Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1997 INSC 685
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 438 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Section 437(1) of the Code
  • Section 438 of the Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1997 INSC 685
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 438 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • Section 437(1) of the Code
  • Section 438 of the Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents, Bimal Krishna Kundu and his son Hrishakesh Kundu, owned Eureka Printers Pvt. Ltd. They were previously engaged by the Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission (PSC) to print examination question papers. Following a 1993 question-paper leak, the State black-listed them on 6-1-1994. Despite this, further leaks occurred in examinations held in December 1996 and March 1997. Investigations in Crime Nos. 31/1997 and 45/1997 revealed: (i) the respondents allegedly continued printing PSC papers by using the name of one S.K. Saha and the firm “Manjusree Printers, Bangalore,” and (ii) they purportedly masqueraded as owners of “Nisarge Printers, Bangalore” to secure printing work for the Intermediate examination of the Board of Intermediate Education, in conspiracy with certain Board officials.

While the CID investigation was underway, the respondents sought anticipatory bail before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh. A learned Single Judge granted bail on 20-6-1997. The State of Andhra Pradesh, aggrieved by that order, filed the present appeals before the Supreme Court. Special leave was granted, and the Supreme Court rendered the instant judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court correctly exercised discretion under Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) in granting anticipatory bail to the respondents accused of conspiracy and question-paper leakage.
  2. Whether the nature of the offences—being punishable with imprisonment of less than life—was a legally sustainable ground for granting anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State of Andhra Pradesh)

  • Pointed to statements of proof-reader Smt. Aruna Kumari and her husband K.P. Rao indicating that S.K. Saha worked as a proof-reader in the respondents’ Calcutta press and that the questioned papers were printed there.
  • Relied on the confessional statement of accused Ramabrahmam showing the respondents’ press was the source of the leaked papers.
  • Contended that granting anticipatory bail would hamper investigation into a well-orchestrated conspiracy affecting “millions of students.”

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pokar Ram v. State of Rajasthan (1985) 2 SCC 597; AIR 1985 SC 969 Considerations for granting anticipatory bail are materially different from those governing post-arrest or appellate bail. The Court invoked this distinction to fault the High Court for importing Section 437 considerations into a Section 438 context.
State Rep. by the C.B.I. v. Anil Sharma (1997) 7 SCC 187; JT (1997) 7 SC 651 Criteria for anticipatory bail need not mirror those for bail after arrest. Cited to reinforce that pre-arrest bail demands stricter scrutiny, underscoring the High Court’s error in approach.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that the Single Judge granted anticipatory bail primarily because the alleged offences were not punishable with death or life imprisonment. The Court emphasized:

  • Section 438 CrPC applies to all non-bailable offences; it does not create a sub-classification based on maximum punishment. Unlike Section 437(1), Section 438 contains no textual basis for distinguishing offences punishable with life imprisonment from lesser offences.
  • The High Court improperly “telescoped” considerations under Section 437 (post-arrest bail) into the anticipatory-bail framework of Section 438.
  • Precedents in Pokar Ram and Anil Sharma underscore that anticipatory-bail determinations require distinct, more stringent considerations than ordinary bail.
  • The accusations involve a “well-orchestrated conspiracy” affecting the academic careers of “millions of students.” Granting pre-arrest bail would likely impede investigation, particularly custodial interrogation necessary to uncover the full extent of the conspiracy.
  • The Single Judge’s conclusion that materials did not “indicate any nexus” was contradicted by witness statements cited by the State linking the respondents’ press to the leaked papers.

Holding and Implications

Order: Appeals allowed; the High Court’s order granting anticipatory bail to the respondents is quashed.

Implications: The respondents are now subject to arrest and custodial interrogation, facilitating continued investigation into the alleged conspiracy. The judgment reinforces that courts must not conflate Section 437 and Section 438 considerations and highlights the stricter scrutiny applicable to anticipatory-bail petitions. No new legal doctrine was created, but existing principles on anticipatory bail were re-affirmed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of A.P v. Bimal Krishna Kundu And Another

    K.T Thomas, J.— Special leave granted.

    2. The State of Andhra Pradesh is very much aggrieved by the order of a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh granting anticipatory bail to the respondents in this case. Hence the State has filed these appeals challenging the said order dated 20-6-1997.

    3. A summary of the facts necessary for disposal of these appeals is the following:

    First respondent Bimal Krishna Kundu and his son Hrishakesh Kundu (who is second respondent) were owners of a printing press run by M/s Eureka Printers Pvt. Ltd. They were engaged by the Public Service Commission of the State of Andhra Pradesh (PSC for short) for printing question papers set for the examination conducted by the PSC. In the year 1993, there was leakage of question papers and it was revealed then that the printers were also responsible for such leakage. The Government of Andhra Pradesh by order dated 6-1-1994 blacklisted the respondents. However, such blacklisting did not put a stoppage to leaking of question papers even in later years for such examinations conducted by the PSC. In respect of one such examination held in December 1996 and another held in March 1997 Government had to cancel the examinations consequent on serious allegations that question papers leaked out before the examinations. Thereupon the Hyderabad Police registered two crime cases and the CID police took up investigation thereof. (Crime No. 31 of 1997 and Crime No. 45 of 1997) During investigation it was revealed to the police that despite blacklisting of the respondents they managed to obtain the printing work of question papers in collusion with the Secretary of the PSC by putting forward the name of one S.K Saha as owner of M/s Manjusree Printers, Bangalore. But according to the appellant, the question papers were actually printed in the press of the respondents at Calcutta and that S.K Saha was a mere name lender. It was also revealed that the respondents personated themselves as owners of yet another printing establishment called Nisarge Printers, Bangalore and obtained printing work of question papers for the Intermediate examination conducted by the Board of Intermediate Education. For this a criminal conspiracy was hatched by the respondents with some officers of the Board of Intermediate Education. It was at the said stage that the respondents approached the High Court for anticipatory bail.

