Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, a Police Constable in Kanyakumari District, Tamil Nadu, faced departmental proceedings on multiple charges of misconduct, including coercive extraction of gold jewellery, irregular handling of seized property, and improper custodial practices. A regular enquiry conducted by the Deputy Superintendent of Police found the first set of charges proved. After the respondent’s transfer to Tirunelveli District, the Superintendent of Police, Tirunelveli, acting as Disciplinary Authority, dismissed him from service on 21-4-1987. Successive departmental appeals and a review were rejected.

The respondent then filed OA No. 446 of 1991 before the Tamil Nadu Administrative Tribunal. On 6-5-1996, the Tribunal set aside the dismissal on three grounds: (1) non-supply of the enquiry report, (2) lack of competence of the Tirunelveli Superintendent of Police to impose the penalty, and (3) alleged discrimination because co-delinquents received lesser punishment. The State appealed to the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dismissal was vitiated by the non-furnishing of the enquiry officer’s report, in light of later Supreme Court jurisprudence.
  2. Whether the Superintendent of Police, Tirunelveli District, was a competent disciplinary authority after the respondent’s inter-district transfer.
  3. Whether the punishment was discriminatory compared to that imposed on co-delinquents.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (State)

  • The Tribunal’s reliance on the duty to furnish the enquiry report is untenable after the Constitution Bench decision in Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, which made the earlier rule in Ramzan Khan prospective and inapplicable to orders passed before 20-11-1990.
  • The Tirunelveli Superintendent of Police was competent to act because Police Standing Orders permit inter-district transfers; the respondent’s transfer was never challenged.
  • Different treatment of co-delinquents was justified: the Disciplinary Authority disagreed with the enquiry findings for two of them, while a Head Constable was compulsorily retired.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The respondent accepted the State’s contentions on the first two issues but urged that dismissal was still excessive and that, to maintain parity with the Head Constable, the punishment should be reduced to compulsory retirement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar (1993) 4 SCC 727 Held that the requirement to supply the enquiry report is prospective and does not affect disciplinary orders passed before 20-11-1990. Used to reject the Tribunal’s first ground; the respondent’s dismissal (dated 21-4-1987) could not be invalidated on this basis.
Union of India v. Mohd. Ramzan Khan (1991) 1 SCC 588 Recognised the right of the delinquent to receive the enquiry report before punishment is imposed. Cited only to explain that its rule was rendered prospective by Karunakar; therefore, it did not govern the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court agreed with the State that:

  • The Tribunal erred in relying on Ramzan Khan; under Karunakar, non-supply of the enquiry report did not invalidate the 1987 dismissal order.
  • The respondent’s transfer was lawful under the Police Standing Orders, and consequently the Superintendent of Police, Tirunelveli, was a competent disciplinary authority.

However, the Court considered proportionality and parity in punishment. Observing that a Head Constable involved in similar misconduct had been compulsorily retired, the Court held that substituting compulsory retirement for dismissal would “meet the ends of justice.”

Holding and Implications

HELD: The Tribunal’s order is set aside; the penalty of dismissal is replaced with compulsory retirement. The appeal is disposed of with no order as to costs.

Implications: The respondent ceases service through compulsory retirement, receiving whatever benefits accompany that status, while the State avoids reinstatement. The decision turns on established precedent regarding prospective application of natural-justice requirements and does not establish a new legal rule.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Director General Of Police And Others v. G. Dasayan .

    K. Venkataswami, J.— Special leave granted.

    2. Heard counsel on both sides.

    3. The respondent was working as Police Constable in Kanyakumari District, Tamil Nadu. He was proceeded departmentally for the following charges:

    “(i) Highly reprehensible conduct in having demanded and extracted gold jewels weighing 31 grams from one T. Pitchandi Asari, Thangam Jewellers, Alexandria Press Road, Nagercoil, under coercion on 28-5-1983 with other members of Crime Detective Party.
    (ii) In having not issued with any receipt to the said T. Pitchandi Asari, or in not having seized the said jewels under proper mahazar; and
    (iii) In not having showed the jewels in any of the crimes investigated by the Crime Detective Party.
    II. Highly reprehensible conduct as a member of Crime Detective Party:
    (i) In not having shown the arrest of one Henry Victor and Shahul Hameed concerned in CCS No. 257 of 1983 under Sections 457/380 IPC which was registered on 12-5-1983 on the complaint of T. Dennison and keeping the accused for a number of days without any record;
    (ii) In having not recovered the property under proper mahazar and not properly accounted for the cloth and money recovered from various places in Tamil Nadu.
    (iii) In having charged the actual properties recovered in Cr. No. 257 of 1983 under Sections 457, 380 IPC by changing the high quality cloth into cheaper quality of cloth while sending them in Form 95 to the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nagercoil, the receipt of which was acknowledged on 22-7-1983 in RP No. 490 of 1983.”

