Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not mentioned in the excerpt, but a general example)
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1971
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not mentioned in the excerpt, but a general example)
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1971
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents—twenty contract labourers—have been working continuously since 1988 in the Eastern Railway printing press at Calcutta. They were supplied by M/s Bandel Handling Porters' Cooperative Society Ltd. under various contracts, most recently Agreement No. S/489.BI/Contract/Handling/NH/94 dated 22-11-1994. Claiming that their work was perennial in nature and that they had attained temporary status, the respondents sought absorption and regularisation in Group D posts of the Eastern Railway.

They filed OA No. 1045 of 1995 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Calcutta. By order dated 13-3-1997, the CAT directed the Eastern Railway to absorb those petitioners who were still working, subject to availability of perennial work and fitness, and to pay them at the minimum of the appropriate Group D scale within eight weeks.

The Eastern Railway and its officers (appellants) challenged that order before the Supreme Court by special leave, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether labourers engaged through a cooperative society can claim absorption and regularisation as Group D employees of the Eastern Railway.
  2. Whether a relationship of employer and employee existed between the Eastern Railway and the respondents.
  3. Whether the Central Administrative Tribunal possessed jurisdiction to entertain the respondents’ application.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The respondents were employees of the cooperative society, not of the Eastern Railway; hence no employer-employee relationship existed.
  • Clauses of the 22-11-1994 agreement established that the society, not the Railway, was responsible for the labourers.
  • The respondents therefore had no right to seek absorption or regularisation in Group D posts.
  • The CAT lacked jurisdiction to entertain OA No. 1045 of 1995.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The CAT’s directions were fair and appropriate in view of their continuous and uninterrupted service on perennial work.
  • No interference was warranted under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Biswa Nath Saha v. Union of India, (1998) 5 SCC 304 Held that contract labour intermittently requisitioned by the Railway are not Railway employees and that the CAT lacks jurisdiction over their claims. The Court distinguished this precedent, noting that in the present case the respondents belonged to an existing cooperative society continuously supplying labour for perennial work; hence the factual matrix differed and did not bar CAT’s jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found the appellants’ affidavit “as vague as it could be,” containing no specific denial of the respondents’ continuous and perennial service. Distinguishing Biswa Nath Saha, the Court emphasised that:

  • The respondents formed part of an established cooperative society already fulfilling the Railway’s perennial labour needs, unlike the intermittent requisitions in Biswa Nath Saha.
  • The CAT’s directions were discretionary, allowing absorption only to the extent of available perennial work and subject to fitness, thereby protecting the Railway’s operational interests.

Given these facts, the Court deemed the CAT’s order “quite fair” and declined to exercise its discretionary power under Article 136 to interfere. It expressly stated that the order was passed “in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case,” leaving the broader legal question open.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court affirmed the CAT’s order dated 13-3-1997 directing conditional absorption of the respondents as Group D employees.

Implications: The respondents may now be absorbed, subject to the CAT’s conditions, and receive Group D pay at the minimum of the relevant scale. The decision is fact-specific and leaves the general legal questions concerning contract labour and CAT jurisdiction unresolved, setting no new precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Others v. Subir Mukharji And Others

    S.P Kurdukar, J.— This appeal by special leave is filed by the appellants challenging the correctness of the judgment and order dated 13-3-1997 passed in OA No. 1045 of 1995 by the Central Administrative Tribunal (for short “CAT”), Calcutta.

    2. The respondents who are 20 in number filed OA No. 1045 of 1995 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Calcutta alleging inter alia that they have been working as labourers since 1988 till date continuously and uninterruptedly in the printing press of the Eastern Railway at Calcutta. They were engaged as labourers through a contractor, viz., M/s Bandel Handling Porters' Cooperative Society Ltd. Several labourers were also engaged by different organizations/labour contractors for doing the work on several development projects undertaken by the Eastern Railway on contract basis. The contracts were entered into between the said Cooperative Society and the authorities of the Eastern Railway. The respondents have been performing their duties and the functions to the satisfaction of the appellants and no complaint of whatsoever nature was made against their work. They were initially paid daily wages @ Rs 14 per day which came to be enhanced to Rs 31 per day. It is then alleged that since they have been working for all these years uninterruptedly and continuously, they are entitled to be absorbed and regularised in Group D category in terms of the Rules and Regulations framed by the Railway authorities. The respondents further averred that by reason of continuous and uninterrupted service for all these years, they have acquired the temporary status and they are entitled to be absorbed in Group D in the pay scale attached thereto. It is then alleged that the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act and Rules were enacted in the year 1971 for the purpose of ameliorating the grievance of the contract labourers who have been engaged by the contractors. In the instant case though these respondents discharge their duties and functions under the principal employer through the agency of the said Society but the principal employer, namely, the Eastern Railway is now denying the legitimate right to them for being absorbed and regularised in the Railway services. The respondents have annexed with their OA various documents to indicate their service record. They have also referred to various correspondence that ensued between the Railway authority and the said Society. The respondents, therefore, prayed that suitable directions be issued to the appellants to absorb and regularize the services of these respondents in Group D in the pay scale attached thereto and the appellants be restrained from terminating the services of any of these respondents.

