AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2008 INSC 852
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 406, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • CrPC (Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2008 INSC 852
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 406, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • CrPC (Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973)
Smart Summary

Supreme Court of India – Case Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is an accused in a criminal case originally registered by Vishnu Kanchi Police Station, Tamil Nadu. After investigation, a final report was filed on 21-1-2005 and the matter was committed to the Court of the Principal Sessions Judge, Chinglepet as Sessions Case No. 197 of 2005.

Invoking Section 406 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), the appellant sought transfer of the trial outside Tamil Nadu, alleging that he would not receive a fair trial there. In Jayendra Saraswathy Swamigal (II) v. State of T.N. (2005) 8 SCC 771, the Supreme Court accepted that apprehension and transferred the case to the Court of the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Pondicherry, where it was renumbered as Sessions Case No. 94 of 2005.

On 25-11-2005, the Home Department of Tamil Nadu appointed one Special Public Prosecutor and four Additional Special Public Prosecutors to conduct the trial in Pondicherry. The appellant challenged this appointment before the Principal Sessions Judge, Pondicherry, arguing that only the Government of Pondicherry could appoint prosecutors for a trial within its territorial jurisdiction. The Sessions Court (order dated 25-1-2006) and subsequently the Madras High Court upheld Tamil Nadu’s appointments.

The present appeal challenges the concurrent orders of the Sessions Court and High Court that had recognised the authority of Tamil Nadu to appoint the prosecuting team.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after a criminal case is transferred from one State to another under Section 406 CrPC, the transferor State (Tamil Nadu) retains the power under Section 24 CrPC to appoint a Public Prosecutor/Special Public Prosecutor for the trial in the transferee State (Pondicherry).
  2. In the absence of any specific direction in the transfer order, which State Government is legally empowered to appoint the prosecuting counsel for the transferred trial?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Under the scheme of Section 24 CrPC, the State Government where the court is situated has exclusive authority to appoint the Public Prosecutor or Special Public Prosecutor.
  • Because the trial is now pending before a court in Pondicherry, only the Government of Pondicherry can make such appointments; Tamil Nadu’s appointments are ultra vires.

Respondent (Tamil Nadu) Arguments

  • The Supreme Court’s earlier transfer order did not forbid Tamil Nadu from appointing prosecutors; therefore its authority remains intact.
  • The offence was committed in Tamil Nadu and is an offence “against the State of Tamil Nadu”; accordingly, Tamil Nadu should control the prosecution unless expressly directed otherwise.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jayendra Saraswathy Swamigal (II) v. State of T.N. (2005) 8 SCC 771 The Supreme Court may transfer a criminal trial to another State when there is a reasonable apprehension of denial of fair trial. Recalled to show that the present case was transferred to Pondicherry precisely because actions of the Tamil Nadu prosecution created apprehension of injustice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a textual analysis of Chapter II CrPC, emphasising Sections 6, 7, 9 and especially Section 24, which governs the appointment of Public Prosecutors. Key points in the reasoning include:

  • A State Government’s authority to appoint a Public Prosecutor or Special Public Prosecutor is limited to “any prosecution, appeal or other proceeding” in courts within that State. Once a case is transferred out of the State, that power does not travel with the case.
  • The Supreme Court, when exercising power under Section 406 CrPC, can expressly designate which State is to appoint the prosecutor, but where the order is silent the default statutory regime under Section 24 prevails.
  • The very purpose of transferring this case to Pondicherry was to alleviate the accused’s apprehension of bias arising from the Tamil Nadu prosecuting agency. Permitting Tamil Nadu to prosecute the case would undermine that objective.
  • Even the special provision for appointing a Special Public Prosecutor is exercisable by “the Central Government or the State Government” where the trial is held—in this instance, Pondicherry.
  • While prosecutorial control shifts to Pondicherry, the Court directed that Tamil Nadu bear the expenses because the offence was initially investigated by its police and it remains the “concerned State”.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is ALLOWED; the orders of the Sessions Court, Pondicherry, and the Madras High Court upholding the appointment of prosecutors by the State of Tamil Nadu are set aside. The State of Pondicherry is directed to appoint the Public Prosecutor or Special Public Prosecutor for Sessions Case No. 94 of 2005. Tamil Nadu shall bear the costs associated with such appointment.

