Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act
  • Section 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987
  • Section 428 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 25(1-A) and 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act
  • Section 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987
  • Section 428 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 25(1-A) and 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On the night of 24 February 1994, at approximately 8:15 p.m., Amar Bhaskar Suvarna was shot dead in front of Trishna Restaurant at Kala Ghoda, Mumbai, while accompanied by prosecution witness PW-3, Cyrus. Two accused relevant to this appeal were later arrested:

  • A-1 Mohmed Aslam (@ Sheru Mohd. Hasan) – arrested on 6 October 1994; a subsequent search of his residence allegedly yielded a semi-automatic U.S. carbine magazine and 113 cartridges.
  • A-7 Adam Gafoor Shaikh (@ Adam Toofani) – arrested in March 1995.

Both appellants made confessional statements under Section 15 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (TADA). A Designated Court convicted:

  • A-1 under Section 5 of TADA and Sections 25(1-A) and 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act, sentencing him to rigorous imprisonment (RI) for 10 years on each of the first two counts, to run concurrently, and imposing fines.
  • A-7 under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) (life imprisonment) and under Section 5 of TADA and Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act (lesser concurrent sentences).

Separate criminal appeals were filed before the Supreme Court: Criminal Appeal No. 613 of 1999 (A-1) and Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 1999 (A-7).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether A-7 was correctly identified as one of the assailants who shot Amar Bhaskar Suvarna, thereby justifying his conviction under Section 302 IPC and allied offences.
  2. Whether the recovery of lethal weapons from A-1’s residence was proved beyond reasonable doubt, sustaining his convictions under Section 5 TADA and Sections 25(1-A) & 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act.
  3. Whether A-1 was entitled to a reduction of sentence or the benefit of set-off under Section 428 of the Criminal Procedure Code despite observations by the Designated Court to the contrary.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant A-7 (Adam Gafoor Shaikh)

  • Accepted that the homicide occurred but disputed identification, arguing he was not one of the shooters.
  • Contended that the test identification parade suffered from “many lapses,” rendering it unreliable.
  • Argued that the nighttime conditions prevented eyewitnesses from getting a clear view of the assailants.

Appellant A-1 (Mohmed Aslam)

  • Asserted that both panch witnesses to the alleged recovery of arms turned hostile, leaving PW-34’s testimony unsupported.
  • Questioned PW-34’s credibility and claimed the recovery was not made from the flat in which A-1 resided.
  • Sought a reduction of the 10-year RI sentence, pointing out that he was already serving life imprisonment for a separate Section 302 conviction.
  • Challenged the Designated Court’s observation denying him set-off under Section 428 CrPC for the period 8-12-1994 to 19-7-1998.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Identification of A-7: The Court deemed PW-3 and PW-4 to be reliable eyewitnesses. Both had identified A-7 in a properly conducted test identification parade and again in court. Minor procedural lapses, if any, in the parade were held insufficient to vitiate their evidence. The Court noted that Mumbai at 8:15 p.m. would not be dark, making visibility adequate. Given the proximity of PW-3 to the deceased, the Court considered it unlikely that the eyewitnesses misidentified the assailant.

Recovery from A-1: Despite hostile panch witnesses, the Court accepted PW-34’s testimony, emphasizing that the physical production of the recovered arms in court substantiated his account. The presence of A-1’s family in the searched flat and the lack of defence evidence contesting the recovery further bolstered credibility. Consequently, the statutory ingredients of Section 5 TADA and the relevant Arms Act provisions were satisfied.

Sentence & Set-Off for A-1: The Court found no basis to reduce A-1’s 10-year sentence, noting it would effectively overlap with his existing life sentence. However, it clarified that jail authorities must grant set-off under Section 428 CrPC “notwithstanding” the Designated Court’s contrary observation, provided A-1 meets the statutory criteria, in line with Supreme Court jurisprudence.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITION: Both appeals were dismissed; the convictions and sentences imposed by the Designated Court stand affirmed. The Court directed that A-1 be given the statutory benefit of set-off under Section 428 CrPC if otherwise eligible.

Implications: The decision upholds the evidentiary value of eyewitness testimony corroborated by a test identification parade, even where minor procedural shortcomings exist, and affirms that hostile panch witnesses do not automatically vitiate a recovery when the seizing officer’s testimony is credible. No new legal precedent was established beyond these confirmations, and the ruling primarily affects the appellants’ sentences and custodial calculations.

    Mohd. Aslam v. State Of Maharashtra .

    Order

    1. A Designated Court convicted these two appellants, who were arraigned in that Court as A-1 and A-7, along with other accused for different offences. A-1 Mohmed Aslam (@ Sheru Mohd. Hasan) has been convicted under Section 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (hereinafter referred to as “TADA”) besides under Sections 25(1-A) and 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act. He was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years under the first two counts each, besides fine, with a direction that sentence of imprisonment under each count will run concurrently. He filed Criminal Appeal No. 613 of 1999. A-7 Adam Gafoor Shaikh @ Adam Toofani was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code and has been sentenced to life imprisonment. He was also convicted under Section 5 of TADA besides under Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act for which he was sentenced to varying terms of imprisonment which are lesser in duration. He filed Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 1999.

