance, and directed issuance of summons to the four persons named above.

The summoned individuals (appellants) challenged the High Court’s order before the Supreme Court. Leave was granted, and the present appeal followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court correctly exercised its jurisdiction under Section 319 CrPC in directing summons to the appellants on the basis of PW 1’s deposition.
  2. Whether the trial court’s discretion under Section 319 CrPC was improperly curtailed by the High Court’s directions.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The appellants were summoned solely on PW 1’s testimony; no other eyewitness or Section 161 CrPC statement implicated them.
  • PW 1’s own presence at the scene was doubtful because he omitted names mentioned by other witnesses.
  • The injured eyewitness, Manvender Singh, did not name the appellants, undermining the High Court’s reliance on PW 1.
  • The High Court misapplied Section 319 CrPC, ignoring that the trial court must be satisfied of a likelihood of conviction before issuing summons. Reliance placed on Mohd. Shafi v. Mohd. Rafiq (2007) 14 SCC 544.
  • The High Court effectively dictated the outcome on remand, depriving the trial court of its statutory discretion.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Section 319 CrPC requires only that evidence on record show the proposed accused were implicated and likely to be convicted.
  • The appellants were named in both the FIR and PW 1’s sworn testimony—sufficient material to invoke Section 319.
  • The High Court correctly found the trial court in “direct defiance” of its earlier order and justifiably issued summons.
  • No interference by the Supreme Court is warranted because the High Court’s order conforms to the statutory scheme.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohd. Shafi v. Mohd. Rafiq, (2007) 14 SCC 544 Before invoking Section 319 CrPC, the court must be satisfied that evidence makes it “in all likelihood” that the proposed accused will be convicted; discretion must be judicially exercised. Cited by appellants to argue that the High Court summoned them without the requisite satisfaction; Supreme Court distinguished and did not rely on it to overturn the High Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined Section 319 CrPC, emphasising its “unambiguous” text: during inquiry or trial, if evidence shows a person not already an accused appears to have committed an offence triable with the existing accused, the court may proceed against such person.

Key analytical steps:

  • The statute leaves discretion with the court, triggered by evidence suggesting clear complicity.
  • Although the appellants were not charge-sheeted, they were named in the FIR and explicitly implicated by PW 1 during trial.
  • The trial court twice declined to summon them despite this evidence; the High Court’s contrary view was reasonable given PW 1’s deposition.
  • While the Supreme Court noted that some of the High Court’s remarks toward the trial judge “could and should have been avoided,” it held that the substantive direction to summon the appellants was legally sound.
  • The precedent of Mohd. Shafi was not controlling because, on the facts here, the evidence (FIR + sworn testimony) provided the requisite basis for summoning.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed; High Court’s direction to summon the appellants under Section 319 CrPC affirmed.

Immediate Effect: The four appellants must appear as accused in Sessions Trial No. 1163/2006 on charges under Sections 302, 307 and 120-B IPC.

Broader Implications: The judgment reinforces that naming in the FIR coupled with corroborative trial testimony can suffice to invoke Section 319 CrPC, and appellate courts may intervene when trial courts disregard such evidence. No new legal principle was announced, but the decision underscores the discretionary yet evidence-based nature of Section 319 powers.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ram Pal Singh And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another

    Altamas Kabir, J.— Leave granted.

    2. In respect of an incident which took place on 1-10-2006, in the daytime at about 1.00 p.m, Kamlesh Singh (PW 1) lodged a complaint before the Station House Officer, Police Station Sitapur, U.P, alleging that while his younger brother, Brijesh Kumar Singh alias Bablu Singh along with his brother-in-law Manvender Singh, was going on foot towards Mani Chauraha through Gupta Colony at Sitapur, U.P, the accused persons, in a planned manner with common intention, attacked the deceased and Manvender Singh. On account of such assault, Brijesh Kumar Singh died on the spot and Manvender Singh also sustained injuries.

