Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 302/34, 304/34, 201/34 and 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 302/34, 304/34, 201/34 and 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Four individuals—Gopal Sah, Dasrath Sah, Bhushan Sah and Raghunath Sah—were prosecuted before the Additional Sessions Judge, Saharsa for offences under Sections 302/34, 304/34, 201/34 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code. On 14 September 1985, the trial court convicted Gopal, Dasrath and Bhushan Sah of murder (Section 302/34) and sentenced each to life imprisonment, while acquitting Raghunath Sah.

The convicted persons appealed to the Patna High Court; the complainant filed a revision challenging Raghunath Sah’s acquittal. During the appellate proceedings Dasrath Sah died. The High Court nonetheless affirmed the convictions of the remaining three accused and dismissed the complainant’s revision.

Only Gopal Sah pursued a further appeal, resulting in the present proceeding. Bhushan Sah later sought special leave to appeal, but his petition was dismissed in limine for limitation and lack of merit.

As to the underlying incident, 18-year-old Gopal Prasad Gupta disappeared at about 6 p.m. on 7 June 1982. His body was discovered the next afternoon in a ditch near Village Chhekabadh. An FIR was lodged at 2:30 p.m. on 8 June 1982, naming several accused who had allegedly been seen with the deceased the preceding evening. Police investigations yielded a blood-stained axe and sickle, and certain articles were seized from the houses of the accused. The prosecution examined twenty-nine witnesses; there were no eyewitnesses.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the circumstantial evidence—comprising (a) an inferred “last-seen” circumstance, (b) an extra-judicial confession by co-accused Dasrath Sah, and (c) recovery of a sickle three months after the murder—was sufficient to sustain the conviction of Gopal Sah for murder.
  2. Whether dismissal in limine of co-accused Bhushan Sah’s special leave petition warranted dismissal of the present appeal on parity of reasoning.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The prosecution presented no direct or reliable circumstantial evidence linking Gopal Sah to the crime.
  • The sickle was recovered approximately three months after the incident; such a remote recovery lacks probative value.
  • The “last-seen” evidence implicated only Bhushan and Dasrath Sah; no witness identified the unidentified third person at the bridge as the appellant.
  • The extra-judicial confession of Dasrath Sah is inadmissible or, at best, a weak piece of evidence that cannot be used against a co-accused.

Respondent State’s Arguments

  • Because Bhushan Sah’s special leave petition was dismissed on the same evidentiary record, the present appeal should likewise fail.
  • The recovery of the sickle and the extra-judicial confession collectively established a complete chain of circumstances implicating the appellant.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court isolated three incriminating circumstances advanced by the prosecution: (i) the inference that the unidentified person seen urinating near the wooden bridge was the appellant, (ii) an extra-judicial confession by co-accused Dasrath Sah, and (iii) the recovery of a sickle said to be the murder weapon.

First, the Court held that a conviction cannot rest on mere inference; no witness actually identified the appellant as the third person near the bridge. Second, it reiterated that an extra-judicial confession is inherently weak and normally requires strong corroboration; moreover, such a confession, if credible at all, is admissible only against the maker, not a co-accused. Third, the sickle was recovered from a pond three months after the incident, rendering its evidentiary value “tenuous.”

The Court then addressed the State’s parity argument, noting that Bhushan Sah’s petition was dismissed in limine and that the evidence against Bhushan differed qualitatively and quantitatively from that against the appellant. Accordingly, the dismissal of Bhushan’s petition was not determinative of the present appeal.

Finding each of the three alleged circumstances unreliable, the Court concluded that the convictions recorded by the trial court and affirmed by the High Court were unsustainable insofar as they concerned Gopal Sah.

Holding and Implications

ACQUITTAL: The appeal is allowed and Gopal Sah is acquitted of all charges.

Immediate Effect: The appellant is to be released forthwith if not required in any other case. The decision affects only the appellant and sets no new legal precedent beyond reaffirming the cautious approach to extra-judicial confessions and weak circumstantial links.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gopal Sah v. State Of Bihar .

    H.S Bedi, J.— Four persons, Gopal Sah, Dasrath Sah, Bhushan Sah and Raghunath Sah were tried by the Additional Sessions Judge, Saharsa for offences punishable under Sections 302/34, 304/34, 201/34 and 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860. The trial court in its judgment dated 14-9-1985 held the first three accused guilty of the offence under Sections 302/34 IPC and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for life whereas Raghunath Sah was acquitted.

