AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Hyderabad District Court of Wards Act
  • Section 46 of Raidurg Paigah Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh under a registered sale deed dated 11-10-1996 does not contain any legislative act/article title.
  • Hyderabad Land Revenue Act
  • Registration and Stamps Act
  • Civil Procedure Code
  • Urban Land Ceiling Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Hyderabad District Court of Wards Act
  • Section 46 of Raidurg Paigah Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh under a registered sale deed dated 11-10-1996 does not contain any legislative act/article title.
  • Hyderabad Land Revenue Act
  • Registration and Stamps Act
  • Civil Procedure Code
  • Urban Land Ceiling Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant purchased 4 acres of agricultural land in Survey No. 46 of Raidurg Paigah Village, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh under a registered sale deed dated 11-10-1996. His chain of title traces back to Shri Waliullah Hussaini, who in turn derived title from his father, late Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini. After the latter’s death in 1923, the Court of Wards assumed custody of his private properties, including the land in question. A compromise in 1925 allotted the Raidurg lands to Shri Waliullah Hussaini, who subsequently obtained the shares of the remaining heirs and paid land revenue from 1950 onwards.

Meanwhile, a partition suit (CS No. 7 of 1958) was filed on the original side of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh by other heirs of the Hussaini estate. A preliminary decree dated 6-4-1959 excluded Items 230-254 (including Item 234—Raidurg) from partition because title to those items was under inquiry. In 2002, more than four decades later, certain legal representatives filed applications (Applications 1144–1147/2002) in CS No. 7/1958 seeking recognition of assignments and mutation of 143 acres of Raidurg land. A learned Single Judge allowed those applications on 9-10-2002 and, on 26-12-2003, passed a final decree (Application 1409/2003).

The appellant, a stranger to those proceedings, asserted that the 2003 final decree adversely affected his land. He filed an Original Side Appeal—OSA (SR) No. 1900 of 2005—before a Division Bench under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent. The High Court dismissed the appeal on 26-4-2005 as time-barred. The present matter is the appellant’s further appeal by special leave to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Division Bench of the High Court erred in dismissing OSA (SR) No. 1900 of 2005 as barred by limitation.
  2. Whether a stranger to CS No. 7/1958 can, by a Letters Patent Appeal, challenge the final decree passed therein.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Items 230-254, including Item 234 (Raidurg), were expressly excluded from partition in the 1959 preliminary decree; their inclusion in the 2003 final decree is unsustainable.
  • Being an aggrieved bona fide purchaser, the appellant became aware of the adverse orders only later and filed the OSA promptly thereafter; hence the delay should have been condoned.
  • The High Court’s refusal to entertain the appeal on limitation grounds deprived the appellant of an effective remedy against orders obtained without making the State Government a party and without proper inquiry.

Respondents' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents’ legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the record of CS No. 7/1958. It found that Shri Waliullah Hussaini—through whom the appellant claims title—was Defendant 41 in that suit, and that the suit against Defendants 27-49 (including Defendant 41) had been dismissed under Clause 14 of the preliminary decree recorded on 6-4-1959. Consequently, after the final decree was passed in 2003, any grievance of the appellant could not be addressed through a Letters Patent Appeal, because:

  • He was not a party to the proceedings culminating in the final decree.
  • The appropriate remedy would be a separate, independent proceeding to establish his title, not an appeal under Clause 15.
  • The Division Bench’s finding that the OSA was time-barred was supported by the absence of a satisfactory explanation for delay.

Given these factors, the Supreme Court concluded that the High Court rightly refused to entertain the time-barred appeal and that the appellant’s substantive claims regarding title and allotment should be pursued in a different forum.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s order dismissing OSA (SR) No. 1900 of 2005 on limitation grounds. It granted the appellant liberty to initiate separate proceedings to vindicate his grievances, explicitly refraining from expressing any opinion on the merits of such proceedings. No costs were awarded.

