AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act, 1956
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act, 1956
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Union of India appealed to the Supreme Court against a common judgment dated 16 December 1993 of the Bombay High Court (Panaji Bench, Goa) in Writ Petitions Nos. 480, 490, 522 and 521 of 1993. The High Court had:

  • Quashed orders of the licensing authorities that had rejected the respondents’ applications for “additional licences” based on exports of processed iron ore made between 1 April 1989 and 31 March 1990.
  • Directed the Union of India, in lieu of issuing the licences, to pay a 20 % premium pursuant to REP Circular No. 11/93 dated 5 May 1993, subject to the exporters producing bank certificates evidencing realisation of foreign-exchange proceeds.

The respondents, recognised trading houses engaged in exporting processed iron ore of Goan origin, had originally applied on 4 June 1990 for an additional licence valued at ₹ 2,12,63,924. The Assistant Chief Controller of Imports and Exports rejected the application on 24 September 1990 citing the absence of any transitional provision under the new Import-Export Policy (April 1990–March 1993). Subsequent appeals and a review were dismissed (21 January 1991, 12 March 1992 and 9 June 1993). The exporters then invoked Circular 11/93 and sought payment of the 20 % premium, which was again refused on 1 September 1993, prompting the writ petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether exporters who were admittedly entitled to an additional licence under the Import-Export Policy of April 1988–March 1991 (“old policy”) lost that entitlement upon the commencement of the new policy on 1 April 1990.
  2. Whether, under paragraph 222 (“Transitional Arrangements”) of the new policy, pending or undecided applications for additional licences had to be processed under the provisions of the old policy.
  3. The legal effect and applicability of REP Circular No. 11/93, which mandates payment of a 20 % premium in lieu of licences for exports and realisations prior to 1 March 1992.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The export of processed iron ore in 1989–1990 created a vested right to receive an additional licence in 1990–1991, which could not be defeated by provisions of the new policy.
  • Proper construction of paragraph 220 of the new policy still entitled them to the licence for exports made in the preceding year, and the authorities had misconstrued the policy.
  • The Government was estopped, under the doctrine of promissory estoppel, from reneging on its representation that trading houses would receive the additional licence, a representation on which exporters had relied.

Appellants’ (Union of India) Arguments

  • The respondents’ applications were rightly rejected because minerals and ores listed in Appendix 12 of the 1990-93 policy were ineligible for additional licences.
  • No vested right accrued to exporters once the old policy expired on 31 March 1990; incentives are inherently subject to change in the public interest.
  • The doctrine of promissory estoppel was inapplicable because no definitive promise had been made; policy amendments were driven by public-interest considerations such as curbing foreign-exchange outflow.
  • Since the application for a licence had already been rejected, no “pending” application existed to attract Circular 11/93.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court focused on the interaction between paragraph 215 of the old policy and paragraph 222 of the new policy:

  • Paragraph 215 granted eligibility for additional licences based on exports made in the preceding licensing year.
  • Paragraph 222 expressly states that where applications for additional licences for a preceding licensing year “have not been disposed of by the end of that licensing year,” licences must be issued “as per the relevant policy provisions prevailing during the period to which the additional licences relate.” Hence, applications relating to exports under the old policy must be decided under that policy, notwithstanding the advent of the new policy.
  • The only limitation under paragraph 222 is that the items actually imported under the licence must conform to the import policy in force at the time of import; the entitlement to the licence itself remains intact.
  • Consequently, the authorities’ refusal to grant the licence, and their view that the respondents had forfeited entitlement under the new policy, were legally untenable.

As to Circular 11/93, the Court noted that it explicitly replaces the grant of licences with payment of a 20 % premium where (i) applications are pending and (ii) exports and realisations occurred prior to 1 March 1992. The respondents satisfied these conditions; therefore, the High Court’s mandamus directing payment of the premium strictly followed the circular issued by the Government itself.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Dismissed. The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s judgment, resulting in:

  • Quashing of all orders that had rejected the respondents’ applications for additional licences.
  • A mandatory direction to the Union of India to pay a 20 % premium in lieu of the licences, in accordance with REP Circular 11/93, once the exporters produce bank certificates of foreign-exchange realisation.
  • Discharge of bank guarantees furnished by the respondents pursuant to an earlier interim order of the Supreme Court.
  • Each party to bear its own costs.

