Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 776
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 776
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Land Acquisition Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Santanu Chaudhuri (landlord) instituted an eviction suit against his tenant, Subir Ghosh, before the Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), 9th Court, Alipore. The trial court dismissed the suit, but a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court reversed that decision on 25 August 2005 and decreed eviction.

Subir Ghosh challenged the High Court decree by filing SLP (C) No. 21766 of 2005 in the Supreme Court. On 13 February 2006 the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP but, on agreement of counsel, granted the tenant time until 31 August 2006 to vacate the premises, subject to his filing “the usual affidavit by way of undertaking” within two weeks.

No undertaking was filed and the tenant did not vacate. On 5 January 2007 the landlord filed the present petition seeking initiation of contempt proceedings. Notice issued, and both sides filed affidavits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenant’s failure to vacate the premises in the absence of any filed undertaking amounts to civil contempt of the Supreme Court’s order dated 13 February 2006.
  2. Whether, notwithstanding the absence of an undertaking, the Supreme Court can enforce its earlier order by directing delivery of possession to the landlord through the trial court.

Arguments of the Parties

Tenant (Subir Ghosh)

  • No contempt lies because no undertaking, as contemplated by the Court’s order, was ever filed; hence no breach of an undertaking occurred.
  • The landlord’s remedy is to execute the eviction decree, not to invoke the Court’s contempt jurisdiction.
  • Relied on Rita Markandey v. Surjit Singh Arora (1996) 6 SCC 14; R.N. Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik (2000) 4 SCC 400; and Anil K. Surana v. State Bank of Hyderabad (2007) 10 SCC 257.

Landlord (Santanu Chaudhuri)

  • Even without a formal undertaking, the Court has inherent power to ensure that its orders are not frustrated and to secure delivery of possession.
  • Relied on Firm Ganpat Ram Rajkumar v. Kalu Ram 1989 Supp (2) SCC 418; Ram Pyari v. Jagdish Lal (1992) 1 SCC 157; and Zahurul Islam v. Abul Kalam 1995 Supp (1) SCC 464, where the Court directed eviction when tenants failed to honour similar conditions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rita Markandey v. Surjit Singh Arora (1996) 6 SCC 14 No contempt if no undertaking is filed; contempt may still lie if court acted on false representation. Cited by tenant to argue absence of undertaking negates contempt liability.
R.N. Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik (2000) 4 SCC 400 Contempt jurisdiction should not be used to execute decrees. Cited by tenant; Court held it inapplicable to landlord-tenant eviction context.
Anil K. Surana v. State Bank of Hyderabad (2007) 10 SCC 257 When consent decree exists and no undertaking is filed, remedy lies in execution. Cited by tenant; Court distinguished on facts.
Firm Ganpat Ram Rajkumar v. Kalu Ram 1989 Supp (2) SCC 418 Court may ensure compliance with its orders and direct delivery of possession even without undertaking. Formed part of the ratio relied on by the Court to grant enforcement relief.
Ram Pyari v. Jagdish Lal (1992) 1 SCC 157 Similar eviction situation; Court ordered delivery of possession despite no undertaking. Followed; guided the Court’s direction to trial court.
Zahurul Islam v. Abul Kalam 1995 Supp (1) SCC 464 Court should ensure its order is not frustrated; delivery of possession can be directed. Followed; reinforced power to secure landlord’s possession.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged that, strictly speaking, no undertaking had been given; therefore, applying the ratio in Rita Markandey, civil contempt was not technically made out. However, relying on the trilogy of Firm Ganpat Ram Rajkumar, Ram Pyari, and Zahurul Islam, the Court emphasised its duty to prevent its earlier order of 13 February 2006 from being rendered nugatory.

It reasoned that allowing the tenant to remain would undermine the efficacy of its dismissal of the SLP and the time-bound direction to vacate. Consequently, even if contempt sanctions were unavailable, the Court could issue directions to ensure enforcement of its prior order and the subsisting eviction decree.

