Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was appointed Headmaster of Shri Ramdas High School, Amona, Goa, on 25-5-1990 and confirmed on 1-6-1972. When the private school was taken over by the Government on 1-4-1974, he was transferred to a Government Middle School on a lower pay scale, a move he consistently protested. After periodic representations, the Government issued an order on 16-2-1994 absorbing him as Headmaster of a Government High School with retrospective effect from 1-4-1974 and granted all consequential benefits. Because those benefits were never released, the appellant filed Writ Petition No. 261 of 1996 before the Bombay High Court at Goa. The High Court disposed of the petition on 14-7-1998, permitting the appellant to make a fresh representation and making certain adverse observations about alleged consent to the earlier appointment. Relying on those observations, the State passed an order on 21-1-1999/22-1-1999 rescinding the 16-2-1994 absorption order and denying consequential benefits without notice to the appellant. The present appeal by special leave challenges both the High Court’s observations and the Government’s rescinding order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court’s adverse observations, made while deciding a limited issue concerning consequential benefits, were warranted.
  2. Whether the Government could lawfully rescind the appellant’s absorption as Headmaster and deny consequential benefits without affording him an opportunity of hearing, in light of the principles of natural justice.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the writ petition before the High Court concerned only the release of consequential benefits, and therefore the adverse observations in paragraph 2 of the High Court’s order were “not called for.” Those remarks directly prompted the State’s order of 21-1-1999/22-1-1999 rescinding the appellant’s earlier absorption.

The Court held that the State’s rescinding order violated fundamental principles of natural justice because it was issued without notice to, or hearing of, the appellant. The appellant’s absorption as Headmaster under the 16-2-1994 order had never been challenged in any proceeding, and the benefit conferred could not be withdrawn unilaterally. Because the State acted solely on the High Court’s unsolicited observations, both the High Court’s observations and the consequential State order were unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed. The Supreme Court set aside (i) paragraph 2 of the High Court’s order dated 14-7-1998 and (ii) the Government’s order dated 21-1-1999/22-1-1999. The order of 16-2-1994, which absorbed the appellant as Headmaster of the Government High School with retrospective effect, stands revived. The appellant is permitted to submit a representation for consequential benefits within six weeks, and the Department must decide it within twelve weeks, uninfluenced by the set-aside orders.

The decision restores the appellant’s substantive position and pay benefits but sets no new precedent beyond reaffirming the necessity of adhering to natural justice before rescinding vested rights.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gajanan L. Pernekar v. State Of Goa And Another

    1. Delay condoned.

    2. Leave granted.

    3. The appellant was appointed as the Headmaster of Shri Ramdas High School, Amona, Goa on 25-5-1990 in the pay scale of Rs 325-575. He was confirmed in the post of Headmaster after completion of the period of probation on 1-6-1972. Shri Ramdas High School, which was a private school, was taken over by the Government, along with the staff working in the said School w.e.f 1-4-1974. At the time when the School was taken over, the appellant was drawing his pay in the revised pay scale of Rs 400. After the takeover of the School vide an order dated 13-6-1974, the Government appointed the appellant as Headmaster of Government Middle School at Saligao in the pay scale of Rs 300-25-450-EB-25-600. The appellant protested against his appointment as Headmaster of the Middle School, since earlier he had been working as a Headmaster of the High School. The appellant, after having joined the post of the Headmaster of the Middle School, made various representations. He cited cases of some others to point out the injustice that had been done to him. On 13-1-1993, the appellant was promoted to the post of Deputy Education Officer in the Directorate of Education on ad hoc basis.