Implications are confined to enforcing exporters’ accrued rights under transitional provisions and to affirming that the Government is bound by its own circular; the judgment does not articulate any broader doctrinal innovation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Others v. Chowgule & Co. Ltd. And Others

    Bhan, J.— The Union of India has filed these appeals against a common judgment/order of the High Court of Bombay, Panaji Bench, Goa dated 16-12-1993 passed in Writ Petitions Nos. 480, 490, 522 and 521 of 1993 filed by the respondents who were the petitioners before the High Court. By the impugned judgment the High Court has quashed the orders passed by the authorities rejecting the claim of the respondents for grant of additional licence against the export orders. But because of the intervening circumstances i.e issuance of REP Circular No. 11 of 1993 dated 5-5-1993 by the Directorate General of Foreign Trade, instead of granting the additional licence the Union of India has been directed to pay to the respondents the premium amount of 20% in terms of the said circular. The Union of India was directed to work out the amount payable subject to the respondents producing the bank certificate in respect of the realisation of foreign exchange of export proceeds.

    2. The facts which are common to all the appeals being similar are taken from the appeal: Union of India v. Chowgule & Co. Ltd.

    3. The respondent is a limited company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956. It is engaged, inter alia, in the export of processed iron ore of Goan origin. It is also recognised as a trading house. Under the import-export policy for April 1988-March 1991 (hereinafter referred to as “the old policy”) trading houses were eligible for the benefit inter alia of additional licences of defined value against the export of processed iron ore under the policy. The old policy was terminated and instead a new policy starting w.e.f April 1990-March 1993 (for short “the new policy”) was introduced. During the period 1-4-1989 to 31-3-1990 the respondents had exported processed iron ore of the value of Rs 21,92,15,711.69. On 4-6-1990 the Company applied to the Assistant Chief Controller of Imports and Exports for additional licence of a value of Rs 2,12,63,924 against the said exports. The application was rejected by the Assistant Chief Controller of Imports and Exports on 24-9-1990 on the ground that application for additional licence for the licensing year 1990-91 could not be considered on the basis of the items appearing in Appendix 12 of the new policy because there was no provision for grant of licence under the heading “Transitional arrangements” in terms of para 222 of the new policy. The respondents preferred an appeal which was dismissed on 21-1-1991. Likewise, the second appeal was dismissed on 12-3-1992. Review petition filed by the respondents was also rejected on 9-6-1993.

    4. The Government of India, Ministry of Commerce, Directorate General of Foreign Trade, Udyog Bhavan, New Delhi issued REP Circular No. 11/93 dated 5-5-1993 (hereinafter referred to as “Circular 11 of 93”) providing therein:

    “(b) Where the applications for issue of exim scrips/REP etc. licences are pending in respect of exports made and export proceeds realised thereagainst prior to 1-3-1992, the 20% premium will be straight away paid, instead of issuing the licences, provided that the licensing authority after processing the application and determining the eligibility for issue of licences is satisfied that the applicant is eligible for grant of exim scrips/REP etc. licences.”

    5. On 14-7-1993 the respondents lodged their claim for 20% premium instead of additional licence for the licensing year April-March 1991 against exports of processed iron ore in the preceding licensing year April-March 1990. The claim of the Company was rejected by the Deputy Director General of Foreign Trade, Panaji vide letter dated 1-9-1993 on the ground that minerals and ores appearing in Appendix 12 of the policy book 1990-93 were ineligible for additional licence.

    6. Aggrieved against the aforesaid sets of orders the respondents filed the writ petitions in the High Court of Bombay, Panaji Bench, Goa seeking twofold relief. Firstly, for quashing of the orders passed by the various authorities as mentioned above refusing their prayer for additional licence and secondly, a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ directing the Union of India to forthwith pay to them premium of 20% of Rs 2,12,63,924 being the face value of the additional licence for April-March 1991 to which the respondents were entitled under Circular 11 of 93.

    7. The respondents in their writ petitions raised threefold contentions: firstly, it was urged on their behalf that by exporting processed iron ore during the period 1-4-1989 to 31-3-1990 under the import-export policy for the years 1988-91 (old policy), they had acquired a vested right to get additional licence in the licensing year April-March 1990-91 of the value prescribed in the import-export policy relevant for April 1988-March 1991 and the said right could not be defeated by the provisions of the new policy. Secondly, it was contended that on a true construction of the relevant provisions of the import-export policy for April 1990-March 1993, in particular, para 220 thereof, the respondents were entitled to additional licence for the licensing year April 1990-March 1991 against exports of processed iron ore made in the preceding licensing year i.e April 1989-March 1990 and that the authorities have misconstrued the relevant provisions. Thirdly, it was contended that the Union of India was precluded by the doctrine of promissory estoppel for denying the additional licence to the Company during the licensing year April-March 1991 of the value defined having represented to the trading houses/exporters that they would be entitled to the additional licence, the parties having acted upon that representation and having exported processed iron ore during the period 1-4-1989 to 31-3-1990.