Accordingly, the Court:

  • Directed the trial court to deliver vacant possession to the landlord within one month of presentation of the certified copy of the order, using police assistance if necessary.
  • Clarified that the landlord remained free to pursue rent and mesne profits in accordance with law.
  • Awarded Rs 50,000 costs against the tenant, to be deposited within one month, failing which the trial court was empowered to recover the amount.

Holding and Implications

Contempt Petition Dismissed – no civil contempt established because no undertaking had been filed.

Enforcement Direction Issued – the trial court is ordered to evict the tenant and hand over possession to the landlord within one month, with police assistance if necessary, and to ensure recovery of Rs 50,000 costs.

Implications: The decision reinforces the Supreme Court’s power to protect the integrity of its orders even when contempt is not formally proved. While setting no new precedent, it confirms that the Court may bypass execution delays and compel delivery of possession to prevent frustration of its judgments.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Santanu Chaudhuri v. Subir Ghosh .

    G.P Mathur, J.— This petition has been filed by the landlord, Santanu Chaudhuri for initiating contempt proceedings against the tenant, Subir Ghosh.

    2. The petitioner Santanu Chaudhuri filed a suit for eviction against Subir Ghosh in the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), 9th Court, Alipore, which was dismissed. The appeal filed by the petitioner was allowed by a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court and a decree for eviction was passed against the respondent Subir Ghosh (the tenant) on 25-8-2005. Subir Ghosh then filed Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 21766 of 2005 in this Court. The petitioner Santanu Chaudhuri (the landlord) also put in appearance on caveat. The special leave petition was dismissed on 13-2-2006 and the following order was passed:

    “The special leave petition is dismissed.
    Counsel for the petitioner prays for six months' time to vacate the premises. Counsel for the respondent present on caveat is agreeable to the same. Accordingly, the petitioner is granted time to vacate the suit premises by 31st August, 2006 subject to filing the usual affidavit by way of undertaking within two weeks from today. An advance copy of the affidavit will be supplied to the counsel for the respondent.”

    3. The present contempt petition has been filed on the ground that the time granted by this Court to vacate the premises expired on 31-8-2006, but the tenant has not yet vacated the premises. Notice was issued on the contempt petition on 5-1-2007. Subir Ghosh (the tenant) has filed a counter-affidavit in reply to the contempt petition and the main ground taken therein is that he did not file any affidavit or undertaking as was directed in the order dated 13-2-2006 and in absence of any undertaking having been filed, it cannot be said that disobedience of any order of this Court has been committed. It has been further submitted that as no affidavit or undertaking had been filed, it was open to the landlord to execute the decree forthwith and there is no occasion for initiating contempt proceedings against him.

    4. Shri Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel for the tenant Subir Ghosh has placed strong reliance on Rita Markandey v. Surjit Singh Arora (1996) 6 SCC 14 in support of his submission that no contempt has been committed by his client. In the said case it was held as under:(g-15b)

    “If any party gives an undertaking to the court to vacate the premises from which he is liable to be evicted under the orders of the court and there is a clear and deliberate breach thereof it amounts to civil contempt but since, in the present case, the respondent did not file any undertaking as envisaged in the order of the Supreme Court the question of his being punished for breach thereof does not arise. However, even in a case where no such undertaking is given, a party to a litigation may be held liable for such contempt if the court is induced to sanction a particular course of action or inaction on the basis of the representation of such a party and the court ultimately finds that the party never intended to act on such representation or such representation was false. In other words, if on the representation of the respondent herein the Court was persuaded to pass the order extending the time for vacation of the suit premises, he may be held guilty of contempt of court, notwithstanding non-furnishing of the undertaking, if it is found that the representation was false and the respondent never intended to act upon it. However, the respondent herein cannot be held liable for contempt on this score also for the order in question clearly indicates that it was passed on the basis of the agreement between the parties and not on the representation of the respondent made before the Court. It was the petitioner who agreed to the unconditional extension of time by four weeks for the respondent to vacate and subsequent extension of time on his giving an undertaking and the Court only embodied the terms of the agreement so arrived at, in the order. Therefore, the respondent cannot in any way be held liable for contempt for alleged breach of the above order.”

