Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 43-C of the Karnataka Land Revenue Code
  • Rule 43-G(4) of the Karnataka Land Revenue Code
  • The Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1888
  • Rule 43(2) of the Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1940
  • Section 4 of the Mysore Land Revenue Code
  • Section 4 of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • Rule 43-G of the Mysore Land Revenue Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 43-C of the Karnataka Land Revenue Code
  • Rule 43-G(4) of the Karnataka Land Revenue Code
  • The Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1888
  • Rule 43(2) of the Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1940
  • Section 4 of the Mysore Land Revenue Code
  • Section 4 of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • Rule 43-G of the Mysore Land Revenue Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Nanjaiah alias Gungaiah was allotted 1 acre 20 guntas of land by the State for a consideration of Rs 750 under the Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1888. On 10-9-1968 the appellant purchased this land from Gungaiah. The Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978 came into force on 1-1-1979, and Section 4 of that Act declared certain alienations contrary to the terms of grant to be null and void.

Pursuant to Section 4, the Assistant Commissioner issued notice to the appellant alleging that the 1968 sale violated the terms of the original grant. After considering objections, the Assistant Commissioner ordered resumption of the land on 26-3-1990. The appellant’s appeal to the Deputy Commissioner failed, as did a writ petition and a subsequent writ appeal before the High Court of Karnataka. The present opinion resolves the appellant’s further challenge to those orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the land granted to Gungaiah was sold at “full market value” or at a price lower than market value, thereby attracting the 15-year non-alienation prohibition in Rule 43-G of the Mysore Land Revenue Code.
  2. Consequently, whether the 1968 sale to the appellant is void under Section 4 of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The land was granted for an upset price that represented the full market value (Rs 500 per acre); therefore, Rule 43-G, which restricts alienation when land is granted below market value, does not apply.
  • The saguvali chit (grant certificate) contained no specific clause prohibiting alienation, making the 1968 sale valid.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The “upset price” was merely an occupancy price and was less than the true market value; thus Rule 43-G’s prohibition applies.
  • Any grant made under Rule 43-C automatically attracts the restriction in Rule 43-G when the consideration is below market value; consequently, the 1968 transfer is void under Section 4 of the 1978 Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the decisive question as whether the consideration paid by Gungaiah equalled the land’s full market value. It examined Rule 43-G(4), which imposes a 15-year bar on alienation where land is granted free of cost or below market value, and Rule 43(2), which outlines how “upset price” is to be fixed.

The Court noted that although Rule 43(2) aspires to align upset price with market value, the two concepts are not automatically identical. No evidence was produced to prove that the Rs 500 per acre upset price reflected actual market value. In fact, the appellant’s own purchase of the same land for Rs 3000 within three years of the grant suggested that the original price was below market value.

Because the grant price was not shown to equal market value, Rule 43-G’s prohibition applied. The grant also contained a clause subjecting future enjoyment of the land to the Land Revenue Code and rules in force, thereby importing the statutory restriction even in the absence of an express non-alienation clause in the grant certificate.

The Court observed that the appellant had not raised the “market value” argument before the Assistant Commissioner, where the primary contention had been the absence of a specific non-alienation clause. Given these findings, the Court concluded that the 1968 transfer contravened Section 4 of the 1978 Act.

Holding and Implications

Appeal dismissed. The sale in favour of the appellant is void, and the land is liable to be resumed and restored to the respondents.

Immediate consequence: the appellant loses title and possession must revert to the original grantee’s successors. The Court added that the appellant may apply to the Assistant Commissioner for compensation for improvements, and any such application shall be decided according to law. No broader precedent was established beyond enforcement of the statutory scheme in similar factual circumstances.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Siddegowda v. Assistant Commissioner And Others

    Order

    1. One Nanjaiah alias Gungaiah was allotted 1 acre 20 guntas of land by the State for a total sum of Rs 750. The land allotted to Gungaiah was purchased by the appellant herein on 10-9-1968. This allotment was made under the Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1888. The Karnataka State Legislature passed the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978 and it came into force on 1-1-1979. Under Section 4 of the said Act, certain alienations made in contravention of the terms of grant of land were declared null and void. Pursuant to that, notice was issued under Section 4 of the Act to the appellant alleging that the sale in favour of the appellant by the predecessor-in-interest of Respondents 3-A to E was violative of the provisions of the Act and the land was to be resumed and possession be given back to these respondents. The appellant filed objection and the Assistant Commissioner by his order dated 26-3-1990 ordered resumption of the land. The appellant challenged the same before the Deputy Commissioner. The appeal was rejected. The appellant thereafter filed writ petition before the High Court of Karnataka. The same was dismissed. The appellant thereafter filed a writ appeal and by the impugned judgment the Division Bench dismissed the writ appeal.