    3. On completion of investigation, the investigating officer filed a challan against the accused persons on 22-10-2006 under Sections 307, 302 read with Section 120-B IPC and the matter was, thereafter, committed to the Sessions Court for trial.

    4. On 19-6-2007, the deposition of Kamlesh Singh (PW 1) was recorded by the learned Sessions Judge, Sitapur. The said witness reiterated the statements which had been made by him in the first information report. It also appears that on the same day, Kamlesh Singh filed an application under Section 319 CrPC before the learned Sessions Judge, Sitapur, for summoning the appellants herein to face trial in respect of the said incident. The said application was dismissed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge on 5-7-2007, and against such order of dismissal, Kamlesh Singh filed Criminal Revision No. 413 of 2007, which was disposed of by the High Court on 29-8-2007, by setting aside the impugned order and directing the trial court to pass a fresh order in the light of the observations made in the order of the High Court.

    5. In compliance with the said order, the learned Additional Sessions Judge reheard the application filed under Section 319 CrPC and by his order dated 15-9-2007, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, once again, dismissed the application filed by Respondent 2 for summoning the appellants herein under Section 319 CrPC.

    6. The dismissal of the application was followed by a second criminal revision petition filed by Respondent 2 on 5-10-2007, being No. 549 of 2007 and after hearing the parties, the High Court came to the conclusion that the fresh order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge on 15-9-2007, was in direct defiance of the order passed by the High Court earlier on 29-8-2007. In that view of the matter, the High Court not only sought for an explanation from the learned trial Judge for not complying with the aforesaid order of the High Court, but after quashing the impugned order dated 15-9-2007, directed the trial court to issue summons against Ram Pal Singh, Deepak Singh, Ajai Kumar Singh and Anil Kumar Singh for their appearance as accused in Sessions Trial No. 1163 of 2006 under Sections 302, 307 and 120-B IPC. It is the said order of the High Court which has been impugned in the instant appeal by the persons summoned under Section 319 CrPC.

    7. Mr V.J Francis, learned advocate, appearing for the appellants, submitted that although the appellants had not been named by any of the other witnesses, only on the statement of Kamlesh Singh (PW 1), they had been summoned under Section 319 CrPC as accused in the sessions trial.

    8. Mr Francis also submitted that the very presence of Kamlesh Singh (PW 1) at the time of the incident was highly doubtful as he had not named some of the other persons named by other eyewitnesses who were said to have been present at the time of the incident. He also urged that none of the eyewitnesses to the incident had named the appellants in their statements made under Section 161 CrPC.

    9. Mr Francis submitted that the High Court did not also consider the fact that Manvender Singh, who had been accompanying the deceased at the time of the incident and had also sustained injury in the alleged assault, did not name any of the appellants as having participated in the incident. Mr Francis submitted that the order of the High Court summoning the appellants under Section 319 CrPC on the sole evidence of PW 1 whose presence at the time of incident was highly doubtful, was erroneous and was liable to be set aside.

    10. In support of his submissions, Mr Francis referred to and relied on a recent decision of this Court in Mohd. Shafi v. Mohd. Rafiq (2007) 14 SCC 544, (2007) 5 Scale 611 wherein in a similar situation, the order of the High Court directing issuance of summons was set aside on the ground that before the trial court decided to take recourse to the provisions of Section 319 CrPC, it would have to be satisfied that the requisite conditions for taking such action actually existed. Commission of an offence by a person not facing trial must, therefore, appear to the court concerned to be a certainty. It cannot be based on an ipse dixit on the part of the court and the discretion in this regard had to be judicially exercised. This Court, while setting aside the order of the High Court, inter alia, observed that before the court exercises its discretionary jurisdiction in terms of Section 319 CrPC, it must arrive at a satisfaction that there exists a possibility that the accused, so summoned, is in all likelihood liable to be convicted.

