Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 424
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 5 second proviso to Rule 19-A of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 424
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 5 second proviso to Rule 19-A of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The landlord filed Suit No. 473 of 1985 against the present appellants–tenants. Summons were first ordered on 2-4-1986 to be served both by ordinary process and by registered post. As the registered notices (Postal Receipts Nos. 875 and 876 dated 24-4-1986) did not return by 30-4-1986, the matter was adjourned to 30-6-1986. On that date fresh summons were directed, along with substituted service by newspaper publication. The publication ultimately appeared on 9-8-1986 in the local daily “Aacharan” (rather than “Dainik Bhaskar,” initially named by the court). The trial court proceeded ex parte on 22-8-1986, recorded evidence on 5-9-1986, and passed an ex parte decree on 30-9-1986.

The tenants learnt of the decree on 1-10-1986 and, on 6-10-1986, moved an application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC to set it aside. The trial court dismissed that application; their appeal and revision also failed. The present appeal by special leave, therefore, concerns only the legality of service of summons that culminated in the ex parte decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether service of summons sent by registered post with acknowledgment due, in terms of Order 5 Rule 19-A (second proviso) CPC read with Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, creates a sufficient presumption of due service on the defendants.
  2. Whether substituted service published in a newspaper (“Aacharan”) other than the one specifically ordered (“Dainik Bhaskar”) vitiates service and warrants setting aside the ex parte decree.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (Defendants/Judgment-Debtors)

  • The trial court contravened Order 5 CPC by ordering substituted service without recording the satisfaction that defendants were avoiding service or could not be served in the ordinary way.
  • Publication in “Aacharan” instead of the court-directed “Dainik Bhaskar” rendered substituted service invalid.
  • Consequently, summons were not “duly served,” satisfying the first limb of Order 9 Rule 13, and the ex parte decree should be set aside.

Respondent (Plaintiff/Landlord)

  • Both “Aacharan” and “Dainik Bhaskar” are widely circulated local dailies; publication in either suffices for substituted service.
  • The registered summons were properly addressed, prepaid, and dispatched, raising a statutory presumption of service under Order 5 Rule 19-A CPC and Section 27 of the General Clauses Act.
  • Defendants had actual knowledge of the suit but chose not to appear, and their application under Order 9 Rule 13 was filed merely to delay execution.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice H.K. Sema observed that the appellants had to satisfy both requirements under Order 9 Rule 13: (a) non-service of summons and (b) sufficient cause for non-appearance. The second requirement was not even alleged. On service, the Court reasoned as follows:

  • Statutory Presumption: Under Order 5 Rule 19-A (second proviso) CPC and Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, once summons are properly addressed, prepaid, and sent by registered post, the Court must presume due service if acknowledgment is not returned within thirty days. This presumption is rebuttable.
  • Onus on Defendants: Postal receipts proved that summons were sent on 24-4-1986 to the correct addresses. Defendant Hari Singh merely asserted non-receipt; he did not examine the postman or produce other cogent evidence. Defendant Basant Singh offered no evidence at all. The statutory onus to rebut the presumption therefore remained unsatisfied.
  • Substituted Service: Although the order mentioned “Dainik Bhaskar,” publication actually occurred in “Aacharan,” which was also a widely circulated local daily. The Court treated this as a mere procedural irregularity. Moreover, the second proviso to Order 9 Rule 13 bars setting aside an ex parte decree solely for irregularity in service.

Given the unrefuted presumption of registered-post service and the harmless nature of the newspaper substitution, the Court concluded that summons were duly served.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The ex parte decree remains intact, and the tenants’ application under Order 9 Rule 13 stands rejected.

Implications: The decision reinforces the statutory presumption of service arising from properly dispatched registered post and clarifies that minor irregularities in substituted service—such as publication in a comparable newspaper—do not, by themselves, justify setting aside an ex parte decree. No new precedent was articulated beyond applying existing statutory provisions to the facts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Basant Singh And Another v. Roman Catholic Mission .

    H.K Sema, J.— Leave granted.

    2. The sole question that falls for consideration in this appeal is, whether the service of notice sent by registered post with acknowledgement card in terms of Order 5 second proviso to Rule 19-A of the Code of Civil Procedure read with Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 can be accepted as a sufficient notice.

    3. This appeal filed by the defendants (judgment-debtors) arises out of the following material facts. Suit No. 473 of 1985 filed by the landlord ended in passing of an ex parte decree by the trial court on 30-5-1986. The appellants preferred an application on 6-10-1986 under Order 9 Rule 13 for setting aside the ex parte decree which was rejected by the trial court. Their appeal before the appellate court and revision petition before the High Court ended without any success. It appears, initially the plaintiff (respondent herein) could not deposit the requisite process fee for which the summons could not be issued to the appellant-defendants. On 2-4-1986, the trial court ordered the summons to be issued to the defendants, both by ordinary process and by registered post, and the case was adjourned to 30-4-1986. On a perusal of the record, and not disputed by the parties, we find that the registered notices were issued to the defendants vide Postal Receipts Nos. 875 and 876 dated 24-4-1986. As on 30-4-1986, summons issued by registered posts were not received back, the case was adjourned to 30-6-1986 awaiting the receipt of the service report. On 30-6-1986, the trial court again ordered that fresh summons both by ordinary post and registered post be issued within three days. The trial court also ordered substituted service by resorting to Order 5 Rule 20 CPC by publication of summons in the local daily Dainik Bhaskar. On 5-8-1986, it appears that a notice of publication in the daily newspaper Aacharan instead of Dainik Bhaskar as ordered by the court has been produced. This is one of the grievances of the appellants, with which we shall be dealing at appropriate place. On 22-8-1986, the trial court passed an order to proceed ex parte and fixed the case for 4-9-1986 for evidence of the plaintiff. As the date fixed — 4-9-1986, was declared a public holiday, the plaintiff's witness was examined on 5-9-1986 and the ex parte judgment and decree was passed on 30-9-1986. It is stated that the appellants came to know of the ex parte decree on 1-10-1986 and filed an application on 6-10-1986 for setting aside the ex parte decree, as noticed above.