    2. We heard the learned counsel for the appellant and learned counsel for the respondents. The main contention urged by the appellant's counsel was that the land granted to Gungaiah was for an upset price fixed as per the rules and the upset price being equivalent to market value of the land, the prohibition against alienating of the property, envisaged under Rule 43-G of the Mysore Land Revenue Code is not applicable. The counsel for the appellant also contended that in the “sagu vali chit” (grant certificate) executed in favour of the original grantee Gungaiah there was no specific clause prohibiting alienation of the land to any other party. Therefore, it was argued that the sale in favour of the appellant was perfectly valid and Section 4 of the Act has no application.

    3. The counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, contended that the grant in favour of Gungaiah was effected on payment of the occupancy price payable by the grantee, though it is described as upset price and the same does not amount to market value of the land. The counsel for the State also supported this contention and submitted that any grant of land made under Rule 43-C would automatically attract the provision of prohibition contained in Rule 43-G if the grant is for any amount less than the market value.

    4. The counsel for the appellant has drawn our attention to the various rules applicable to the grant of land. Evidently, the grant made to Gungaiah was under Rule 43-C of the Karnataka Land Revenue Code and under such circumstances, the prohibition prescribed under Rule 43-G would apply. Rule 43-G(4) read as follows:

    “Where the grant is made free of cost, or is made at a price which is less than the full market value, the grant shall be subject to the condition that the land shall be alienated for a period of fifteen years from the date of the grantee taking possession of the land, after the grant.”

    5. Therefore, the crucial question is whether the grant in favour of Gungaiah was for the full market value or for any price lesser than that. The argument of the appellant's counsel is that upset price was fixed at Rs 500 per acre and that clearly reflected the full market value of the land. Our attention was also drawn to Rule 43(2) of the Mysore Land Revenue Code, 1940 describing the mode in which the upset price shall be fixed. It says that:

    “The ‘upset price’ shall not be arbitrarily fixed but shall represent the actual market value of the land, as nearly as it can be ascertained by local enquiries and the examination of records of sales of similar lands in the neighbourhood, and if necessary, of the registration statistics relating to them.”

    6. From the above rule, it is not possible to assume that upset price would always be the market value of the land. The upset price and market price are certainly different concepts and it may be true that in certain cases upset price may be the market value of the land. But that does not mean that upset price fixed shall always be equivalent to the market value of the land. There are no materials placed before us to show that Rs 500 fixed by the authorities was equivalent to the market value for this land. It is also relevant to note that the appellant himself purchased this land within a period of three years from Gungaiah for a total sum of Rs 3000. Therefore, we are unable to hold that the upset price fixed at Rs 500 per acre was really the market value of the land. If that be so, the prohibition under Rule 43-G would apply. The appellant who had filed the objections before the Assistant Commissioner, did not take a plea that the upset price for the grant was really the market value of the land. The main contention raised before the first authority was that the grant did not contain a specific clause prohibiting alienation. Nevertheless, the grant contained a clause that the further enjoyment of the land was subject to the Land Revenue Code and the rules thereunder for the time being in force and other laws. Evidently, the provisions contained in the Mysore Land Revenue Code are applicable and the assignment in favour of the appellant was in contravention of Section 4 of the Act and we do not find any merit in the appeal. It is accordingly dismissed.

    7. Counsel for the appellant lastly submitted that after the assignment, the appellant effected several improvements to the property and he is entitled to reasonable compensation. It is up to the appellant to file appropriate application before the Assistant Commissioner. In case such an application is filed, the same shall be disposed of in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Siddegowda v. Assistant Commissioner And Others
    (Feb 13, 2003)