Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 164
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 141 of the old Limitation Act
  • Section 14(2) of the Hindu Succession Act
  • Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963
  • Section 14(1) of the Hindu Succession Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 164
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 141 of the old Limitation Act
  • Section 14(2) of the Hindu Succession Act
  • Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963
  • Section 14(1) of the Hindu Succession Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Sunder, the original owner of the disputed land, executed a gift deed on 23-6-1920 in favour of his daughter, Smt Manshan. Upon Sunder’s death on 17-9-1941, his widow, Smt Kirpi, and their two daughters—Smt Manshan and Smt Sita Devi—survived him. A compromise decree dated 3-8-1945 in a suit filed by Smt Kirpi against Smt Manshan allowed the widow to enjoy the property for life, with reversion to Smt Manshan on her death.

On 23-8-1958, Smt Kirpi purported to adopt Varinder Prakash (grand-son through her second daughter) and executed a gift deed in his favour. Smt Manshan challenged both adoption and gift by filing a suit on 27-5-1959; that suit was decreed in her favour on 16-1-1960. Appeals culminated in dismissal of a letters patent appeal on 18-11-1981.

After the appellate litigation ended, Jagat Ram (son of Smt Manshan) instituted the present suit for possession on 14-12-1982. The trial court dismissed the suit on 24-6-1986 as time-barred. The first appellate court reversed that decision on 19-9-1991. In second appeal, the High Court of Himachal Pradesh restored the trial court’s dismissal on 3-10-1997, finding the suit barred by limitation. The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff’s suit for possession, filed on 14-12-1982, was barred by limitation under Article 65(b) of the Limitation Act, 1963.
  2. Whether the pendency of earlier litigation regarding adoption and gift deeds deferred the commencement of limitation for the present possession suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Contended that the High Court applied the pre-1963 Limitation Act (Article 141) instead of the applicable Article 65 of the 1963 Act, thereby arriving at an erroneous limitation computation.
  • Argued that under Article 65 of the 1963 Act the cause of action arises when possession becomes adverse, and that the continuing appellate litigation until 18-11-1981 prevented the filing of a possession suit earlier.

The opinion does not record any specific arguments advanced on behalf of the respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court approved the High Court’s interpretation of Article 65(b) of the Limitation Act, 1963. The provision expressly states that, when the plaintiff claims through a Hindu female owner, “the possession of the defendant shall be deemed to become adverse only when the female dies”. Because Smt Kirpi died on 5-9-1967, the plaintiff had twelve years—until 5-9-1979—to sue for possession. The suit filed on 14-12-1982 was therefore time-barred.

The Court rejected the contention that ongoing litigation over adoption and the gift deed tolled or suspended the limitation period. It observed that the prior suits sought cancellation and declaratory relief, not possession, and noted that the plaintiff could have sought amendment in those proceedings to include a possession claim but did not do so. Consequently, the limitation period was unaffected by that litigation.

Because limitation was dispositive, the Court did not disturb the High Court’s ancillary observations that the widow’s right under the 1945 compromise fell under Section 14(2) of the Hindu Succession Act (life-estate without pre-existing right of maintenance).

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED – SUIT HELD BARRED BY LIMITATION.

Direct consequence: the plaintiff is definitively denied recovery of possession of the suit land, and the High Court’s judgment stands. The decision turns exclusively on the statutory language of Article 65(b) and sets no new precedent beyond reaffirming that limitation begins upon the death of the female holder, irrespective of other pending litigation not seeking possession.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Jagat Ram v. Varinder Prakash .

    B.P Singh, J.— This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 3-10-1997 of the Single Judge of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla in Regular Second Appeal No. 410 of 1991. The appellant before us is the plaintiff whose suit for possession was dismissed by the High Court holding that the suit was barred by limitation. The correctness of the judgment is impugned before us.

    2. The facts not in dispute are as follows:

    One Sunder, owner of the suit land, died leaving behind his widow Smt Kirpi and two daughters, namely, Smt Manshan and Smt Sita Devi. The appellant-plaintiff, namely, Jagat Ram is the son of Smt Manshan while Varinder Prakash claimed to be the son of Smt Sita Devi but adopted by Smt Kirpi, the widow of Sunder.

