AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • The Electricity Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • The Electricity Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 13-01-1998 a High Powered Committee was constituted to investigate several aspects of the functioning of the erstwhile Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board. The Committee, first headed by Shri S. Venkatnarayanan and later by Shri P.K. Kaul, worked with technical assistance from the Central Power Research Institute and the Indian Institute of Management, Lucknow. Its two-volume report (hereafter “Kaul Committee Report”) revealed pervasive political interference—particularly in transfers and postings of personnel—that undermined the Board’s autonomy and efficiency.

During the pendency of the proceedings, the Electricity Board was unbundled into eight government-owned corporations responsible for generation, transmission and distribution of power in Uttar Pradesh. The present order addresses remedial measures to insulate those corporations from political influence in personnel matters, especially with the annual “transfer season” imminent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government or its Ministers/officers possess lawful authority to direct or influence transfers and postings within the eight successor electricity corporations.
  2. Whether the Court should constitute an independent committee to monitor all future transfers/postings so as to ensure transparency and prevent political interference.

Arguments of the Parties

Amicus Curiae

  • Drew the Court’s attention to multiple paragraphs of the Kaul Committee Report highlighting systemic political interference, low morale, and corruption.
  • Suggested immediate creation of an independent Monitoring Committee of persons with impeccable reputation to vet every transfer/posting, thereby preventing another round of politically motivated personnel changes.

State of Uttar Pradesh and Electricity Corporations

  • Could not dispute the absence of statutory authority permitting Ministers or government officers to intervene in corporate personnel decisions.
  • Did not present any substantive alternative to the amicus curiae’s proposal.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court relied heavily on the factual findings of the Kaul Committee, which documented that:

  • The Electricity Board functioned as an extension of the State Government rather than an independent commercial entity.
  • Frequent, politically driven changes in management and personnel policies depressed morale and fostered corruption.

Upon questioning, counsel for the State and the corporations conceded that no legal instrument authorised ministerial or bureaucratic involvement in transfers/postings. Given the forthcoming transfer cycle, the Court found an “imperative necessity” for urgent intervention to safeguard the corporations’ statutory autonomy.

Accepting the amicus curiae’s proposal as both practicable and necessary, the Court determined that transparent, merit-based transfers required oversight by an independent body insulated from political pressures.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: The Court:

  • Prohibits all Ministers and government officers of Uttar Pradesh from interfering in transfers/postings within the eight electricity corporations.
  • Constitutes an independent Monitoring Committee comprising five members (named representatives of UPSC, CEA, C&AG, CVC, and chaired by Shri S. Venkatnarayanan) to pre-approve all personnel movements.
  • Mandates that any transfer/posting disapproved by the Committee shall not be effected.
  • Directs the Committee to report to the Court on all 2005 transfers/postings and establishes remuneration and cost-sharing arrangements among the corporations and the State.

Implications: The order immediately centralises oversight of personnel decisions, aiming to restore autonomy and integrity to the power corporations. While the decision is tailored to the facts of this case and sets no articulated precedent, it signals judicial willingness to impose structural remedies when governmental interference subverts statutory independence.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Suresh Chandra Sharma v. Chairman, U.P Seb And Others

    Order

    1. By an order made on 13-1-1998, a High Powered Committee came to be appointed to carry out investigations into five areas, as indicated in the order. The High Powered Committee was initially headed by Shri S. Venkatnarayanan (IAS), Retd., former Chairman, National Power Finance Corporation, who was substituted later on by Shri P.K Kaul, former Cabinet Secretary of the Government of India. The High Powered Committee (hereinafter referred to as “the Kaul Committee”), with the expert advice and assistance of M/s Central Power Research Institute, Bangalore and Indian Institute of Management, Lucknow, made an in-depth investigation into the areas of reference and produced a report in two volumes.

    2. One of the issues on which the Kaul Committee had adversely commented is that transfers and postings of officers and staff are not made in the State Electricity Board in a transparent and accountable manner. Although guidelines for transfer policy of officers of the State Government (see at p. 495, Vol. IA of the paper-book), are supposed to be the transfer policy of such officers of the Board also, they have been observed in breach. The State Government has power under the Electricity Act to issue directives in the nature of policy directives, but with the Board's Chairman and top executive heads packed by political bosses, the State Government appears to be exercising unbridled power of interference in the day-to-day working of the Electricity Board. This interference in transfers and postings with political patronage has totally destroyed the autonomous nature of the Electricity Board, which has been identified as a serious malaise affecting the functioning of the Electricity Board.

    3. The original Electricity Board has now been split into U.P Power Corporation Limited (for distribution and transmission), with five subsidiary distribution companies, namely, Kanpur Electric Supply Company Limited (KESCO), Purvanchal Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited, Varanasi, Madhyanchal Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited, Lucknow, Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited, Meerut and Dakshinanchal Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited, Agra. Thermal generation is entrusted to U.P Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Limited and hydro generation to U.P Jal Vidyut Nigam Limited. All these companies are government companies, though under the provisions of the Electricity Act, yet independent bodies subject only to the directives of the State Government only on matters of general policy.