    8. The appellants apart from raising certain preliminary objections regarding the maintainability of the writ petitions which were rejected by the High Court and which have not been pressed before us did not dispute the factual statements of facts made in paras 1 to 8 in the writ petitions stating that these were matters of record. Insofar as the claim of the respondents for 20% premium, it was contended that there was no application from the party pending for entitlement of additional licence as their application for additional licence was rejected. It was denied that their action in rejecting the application of the respondents for the grant of additional licence was contrary to law or null and void or in excess of jurisdiction. That the claim for additional licence in the subsequent year was ineligible under the new policy although that might have been available under the old policy, which, however, ceased to exist after 31-3-1990. Claim of the respondent writ petitioners that they had acquired any vested right to get an additional licence by virtue of exports made during the year 1989-90 was denied. That the amendment made in the policy was valid and the consequences flowing thereof were in the public interest and therefore not open to challenge. Circumstances which necessitated the amendment in public interest were set out. According to the appellants the export incentive was subject to changes from time to time during the policy period. A change when it was brought in the policy after 30-3-1990 could thus be made and was binding upon the parties and that the said amendment was made in public interest particularly taking into account that in spite of other existing financial burden on the exchequer, incentive on iron ore was further amounting to a large amount of outflow of foreign exchange by way of additional licence and higher REP benefits. For these reasons, according to the appellants, there did not arise any question of any promise having been made by the Government to the trading houses/exporters and, therefore, the principle of promissory estoppel could not be invoked and the same was not applicable to the facts of the case. It was maintained that the application for additional licence made by the respondents was rejected in accordance with the position of law as it obtained on that date.

    9. It may be highlighted that the appellants did not dispute that the respondent's Company was a recognised trading house. The extent of export of processed iron ore made by the respondents between 1-4-1989 to 31-3-1990 and the value thereof stated in the writ petition were not controverted. The value shown by the respondents for the purpose of additional licence was also not disputed. No issue as regards the net foreign exchange earnings as may have been earned against the export of iron ore was raised. Except for contending that the respondents were ineligible for grant of additional licence as per the new policy, it was not stated that the application for licence was liable to be rejected on any other ground. Issuance of Circular 11 of 93 for payment of premium in the manner provided instead of additional licence to which the applicant may have been entitled to was also not disputed.

    10. The High Court by the impugned order independent of and relying upon an earlier Division Bench judgment of its own court held that the writ petitioners were entitled to the grant of additional licence and accordingly, quashed the orders passed by the authorities rejecting their claim for the additional licence. Because of the coming into force of Circular 11 of 93 instead of directing the authorities to grant the additional licence, it was declared that the respondents would be entitled to the payment of premium of 20% in terms of the relevant clause which is extracted in para 4 of this judgment.

    11. The short point to be decided in these appeals is: as to whether the respondents who were admittedly entitled to grant of additional licence under the old policy stand debarred from claiming the said additional licence because of the new import-export policy which came into force from 1-4-1990 and further, the applicability of Circular 11 of 93 dated 5-5-1993 and the effect thereof.

    12. Before addressing on the controversy, the salient features of the old import-export policy effective for April 1988-March 1991, which was terminated on 30-3-1990 and was replaced by the new import-export policy April 1990-March 1993, may be set out. Para 211 of the old policy sets out the objectives of the scheme for registration of export houses and trading houses. It states that it is to grant recognition and facilities to a select band of efficient registered exporters who would develop a strong marketing capability and that it is expected that they would operate as highly specialized and dynamic institutions with a strong marketing infrastructure and act as an important instrument for export growth. Para 212 provides that the eligibility for grant of trading houses/export houses certificate shall be determined on the basis of the net foreign exchange earnings from the exports actually made during the past period subject to the conditions set out in sub-para (2) of the said paragraph. Para 215 provides for additional licence. Thereunder, the trading houses/export houses will be eligible to additional licence on the basis of the admissible exports made in the preceding licensing year and that the value of this licence will be calculated at 10% of the net foreign exchange (NFE) earnings on the total eligible exports made in the preceding licensing year. Remaining part of the paragraph is not material and therefore is not being set out. Sub-para (2) laid down that the additional licence shall be valid for the export of the items listed thereunder. Sub-para (8) provides that the items permissible shall be those eligible under the policy on the date of issue of the licence. Para 218, inter alia, provides that where the applications for additional licence have not been disposed of by 31st March of the preceding licensing year, the rate of entitlement will be the same as permissible during the licensing year to which the applications pertained but the items to be allowed will be as per the import policy on the date of the licence. Appendix 12 of the old policy does not list iron ore as ineligible product for import replenishment licence or additional licence.