    2. On 24-2-1994 at 8.15 p.m one Amar Bhaskar Suvarna was shot dead in front of Trishna Restaurant at Kala Gohda (near the High Court of Mumbai). Then PW 3 Cyrus was also present. A-1 was arrested on 6-10-1994 and on the strength of the information elicited from him one semi-automatic US carbine magazine along with 113 cartridges were recovered from his own house at Mumbai. A-7 was arrested in March 1995. Confessional statements were recorded under Section 15 of TADA from both the appellants.

    3. The Designated Court found that one of the assailants who fired the firearm at the deceased was A-7 and accordingly he was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code besides other offences. While dealing with the case of A-7 Adam Gafoor Shaikh @ Adam Toofani, we may record here that learned counsel for the appellant frankly conceded that he is not disputing the fact that Amar Bhaskar Suvarna was shot dead in front of Trishna Restaurant around 8.15 p.m on 24-2-1994. So, the limited question to be considered is whether A-7 was one of the assailants who shot him dead.

    4. The case was initiated on the statement recorded from the deceased which became a dying declaration under Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act. In that statement the deceased was not able to state the particulars of the assailants, but he did state that he was then in the company of PW 3 Cyrus. If so, the decisive importance of the testimony of PW 3 need not be described in so many words. PW 3 said in court pointing to A-7 that he is one of the persons who shot at the deceased. (It is unnecessary to mention the name of the other persons who shot him as the conviction passed against the other persons has not been at all challenged in appeals.) PW 3 has also identified A-7 Adam Gafoor Shaikh @ Adam Toofani in a test identification parade conducted on 30-3-1995. The version of PW 3 is further supported by another eyewitness PW 4 Selwaraj Naikar who also identified A-7 Adam Gafoor Shaikh @ Adam Toofani in the court as well as in a test identification parade.

    5. The testimony of the above two eyewitnesses was believed by the TADA Court and their evidence had been relied on. Learned counsel for the appellant made an endeavour to contend that the test identification parade is replete with many lapses and therefore that cannot be used for the purpose of corroborating the testimony of PW 3. We are not told of any serious lapse in the parade conducted by a Magistrate and therefore even if there are some minor lapses that would not help to hold that the test identification parade was vitiated. We too have no reason to doubt the truth of the version given by PW 3 and PW 4. Of course, learned counsel then contended that the time of the occurrence was night and hence it would not have been possible for the eyewitnesses to get a proper glimpse of the assailants. We cannot forget the fact that the incident happened in the city of Mumbai at about 8.15 p.m It was not a time when the city would be dark. PWs 3 and 4 could have seen the assailant in the light of the city. The incident is also of such a nature that the face of the assailants cannot normally fade out from the memory canvas of the eyewitnesses, particularly, PW 3 who was a close associate of the deceased. Therefore, we are not impressed by the said argument of the learned counsel.

    6. As we do not find any reason to disbelieve the testimony of PWs 3 and 4, the conviction and sentence passed on A-7 Adam Gafoor Shaikh @ Adam Toofani do not require any interference.

    7. Regarding A-1 Mohmed Aslam (@ Sheru Mohd. Hasan) the only evidence for possession of the forbidden lethal weapon is the testimony of PW 34 (Nagesh Shivdas Lohar, Assistant Commissioner of Police, CID Intelligence, Mumbai). Learned counsel contended that two panch witnesses who were cited to support the recovery turned hostile and therefore the evidence of PW 34 became unsupported. We cannot agree with the said contention. If panch witnesses turned hostile, which happens very often in criminal cases, the evidence of the person who effected the recovery would not stand vitiated. Nor do we agree with the contention that his testimony is unsupported or uncorroborated. The very fact that PW 34 produced in the court lethal weapons recovered is a very formidable circumstance to support his evidence. Learned counsel made an attempt to show that the recovery in fact was not effected from the said flat in which A-1 Mohmed Aslam (@ Sheru Mohd. Hasan) was residing. It is admitted that A-1's wife and children were residing in that flat. If no such recovery was made from such flat why was nobody examined on the defence side at least to suggest that no police officer effected any recovery from there? As the trial court has chosen to believe the testimony of PW 34 and on a further scrutiny we too have no reason to reject the same, we are emboldened to accept the testimony of that witness.

    8. We, therefore, hold that the Designated Court was right in holding that A-1 was in possession of the lethal weapons which would attract conviction under Section 5 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 besides Sections 25(1-A) and 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act.

    9. Learned counsel lastly made a plea for reduction of the sentence as he is sentenced to RI for 10 years. We pointed out the futility of the said argument in view of the fact that A-1 was already convicted in another case for the offence under Section 302 IPC and was sentenced to imprisonment for life. For him to complete that period of life imprisonment he would have to suffer imprisonment of about 4 years more which will complete almost with the sentence imposed in this case. But learned counsel pointed out that the Designated Court has observed in para 5 of the operative part of the sentencing order that A-1 will not be entitled to set-off under Section 428 of the Criminal Procedure Code for the period between 8-12-1994 to 19-7-1998. The jail authorities shall give the benefit of set-off provided under Section 428 CrPC notwithstanding such observations, if he is otherwise entitled to it as per the law declared by this Court.

    10. These appeals are disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohd. Aslam v. State Of Maharashtra .
    (Apr 27, 2000)