AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • (no specific act/article mentioned)
  • The Apprentices Act, 1961
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • (no specific act/article mentioned)
  • The Apprentices Act, 1961
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants completed apprenticeship training in various trades with the erstwhile Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board more than eleven years prior to the present proceedings. Upon completion, they sought absorption as Junior Engineers or in comparable operating-staff posts, claiming preference over non-apprentice candidates and exemption from age limits.

The Board declined their request and, on 17-10-1998, issued an open advertisement to fill the disputed posts. The appellants filed a writ petition in the Allahabad High Court challenging the advertisement and asking for preferential appointment without having to sit for any written examination.

Because a three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in U.P. SRTC v. U.P. Parivahan Nigam Shishukh Berozgar Sangh (1995) 2 SCC 1 had exempted certain trainees from written examinations, the writ petition was tagged with Arvind Gautam v. State of U.P. and referred to a Full Bench. On 27-5-1999 the Full Bench, finding the issues identical and noting the absence of counsel, disposed of the appellants’ writ in terms of Arvind Gautam, holding that the 1995 exemption applied only to the trainees who were parties in that case.

The appellants then approached the Supreme Court (Civil Appeals Nos. 1838-39 of 2001). A three-Judge Bench remitted the matter to the High Court on 14-3-2001, directing it to examine the governing recruitment rules to determine whether apprentices were statutorily required to take a written test.

Meanwhile, fresh vacancies were advertised in 2001 and the Board was reorganised into the Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation. On remand, a Division Bench of the High Court analysed the U.P. State Electricity Board (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1978, and concluded that a written examination was a mandatory component of the selection process for all candidates, including apprentices.

The present appeal by special leave challenges that High Court judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the applicable recruitment regulations, apprentices are required to sit for a written examination before appointment to posts such as Junior Engineer and other operating-staff positions.
  2. Whether the exemption from written examinations granted in U.P. SRTC v. U.P. Parivahan Nigam Shishukh Berozgar Sangh (1995) 2 SCC 1 extends beyond the parties to that case and applies generally to all apprentices in public sector undertakings of Uttar Pradesh.
  3. How the term “examine” in Clause 3(2) of the U.P. State Electricity Board (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1978, should be construed—specifically, whether it necessarily includes a written test.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The word “examine” in Clause 3(2) of the 1978 Regulations should not be read as mandating a written examination, particularly for former apprentices.
  • The High Court’s interpretation conflicts with the “spirit” of the Supreme Court’s 1995 decision in U.P. SRTC, which, according to counsel, intended a broader exemption for apprentices.
  • The High Court allegedly failed to give due effect to the Supreme Court’s remand directions, which, in the appellants’ view, envisaged the possibility of exempting apprentices from written tests.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. U.P. Parivahan Nigam Shishukh Berozgar Sangh, (1995) 2 SCC 1 Trainees are entitled to consideration for employment; exemption from written examination was granted to trainees who were parties to that specific case. The Court reaffirmed that the exemption from written examination was case-specific and does not automatically apply to other apprentices; recruitment requirements must be ascertained from the governing regulations.
Arvind Gautam v. State of U.P. (Allahabad High Court, Full Bench) Interpreted U.P. SRTC to hold that the written-exam exemption was confined to the parties before the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court had earlier upheld this Full Bench view; it remained the operative interpretation and informed the High Court’s decision under appeal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first noted that the High Court, on remand, had meticulously examined the governing recruitment framework, namely the U.P. State Electricity Board (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1978. Clause 3(2) authorises the Electricity Service Commission to “examine, interview, select and recommend” candidates. Reading the clause in its entirety, the High Court had concluded that “examine” encompasses a mandatory written test.

Addressing counsel’s submission that apprentices should be exempt, the Court endorsed the High Court’s reasoning, emphasising that the 1995 U.P. SRTC exemption was expressly limited to the litigants in that case (paras 12-13 of the 1995 judgment). Consequently, unless the applicable recruitment rules themselves waive the examination requirement, apprentices must participate in the same process as other candidates.