    3. Appellants 1 to 5 have filed their reply denying the claim made by the respondents. According to them they were employees of the Society and they are not in any way liable either to absorb and/or regularize them in Group D. They are also not entitled to claim the pay scale of Group D employees. The CAT on appraisal of evidence on record by its order dated 13-3-1997 upheld the claims set up by the respondents and issued the following directions:

    “The application is, therefore, disposed of with a direction upon the respondents to absorb the petitioners as regular Group D employees or such of them who may be required to do the quantum of work which may be available on a perennial basis, if they are otherwise found fit, their pay or wages being fixed at the minimum of the appropriate scale, provided they are still working as contract labourers. This exercise shall be completed within 8 weeks from the date of communication of this order.”

    It is this order which is the subject-matter of challenge in this appeal.

    4. Mr N.N Goswami, learned Senior Counsel appearing in support of this appeal urged that the respondents being the employees of the Society, the appellants are not their employers. Notwithstanding the fact that the work allotted to the Society was carried out by the respondents who were labourers of the said Society, there was no relationship of employer and employee between them. He also drew our attention to some of the clauses of the agreement dated 22-11-1994 entered into between the said Society and the CMM (BI), Eastern Railway, Calcutta. He, therefore, urged that the respondents have no right whatsoever to seek direction for absorption and regularisation as Group D employees of the Eastern Railway. During the course of arguments he urged that the CAT has no jurisdiction to entertain OA No. 1045 of 1995 filed by the respondents.

    5. The learned counsel for the respondents supported the order and urged that in the facts and circumstances of the case the directions contained in the order dated 13-3-1997 are quite fair and do not call for any interference in exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution.

    6. We heard learned counsel for the parties at great length and perused the pleadings of the parties and documents on record. In our opinion the affidavit in reply filed on behalf of Appellants 1 to 5 is as vague as it could be. There is no specific denial to the averments in the OA filed by the respondents that they have been working continuously and uninterruptedly since 1988, that the nature of work which they have been doing is of perennial nature.

    7. Mr Goswami strongly relied upon the judgment of this Court in Biswa Nath Saha v. Union of India (1998) 5 SCC 304 with other connected civil appeals and special leave petitions rendered on 3-4-1997.

    8. We have gone through this judgment and it appears to us that in the case of Biswa Nath Saha (1998) 5 SCC 304 the contract labourers were requisitioned intermittently by the authority of the Eastern Railway as and when there was work and on such requisition the labour contractor used to supply the labourers. Moreover the said order appears to be a consent order as is clear from the following observation:

    “… since the contractor's labour cannot be considered as employed by the Railways. The Eastern Railway however, in the affidavit filed on its behalf by Shri B. Maji, Chief Mechanical Engineer (Planning), Eastern Railway, Calcutta dated 13th April, 1993 has offered, on humanitarian grounds, that the contractor's labourers can form their cooperative societies and participate in handling and other contracts issued by the Railways from time to time. The appellants/petitioners state that they will accept the scheme. It is directed accordingly.”

    It is in these circumstances this Court held that the CAT has no jurisdiction to entertain the application filed on behalf of the railway contractor's labourers.

    9. There is a distinguishing feature in the case before us. In the present case admittedly the respondents who were labourers of M/s Bandel Handling Porters' Cooperative Society Ltd., were given the work under Agreement No. S/489.BI/Contract/Handling/NH/94 dated 22-11-1994. Therefore, there was already a Society of which the respondents happened to be members and being the members M/s Bandel Handling Porters' Cooperative Society Ltd., the contractor supplied them for doing the work of Eastern Railway. As indicated earlier there is no denial on the part of Appellants 1 to 5 that the work which the respondents have been doing is of perennial nature. Even otherwise the directions issued by the CAT in its order dated 13-3-1997 have given enough discretion to the Eastern Railway to absorb them as regular Group D employees bearing in mind the quantum of work available on perennial basis and subject to their fitness. In our opinion the directions contained in the order dated 13-3-1997 passed by the CAT are quite fair in the facts and circumstances of the case and it is for this reason we are not inclined to interfere with the impugned order in exercise of our jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution.

    10. This order is being passed in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and leaving the question of law open.

    11. For the aforesaid conclusions we do not find any reason to interfere with the order dated 13-3-1997 passed in OA No. 1045 of 1997 by the CAT. We accordingly dismiss this appeal but however there will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. Subir Mukharji And Others
    (Apr 29, 1998)