Implications: The judgment clarifies that, absent an express direction to the contrary, prosecutorial appointments under Section 24 CrPC must be made by the State in which the transferee court is located after a transfer under Section 406 CrPC. It reinforces the principle that a transfer aimed at ensuring a fair trial includes transferring control over the prosecution’s conduct, while allowing the transferor State to defray the financial burden.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Jayendra Saraswati Swamigal Alias Subramaniam v. State Of Tamil Nadu .

    K.G Balakrishnan, C.J— Leave granted.

    2. The appellant herein is one of the accused in a crime registered by Vishnu Kanchi Police Station at Tamil Nadu. The police after investigation filed final report on 21-1-2005 and the case was committed to the Principal Sessions Judge, Chinglepet and was registered as Sessions Case No. 197 of 2005. The appellant then moved this Court under Section 406 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”) seeking transfer of the case to any other State. The appellant alleged in the transfer petition that he was being unnecessarily harassed by the State of Tamil Nadu and that he would not get a fair trial.

    3. This Court in Jayendra Saraswathy Swamigal (II) v. State of T.N (2005) 8 SCC 771 considered the matter in detail and reached the following conclusion in para 24 of the judgment:

    “24. Taking into consideration the entire facts and circumstances of the case and the material on record, we have no hesitation in holding that the petitioner and other co-accused of the case have a reasonable apprehension that they will not get justice in the State of Tamil Nadu. We would like to clarify here that we are casting no reflection on the district judiciary in the State of Tamil Nadu. But it is the actions of the prosecuting agency and the State machinery, which are responsible for creating a reasonable apprehension in the mind of the petitioner and other co-accused that they will not get justice if the trial is held in any place inside the State of Tamil Nadu. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the interest of justice requires that the trial may be transferred to a place outside the State of Tamil Nadu.”

    Thus, Sessions Case No. 197 of 2005, pending before the Principal Sessions Judge, Chinglepet, was transferred to the Court of the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Pondicherry and was numbered as Sessions Case No. 94 of 2005.

    4. The Home Department of the State of Tamil Nadu on 25-11-2005 appointed one Special Public Prosecutor and four Additional Special Public Prosecutors for conducting the trial of the sessions case pending before the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Pondicherry. The appellant herein filed a petition before the Sessions Court challenging the appointment of the Public Prosecutors by the State of Tamil Nadu and contended that the Special Public Prosecutor appointed by the State of Tamil Nadu has no right to conduct the prosecution of the sessions case pending before the Pondicherry Court, outside the State of Tamil Nadu. The Principal Sessions Judge, Pondicherry, by an order dated 25-1-2006, held that under Section 24 CrPC the State of Tamil Nadu has the power to appoint the Special Public Prosecutor for conducting the trial of the case and the State had not lost its right to appoint the Public Prosecutor, merely on account of transfer of the case to the Sessions Court at Pondicherry. The court also noticed the fact that this Court, while transferring the sessions case at Pondicherry, had not specifically directed that the State of Tamil Nadu shall not appoint a Public Prosecutor to conduct the case.

    5. The appellant preferred a revision petition challenging the order passed by the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Pondicherry. The High Court of Madras confirmed the decision of the Sessions Court and held that the offence had been committed within the State of Tamil Nadu, the investigation was done by Tamil Nadu Police and the committal proceedings had also taken place in the court at Tamil Nadu and hence the Government of Tamil Nadu had the domain over that sessions case and unless this Court, considering the special circumstances, directs in a particular case, appointment of a Special Public Prosecutor by the State to which the case has been transferred in the interest of justice, the transferee State cannot normally venture to appoint any Special Public Prosecutor to handle the case which it received as per the orders of this Court. The High Court was also of the view that it would be unjust to direct the transferee State Government to open the purse strings to meet out the expenditure for the appointment of a Special Public Prosecutor.

    6. The appellant has challenged the order passed by the Sessions Court as well as the High Court by which the Special Public Prosecutor and the Additional Special Public Prosecutors were appointed to conduct the trial of the case.

