Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1999 INSC 254
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Bihar Sanskrit Education Board Act, 1981 (Act 31 of 1982)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1999 INSC 254
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Bihar Sanskrit Education Board Act, 1981 (Act 31 of 1982)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Shri Umapati Choudhary, originally a Lecturer at Kameshwar Singh Darbhanga Sanskrit University, was deputed in 1981 to serve as Controller of Examinations for the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board (“the Board”). Over time, the Board sought to regularise and permanently absorb him in that post, a proposal to which both the University and the State Government agreed. By notification dated 10-11-1986, the State formally appointed him Controller of Examinations.

In 1982 certain University employees challenged his deputation (CWJC No. 2230 of 1982). A Single Judge of the Patna High Court dismissed that petition on 16-11-1987 but directed the State to frame service conditions for a substantive appointment within six months. Thereafter, in CWJC No. 6054 of 1991, the High Court held on 17-12-1991 that the appellant could not claim permanency with the Board, leading to the termination of his services by orders dated 17-3-1992, 20-3-1992 and 21-3-1992. The appellant filed Civil Appeal No. 336 of 1993 against the 1991 High Court judgment and Writ Petition (C) No. 667 of 1992 to quash the termination orders. The Supreme Court stayed those orders, reinstated the appellant, and he eventually retired in 1996.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant should be regarded as a permanent employee of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board or merely a deputationist from Kameshwar Singh Darbhanga Sanskrit University.
  2. Whether the Patna High Court erred in dismissing the appellant’s writ petition (CWJC No. 6054 of 1991) and upholding the termination of his services.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court traced the appellant’s service history, emphasising that:

  • The deputation was consensual: the lending authority (University), borrowing authority (Board), and the appellant all agreed.
  • Both the Board and the State Government had explicitly approved the appellant’s permanent absorption, and the University had issued its no-objection.
  • No evidence suggested that the deputation or proposed absorption was contrary to public interest or tainted by mala fides.
  • The 1987 Single Judge decision had not invalidated the deputation; it merely required the State to finalise service conditions—a directive with which no subsequent non-compliance was demonstrated.
  • The Division Bench therefore erred in treating the appellant as a mere deputationist and refusing relief. Given that the appellant had already retired, the dispute now concerned only his retiral benefits.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgment dated 17-12-1991 set aside. Termination orders dated 17-3-1992, 20-3-1992 and 21-3-1992 quashed.

Consequences: The appellant is deemed a permanent employee of the Board as of his retirement date, entitling him to full retirement benefits on that basis. The decision provides clarity on the legal effect of consensual deputation followed by governmental and institutional approval for permanent absorption but does not announce a new legal precedent beyond its facts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Umapati Choudhary v. State Of Bihar And Another

    D.P Mohapatra, J.— These two cases are interlinked with each other. Both the cases have been filed by the same person Shri Umapati Choudhary. While Civil Appeal No. 336 of 1993 is directed against the judgment and order dated 17-12-1991 of the Patna High Court in CWJC No. 6054 of 1991, in Writ Petition (C) No. 667 of 1992 the petitioner has sought quashing of the orders dated 17-3-1992, 20-3-1992 and 21-3-1992 filed as Annexures 11, 12 and 13 respectively of the writ petition which appear to have been passed on the basis of the judgment dated 17-12-1991 in CWJC No. 6054 of 1991.

    2. The controversy raised in the case relates to the question whether the appellant should be treated as a permanent employee of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board (for short “the Board”) or he was on deputation to the Board from Kameshwar Singh Darbhanga Sanskrit University (for short “the University”). The High Court having held that the appellant could not claim to be a permanent employee of the Board and his service as Controller of Examinations of the Board having been terminated on that basis, he has filed the two cases.

    3. The factual matrix relevant for appreciating the controversy may be stated thus:

    The Board was constituted under the Bihar Sanskrit Education Board Act, 1981 (Act 31 of 1982) and it was vested with the power to direct, supervise and control Sanskrit education up to Madhyama standard in the State of Bihar. The Chairman of the Board made a request to the University to depute a competent and experienced person to conduct and control the examinations conducted by the Board vide his Letter No. 21/15 dated 29-7-1981. The Registrar of the University by his Letter No. 8105/89 dated 14-8-1981 (Annexure 2 to the SLP) communicated the decision of the University granting permission to the appellant who was then a Lecturer in the Postgraduate Department of the University to be deputed as Controller of Examinations of the Board until further orders. The Government of Bihar in the Department of Education by notification dated 17-9-1982 (Annexure 3) authorised the appellant to discharge all duties and responsibilities of the Controller of Examinations of the Board and made the order effective from the first day of deputation. It appears from the letter of the State Government to the Accountant General, Bihar dated 16-6-1983 (Annexure 4) that the post of Assistant Registrar (Sanskrit Education) which was created in the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Parishad on being transferred to the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board was redesignated as Controller of Examinations. Thereafter the question of confirmation of the appellant on the post of Controller of Examinations was taken up by the Board and by the letter dated 15-9-1983 (Annexure 5) the Chairman of the Board wrote to the State Government recommending his confirmation. It appears from the said letter that the Board took the decision appreciating the efficiency and hard work put in by the appellant as Controller of Examinations took the decision for his confirmation. In the letter dated 20-4-1985 (Annexure 7) of the Registrar of the University addressed to the Chairman of the Board consent of the University for permanent absorption of the appellant on the post of Controller of Examinations of the Board was communicated. Therefore, by a notification dated 10-11-1986 (Annexure 8) issued by the Department of Education of the Government of Bihar the appellant was appointed as Controller of Examinations under the Board on the pay scale of Rs 1000-1820 from the date of issue of the notification till further orders.