Implications are confined to the parties: the dismissal leaves the final decree of 26-12-2003 undisturbed, but the appellant remains free to seek relief in an independent suit or other appropriate forum. The judgment sets no new precedent beyond reiterating that non-parties to a decree must pursue separate remedies rather than appellate relief under the Letters Patent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M. Purnachander Rao v. Nawab Mazaharuddin Khan (Dead) Through Lrs. And Others

    P. Sathasivam, J.— Leave granted.

    2. This appeal is directed against the order dated 26-4-2005 of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in OSA (SR) No. 1900 of 2005 in and by which the Division Bench dismissed the said appeal on the ground of limitation. The appellant preferred OSA before the Division Bench of the High Court under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the order of the Single Judge dated 26-12-2003 in Application No. 1409 of 2003 in CS No. 7 of 1958.

    3. According to the appellant, he purchased an extent of 4 acres of agricultural land situated in Sy. No. 46 of Raidurg Paigah Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh under a registered sale deed dated 11-10-1996. The appellant's title flows from Shri Mala Ramulu and others who had purchased land under a registered sale deed dated 12-11-1962 from Shri Waliullah Hussaini. The said Shri Waliullah Hussaini derives title from his father late Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini. Late Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini was given four villages by the then Paigah under the Nizam rule somewhere in the beginning of the century.

    4. The said late Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini, who was the estate-holder, died in the year 1923. He was survived by his wife, three sons and four daughters. After his death, the Court of Wards (Revenue Department), constituted under the Hyderabad District Court of Wards Act, took custody of the property of late Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini. The Court of Wards will take custody of the property only if it is a private property. The land in Patta Raidurg was also taken over by the Court of Wards after the death of Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini.

    5. In 1925, there was a compromise between the legal heirs of late Shri Moulvi Syed Akbar Hussaini. The properties located in Yenkapally Maqta and Patta Raidurg were allotted to Shri Waliullah Hussaini and other sisters and brothers and Maqta Karimnagar was allotted to other members of the family. After the compromise, the other shareholders sold away their rights in favour of Waliullah Hussaini and two minors, namely, Shri Syed Akbar Nizamuddin and Shri Syed Aminuddin Hussaini, under registered sale deeds.

    6. It is the further claim of the appellant that the land in Raidurg Village is a patta land (private property). In view of the fact that Shri Waliullah Hussaini purchased other shareholders' rights over the property, except Shri Waliullah Hussaini no other person got any right. Shri Waliullah Hussaini paid land revenue from 1950 onwards and he sold the same in favour of the appellant's predecessors-in-title Shri Mala Ramulu and others after obtaining permission in the year 1962 as per the sale deed dated 12-11-1962. They, in turn, sold the property in favour of the appellant's vendors.

    7. It is the further case of the appellant that he is a bona fide purchaser of land to an extent of 4 acres in Survey No. 46 of Village Raidurg Paigah, District Ranga Reddy, Andhra Pradesh for valuable consideration under a registered sale deed in the year 1996.

    8. The civil suit was filed on the original side jurisdiction of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in CS No. 7 of 1958. The suit was filed by the legal heirs who are the sharers of the property belonging to the estate as “Asmanja Paigah”. A preliminary decree was passed on 6-4-1959 and in the list of properties shown in ‘A’ Schedule to the preliminary decree, Item 234 is shown as Raidurg and in the preliminary decree Items 230 to 254 have been excluded since the properties were under inquiry with the Board of Revenue as to the title and claim. Item 234 shown as Raidurg is also excluded from the distribution in the preliminary decree.