    2. Two appeals were thereafter filed by the convicted accused before the Patna High Court whereas the complainant also filed a revision against the acquittal of Raghunath Sah. During the pendency of the appeal in the High Court, Dasrath Sah died. The High Court, however, upheld the trial court judgment with respect to the three accused.

    3. Gopal Sah, accused then filed the present criminal appeal challenging his conviction and the matter has been put up for final hearing before us. Bhushan Sah subsequently filed a special leave petition in this Court as well, but it is the admitted position that this matter has been dismissed by this Court on the ground of limitation as well as having no merit.

    4. The prosecution story is as under: Gopal Prasad Gupta, deceased aged about 18 years went out of his house at about 6 p.m on 7-6-1982 and when he did not return till dinner time, his family members went in search for him but he could not be found. The search continued the next morning as well though without success.

    5. At about 2 p.m on 8-6-1982 Murtaza Khan, PW 22 informed the family that Gopal Prasad Gupta's dead body was lying in a ditch near Village Chhekabadh on which PW 20 Jagdish Prasad Gupta, the uncle of the deceased lodged an FIR at about 2.30 p.m stating, inter alia, that at about 6 p.m on 7-6-1982 the deceased had been seen with Raghunath Sah and his son, Bhushan Sah near the wooden bridge.

    6. During the course of the investigation, the accused were arrested and on their disclosure statements, a bloodstained axe and a sickle allegedly used in the murder on 8-9-1982 were recovered from a water filled pond. The police also conducted a raid at the houses of the four accused and a bloodstained ganji, a spade and a bucket were recovered from the house of Bhushan Sah and Raghunath Sah. The statement of Dasrath Sah was also recorded under Section 164 CrPC by Judicial Magistrate B.K Singh, PW 11. On the completion of the investigation, the accused were charged as already indicated above.

    7. The prosecution examined twenty-nine witnesses in all to support the circumstances appearing against the accused, as admittedly there was no eyewitness to the murder. PW 1, Nageshwari Devi, the mother of the deceased deposed that on the relevant day her son had been taken away by Bhushan Sah for a walk and he had thereafter not returned. PW 3, Shivnath Sahu stated that he had seen Gopal Sah, the present appellant, in the orchard of Jai Narayan Sah carrying a sickle in his hand on the date of the incident. PW 4, Sofil Khan and PW 6, Digamber Mandal testified that they had seen Raghunath Sah carrying a spade and a bucket in his hand moving away hurriedly whereas PW 5, Mohd. Nadaf stated further that he had seen the three accused (Gopal Sah, Dasrath Sah and Bhushan Sah) moving away in a disturbed state of mind. PW 8, Kameshwar Choudhary too corroborated this statement and further added that he had seen the deceased along with Bhushan Sah and Dasrath Sah near the wooden bridge and a third person whom he could not identify, was urinating close by. He stated that man was not Gobind Gupta, a cousin of the deceased, who too, at one time, was suspected of the murder. PW 17, Lakhan Sah further stated that he had seen Gopal Parsad Gupta sitting near the bridge at about sunset with Bhushan Sah and Dasrath Sah, accused. The recoveries of the axe, sickle and other articles were sought to be proved by the evidence of PW 9, Satyadeo Singh and PW 12, Mohd. Arif. The prosecution also produced in evidence PW 16, Birendra Maharaj and PW 19, Jagannath Choudhary to whom Dasrath, accused had allegedly made an extra-judicial confession of the involvement of all the accused in the murder.

    8. The trial court in its judgment held that the evidence of PW 1, the mother of the deceased to the effect that the deceased had gone with Bhushan Sah on the evening of 7-6-1982 could not be relied upon in the light of the evidence of PW 21, Binod Kumar, who stated that the deceased had gone with him on his cycle up to the water tank. The trial court also refused to rely on the confession made under Section 164 CrPC by Dasrath, as it had not been recorded by following the correct procedure the more so as Dasrath Sah in the course of the trial had alleged that it had been made by him under coercion. The trial court then went on to examine the other evidence.