    4. Some employees of the University challenged the deputation of the appellant as Controller of Examinations of the Board before the Patna High Court in a writ petition CWJC No. 2230 of 1982 which was disposed of by the Single Judge of the Court by the judgment dated 16-11-1987. The operative portion of the said judgment reads as follows:

    “10. Respondent 3 has been given a temporary appointment and not a substantive appointment. Service conditions for the post of the Controller of Examinations are yet to be provided for. The respondent State Government and the Board are duty bound to decide finally whether they shall have a Controller of Examinations or not and if they decide to have one they must have a procedure to make a substantive appointment. Since the office of the Controller of Examinations is not yet permanently filled by a qualified person, in my view ends of justice shall be satisfied by giving a direction to the State Government to proceed forthwith to decide the mode of appointment and service conditions of the post of Controller of Examinations and make substantive appointment in the said post. The State Government will complete the necessary formalities within six months from today. If such formalities are not completed within six months and the temporary appointment of Respondent 3 is continued any further it shall be open to the petitioners to question the validity and genuineness of the appointment by notification dated 10-1-1987.

    11. In the result, with the directions made above, this application is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.”

    This judgment is under challenge in Civil Appeal No. 336 of 1993.

    5. In pursuance of the aforementioned judgment of the High Court the Secretary of the Board by an order dated 17-3-1992 (Annexure 11 of the writ petition) communicated to the appellant the order of the Chairman terminating his service with immediate effect in anticipation of approval of the Government. The relevant portion of the communication reads as under:

    “In pursuance of the judgment dated 17-12-1991 passed by the Hon'ble High Court in CWJC No. 6054 of 1991 on the above subject and under the order of the Chairman, Bihar Sanskrit Education Board your services are terminated with immediate effect in anticipation of the approval of the Government.”

    6. The decision of the Board to terminate the service of the appellant was approved by the State Government vide notification dated 21-3-1992 (Annexures 14 and 15) issued by the Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Human Resource Development Department, Bihar. These orders are under challenge in the writ petition. Therein by order passed on 27-1-1993 in IA No. 1 of 1992 this Court while issuing notice ordered that in the meantime operation of the impugned orders in Annexure 11 dated 17-3-1992 and Annexure 14 dated 21-3-1992 shall remain stayed. This Court further directed that the petitioner be reinstated as Controller of Examinations and be paid his arrears of salary up to date, within two months from the date of the order, by the Board. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/appellant submitted that in pursuance of the said order the petitioner/appellant continued on the post of Controller of Examinations of the Board and retired from the said post sometime in 1996.

    7. From the contents of the documents discussed in the preceding paragraphs the position that emerges is that since 1981 the appellant was holding the post of Controller of Examinations of the Board. Initially he was brought on deputation from the University and thereafter taking into account his efficiency and sincerity in the job the Board sought permission of the University for regularising his service on that post and sent its recommendation to the State Government. The University also had communicated its consent (no objection) for permanent absorption of the appellant on the post of Controller of Examinations of the Board. Thereafter the appointment to the post was to be made by the Board and the Board had decided to regularise the service of the appellant in the said post. However, the Board sought permission of the State Government which was also accorded.

    8. Deputation can be aptly described as an assignment of an employee (commonly referred to as the deputationist) of one department or cadre or even an organisation (commonly referred to as the parent department or lending authority) to another department or cadre or organisation (commonly referred to as the borrowing authority). The necessity for sending on deputation arises in public interest to meet the exigencies of public service. The concept of deputation is consensual and involves a voluntary decision of the employer to lend the services of his employee and a corresponding acceptance of such services by the borrowing employer. It also involves the consent of the employee to go on deputation or not. In the case at hand all the three conditions were fulfilled. The University, the parent department or lending authority, the Board, the borrowing authority and the appellant, the deputationist, had all given their consent for deputation of the appellant and for his permanent absorption in the establishment of the borrowing authority. There is no material to show that the deputation of the appellant was not in public interest or it was vitiated by favouritism or mala fide. The learned Single Judge in the previous writ petition had neither quashed the deputation order nor issued any direction for its termination. Indeed the learned Single Judge had dismissed the writ petition. No material has been placed before us to show that between November 1987 when the judgment of the Single Judge was rendered and December 1991 when the Division Bench disposed of the writ petition filed by the appellant the petitioners of the previous case had raised any grievance or made any complaint regarding non-compliance with the directions made in the judgment of the learned Single Judge. In these circumstances the Division Bench was clearly in error in declining to grant relief to the appellant. Further, the appellant has, in the meantime, retired from service, and therefore, the decision in the case is relevant only for the purpose of calculating his retiral benefits.

    9. On consideration of the entire matter we are of the view that the High Court was in error in dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellant.

    10. Accordingly the appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment dated 17-12-1991 in CWJC No. 6054 of 1991 is set aside. Consequentially, Writ Petition No. 667 of 1992 is allowed and the orders dated 17-3-1992, 20-3-1992 and 21-3-1992 which are based on the judgment in CWJC No. 6054 of 1991 are quashed. The appellant shall be treated to be a permanent employee of the Board on the date of his retirement from the post of Controller of Examinations and his retirement benefits shall be calculated on that basis. There will, however, be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Umapati Choudhary v. State Of Bihar And Another
    (May 14, 1999)