The Court also found that its own remand order in 2001 explicitly directed the High Court to determine, post-rule analysis, whether a written test was obligatory. The High Court complied with that mandate, and its conclusion that a written examination is a “condition precedent” was therefore unassailable.

In light of these findings, the Court held that no ground existed to disturb the High Court’s decision.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

All impleadment and interlocutory applications stand dismissed as a consequence.

Implications: The decision reinforces that exemptions from written examinations granted in earlier judgments are not of general applicability. Apprentices seeking public-sector appointments in Uttar Pradesh must comply with the written-examination requirement when such a requirement is embedded in the relevant recruitment regulations. No new legal precedent has been set, but the ruling clarifies the limited scope of prior exemptions and upholds the primacy of statutory recruitment rules.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Santosh Kumar Tripathi And Others v. Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation And Others

    Aftab Alam, J.— This appeal by special leave is at the instance of a number of appellants who, more than eleven years ago, had done a term of apprenticeship in different trades with the Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board under the provisions of the Apprentices Act, 1961. On completion of the period of apprenticeship they claimed absorption as junior engineers and on different posts of operating staff on the basis of their apprentice training in the respective trades suitable for the posts.

    2. The Board did not accede to the appellants' claim and instead issued an advertisement on 17-10-1998 inviting applications for filling up the vacancies of junior engineers, sub-station officers, fitters, draftsman mechanical, machinists, lineman, plumbers, instrument mechanic, wireman, diesel mechanic, boiler operators, electricians and similar other posts. The appellants moved the Allahabad High Court seeking a direction in their favour and asking the Board to consider them for appointment on the respective posts relating to the different trades in which they had received training as apprentices, ignoring the age bar and giving them preference over the candidates who were not trained apprentices.

    3. Here, it may be noted that a three-Judge Bench of this Court had rendered the decision on 12-1-1995 in U.P SRTC v. U.P Parivahan Nigam Shishukhs Berozgar Sangh (1995) 2 SCC 1, (1995) 29 ATC 171, and in para 13 of the judgment it was observed as follows:

    “13. … We make it clear that while considering the cases of the trainees for giving employment in suitable posts, what has been laid down in the Service Regulations of the Corporation shall be followed, except that the trainees would not be required to appear in any written examination, if any provided by the Regulations.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    4. In 1998 when the appellants moved against the advertisement dated 17-10-1998, the issue was alive before the Allahabad High Court as to whether the exemption from appearing in any written examination as directed by this Court in U.P SRTC (1995) 2 SCC 1, (1995) 29 ATC 171 was of general application and would apply to all the apprentices for employment in all the different departments and organisations.

    5. The writ petition filed by the appellants was, therefore, tagged to another case being Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 23076 of 1998, Arvind Gautam v. State of U.P and the matter was referred for hearing before a Full Bench. The Full Bench took the view that the direction given in para 12 of the Supreme Court judgment in U.P SRTC (1995) 2 SCC 1, (1995) 29 ATC 171 was indeed of general application but the exemption from appearing in the written examination as directed in para 13 of the judgment was meant only for the persons who were before the Supreme Court in that appeal and to no others.

    6. The case of the appellants was also before the Full Bench and since no one appeared in support of the writ petition the Full Bench disposed it of on 27-5-1999 by passing the following order:

    “The case has been called out.
    Learned counsel for the petitioner is not present.
    The controversy involved in this petition is identical to the one raised in Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 23076 of 1998, Arvind Gautam v. State of U.P decided and disposed of by this Bench by the order of date.
    Thus, this writ petition also is decided and disposed of in terms of and subject to the decision of the date rendered in Arvind Gautam v. State of U.P”