    3. Sunder had executed, during his lifetime, a gift deed on 23-6-1920 in favour of his daughter Smt Manshan (mother of the plaintiff). He died on 17-9-1941. On 3-8-1945 Smt Kirpi, widow of Sunder, filed suit against Smt Manshan which finally resulted in a compromise to the effect that Smt Kirpi will enjoy the suit property as long as she was alive and after her death the property will be inherited by her daughter Manshan. It appears that on 23-8-1958, Smt Kirpi executed an adoption deed in favour of her second daughter's son, namely, Varinder Prakash—the defendant and also executed gift deed in his favour. Smt Manshan, mother of the plaintiff, filed a suit on 27-5-1959 for cancellation of the gift deed and for a declaration that the adoption was illegal. The suit was decreed by the trial court on 16-1-1960. On 5-9-1967, Smt Kirpi, widow of Sunder, died. The decree obtained by Smt Manshan was ultimately challenged in the letters patent appeal before the High Court by the defendant, which was dismissed on 18-11-1981.

    4. After the dismissal of the letters patent appeal on 18-11-1981, Smt Manshan filed the instant suit for recovery of possession of the suit land on 14-12-1982. The suit was dismissed by the trial court by judgment and decree dated 24-6-1986 holding that the suit was barred by limitation. However, the judgment and decree of the trial court was upset by the Additional District Judge by the judgment and decree of 19-9-1991. The aforesaid judgment and decree of the appellate court was challenged before the High Court in the second appeal and the same was allowed by the High Court by its judgment dated 3-10-1997. The High Court held that under the compromise of 3-8-1945 a right was conceded in favour of Kirpi to enjoy the suit land during her lifetime. The High Court further held that Kirpi had no pre-existing right of maintenance, and therefore, the case was covered by Section 14(2) of the Hindu Succession Act and not by Section 14(1). However, the High Court held that the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiff on 14-12-1982 was barred by limitation since the widow had died on 5-9-1967 and the suit for possession was not filed within 12 years of her death.

    5. Learned counsel for the appellant urged before us that while under the old Limitation Act, Article 141 governed the case, so far as the Limitation Act of 1963 is concerned the legal position has changed. The High Court failed to notice this change in law and erroneously held on the basis of the limitation prescribed under the old Limitation Act that the suit was barred by limitation.

    6. In our view, the High Court was right in holding that the suit was barred by limitation. Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 prescribes the period of limitation for possession of immovable property or any interest based on title where the suit is by a Hindu or Muslim entitled to possession of immovable property on the death of a Hindu or Muslim female. Article 65(b) in express terms provides that “the possession of the defendant shall be deemed to become adverse only when the female dies”. The limitation prescribed is 12 years beginning from the date when the possession of the defendant becomes adverse to the plaintiff. Learned counsel submitted that in view of Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 the suit had to be filed within 12 years from the date on which the possession of the defendant became adverse and, therefore, it was immaterial as to when the Hindu female died. It is not possible to sustain the contention because the article itself provides that the possession of the defendant shall be deemed to become adverse only when the female dies. Thus, there is no scope for the argument that limitation does not run from the date on which the Hindu female died and that it would start running from some other date. In our view, the High Court has rightly held that the suit should have been filed by the plaintiff within 12 years of the death of the Hindu female, namely, Smt Kirpi and the same having not been filed within 12 years was barred by limitation. Much was sought to be made of the pending litigation relating to the adoption and gift deed executed in favour of the defendant. It was contended before us that since the matter was still pending and though the plaintiff's suit had been decreed on 16-1-1960, the plaintiff could not have filed the instant suit till such time as the letters patent appeal was not dismissed by the High Court i.e till 18-11-1981. The submission has no substance because in the litigation which was pending before the High Court the plaintiff had not claimed possession of the suit land. The High Court has rightly pointed out that even if the plaintiff had sought amendment of the pleadings in the pending matter and claimed decree for possession, the legal position would have been different. He having not done so, he should have filed the suit for possession of the suit land within 12 years of the death of Smt Kirpi, which he failed to do.

    7. We find no reason to set aside the judgment of the High Court. This appeal is therefore dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jagat Ram v. Varinder Prakash .
    (Mar 22, 2006)