AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
009 INSC 1020
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act
  • Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (Section 23)
  • The A.P Hindu Succession Act, 1987
  • Section 23 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
009 INSC 1020
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act
  • Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (Section 23)
  • The A.P Hindu Succession Act, 1987
  • Section 23 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute arises out of a partition suit within the family of the late G. Ramanujulu Naidu. His grandson, G.K. Kuppuswamy Naidu, allegedly effected a partition of family properties before 31-12-1964 and executed a will dated 25-10-1973. After his death in 1976, differences surfaced among his descendants regarding the devolution of certain properties.

The plaintiffs (widow and minor son of G.S. Ravi Kumar) issued a notice seeking partition of joint family assets. When cooperation was not forthcoming, they instituted a civil suit. The trial court framed nine issues and passed a preliminary decree granting the plaintiffs two-thirds of Item 7, dismissing the rest of the claim for non-joinder of necessary parties.

On appeal, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh dismissed the challenge (except for Item 7). The plaintiffs obtained special leave to the Supreme Court, which confined the scope of the appeal—by order dated 6-5-2004—to Items 5 and 7 of Schedule I and the issue of a missing will dated 1-11-1975. During Supreme Court proceedings the respondents informed the Court that the will could not be traced, prompting the Court to proceed on the footing that it did not exist.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the absence of the purported will dated 1-11-1975, Items 5 and 7 devolved by intestate succession.
  2. Whether the widow and daughters of Srinivasa Rao could inherit the properties, having regard to Mitakshara coparcenary principles and the amendments to Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act.
  3. Whether the Supreme Court should enlarge the scope of the appeal beyond Items 5 and 7 despite the earlier limiting order dated 6-5-2004.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The widow (Prabhavati) and daughters (Vinodini, Vinita, Vibha and Shalini) of Srinivasa Rao could not inherit as the properties were allegedly Mitakshara coparcenary property.
  • The Court should consider the entirety of the suit properties, not merely Items 5 and 7.

Respondents' Arguments

  • When called upon, counsel stated that the will dated 1-11-1975 was “not traceable,” implying it could not be relied upon.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R. Mahalakshmi v. A.V. Anatharaman (2009) 9 SCC 52 Effect of State amendments (e.g., Andhra Pradesh) and the 2005 central amendment on daughters’ coparcenary rights. Cited to affirm that by virtue of the Andhra Pradesh amendment, daughters acquire coparcenary rights, reinforcing the equality of female heirs.
G. Sekar v. Geetha (2009) 6 SCC 99 Interpretation of the omission of Section 23 of the Hindu Succession Act and equal rights of female heirs to demand partition. Relied upon to underscore that daughters’ title is equal to sons’ and that any earlier restriction (Section 23) no longer bars partition suits by female heirs.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Non-production of the will: Because the respondents conceded that the will dated 1-11-1975 “is not traceable,” the Court treated it as non-existent. Consequently, no party could claim under that instrument.

2. Nature of the property: The Court rejected the contention that the properties were Mitakshara coparcenary. G.K. Kuppuswamy Naidu had acquired the properties individually through a 1921 will from his father, making them his separate property. Therefore, succession was governed by Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

3. Rights of female heirs: Drawing on the Andhra Pradesh amendment to Section 6 (1987) and the 2005 central amendment, read with the precedents cited, the Court held that daughters and the widow are entitled to inherit equally.

4. Scope of appeal: The Court declined the request to reopen issues beyond Items 5 and 7, noting that all parties had proceeded on the earlier Supreme Court order restricting the appeal to those two items.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF: The parties are directed to take equal shares in respect of Items 5 and 7 of Schedule I.

Implications: The decision affirms that, in Andhra Pradesh, female heirs enjoy inheritance rights equal to male heirs even in formerly coparcenary property, and that failure to produce a will precludes reliance on it. The ruling resolves the dispute only as to Items 5 and 7 and does not set broader precedent beyond reiterating existing statutory and case-law principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    G. Varalakshmi And Another v. G. Srinivasa Rao (Dead) Through Lrs. And Another

    Order

    1. Leave granted. The late G. Ramanujulu Naidu had four sons—G.K Kuppuswamy Naidu, G.R Varadaraula, G.R Sripathi Naidu and G.R Gajapati Naidu. G.K Kuppuswamy Naidu had two sons, Mohan Babu and G. Srinivasa Rao (the 1st defendant). Defendant 2 is the wife of Defendant 1. They have four daughters, namely, Vinodini, Vinita, Vibha and Shalini and one son, G.S Ravi Kumar who married the first plaintiff in the year 1978 and the 2nd plaintiff was born to them in the year 1980.

    2. G.K Kuppuswamy effected the partition as alleged by the plaintiffs, some time prior to 31-12-1964. He, before dying in 1976 executed a will on 25-10-1973, which was in the custody of the first defendant.

    3. After the death of G.S Ravi Kumar in tragic circumstances, the plaintiffs issued notice to the defendants to partition the properties belonging to the joint family, but they allegedly did not cooperate. Hence a civil suit was filed. The defendants admitted relationship between them and about Kuppuswamy dying in the year 1976 and leaving behind a will dated 1-11-1975.

    4. As many as nine issues were framed by the trial court and a preliminary decree was passed for partition of Item 7 into three shares of which two belonged to the plaintiff. The remaining suit was dismissed on the ground of non-joinder of necessary parties.

    5. An appeal was preferred before the High Court of Judicature of Andhra Pradesh, relating to all the suit properties except Item 7 wherein the point for consideration was whether the properties in the plaintiff (sic plaint) schedule are joint family properties of the 1st plaintiff and 1st defendant. During pendency of the appeal the minor son attained majority and wanted to implead the daughters of Respondent 1 as some of the properties were in their names. The appeal was dismissed, hence the appellants are before us through this appeal by way of special leave.