    9. The trial court concluded that from the evidence of PW 22 Murtaza Khan it had been established that the dead body of the deceased clad only in a ganji had been found near the orchard on 8-6-1982 at about 2 p.m The trial court relied upon the extra-judicial confession made by Dasrath Sah and on the recovery of the sickle made at the instance of Gopal Sah and found corroboration from the fact that he had been seen rushing away from the place of incident. The trial court concluded that the evidence supported the view that Bhushan Sah and Dasrath Sah had been seen near the bridge at about 6 p.m on 7-6-1982 whereas one unidentified person was urinating close by who could be Gopal Sah, appellant. The court also accepted the story that Bhushan Sah and Gopal Sah had disclosed to the police on 9-6-1982 that they had thrown an axe and a sickle in the pond and the axe had been recovered on that day whereas the sickle had been recovered three months thereafter.

    10. The High Court in appeal upheld the judgment of the trial court and dismissed both the appeals as well as the criminal revision filed by the complainant. As already mentioned, the present appeal has been filed at the instance of Gopal Sah alone; and the special leave petition filed by Bhushan Sah has been dismissed on the ground of limitation as well as on merits.

    11. The learned counsel for the appellant has raised several arguments during the course of the hearing. It has been pointed out that there was absolutely no evidence to connect Gopal Sah with the crime, as the recovery of the sickle made in September 1982 i.e about three months after the incident was too remote a factor. It has also been pleaded that the evidence of last seen pertained only to Bhushan Sah and Dasrath Sah, accused, as the third person with them near the wooden bridge had not been identified as being Gopal Sah by any of the witnesses. It has further been pleaded that the extra-judicial confession allegedly made by Dasrath Sah could not be used as evidence against the other accused and that in any case this evidence too was unbelievable.

    12. The learned counsel for the respondent State has, however, argued that the appeal of Bhushan Sah having been dismissed on the same evidence, the present appeal too was liable to dismissal on that basis. He has also pointed out that the recovery of the sickle and the statement of Dasrath Sah which was to be taken as an extra-judicial confession completed the chain of events involving Gopal Sah in the murder.

    13. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone through the record. Admittedly, there are three main incriminating circumstances against the accused. The first piece of evidence is the suggestion that the third person who was urinating close by the bridge was Gopal Sah, the second the extra-judicial confession made by Dasrath Sah and the third the recovery of alleged murder weapon, a sickle. We are of the opinion that this evidence is, to say the least, unacceptable. It has come in the statement of PW 8 Kameshwar Choudhary that he had seen Dasrath Sah along with the deceased near the bridge and that another person was urinating close by. It is the suggestion and inference that this person was Gopal Sah. We are, however, of the opinion that there can be no conviction on inferences to be drawn from the prosecution evidence, more particularly as there is absolutely no evidence to suggest that the third person was indeed Gopal Sah, appellant. We find that in this situation the statement of PW 5 Mohd. Nadaf that he had seen the three convicted accused moving swiftly away from the direction of the site of the murder at about 7.30 p.m or that he had seen the appellant Gopal Sah with a sickle in hand is hardly sufficient to hold him guilty of murder.

    14. We are, further, of the opinion that an extra-judicial confession is, on the face of it, a weak piece of evidence and the courts are reluctant in the absence of a chain of cogent circumstances to rely on this evidence for the purpose of recording a conviction. In any case, we find that the confession made by Dasrath Sah can, if at all, be used against him and not against his co-accused. The statement of the investigating officer with respect to the place where the two murder weapons had been allegedly thrown makes the recovery itself tenuous. Moreover, as the sickle allegedly in the hands of Gopal Sah had been recovered from a pond three months after the murder, no evidentiary value whatsoever can be attached to this circumstance as well.

    15. The argument of the State counsel that as the appeal of Bhushan Sah had been dismissed on merits, the appeal of Gopal Sah must meet the same fate must now be examined. We observe that Bhushan Sah's appeal had been dismissed in limine on the ground of limitation as also on merit but we have chosen to hear the present appeal after leave had been granted by this Court long before Bhushan's special leave petition had been filed. We, even otherwise, are of the opinion that the evidence involving Bhushan Sah is qualitatively and quantitatively different from the evidence against Gopal Sah, as would be apparent from the circumstances noted above, not only with respect to the last seen but also relating to the recovery of various items from his house which could be said to be relatable to the murder. We must, therefore, conclude that the dismissal of the special leave petition of Bhushan Sah in limine, would not by itself be a ground to dismiss the appeal of Gopal Sah.

    16. For the reasons stated above, we find the judgment of the trial court and the High Court insofar as Gopal Sah is concerned to be unsustainable. He is accordingly acquitted of all charges. The appeal is allowed in the above terms.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gopal Sah v. State Of Bihar .
    (Dec 3, 2008)