    4. That there has been large-scale interference with the autonomous functioning of the Electricity Board (now transformed into eight autonomous Corporations), is evident from the highly critical report made by the Kaul Committee, whose findings are as under:

    “(a) The State Electricity Board is functioning as an extension of the State Government.
    (b) The Government of U.P and individual U.P politicians have long regarded U.P SEB as a social service agency, not a commercial enterprise.
    (c) Although U.P SEB is, on paper, an independent entity, its management serves at the pleasure of the Government of U.P and changes frequently.
    (d) The Government of U.P officially imposes non-commercial constraints on U.P SEB pricing and personnel policies.
    (e) While individual politicians interfere unofficially in personnel, operations, collections, procurement and more.
    (f) Employee morale and productivity are low due to lack of accountability and incentives.
    (g) Corruption is generally accepted to be serious at all levels.”
    (See Kaul Committee Report, Vol. 1, p. 70.)

    5. Learned amicus curiae took us to the several paras of the Kaul Committee's Report which highlighted the deplorable state of affairs found by it.

    6. When we queried the learned counsel appearing for the State of U.P and the learned counsel representing the Electricity Corporations as to under what authority there was governmental interference with the day-to-day affairs of the Corporations in the matters like transfers and postings of officers and staff, neither of them was in a position to contest the position that no Minister or government officer had any role to play in the transfers/postings of officers and staff of such Corporations.

    7. Learned amicus curiae suggested that as the transfer season is round the corner, it is necessary to pre-empt another round of transfers/postings in the manner and for the reasons as highlighted by the Kaul Committee Report. He submitted that one way to ensure transparency in the matter of postings/transfers of officers of these Corporations would be to appoint an independent Monitoring Committee consisting of persons with impeccable reputation and proven administrative ability, which would look into each and every case of posting/transfer and ensure that they are totally free from political interference.

    8. We have heard the learned counsel for the State of U.P and the Corporations. We are satisfied that the suggestion made by the amicus curiae has merit and needs to be accepted. That there is imperative necessity to act urgently, is borne out by the facts. Considering that the transfers are likely to be made in a couple of months, we think that urgent steps are needed to be taken. We, therefore, direct as follows:

    1. No Minister of the State of U.P, nor any government officer shall interfere with the transfers/postings of the officers in any of the Corporations named above.
    2. All postings/transfers of the officers/staff of the aforesaid Corporations shall be monitored by an independent Committee consisting of the following persons:
    (i) Shri S. Venkatnarayanan (IAS), Retd., former Chairman, National Power Finance Corporation, as Chairman;
    (ii) A member of UPSC to be nominated by the Chairman of UPSC;
    (iii) A nominee of the Chairman of the Central Electricity Authority;
    (iv) A nominee of the Comptroller and Auditor General; and
    (v) A nominee of the Central Vigilance Commission.
    3. All proposals for transfers/postings of officers and staff of the aforesaid Corporations should, before finalisation, be placed before the independent Committee which shall examine and approve the transfers/postings on merits and in the light of the guidelines for transfer policy of officers. (See at p. 495 of Vol. IA of the paper-book.)
    4. No transfer/posting which is disapproved by the said Committee shall be made by the Board of Directors of any of the aforesaid eight Corporations.
    5. The Committee shall make a report to this Court containing its observations with regard to the transfers/postings of officers and staff, if any, made for the year 2005, after all such cases have been considered and decisions thereupon taken.

    9. The Chairman, Union Public Service Commission, the Chairman, Central Electricity Authority, the Comptroller and Auditor General and the Central Vigilance Commission shall appoint one nominee each to be a member of the independent Committee referred to in para 2 of this order. The said nominations shall be made within a period of 3 weeks of receipt of a copy of this order.

    10. The Chairman of the said independent Committee shall be entitled to remuneration of Rs 3000 per sitting, while each of the members shall be entitled to remuneration of Rs 2500 per sitting. The remuneration payable to the Chairman and the members of the said Committee as well as the expenditure incurred by the Committee in the discharge of its functions shall be payable in equal proportion by the abovesaid eight Corporations and the State of U.P U.P Power Corporation Limited shall, in the first instance, defray the expenses of the said Committee and pay the remuneration fixed per sitting and shall be entitled to recover the proportionate shares from the other Corporations as well as the State of U.P

    11*. The Registrar General is directed to forthwith forward a copy of this order to Shri S. Venkatnarayanan (IAS), Retd., former Chairman, National Power Finance Corporation, Chairman, CEC, the Chairman, UPSC, the Comptroller and Auditor General and to the Central Vigilance Commission, for information and immediate action.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Suresh Chandra Sharma v. Chairman, U.P Seb And Others
    (Feb 24, 2005)