    5. Learned counsel has also referred to R.N Dey v. Bhagyabati Pramanik (2000) 4 SCC 400 wherein it was held that weapon of contempt cannot be used for purposes of executing a decree or implementing an order for which law provides appropriate procedure. This case, in our opinion, has no application as it related to award of compensation under the Land Acquisition Act, wherein it was subsequently revealed that the landowners, who had applied for compensation and had succeeded in its enhancement from the Reference Court, had in fact no title to the land acquired as the land already stood vested in the State. The next case relied upon by Shri Mukul Rohatgi is Anil K. Surana v. State Bank of Hyderabad (2007) 10 SCC 257, (2003) 10 Scale 580 which is a case relating to repayment of loan of a bank and on the finding that no undertaking had been given, it was held that by the consent of the parties an executable decree had been passed in favour of the bank and the remedy lay in execution of the decree.

    6. Shri Arun Jaitley, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner Santanu Chaudhuri (the landlord) has, on the other hand, placed strong reliance on Ram Pyari v. Jagdish Lal (1992) 1 SCC 157 wherein the special leave petition was dismissed but it was directed that the order of eviction shall not be executed before three months on the condition that the tenant filed an undertaking within three weeks. The tenant, however, neither filed any undertaking nor handed over vacant possession. Placing reliance upon an earlier decision rendered in Firm Ganpat Ram Rajkumar v. Kalu Ram 1989 Supp (2) SCC 418, AIR 1989 SC 2285 it was held that though contempt is a serious matter and it interferes with the rights of those who are found guilty of contempt, no court should allow any party to mislead the court and thereby frustrate its order. It was also held that though perhaps the respondent could not be found guilty of violating any undertaking as there was none, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the court should ensure compliance with its order and see that vacant and peaceful possession is given to the landlord in the interest of justice. Accordingly, a direction was issued to the trial court to cause delivery of vacant possession of the shop to the landlord, if necessary, with police help. This case has been subsequently followed in Zahurul Islam v. Abul Kalam 1995 Supp (1) SCC 464 where time was granted to the tenant to vacate the disputed premises subject to his filing the usual undertaking within four weeks, but the tenant did not file any undertaking nor vacated the premises. It was held that the court should ensure compliance with the order by ensuring delivery of possession to the landlord. In our opinion, the present case is fully covered by the ratio of Firm Ganpat Ram Rajkumar v. Kalu Ram 1989 Supp (2) SCC 418, AIR 1989 SC 2285, Ram Pyari v. Jagdish Lal (1992) 1 SCC 157 and Zahurul Islam v. Abul Kalam 1995 Supp (1) SCC 464 referred to above.

    7. We, accordingly, direct the trial court to cause delivery of vacant possession of the premises in dispute to the petitioner Santanu Chaudhuri (the landlord) by eviction of the respondent Subir Ghosh (the tenant) or anybody else found in occupation of the premises, if necessary, with the help of police, within one month of presentation of a certified copy of this order before the trial court. We make it clear that this order will not prevent or prejudice the petitioner (the landlord) from taking any steps for recovery of rent and mesne profits as he is entitled to in accordance with law. The petitioner will also be entitled to Rs 50,000 as costs for the present proceedings. The respondent Subir Ghosh (the tenant) is granted one month's time to deposit the costs in the trial court. In case the cost is not deposited as aforesaid, the trial court shall recover the amount from Subir Ghosh (the tenant) in accordance with law and the same shall be paid to the petitioner Santanu Chaudhuri.

    8. The petition is accordingly disposed of.

    Order in Contempt Petition No. 23 of 2007

    9. No case for initiating contempt proceedings is made out. The contempt petition is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Santanu Chaudhuri v. Subir Ghosh .
    (Jul 24, 2007)