    13. Para 204 of Chapter XV of the new policy provides that in the case of exports made prior to 1-4-1990 against which REP licence was issued on or after 1-4-1990, the rate of import replenishment will be as admissible on the date of export but subject to the conditions laid down in the 1988-91 policy book. Chapter XVI deals with deemed exports. Under para 210 the deemed exports will qualify for grant of import replenishment licence. The material provision, however, is contained in Chapter XVIII. Part A thereof deals with export houses/trading houses. The objective is similar to that of earlier policy. The eligibility criteria laid down in para 218 for the grant of export/trading house certificate is to be determined on the basis of NFE earnings from the exports actually made in the preceding three licensing years termed as “base period”. The earnings from export of products in Appendix 12 shall not qualify for this purpose. Para 220 deals with additional licence and provides, inter alia, that the export houses/trading houses will be eligible for additional licences on the basis of admissible exports made in the preceding licensing year and the value of the licence will be calculated at the rate of 10% NFE earnings on the total eligible exports made in the preceding licensing year. Para 222 deals with transitional arrangements and the same reads as under:

    “222. Where the applications from export houses/trading houses for additional licences for any of the preceding licensing year, have not been disposed of by the end of the licensing year, licences will be issued as per the relevant policy provisions prevailing during the period to which the additional licences relate, subject to the condition that the permissibility of the items allowed for import against such licences will be governed by the relevant provisions of the import policy in force, at the time of their actual import.”

    14. Coming to the point raised, it is to be noticed that para 215 of the old policy is clear and provides that eligibility to the additional licence was to be determined on the basis of the admissible exports made in the preceding licensing year. Para 222 of the new policy which has been extracted above provides that where the applications from export houses/trading houses for additional licences for any of the preceding licensing year, have not been disposed of by the end of the licensing year, licences will be issued as per the relevant policy provisions prevailing during the period to which the additional licences relate. Meaning thereby that if an application for additional licence for any preceding licensing year is pending which in this case shall be deemed to be pending as the controversy is still alive being adjudicated then the licence has to be issued as per the relevant policy provisions prevailing during the period to which the additional licence relates, which in the present case would be under the old policy. The grant of additional licence in para 222 has been made subject to the condition that the permissibility of the items allowed for import against such licences will be governed by the relevant provisions of the import policy in force at the time of their actual import, meaning thereby that the items which can be imported would be relatable to the import policy in force i.e the new policy. Transitional arrangements stated in para 222 make it abundantly clear that the applications from export houses/trading houses which have not been finally disposed of by the end of the licensing year would be entitled to the issuance of the additional licence as per the relevant policy provisions prevailing during the period to which the additional licences related. The entitlement of the export houses/trading houses to get the additional licence has not been taken away. The only condition to which the additional licence has been subjected is that the permissible items allowable for import against such (additional licensing) would be governed by the provisions of the import policy in force at the time of their actual import. Contentions raised on behalf of the Union of India that the respondent writ petitioners had to lodge their right/entitlement to get the additional licence under the new policy for the exports made during the period when the old policy was in force, cannot be accepted. The application for the additional licence could be made only after the end of the fiscal year, as only thereafter the export house could know its entitlement. The High Court was, therefore, right in holding that the interpretation put by the authorities on the new policy in declining the claim of the respondents for the grant of additional licence was unacceptable. Under the new policy as well, the export houses/trading houses would remain entitled to the additional licence for the exports made during the period when the old policy was in force but subject to the condition that they would be allowed to import against the additional licence such items which are governed by the policy in force at the time of the import of the goods.

    15. For the reasons stated above, we do not find any infirmity in the orders passed by the High Court in quashing the orders passed by the authorities rejecting the claim of the respondents for grant of additional licence.

    16. Similarly, we do not find any infirmity in the orders passed by the High Courts in the issuance of writ of mandamus directing the Union of India to forthwith pay to the respondents the premium of 20% instead of issuing the additional licence in terms of Circular 11 of 93. Circular 11 of 93 provides that where applications for grant of additional licence are pending in respect of the exports made and export proceeds relating to the period prior to 1-3-1992 then instead of issuing the licences, 20% premium shall be paid. The order passed by the High Court is strictly in conformity with Circular 11 of 93 issued by the appellants itself.

    17. Bank guarantee given by the respondents in pursuance of the order of this Court dated 28-3-1994 shall stand discharged. The appeals being without any merit are, therefore, dismissed. Parties shall bear their own costs in these appeals.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. Chowgule & Co. Ltd. And Others
    (Jan 24, 2003)