    4. The representations made by the appellant from time to time were considered by the Government and on 16-2-1994, an order came to be made whereby the appellant was absorbed as a Headmaster of Government High School with retrospective effect from the date of takeover of the School i.e with effect from 1-4-1974 with all consequential benefits flowing therefrom. The earlier order dated 10-6-1974 was rescinded. Since the consequential benefits, as granted by the Government in its order dated 16-2-1994, were not given to the appellant, he filed Writ Petition No. 261 of 1996 in the High Court of Bombay at Goa. The precise issue raised in the writ petition was with regard to the failure to give consequential benefits to him as flowing from the order of the Government dated 16-2-1994. On 14-7-1998, the writ petition was heard and disposed of. So far as the consequential benefits are concerned, the appellant was given the liberty to make a representation to the Department and the Department was directed to decide that representation within a period of three months from the date of receipt of the representation.

    5. In para 2 of the order of the High Court dated 14-7-1998, the learned Bench observed:

    “2. During the course of hearing it was revealed that the absorption of the petitioner against the post of Headmaster in a Middle School was with his consent. Mr Lotlikar tried to urge that consent was obtained under duress and coercion. It is painful to note that such averment was not incorporated in the petition. We treat this as material suppression. We do not propose to entertain the petition.”

    6. The appellant, being aggrieved of this direction, has filed this appeal by special leave. During the pendency of the proceedings in this Court the Government, influenced by the observations made in para 2 of the order of the High Court dated 14-7-1998 (supra), made an order on 21-1-1999/22-1-1999. The Government not only rejected the request of the appellant for grant of consequential benefits flowing from the earlier order dated 16-2-1994 but even rescinded the order of absorption of the appellant as Headmaster of Government High School without putting the appellant to any notice and without hearing him in that behalf.

    7. It is not disputed before us that the issue before the High Court in Writ Petition No. 261 of 1996 was a limited one, confined to the grant of consequential benefits. The observations made in para 2 (supra) were, in our opinion, strictly speaking, not called for. Those observations have led to the passing of the order dated 21-1-1999/22-1-1999. In the counter filed on behalf of the respondents to the special leave petition, it has been stated in para 2 of the preliminary objections that “the respondents have, in obedience to the High Court's directions passed order dated 22-1-1999 recalling the Government's earlier order dated 16-2-1994 taking a decision on the representations made by the petitioner”.

    8. The manner in which the order dated 21-1-1999/22-1-1999 came to be made was, to say the least, not proper. The appellant was denuded of the benefits of the order dated 16-2-1994 unheard. There has been a breach of the principle of natural justice and a violation of fair play in action. The earlier order made in favour of the appellant as early as on 16-2-1994 was rescinded without giving any opportunity to the appellant to show cause against it. Absorption of the appellant as Headmaster of Government High School by the order dated 16-2-1994 had not been put in issue through any proceedings by any party at any point of time. That benefit could not have been taken away from the appellant without affording him any opportunity of hearing, even where the absorption as Headmaster of the High School had been put in issue. The principles of natural justice have been respected in their breach. The order dated 21-1-1999/22-1-1999 was made by the respondents influenced by the observations contained in para 2 of the order of the High Court (supra), which observations, we have already found, were not at all called for. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the order dated 21-1-1999/22-1-1999 cannot be sustained and we accordingly set it aside. Consequently, we allow this appeal and set aside the observations of the High Court contained in para 2 of its judgment dated 14-7-1998 (supra) as well as the follow-up order made by the State on 21-1-1999/22-1-1999. As a result the order dated 16-2-1994 would stand revived. We grant liberty to the appellant to make a representation to the State Government for grant of consequential benefits flowing from the order of 16-2-1994, as was directed by the High Court itself. In case a representation is filed by the appellant before the Department concerned within six weeks from the date of this order, the same shall be decided by the Department within a period of twelve weeks from the date of the receipt of the copy of the representation. The representation shall be decided by the Department uninfluenced by the order made on 21-1-1999/22-1-1999 as well as the observations made in para 2 of the High Court order (supra), which we have set aside.

    9. The appeal thus succeeds and is allowed in the above terms. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gajanan L. Pernekar v. State Of Goa And Another
    (Aug 16, 1999)