    7. We heard the counsel for the appellant as well as counsel for the State of Tamil Nadu. The counsel for the appellant contended that the appointment of the Public Prosecutor is to be made by the State as per the procedure prescribed under Section 24 CrPC. It is pointed out that the Government of Pondicherry has total authority to appoint a Public Prosecutor or Additional Prosecutor or a Special Public Prosecutor to conduct a criminal case pending before any of the sessions divisions of the State of Pondicherry which was formerly a Union Territory, now being a separate State and the Tamil Nadu Government has no right to appoint any prosecutor—either a Public Prosecutor or a Special Public Prosecutor—to conduct a trial of a case pending before the Principal Sessions Judge, Pondicherry.

    8. The counsel for the respondent on the other hand contended that this Court while ordering the case transfer to the State of Pondicherry had not specifically directed that trial should be conducted by the Prosecutor appointed by the Government of Pondicherry and therefore, the State of Tamil Nadu has got the authority to appoint a Public Prosecutor to conduct the trial of such a case. It was argued that the incident had taken place in the State of Tamil Nadu and that being an offence committed against the State of Tamil Nadu that State alone could appoint the Public Prosecutor to conduct the prosecution of the case unless specifically directed otherwise by this Court while transferring the case under Section 406 CrPC.

    9. For the purpose of understanding the scheme of appointment of a Public Prosecutor to conduct the trial it is necessary to look into various provisions of Chapter II CrPC. Section 6 CrPC prescribes that in every State there shall be following classes of criminal courts: Courts of Session, Judicial Magistrates of the First Class (and in any metropolitan area, Metropolitan Magistrates), Judicial Magistrates of the Second Class and Executive Magistrates. Section 7(1) prescribes that every State shall have a sessions division or shall consist of several sessions divisions and every sessions division shall, for the purposes of the Code, be a district or consist of districts. It also prescribes that every metropolitan area shall be a separate sessions division and district. Sub-section (2) provides that the State may alter the limits of such divisions and districts after consultation with the High Court.

    10. Section 9 requires that the State Government shall establish a Court of Session for every sessions division, and every Court of Session shall be presided over by a Judge to be appointed by the High Court. Section 10 deals with the constitution of the Courts of Assistant Sessions Judge and Section 11 deals with the constitution of the Courts of Judicial Magistrates. Section 12 deals with the appointment of Chief Judicial Magistrate and Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate. Sections 16, 17 and 18 deal with the constitution of the various Metropolitan Magistrates' Courts and Section 20 deals with the appointment of Executive Magistrates. Section 24 deals with the appointment of Public Prosecutors. “Public Prosecutor” has been defined under Section 2(u) CrPC:

    “2. (u) ‘Public Prosecutor’ means any person appointed under Section 24, and includes any person acting under the directions of a Public Prosecutor;

    11. Section 24(1) deals with the appointment of Public Prosecutor or Additional Public Prosecutor for conducting any prosecution, appeal or other proceedings on behalf of the Central Government or State Government in the High Court. Sub-section (3) of Section 24 requires that for every district, the State Government shall appoint a Public Prosecutor and one or more Additional Public Prosecutors. Sub-sections (3) to (7) deal with the appointment of Public Prosecutor and Additional Public Prosecutor for the district. The power of appointment is given to the State Government and such appointment should be from a panel of names prepared by the District Magistrate in consultation with the Sessions Judge. Sub-section (7) of Section 24 provides that a person shall be eligible to be appointed as a Public Prosecutor or as an Additional Public Prosecutor under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) or sub-section (3) or sub-section (6) only if he has been in practice as an advocate for not less than seven years. A conjoint reading of all these provisions would clearly show that the State Government has the power of appointment of Public Prosecutor or Additional Public Prosecutor for each district or Court of Session in the sessions division in the State to conduct any prosecution, appeal or other proceedings pending before the courts in that State. The power of the State Government to appoint a Public Prosecutor and Additional Public Prosecutor would extend only for conducting any prosecution, appeal or other proceedings in the courts within the State.