    4. Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the trial court has acted in violation of the procedure prescribed under Order 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in issuing summons to the defendants. He further contended that the substituted service can be resorted to only when the court is satisfied that the defendant is avoiding the service or the service cannot be effected in an ordinary way. The trial court having not passed any order about the satisfaction as envisaged under the Code, it was not open to the trial court to order for substituted service. This submission need not detain us any longer. On the facts of the case the court's satisfaction is implicit in the order directing service by publication.

    5. Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure insists that the applicant must satisfy the court two conditions (a) that the summons was not duly served, and (b) that the applicant was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing before the court when the suit was called on for hearing. In the present case the second condition is not attracted.

    6. Regarding the contention of the counsel for the appellants that the summons were not duly served, as the substituted service has been published in the local daily Aacharan instead of Dainik Bhaskar, we may point out that it is in the evidence on record that both Aacharan and Dainik Bhaskar are local dailies and are widely circulated in the area. In ordinary circumstances, if both the local dailies are widely circulated in the area the change of the name of the local daily from Dainik Bhaskar to Aacharan would not materially affect the service of notice by way of substituted service, deemed to have been served, and would not invalidate the effect of substituted service just because the notice for substituted service has been published in the local daily which is not ordered by the court. It is the specific contention of the plaintiff-respondent that the notice has been published in the local daily Aacharan on 9-8-1986 and the said local daily is widely circulated in the area and the substituted service would construe as sufficient notice upon the defendants. We are also of the view that it is inherently probable that publication in the local daily Aacharan which is widely circulated in the area would have constituted a sufficient notice to the defendants.

    7. Before the trial court the stand taken by the plaintiff was that the defendants had knowledge about the suit filed by the plaintiff and they had sufficient time to appear and answer the plaintiff's claim but they did not appear and the application had been filed with the intention to cause delay. Be that as it may, we are of the view that the publication of the substituted service in the local daily Aacharan instead of Dainik Bhaskar is a mere irregularity in service of summons.

    8. Second proviso to Order 9 Rule 13 casts an embargo on the court that a decree passed ex parte shall not be set aside merely on the ground that there has been an irregularity in the service of summons.

    9. Order 5, proviso to sub-rule (2) of Rule 19-A CPC provides that where the summons are properly addressed, prepaid and duly sent by registered post with acknowledgement due, notwithstanding the fact that the acknowledgement having been lost or mislaid, or for any other reason, has not been received by the court within thirty days from the date of the issue of the summons, the court shall presume that notice is duly served. Further, Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 (in short “the Act”) provides similar provision. The presumptions are rebuttable. It is always open to the defendants to rebut the presumption by leading convincing and cogent evidence.

    10. It is nobody's case that the postal addresses of the defendants are not properly addressed and, therefore, the registered summons could not be served. It is also nobody's case that the registered summons are not prepaid and not duly sent. In fact the registered summons, bearing Receipts Nos. 875 and 876 dated 24-4-1986, were issued is borne out from the record.

    11. Once it is proved that summons were sent by registered post to a correct and given address, the defendants' own conduct becomes important. Before the trial court, the appellants were allowed to lead evidence in support of their contentions. An order to this effect was passed by the trial court on 11-1-1991. The premises in question are occupied by two defendants jointly — Hari Singh and Basant Singh. Hari Singh appeared and examined himself stating that he did not receive the registered letter. However, the defendant Basant Singh did not appear and no evidence whatsoever, on his behalf, has been led to rebut the presumption in regard to service of summons sent to him under registered post with acknowledgement due. His own conduct shows that the registered summons had been duly served on him. As already noticed, Hari Singh appeared and save and except the bald statement that registered letter was not tendered to him, no evidence whatsoever was led to rebut the presumption. He could have examined the postman, who would have been the material witness and whose evidence would have bearing for proper adjudication. He has failed to discharge the onus cast upon him by the statute. This apart, it is inherently improbable that the registered summons were duly served on Basant Singh but not on Hari Singh when they occupied the tenanted premises jointly.

    12. As noticed above, the registered summons were sent to Basant Singh and Hari Singh vide Postal Receipts Nos. 875 and 876 dated 24-4-1986 on the correct and given address, is borne out from the record. Ex parte proceedings were ordered on 22-8-1986 and ex parte decree was passed on 30-9-1986.

    13. In the facts and circumstances as noticed above, this appeal is devoid of merit and it is, accordingly, dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Basant Singh And Another v. Roman Catholic Mission .
    (Oct 3, 2002)