    7. The appellants then came before this Court in Civil Appeals Nos. 1838-39 of 2001. In those appeals a three-Judge Bench of the Court upheld the Full Bench decision of the Allahabad High Court in Arvind Gautam and agreed that the exemption from appearing in the written examination allowed by the decision in U.P SRTC (1995) 2 SCC 1, (1995) 29 ATC 171 was only for the respondents in that case. The Court further held that the question whether or not the apprentices were required to appear in the written examination would depend upon the statutory rules and regulations governing the recruitments in question. The Court further held that in the case of the appellants the High Court had not examined the relevant rules concerning the recruitments to find out whether or not appearing in a written test, even for an apprentice, was essential to the selection process.

    8. This Court, accordingly, remitted the matter to the High Court vide judgment and order dated 14-3-2001 observing as follows:

    “Insofar as recruitment to different other posts are concerned, the High Court has not applied its mind to different provisions dealing with the matter of recruitment to different posts, and therefore in fitness of things, we think it appropriate to remit all the matters to the High Court where the High Court would go into the relevant provisions as well as the relevant advertisement for filling up of different posts and then decide the question as to whether in a given case the requirement of written examination is provided in any regulation so that even apprentices could be compelled to appear in the same or there is no such provision in which case apprentices may not be required to undertake the said examination, though they will have to undergo the process of selection otherwise. Without applying mind to the specific provision of the recruitment to different posts, the aforesaid problem cannot be solved. It is in these circumstances, we remit all the matters to the High Court for being reconsidered in the light of the observations made by us.”

    9. By the time the matter came up before the High Court for reconsideration another advertisement was issued in 2001 and vacancies were filled up on that basis. Further, following its unbundling and reorganisation the U.P State Electricity Board was replaced by the Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation. A Division Bench of the High Court hearing the writ petition on remand noted the developments taking place since the matter had first come before it and then, as directed by this Court, proceeded to diligently and very thoroughly examine the relevant rules and regulations concerning the recruitments in question.

    10. The High Court found that the recruitments were to be made under the U.P State Electricity Board (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1978 that defined “Commission” in Clause 2(ii) as the Electricity Service Commission, Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board. Clause (iii) of the Regulations provided that the Commission shall be consulted for different purposes, including direct recruitment to the posts of junior engineer, operating staff cadre, etc. Sub-clause (2) of clause 3 read as under:

    “3. (2) The Commission will examine, interview, select and recommend suitable candidates in accordance with the criteria prescribed in the relevant Regulations and if there are no Regulations in order of merit. Actual appointment orders will be issued by the appointing authority concerned.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    In the light of the above provision, the High Court took the view that the Recruitment Regulations provided for a written examination and hence, it was a condition precedent for all candidates, apprentices not excluded, to appear in the examination and to qualify for the appointment. Apart from the aforesaid provision the High Court also took into consideration a vast amount of other materials for coming to its conclusion.

    11. Mr Sunil Gupta, Senior Advocate, appearing for the appellants assailed the judgment of the High Court and submitted that the expression “examine” occurring in the Regulation could not have meant a written examination and not at least for the apprentices. The High Court has considered this submission in some detail and has rejected it giving reasons with which we are in full agreement.

    12. Mr Gupta also submitted that the judgment of the High Court coming under appeal was contrary to the spirit of the three-Judge Bench decision of this Court in U.P SRTC (1995) 2 SCC 1, (1995) 29 ATC 171 and it also overlooked the observations made in the remand order passed by this Court asking the High Court to reconsider the matter. We have heard Mr Gupta at some length but we are unable to accept his submissions.

    13. On hearing Mr Gupta and on going through the High Court judgment and the other materials on record, we find that the High Court has taken the correct view of the matter that does not call for any interference. There is no merit in this appeal and it is, accordingly, dismissed. Following the dismissal of the appeal, all the impleadment applications and other interlocutory applications, if any, stand dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Santosh Kumar Tripathi And Others v. Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation And Others
    (Jun 15, 2009)