    6. A Bench of this Court by an order dated 6-5-2004 issued notice limited only to Items 5 and 7 of Schedule I and on the question of the non-production of the will. The will in question, said to be dated 1-11-1975 executed by G.R Kuppuswamy Naidu has not been produced.

    7. In the proceeding sheet dated 23-1-2008 it was noticed:

    “One of the contentions raised before us is that the will dated 1-11-1975 executed by G.R Kuppuswamy Naidu purported to be in favour of his sons Mohan Babu and G. Sreenivasa Rao as also Ravi Kumar has not been produced so as to enable the Court to ascertain as to whether by reason thereof only Item 7 of the property described in plaint Schedule I was bequeathed in favour of Ravi Kumar or not. We direct the respondent to produce an authenticated copy of the said will, if not the original.”

    8. Shri A.K Ganguli, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents when the matter was called out stated that the will, in question, is not traceable. We, thus, proceed on the basis that the said purported will being non-existent, the parties did not inherit any property pursuant thereto or in furtherance thereof.

    9. Indisputably, G.R Kuppuswamy obtained the property by reason of a will executed by his father in the year 1921 from Ramanujulu Naidu. He expired on 16-1-1976. Srinivasa Rao, the predecessor-in-interest of the parties thereto expired on 30-7-2006.

    10. One of the questions which was raised before us by Mr M.N Krishnamani, the learned Senior Counsel is that Prabhavati, widow of Srinivasa Rao and his daughters, Vinodini, Vinita, Vibha and Shalini could not inherit any property of G.R Kuppuswamy Naidu or Srinivasa Rao, the same being a Mitakshara coparcenary one.

    11. The contention of the learned Senior Counsel is not correct, inasmuch as Kuppuswamy got the property by reason of a will, it was, therefore, his individual property and not, Mitakshara coparcenary property on 30-11-1921. Furthermore, the execution of the said will and effect thereof is not in question as all the four sons of Ramanujulu Naidu were beneficiaries in terms thereof.

    12. Furthermore, the State of Andhra Pradesh amended Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 by the A.P Hindu Succession Act, 1987 in terms whereof the daughters also by reason of a legal fiction became coparceners.

    13. Similar provision has been introduced by Parliament by the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 and the effect of such a State amendment in relation to the State of Tamil Nadu has been considered by us recently in R. Mahalakshmi v. A.V Anatharaman (2009) 9 SCC 52 wherein it was held as under:

    “16. Section 23 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 has since been omitted w.e.f 9-9-2005, but before omission, it stood as thus:
    ‘23. Special provision respecting dwelling houses.—Where a Hindu intestate has left surviving him or her both male and female heirs specified in Class I of the Schedule and his or her property includes a dwelling house wholly occupied by members of his or her family, then, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, the right of any such female heir to claim partition of the dwelling house shall not arise until the male heirs choose to divide their respective shares therein; but the female heir shall be entitled to a right of residence therein:
    Provided that where such female heir is a daughter, she shall be entitled to a right of residence in the dwelling house only if she is unmarried or has been deserted by or has separated from her husband or is a widow.’
    17. In a recent judgment of this Court in G. Sekar v. Geetha (2009) 6 SCC 99 pronounced by one of us (Hon'ble S.B Sinha J.), the effect of amendment in the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 by reason of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 insofar as therein Section 23 has been omitted, was considered. It was held as under:
    ‘21. The said property belonging to Govinda Singh, therefore, having devolved upon all his heirs in equal share on his death, it would not be correct to contend that the right, title and interest in the property itself was subjected to the restrictive right contained in Section 23 of the Act. The title by reason of Section 8 of the Act devolved absolutely upon the daughters as well as the sons of Govinda Singh. They had, thus, a right to maintain a suit for partition. Section 23 of the Act, however, carves out an exception in regard to obtaining a decree for possession inter alia in a case where dwelling house was possessed by a male heir. Apart therefrom, the right of a female heir in a property of her father, who has died intestate is equal to her brother. Section 23 of the Act merely restricts the right to a certain extent. It, however, recognises the right of residence in respect of the class of females who come within the purview of the proviso thereof. Such a right of residence does not depend upon the date on which the suit has been instituted but can also be subsequently enforced by a female, if she comes within the purview of the proviso appended to Section 23 of the Act.’
    18. However, on account of death of Respondent 3, unmarried sister of the parties, the said Question 1 had become academic in nature and it was not necessary for us to answer the same but as it stood answered in a recent judgment of this Court in G. Sekar (2009) 6 SCC 99, to put the controversy at rest, we have considered this aspect of the matter also and answered it accordingly hereinabove.”

    In that view of the matter, there cannot be any doubt or dispute that the defendants herein could be entitled to equal shares of the property of Srinivasa Rao in terms of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act.

    14. We would however, make it clear that in these proceedings we are concerned with the properties left at the hands of G.R Kuppuswamy Naidu. The learned counsel, however, tried to persuade us to modify the said order of this Court dated 6-5-2004 so as to consider the entire matter afresh and in its entirety. The contention having not been raised before us earlier in this Court and all concerned having proceeded on the basis that the subject-matter of this appeal is confined to only Items 5 and 7 of Schedule I to the plaint, we are of the opinion that the said request of the learned counsel cannot be accepted.

    15. We, therefore, direct that the parties shall be entitled to equal shares also in respect of Items 5 and 7. The appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    G. Varalakshmi And Another v. G. Srinivasa Rao (Dead) Through Lrs. And Another
    (Aug 6, 2009)