    4. The respondent was tried along with one Head Constable and two Police Constables. Regular enquiry was held by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Thuckalay (Kanyakumari District), who found that the first count of the charge had been proved but not the second one. In the meanwhile, the respondent was transferred to Tirunelveli District. The other co-delinquents were also transferred to another neighbouring district. The Disciplinary Authority for the respondent, at the relevant time, was the Superintendent of Police, Tirunelveli, who concurred with the Report of the Enquiry Officer and imposed the punishment of dismissal from service by an order dated 21-4-1987. The appeal filed by the respondent to the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Tirunelveli, was dismissed on 9-12-1987. The review filed to the Director General of Police was also rejected on 5-2-1990.

    5. Therefore, the respondent moved the Tamil Nadu Administrative Tribunal, Madras, by filing OA No. 446 of 1991. The Tribunal by an order dated 6-5-1996 set aside the order of dismissal mainly on the ground that the Enquiry Report was not furnished to the respondent herein before the impugned order was passed and that the authority competent to pass the order of dismissal was the Superintendent of Police, Kanyakumari District, where the respondent was working when the charge was framed. According to the Tribunal, the transfer was for administrative purpose pending enquiry and he should have been retransferred after the enquiry was over and the final order should have been passed by the Superintendent of Police, Kanyakumari District. One other ground also was given by the Tribunal for setting aside the order of dismissal, namely, that the co-delinquents were let off without any punishment except the Head Constable, who was only compulsorily retired. Though the charges were identical, the punishment imposed, according to the Tribunal, being discriminatory cannot be sustained.

    6. Aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, the present appeal by special leave has been preferred by the appellants.

    7. Mr Mariarputham, learned counsel for the appellants, submitted that the first ground of the Tribunal for setting aside the order of dismissal is no longer sustainable in view of the judgment of this Court in Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar (1993) 4 SCC 727, (1993) 25 ATC 704. In that case, a Constitution Bench of this Court held that the ruling in Ramzan Khan case (1991) 1 SCC 588, (1991) 16 ATC 505 is prospective in application and no order of punishment made before 20-11-1990 can be tested on the basis of the law laid down in Ramzan Khan case (1991) 1 SCC 588, (1991) 16 ATC 505. Therefore, the order passed in this case being on 21-4-1987 the law laid down in Ramzan Khan case (1991) 1 SCC 588, (1991) 16 ATC 505 will have no application and, therefore, the order of the Tribunal on that score cannot be supported.

    8. On the second ground that the Superintendent of Police, Tirunelveli District, was not the competent authority, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the Tribunal was not right in assuming that the transfer was for administrative purpose and during the pendency of enquiry as the Police Standing Orders enabled the transfer of Constable of one district to another district. The relevant PSO was produced which reads that a Police Constable is liable to serve anywhere in the State. The order of transfer from Kanyakumari District to Tirunelveli District at the relevant time was not challenged. Therefore, this ground of the Tribunal in setting aside the order of dismissal cannot also be supported. The third ground that the co-delinquents except the Head Constable were let off though the charges were identical, it is stated by the learned counsel for the appellants that the Disciplinary Authority did not agree with the findings of the Enquiry Officer so far as those two delinquents were concerned. However, the Head Constable, who was also charged along with the respondent, was compulsorily retired by the Disciplinary Authority.

    9. Mr Murlidhar, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, while agreeing with the contentions of the learned counsel for the appellants on the first two grounds, submitted that the order of dismissal at any rate cannot be sustained and if at all an order of compulsory retirement as was made in the case of the Head Constable, who was tried along with the respondent, has to be imposed.

    10. We have perused the order of the Tribunal and the relevant documents. We find merit in the arguments of the learned counsel for the appellants. At the same time, we are of the view that as pointed out by the learned counsel for the respondent that a punishment of compulsory retirement in the case of the respondent as well would meet the ends of justice on the facts and circumstances of this case.

    11. Accordingly, we set aside the order of the Tribunal and in the place of order of dismissal passed by the Disciplinary Authority, the order of compulsory retirement is substituted. The appeal will stand disposed of accordingly with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Director General Of Police And Others v. G. Dasayan .
    (Jan 28, 1998)