AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1998 INSC 331
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • National Highway 4 Act (year not specified)
  • Section 92-A as well as Section 110 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1998 INSC 331
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • National Highway 4 Act (year not specified)
  • Section 92-A as well as Section 110 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939
Smart Summary

Case Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was travelling in a bus owned by the respondent-Corporation on 17-10-1983. While the vehicle was stationary at its last stop and passengers were alighting, a bomb exploded inside the bus, causing the appellant serious and permanent leg injuries along with injuries to other passengers. The appellant filed MAC Case No. 64(K) of 1984 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kamrup, Guwahati, seeking Rs 3,82,000 in compensation.

The Tribunal held that the accident arose out of the use of the motor vehicle, found the respondent liable, and on 2-2-1993 awarded Rs 1,20,000 with 12% interest. The respondent appealed (MA(F) No. 72 of 1993). The Guwahati High Court did not disturb the factual findings but ruled that the blast was unrelated to any negligence of the owner or driver and therefore set aside the award. The appellant then approached the Supreme Court. At the notice stage, the Supreme Court called for the entire Tribunal record to verify whether the blast occurred inside the vehicle. After examining those materials, leave was granted on 20-11-1995. The respondent, though served, did not appear before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an injury caused by a bomb explosion inside a stationary bus “arises out of the use” of a motor vehicle so as to confer jurisdiction on a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal.
  2. Whether negligence of the owner or driver was established on the evidence, and if so, whether the High Court erred in reversing the Tribunal’s finding on liability.
  3. Whether the compensation of Rs 1,20,000 with 12% interest fixed by the Tribunal required interference.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Shivaji Dayanu Patil v. Vatschala Uttam More, (1991) 3 SCC 530, asserting that “use” of a motor vehicle includes periods when the vehicle is stationary; hence the accident squarely falls within the Motor Vehicles Act.
  • Pointed to pleadings and evidence accepted by the Tribunal showing lack of police escort during a volatile period and absence of due care by the driver and conductor, thereby establishing negligence.
  • Sought restoration of the Tribunal’s award.

Respondent's Position

The respondent did not enter appearance before the Supreme Court. Its earlier stance before the High Court—that the blast was an event beyond the owner’s or driver’s control and therefore involved no negligence—was noted in the impugned judgment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shivaji Dayanu Patil v. Vatschala Uttam More, (1991) 3 SCC 530 The expression “use of a motor vehicle” covers accidents occurring when the vehicle is stationary; “use” does not cease merely because the vehicle is immobile. Adopted to hold that the bus, though stationary, was in “use” when the bomb exploded, bringing the accident within the Act.
Union of India v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., (1997) 8 SCC 683 Reaffirmation and application of the principle laid down in Shivaji Dayanu Patil. Referenced as recent authority consistent with the above interpretation of “use”.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the Tribunal had expressly recorded negligence based on (i) the admitted fact that the explosion occurred inside the bus, and (ii) evidence of a disturbed atmosphere during the Assam agitation requiring heightened caution, which was absent due to lack of police escort and insufficient care by the driver and conductor. The High Court, while accepting the factual findings, had summarily concluded that a bomb blast could not be attributed to negligence, without dislodging the Tribunal’s reasoning.

Drawing on Shivaji Dayanu Patil, the Court stressed that “use” of a vehicle extends to periods when it is stationary; therefore, an accident arising from a bomb inside a parked bus is covered by the Act. The Supreme Court found no basis to disturb the Tribunal’s quantification of Rs 1,20,000 with 12% interest, holding that the Tribunal’s assessment was sound.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Tribunal’s Award Restored.

The High Court’s judgment was set aside and the original award of Rs 1,20,000 with 12% interest reinstated, subject to crediting the Rs 25,000 already received by the appellant. No order as to costs was made.

Implications are confined to the parties: the appellant receives compensation, and the respondent is liable to pay the balance after accounting for the amount already disbursed. No new legal test was created, but the decision re-affirms that injuries from a bomb explosion inside a stationary vehicle can “arise out of the use” of the vehicle, underscoring the breadth of liability under the Motor Vehicles Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Samir Chanda v. Managing Director, Assam State Transport Corporation .

    K. Venkataswami, J.— In spite of notice of lodgement of petition of the appeal having been served, the respondent has not entered appearance to contest this appeal.

    2. The facts, as found by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kamrup, Guwahati, are given below:

    The appellant was a passenger in a bus belonging to the respondent-Corporation. On 17-10-1983, when the bus reached the last stoppage and when the passengers were alighting from the bus, a bomb exploded inside the bus as a result of which the appellant sustained serious injuries on his legs. The other passengers also suffered serious injuries due to the bomb explosion. On account of this, the appellant preferred MAC Case No. 64(K) of 1984 claiming a compensation of Rs 3,82,000. The Tribunal found that it had jurisdiction to entertain and adjudicate the claim since the bomb had exploded inside the bus. The Tribunal held that the injuries sustained by the appellant were permanent in nature and awarded a compensation of Rs 1,20,000 by order dated 2-2-1993.

    3. Aggrieved by that, the respondent preferred an appeal to the Guwahati High Court in MA (F) No. 72 of 1993. The High Court did not disturb the findings of the Tribunal on facts. However, it was of the view that there was no negligence on the part of the owner or the driver of the vehicle and, therefore, the question of paying compensation did not arise. Accordingly, the High Court set aside the award of the Tribunal.

