AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12 of the M.P Accommodation Control Act, 1961
  • Section 18 of the M.P Accommodation Control Act, 1961
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12 of the M.P Accommodation Control Act, 1961
  • Section 18 of the M.P Accommodation Control Act, 1961
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants (landlords) obtained eviction decrees against three respondents (tenants) under Section 12(1)(h) of the M.P. Accommodation Control Act, 1961 on the ground of bona-fide necessity to rebuild their shops. Under Section 18 of the Act, the trial court fixed a one-year period for the landlords to complete reconstruction and to offer the rebuilt premises to the tenants for re-occupation.

The tenants vacated and surrendered possession on 13 November 2000. The landlords did not offer the rebuilt premises within the stipulated year. Consequently, the tenants filed proceedings seeking restoration of possession and compensation for the landlords’ alleged breach. They succeeded before the trial court, the first appellate court, and the High Court.

The landlords filed three Special Leave Petitions before the Supreme Court. During Supreme Court proceedings, the landlords produced a plan showing an 18-shop complex that had replaced the old structure. They offered three contiguous shops (each 8′ × 8′) at the north-eastern corner. After initial reluctance, the tenants occupied these shops on 2 April 2004, resolving the main dispute regarding possession.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenants forfeited their statutory right to re-occupy the rebuilt premises because of alleged delay in vacating the original shops.
  2. Whether the trial court’s award of compensation at ₹3,000 per month per tenant, in the absence of supporting evidence, was legally sustainable.
  3. What constitutes a fair and reasonable rent for the newly constructed shops now occupied by the tenants.

Arguments of the Parties

Landlord Appellants’ Arguments

  • The tenants, having delayed delivery of possession, lost their right to re-occupation; the landlords nevertheless granted the shops only out of deference to the Court.
  • The tenants should pay rent of ₹1,500 per month per shop, allegedly the prevailing market rate paid by adjoining tenants.
  • The order directing payment of compensation at ₹3,000 per month per tenant is unjustified because no evidence was recorded to substantiate that quantum of loss.

Tenant Respondents’ Position

  • Initially objected to the location and size of the offered shops, but ultimately accepted and took possession of them on 2 April 2004.
  • Expressed willingness to pay “reasonable” rent for the newly constructed premises.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the principal controversy—possession of rebuilt shops—had been resolved by the tenants’ occupation on 2 April 2004. Consequently, prolonging the litigation was deemed unnecessary. The Court addressed the remaining monetary disputes in a “reasonable” and summary manner:

  • The direction for compensation at ₹3,000 per month lacked evidentiary foundation; it could not stand as awarded.
  • Fair rent should mirror the rent paid by tenants in adjoining shops of comparable dimensions within the same complex. Because the precise figure was absent from the record, the trial court was tasked with ascertaining that rate.
  • Compensation to tenants was limited to the period 13 November 2001 to 9 April 2003 (when the High Court had reserved three shops for them, which they initially refused). The rate of such compensation would equal the rent ultimately fixed by the trial court.

Holding and Implications

Appeals DISPOSED OF with Directions.

The Court issued detailed directions: (1) the tenants are deemed tenants of the newly allotted shops from 2 April 2004 and must execute rent notes approved by the trial court; (2) the trial court shall determine prevailing rent in comparable adjoining shops, which will become the rent payable by each tenant from 2 April 2004; (3) landlords must pay tenants compensation for the specified period, calculable at the same rate as the rent fixed, with the trial court deciding mode of payment or adjustment.

Implications are limited to the parties: the decision finalizes tenancy terms, resolves compensation, and avoids further litigation. No new legal precedent on statutory interpretation was set.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Syed Jameel Abbas And Others v. Mohd. Yamin Alias Kallu Khan .

    R.C Lahoti, J.— Leave granted in all the three SLPs.

    2. The appellants are the landlords and the three respondents in the three appeals are three tenants in three shop premises belonging to the appellants. Proceedings for eviction of the tenant respondents were initiated by the landlord appellants on the ground available under clause (h) of sub-section (1) of Section 12 of the M.P Accommodation Control Act, 1961, hereinafter, the Act, for short, alleging the bona fide requirement of the landlords for the purpose of rebuilding the shops. The suit was decreed. As required by Section 18 of the Act, the Court appointed the time for vacating of the premises by the tenants accompanied by direction for reoccupation by the tenants after the premises have been rebuilt.