    9. The legal representatives in the year 2002, after a lapse of 43 years, filed applications bearing Nos. 1144 to 1147 of 2002 in CS No. 7 of 1958 claiming (1) recognition of the assignments in favour of Respondents 21 to 40; (2) impleadment of the respondents (assignees) as respondents; (3) direction to the Collector, RDO, MRO, to mutate the names of the assignees in the revenue records pertaining to Survey Nos. 37, 39 to 43 and 45 to 49 in all admeasuring 143 acres 11 guntas of land situated in Raidurg Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District; and (4) direction to the District Judge, Ranga Reddy to deliver possession of the above land to the assignees. Without any enquiry, the learned Single Judge, by order dated 9-10-2002, contrary to the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code and other enactments like the Urban Land Ceiling Act, the Registration and Stamps Act, the Hyderabad Land Revenue Act, etc. allowed those applications. The State Government which was a party in the preliminary decree dated 6-4-1959 was not made a party in the abovementioned applications filed in the year 2002. Thereafter another application was filed bearing No. 1409 of 2003 in CS No. 7 of 1958 for passing final decree and the same was allowed on 26-12-2003.

    10. The appellant is a stranger to the above proceedings.

    11. By virtue of the order passed as stated above, the respondents started interfering with the land purchased by the appellant, and coming to know about the above orders passed by the High Court and being aggrieved by the orders passed in Application No. 1409 of 2003, (the appellant) filed an appeal in OSA (SR) No. 1900 of 2005. By the impugned order, the Division Bench of the High Court sustaining the office objection with regard to the limitation in filing the appeal and finding that there is no satisfactory explanation, dismissed the appeal. Questioning the same, the appellant has filed the present appeal before this Court.

    12. We have heard Mr Anoop G. Chaudhari, Ms June Chaudhari, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and Mr Harish N. Salve, Mr R.F Nariman, Mr Arun Jaitely, Mr L.N Rao, learned Senior Counsel and other learned counsel for the respondents.

    13. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant, after taking us through the chequered history of the case and by drawing our attention to the various proceedings submitted that Items 230-54 which have been excluded in the preliminary decree and Item 234 being Raidurg land which is an excluded property, the action of the respondents in including the same in the final decree cannot be sustained. In such circumstances, according to him, the appellant is an aggrieved person and as soon as he came to know about the various orders including the last one, namely, the final decree, filed the original side appeal before the Division Bench of the High Court. He further contended that the High Court is not justified in dismissing the appeal on the ground of limitation.

    14. We have perused all the earlier proceedings as well as documents in respect of the property in question. It is not in dispute that the appellant, who purchased 4 acres of land by way of sale deed dated 11-10-2003 from his vendor, heavily relied his title to the same from Shri Waliullah Hussaini who was Defendant 41 in CS No. 7 of 1958 on the file of the High Court.

    15. It is relevant to point out that the appellant himself placed a memo of compromise which was filed and recorded in CS No. 7 of 1958. The copy of the decree in CS No. 7 of 1958 dated 6-4-1959 which is available on pp. 156-232 in the SLP paper book (Part II) filed as additional document by the appellant in this Court shows that the suit filed against Shri Waliullah Hussaini was dismissed. Clause 14 which is available at p. 198 of the said paper book reads as under:

    “That the plaintiff's suit against Defendants 27 to 49 be and is hereby dismissed.”

    16. It is not in dispute that Defendant 41 is Shri Waliullah Hussaini from whom the appellant claims title through various persons. In view of the same, the claim of the appellant that the very same property has been shown in the final decree and allotted to one of the sharers in spite of his possession for several decades, cannot be gone into by the High Court after passing a final decree even in the year 2003. Likewise, the allegation that though the lands in Items 232-54 in Schedule ‘A’ to preliminary decree concerning Defendants 2-12 and 14-22 stand excluded and however shown in the final decree dated 26-12-2003 which is in violation of the preliminary decree, cannot be agitated by filing an appeal before the High Court. We are of the view that the proper remedy for the appellant is to initiate a separate proceeding and the same cannot be questioned by way of a letters patent appeal before the High Court (sic by a person) who is not a party to the entire proceedings. In these circumstances, we refrain from considering various details projected before us.

    17. In the light of the above discussion, we agree with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court and dismiss the above appeal. However, the appellant is at liberty to initiate separate proceedings before the appropriate court to vindicate his grievance for which we express no opinion. With the above observation, the appeal is dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M. Purnachander Rao v. Nawab Mazaharuddin Khan (Dead) Through Lrs. And Others
    (Feb 11, 2008)