    4. The appellant aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court has preferred this appeal.

    5. The appellant in his claim petition has categorically stated as follows:

    “On the date of accident, the claimant boarded the bus at Judge's Field in order to go to his residence at Kahilipara. At that time an abnormal situation arose out of the foreigners' deportation movement. The A.S.T.C authority plied the city buses with police help, since before the accident and after the accident. But on the date of the accident, there was no police help in the city bus. The driver of the bus did not take due care and caution in driving the bus.”

    6. In support of that statement, evidence was also given before the Tribunal. In the light of the above averment and evidence, the Tribunal found as follows:

    “It is admitted that the present accident took place when a bomb exploded inside it when the bus stopped at the last stoppage of the route and it was in a stationary condition.

    Here in the case in hand, at the relevant time, the Assam agitation was in full swing which necessitated either the conductor of the bus or its driver to take extra care which was found lacking here and as such the accident, I hold, took place arising out of the use of motor vehicle and both cases are held maintainable.”

    7. After fixing the liability on the respondent, the Tribunal assessed the compensation in a sum of Rs 1,20,000 and awarded the said sum with 12% interest.

    8. The High Court was of the view that there was no question of negligence on the part of the owner or driver of the vehicle. The High Court observed thus:

    “When there is a bomb blast and the accident is caused due to bomb blast, it is not a case of any negligence on the part of the owner or the driver, but because of some other events over which the owner or the driver have no control. Such an accident is not the result of negligence or failure to do some duty. It cannot be said in such a case that there is negligence on the part of the owner or the driver. If there is no negligence on the part of the owner or the driver, the question of paying compensation by the owner or by the driver does not arise. Accordingly, we allow these appeals and set aside the judgment and awards dated 2-2-1993 passed by the Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kamrup at Guwahati in MAC Case No. 64(K) of 1984 and MAC Case No. 65(K) of 1984.”

    9. At the notice stage, this Court by order dated 18-9-1995 observed as follows:

    “The first question which arises for consideration is whether the bomb blast which caused injuries to the petitioner took place outside the motor vehicle and whether the petitioner sustained injuries as a result thereof. The High Court appears to have taken the view that it was so. The jurisdiction of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal depends on the correctness of this finding. The learned counsel for the petitioner wants to produce the entire evidence adduced before the Tribunal to enable proper examination of this finding of the High Court. This be done within eight weeks. List thereafter.”

    10. After perusing the documents produced pursuant to the above order dated 18-9-1995, this Court granted leave on 20-11-1995.

    11. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant invited our attention to a decision of this Court in Shivaji Dayanu Patil v. Vatschala Uttam More (1991) 3 SCC 530 to support and to restore the award of the Tribunal which has been set aside by the High Court. In the said case, there was a collision between a petrol tanker and a truck on a national highway at about 3.00 a.m, as a result of which the tanker went off the road and fell on its left side at a distance of about 20 feet from the highway. As a result of the collision, the petrol contained in the tanker leaked out and collected nearby. About four hours later, an explosion took place in the tanker causing burn injuries to those assembled near it and one such person's legal representative filed claim petition before the Tribunal under Section 92-A as well as under Section 110 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939.

    12. This Court while repelling various arguments put forward repudiating the claim, held as follows:

    “26. These decisions indicate that the word ‘use’, in the context of motor vehicles, has been construed in a wider sense to include the period when the vehicle is not moving and is stationary, being either parked on the road and when it is not in a position to move due to some breakdown or mechanical defect. Relying on the abovementioned decisions, the appellate Bench of the High Court has held that the expression ‘use of a motor vehicle’ in Section 92-A covers accidents which occur both when the vehicle is in motion and when it is stationary. With reference to the facts of the present case, the learned Judges have observed that the tanker in question while proceeding along National Highway 4 (i.e, while in use) after colliding with a motor lorry was lying on the side and that it cannot be claimed that after the collision the use of the tanker had ceased only because it was disabled. We are in agreement with the said approach of the High Court. In our opinion, the word ‘use’ has a wider connotation to cover the period when the vehicle is not moving and is stationary and the use of a vehicle does not cease on account of the vehicle having been rendered immobile on account of a breakdown or mechanical defect or accident. In the circumstances, it cannot be said that the petrol tanker was not in the use at the time when it was lying on its side after the collision with the truck.”

    13. This view has been referred to and applied in a recent decision of this Court in Union of India v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (1997) 8 SCC 683

    14. After going through the judgment of the High Court, we are of the view that the High Court was not right on facts that there was no negligence on the part of the owner or the driver of the bus especially when the appellant has specifically pleaded about the negligence which was accepted by the Tribunal in the light of the pleadings and of the evidence produced before it. The explosion took place inside the bus is an admitted fact and the usual police escort was not there. The High Court, except observing that there was no negligence, has not upset the finding of the Tribunal that the atmosphere during the period of accident was so polluted requiring care on the part of the conductor and the driver of the bus. There cannot be any doubt that the accident arose out of the use of the motor vehicle justifying the claim of the appellant. We are satisfied with the assessment of the Tribunal in quantifying the compensation in a sum of Rs 1,20,000 with interest at the rate of 12%.

    15. In the result, the appeal is allowed, the judgment under appeal is set aside and the award of the Tribunal is restored. There will be no order as to costs.

    16. When the matter was before the High Court, it appears that a sum of Rs 25,000 was given to the appellant and the High Court while disposing of the appeal directed that the amount already paid need not be refunded by the appellant herein. This amount of Rs 25,000 must be given credit to while realising the award amount.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Samir Chanda v. Managing Director, Assam State Transport Corporation .
    (Sep 1, 1998)