    3. On 13-11-2000 the tenants vacated the premises and delivered possession to the landlords. One year's time was allowed to the landlords for completing the rebuilding and offering the premises for reoccupation by the tenants. The landlords failed to honour their obligation of offering the shops for reoccupation by the tenants. The tenants initiated proceedings for restoration of possession and compensation for breach of obligation by the landlords. They succeeded in the trial court, the first appellate court as also before the High Court. Feeling aggrieved, the landlords have filed these appeals by special leave.

    4. It is notable that the trial court has not only directed possession being restored to the tenants but has also directed a compensation calculated at the rate of Rs. 3000 per month to be paid by the landlords to each of the tenants.

    5. During the course of hearing we tried to explore the possibility of settlement between the parties. The landlords have produced a site plan of newly built premises for the perusal of the Court. It appears that a huge shopping complex has come up in place of the old building. There are 18 shops on the ground floor. The landlords offered to the tenants the three shops situated contiguously, each measuring 8′ × 8′ on the north-eastern end of the building. The shops were not acceptable to the tenant respondents for reoccupation mainly for two reasons. Firstly, the shops were situated in the back part of the building at a distance from the front portion of the building while the shops they had vacated were situated in the front portion of the old building abutting on the main road. Secondly, the area of the shops was much less compared to the area of the shops previously in occupation of the tenants. There were other incidental and ancillary disputes. However, the learned counsel for the respondents has been able to persuade the respondents to occupy the shops offered by the landlords and it is reported that on 2-4-2004 three shops measuring 8′ × 8′ each have been occupied by the three tenant respondents. This brings to an end one and the major part of the controversy.

    6. The learned Senior Counsel for the landlord appellants submitted that as the tenant respondents had delayed in delivery of possession over the erstwhile tenancy premises, therefore, they had lost their right to reoccupation. Still in deference to the wishes of the Court they have given possession to the tenant respondents over three shops. Therefore, the respondents must agree to pay rent at the rate of Rs. 1500 per month per shop as is the prevalent market rate and being paid by other tenants of the adjoining shops. Secondly, submitted the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants, that the direction as to payment of compensation by the appellants to the respondents should be set aside as the same is unjust and uncalled for. The Court has not recorded any evidence nor have the respondents brought any material on record of the Court to form an opinion that the quantum of loss allegedly suffered by each of the respondents was at the rate of Rs. 3000 per month.

    7. We do not propose to enter into niceties and perpetuate the litigation. Inasmuch as the principal and major part of the controversy has come to an end by the landlords having offered three shops to the three tenant respondents and the shops have also been occupied by them, the remaining other disputes need a summary burial and that can be done by making reasonable directions. We agree with the learned counsel for the landlord appellants that in the absence of any material supporting the finding, the direction for payment of compensation to each of the tenant respondents at the rate of Rs. 3000 per month for the period for which they have been out of occupation cannot be sustained. The learned counsel for the tenant respondents has conveyed the willingness on the part of the tenant respondents to pay reasonable rent to the landlord appellants in view of the premises having been newly constructed.

    8. In our opinion, the same rent which is being paid by the tenants in the adjoining shops would be a fair measure of rent which the tenant respondents should be directed to pay. However, what is the rent which is being paid by those tenants is not clear from the record.

    9. All the three appeals are disposed of in terms of the following directions:

    (1) The three tenant respondents who have entered into possession of the three shops on 2-4-2004 situated in the north-east corner of the building shall be deemed to be holding the shops in their respective possession as tenants with effect from 2-4-2004. They will execute such rent notes in favour of the landlords as may be approved by the trial court. If the terms of lease are not settled then the tenancy between the parties shall remain one for non-residential purpose running month by month.
    (2) The trial court shall ascertain the rent which is being paid by the tenants in the adjoining shops preferably the three shops which are of the dimension of 8′ 0″ × 8′, 7′ 10″ × 8′ and 7′ 8″ × 8′ and appoint the same rent to be paid by each of the three tenants to the landlords month by month with effect from 2-4-2004.
    (3) The tenant respondents are entitled to payment of compensation for the period commencing 13-11-2001 up to 9-4-2003, the day of the order of the High Court reserving three shops for occupation by the tenants and which the tenants refused to occupy. The rate of compensation payable by the landlords to the tenants shall be calculated at the same rate at which rent is appointed by the trial court for payment by the tenants to the landlords. It shall be in the discretion of the trial court to direct the compensation being paid by the landlords to the tenants lump sum or to direct the same being adjusted as against payment of rent by the tenants to the landlords after the amount of compensation has been quantified.

    10. The appeals stand disposed of in terms abovesaid. Costs as incurred.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Syed Jameel Abbas And Others v. Mohd. Yamin Alias Kallu Khan .
    (Apr 20, 2004)