    11. Mr Francis submitted that while passing the impugned order, the High Court did not consider the fact that the application made under Section 319 CrPC filed for summoning the appellants had been rejected on the ground that the injured witness Manvender Singh had not indicated their complicity with the incident in his statement under Section 161 CrPC. On the other hand, the High Court came to the conclusion that it was obligatory on the part of the learned trial Judge to have summoned the appellants to face trial and has failed to do so against the existing canons of law. Mr Francis submitted that although the High Court had intended the trial court to pass a fresh order along the lines suggested by it in its order dated 29-8-2007, the trial court had in defiance of the said order, recklessly passed the order dated 15-9-2007, which was no different from its earlier order refusing to summon the appellants under Section 319 CrPC.

    12. Mr Francis submitted that the hard stand taken by the High Court would be evident from its order seeking an explanation from the trial Judge for not complying with the intent of the Court, as clearly indicated in the order of 29-8-2007. Apart from quashing the second order passed by the trial Judge on 15-9-2007, the High Court directed the trial court to issue summons against the appellants herein for their appearance as accused in ST No. 1163 of 2006 under Sections 302, 307 and 120-B IPC.

    13. Mr Francis submitted that while interpreting its own order, the High Court made it clear that while passing a fresh order, the same was to be in line with the observations made by the High Court. Mr Francis submitted that this approach of the High Court was completely erroneous since the discretion to decide afresh had to be left to the trial court.

    14. Opposing Mr Francis's submissions, Mr Pramod Swarup, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents, urged that in order to invoke the provisions of Section 319 CrPC, all that was required to be seen was whether the persons to be summoned were in some way implicated in the incident for which the trial was being conducted, and, if so, whether such accused had been named by any of the witnesses for the prosecution. It is also required to be seen that the evidence was of such nature that by relying upon the same, there was a strong possibility of the persons being added as accused of being ultimately convicted.

    15. Mr Swarup contended that in this case the appellants had been directly named not only in the FIR but also by the complainant, Kamlesh Singh, who claimed to be an eyewitness of the murder of his brother committed in broad daylight. Mr Swarup submitted that nothing further was required to be done to satisfy the court for issuing summons to the named persons under Section 319 CrPC, whose complicity had been shown from the evidence adduced during the trial. He submitted that only after being satisfied that the appellants had a positive role to play in the incident, summons under Section 319 CrPC were issued to the appellants. He urged that the order of the High Court did not warrant any interference and the appeal was liable to be dismissed.

    16. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties and the provisions of Section 319 CrPC and have arrived at the conclusion that no interference is called for with the order passed by the High Court.

    17. The ingredients of Section 319 are unambiguous and indicate that where in the course of inquiry into, or trial of, an offence, it appears from the evidence that any person not being the accused has committed any offence, for which such person could be tried together with the accused, the court may proceed against such person for the offence he has committed.

    18. All that is required by the court for invoking its powers under Section 319 CrPC is to be satisfied that from the evidence adduced before it, a person against whom no charge had been framed, but whose complicity appears to be clear, should be tried together with the accused. It is also clear that the discretion is left to the court to take a decision on the matter.

    19. In the instant case, although, the appellants were named in the FIR, they were not named as accused in the charge-sheet during the trial. However, PW 1 in his evidence, has named the appellants as persons who were involved in the incident causing the death of Brijesh Kumar Singh and injuries to Manvender Singh. Despite the above, the trial court, on two separate occasions, rejected the prayer made by Respondent 2 for summoning the appellants herein under Section 319 CrPC. The High Court, after considering the evidence of PW 1, Kamlesh Singh, thought it necessary for the appellants to be summoned.

    20. Although, certain other observations made by the High Court regarding the orders passed by the trial court could and should have been avoided, we are also of the view that the High Court had not committed any error in directing that the appellants be summoned to stand trial along with the co-accused, in view of the evidence of PW 1 during the trial itself.

    21. We, therefore, dismiss the appeal and uphold the direction given by the High Court for summoning the appellants under Section 319 CrPC.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Pal Singh And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another
    (Feb 13, 2009)