    4. Learned Single Judge who granted the order in favour of the respondents apprised himself of the gravity of the crime in the following words:

    “It is no doubt true that leakage of question papers of Intermediate examination is a heinous and unpardonable crime. It may be seen that some persons tried to make business in lakhs and crores of rupees by selling these papers without caring for the consequences. Obviously the career of millions of students who have taken the Intermediate examination can be said to have been adversely affected.”

    5. After perusing the materials on record learned Single Judge persuaded himself to grant anticipatory bail, mainly for the following reasoning:

    “That being so, what are the offences that can be said to have been made out is the question for consideration. It is fairly stated by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor that the offences made out against these petitioners are punishable under Sections 420, 468 and 406 IPC. Be it noted that they are all first-class offences (sic) and not punishable with death or imprisonment for life. Moreover, the investigation appears to have been completed to a great extent. Even if custodial interrogation of the Kundus, who are seeking anticipatory bail is requested, there can be no objection to interrogate them.”

    (It is evident that by the words “first-class offences” learned Single Judge would only have meant “offences triable by a Magistrate of First Class”.)

    6. It is apparent that learned Single Judge has chosen to exercise the discretion envisaged in Section 438 of the Code on the ground that the offences involved are not punishable with death or imprisonment for life. It must be remembered that Section 438 of the Code applies to all non-bailable offences and not merely to offences punishable with death or imprisonment for life. It is also to be remembered that applicability of the section is not confined to offences triable exclusively by the Court of Session.

    7. There is no indication in Section 438 of the Code for justifying a hiatus to be made among non-bailable offences vivisecting those punishable with death or imprisonment for life and those others punishable with less than life imprisonment. No doubt such a classification is indicated in Section 437(1) of the Code, but that section is concerned only with post-arrest bail and not pre-arrest bail. Learned Single Judge seems to have telescoped considerations contemplated in Section 437 into the amplitude of the discretion envisaged in Section 438 of the Code.

    8. A three-Judge Bench of this Court has stated in Pokar Ram v. State of Rajasthan (1985) 2 SCC 597, AIR 1985 SC 969:

    “5. Relevant considerations governing the court's decision in granting anticipatory bail under Section 438 are materially different from those when an application for bail by a person who is arrested in the course of investigation as also by a person who is convicted and his appeal is pending before the higher court and bail is sought during the pendency of the appeal.”

    9. Similar observations have been made by us in a recent judgment in State v. Anil Sharma (1997) 7 SCC 187, JT (1997) 7 SC 651:

    “The consideration which should weigh with the Court while dealing with a request for anticipatory bail need not be the same as for an application to release on bail after arrest.”

    10. Learned Single Judge has observed after examining the materials on record that:

    “Even Section 164 CrPC statement of Aruna Kumari, proof-reader, who is mainly responsible for the leakage of question papers also does not indicate any nexus between these accused petitioners and the persons who leaked out the above question papers.”

    11. Learned counsel for the State of Andhra Pradesh invited our attention to the fact that in the statement recorded during investigation from Smt Aruna Kumari, who is a proof-reader of the printing press of the respondents at Calcutta, and also in the statement of her husband K.P Rao the fact that S.K Saha was working as proof-reader in English and Sanskrit in the press of the respondents at Calcutta, has clearly been made out and that question papers for the crucial examination conducted by the PSC were actually printed in the press of the respondents was also revealed by those witnesses. Learned counsel for the appellant has further invited our attention to yet another fact that in the confessional statement of another accused (Ramabrahmam) it was revealed that the question papers were printed in the press of the respondents and the witness too was privy to the leakage.

    12. We are strongly of the opinion that this is not a case for exercising the discretion under Section 438 in favour of granting anticipatory bail to the respondents. It is disquieting that implications of arming the respondents, when they are pitted against this sort of allegations involving well-orchestrated conspiracy, with a pre-arrest bail order, though subject to some conditions, have not been taken into account by the learned Single Judge. We have absolutely no doubt that if the respondents are equipped with such an order before they are interrogated by the police it would greatly harm the investigation and would impede the prospects of unearthing all the ramifications involved in the conspiracy. Public interest also would suffer as a consequence. Having apprised himself of the nature and seriousness of the criminal conspiracy and the adverse impact of it on “the career of millions of students”, learned Single Judge should not have persuaded himself to exercise the discretion which Parliament had very thoughtfully conferred on the Sessions Judges and the High Courts through Section 438 of the Code, by favouring the respondents with such a pre-arrest bail order.

    13. In the result, we allow these appeals and quash the order of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh granting anticipatory bail to the respondents in this case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of A.P v. Bimal Krishna Kundu And Another
    (Oct 3, 1997)