    12. As per the procedure prescribed under Section 24, the State of Tamil Nadu can appoint a Public Prosecutor to conduct criminal cases in any of the court in that State. Such powers cannot be exercised by the State Government to conduct cases in any other State. Once the case is transferred as per Section 406 CrPC to another State, the transferor State no longer has control over the prosecution to be conducted in a court situated in a different State to which the case has been transferred. It is the prerogative of the State Government to appoint a Public Prosecutor to conduct the case which is pending in the sessions division of that State.

    13*. Of course, this Court while passing order of transfer, can give an appropriate direction as to which State should appoint the Public Prosecutor to conduct that particular case. Such orders are passed having regard to the circumstances of the case and the grounds on which the transfer has been effected. This Court can certainly give directions irrespective of the provisions contained in Section 24 CrPC. But so far as this case is concerned, nothing had been stated in the order of the transfer. The provisions contained in Section 24 CrPC shall prevail and it is for the appropriate State Government within whose area the trial is conducted to appoint Public Prosecutor under sub-sections (3) to (7) of Section 24 CrPC.

    14. Sub-section (8) of Section 24 CrPC is a special provision regarding the appointment of a Special Prosecutor. This power can be exercised by the Central Government and the State Government for the purpose of any case or class of cases, and a person who has been in practice as an advocate for not less than ten years may be appointed as a Special Public Prosecutor. These powers are also to be exercised by the State Government of the transferee court where the sessions case is pending. Of course, the transferee State can appoint any person having qualification prescribed under sub-section (8) of Section 24 CrPC.

    15. The purpose of transfer of the criminal case from one State to another is to ensure fair trial to the accused. In this case, the main ground on which the transfer of the sessions case was ordered from the Sessions Court of Chinglepet in Tamil Nadu to the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Pondicherry, was that the action of the prosecution agency had created a reasonable apprehension in the mind of the appellant-accused that he would not get justice if the trial was held in the State of Tamil Nadu.

    16. The Public Prosecutor plays a key role during trial of a sessions case. Though the Sessions Judge has got a supervising control over the entire trial of the case, it is the Public Prosecutor who decides who are the witnesses to be examined on the side of the prosecution and which witness is to be given up, or which witness is to be recalled for further examination. For proper conduct of a criminal case the Public Prosecutor plays a vital role. It may also be noticed herein that under Section 225 CrPC during every trial before the Court of Session, the prosecution shall be conducted by the Public Prosecutor and as regards withdrawal also, the Public Prosecutor in charge of the case has to make the application for withdrawal of prosecution as per Section 321 CrPC. In case of acquittal of the accused the State Government may direct the Public Prosecutor to file an appeal.

    17. As is evident from various provisions of CrPC, the State Government of Tamil Nadu can only appoint a Public Prosecutor or an Additional Public Prosecutor or a Special Public Prosecutor under Section 24 CrPC to conduct the prosecution and appeal, or other proceeding in any criminal courts in respect of any case pending before the courts of Tamil Nadu and in respect of any case pending before the courts at Pondicherry, the State Government of Pondicherry is the appropriate Government to appoint Public Prosecutor, Additional Public Prosecutor or Special Public Prosecutor.

    18. However, we make it clear that the State of Pondicherry can appoint any counsel as Public Prosecutor having requisite qualifications as prescribed under sub-section (8) of Section 24 CrPC whether he is a lawyer in the State of Pondicherry or any other State. As it is a criminal case registered by the State of Tamil Nadu the expenses for conducting the trial are to be borne by the State of Tamil Nadu. The advocate's fees payable to the Public Prosecutor, Additional Public Prosecutor or Special Public Prosecutor by the State of Pondicherry shall be borne by the State of Tamil Nadu and the Home Departments of the two States may undertake consultations with each other and an appropriate decision may be taken by the authorities concerned in this regard.

    19. We set aside the impugned order passed by the High Court and direct that the State of Pondicherry may continue with the prosecution of the case in accordance with the law and the Public Prosecutor or Special Public Prosecutor may be appointed by the State of Pondicherry to conduct the criminal proceedings in respect of Sessions Case No. 94 of 2005 pending before the Principal and Sessions Judge of Pondicherry.

    20. The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jayendra Saraswati Swamigal Alias Subramaniam v. State Of Tamil Nadu .
    (Jul 22, 2008)