AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The second respondent was a Tax Inspector in the notified area of Nagar Palika, Nataur. On 26-05-1973, the Chairman of the Nagar Palika found him sleeping during office hours and called for an explanation from him and others. Instead of providing an explanation, the second respondent lodged a criminal report against the Chairman.

The second respondent was suspended and served with a charge-sheet containing nine serious charges. He was required to submit his explanation within 15 days and indicate names of any witnesses he wished to examine. Despite repeated reminders, he did not submit any explanation. A registered letter dated 06-10-1977/11-10-1977 again directed him to respond to the charge-sheet dated 23-07-1974; in response, he demanded copies of 65 documents. On 09-11-1977, another registered notice asked him to submit his explanation after inspecting the relevant records, but he neither inspected the records nor submitted an explanation. Multiple subsequent notices were sent without eliciting compliance. Consequently, on 21-01-1978, he was dismissed from service.

Meanwhile, the second respondent filed two suits challenging the suspension orders, which were transferred to the Uttar Pradesh Public Services Tribunal. By order dated 28-11-1980, the Tribunal dismissed both suits on the ground that the second respondent had not exhausted the departmental appellate remedy against the dismissal order. The High Court allowed the second respondent’s writ petition, reasoning that since he had been allowed to amend his suit to challenge the dismissal order, the Tribunal ought not to have dismissed the matter for non-availing of the alternative departmental appeal.

Rather than remanding the matter to the Tribunal for merits adjudication, the High Court relied upon certain observations of the Tribunal and set aside the dismissal, holding that no enquiry was held, no opportunity to inspect the record was provided, and no copy of the enquiry report was furnished with the show-cause notice. The present order allows the appeal against the High Court’s decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of dismissal was vitiated for lack of a proper enquiry, denial of opportunity (including inspection of records), and non-supply of the enquiry report with the show-cause notice.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in setting aside the dismissal by relying on the Tribunal’s observations instead of remanding the matter for a decision on merits, particularly when the second respondent had failed to respond to the charge-sheet despite repeated opportunities.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, (1993) 4 SCC 727; (1993) 25 ATC 704 The non-supply of the enquiry report does not, by itself, vitiate the disciplinary proceedings. Used to reject the contention that failure to provide a copy of the enquiry report rendered the enquiry and dismissal invalid.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court found the High Court’s approach flawed because it relied on the Tribunal’s observations without addressing the respondent’s sustained non-cooperation with the disciplinary process. The Tribunal’s observations—that there was no enquiry, no opportunity to inspect the records, and no copy of the enquiry report furnished—failed to account for the following undisputed facts:

  • The second respondent was repeatedly called upon over several years to respond to a charge-sheet containing nine serious charges but did not submit any explanation.
  • He was expressly asked to inspect the relevant records before filing his explanation, yet he chose not to inspect the records and instead demanded copies of 65 documents without following through.
  • Because of his failure to reply to the charge-sheet or appear before the Enquiry Officer, the Enquiry Officer proceeded to assess the charges on the basis of the material available.

The Court held that conducting the enquiry on the available material, in the face of the charged employee’s non-participation despite repeated opportunities, “cannot be considered as a negation of the principles of natural justice.” The non-supply of the enquiry report did not, in view of Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, vitiate the proceedings.

Accordingly, the High Court’s setting aside of the dismissal order—based solely on the Tribunal’s observations and without remanding the matter for a merits determination—was incorrect. The disciplinary action was upheld as legally sustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed; the High Court’s order is set aside; the dismissal of the second respondent from service is upheld.

Implications: The interim order dated 23-11-1989, which had granted a limited stay confined to back wages and directed reinstatement with salary thereafter, now comes to an end. Since the dismissal is upheld, no back wages are payable. The decision turns on the specific procedural history and the respondent’s failure to participate in the enquiry; it applies the principle that non-supply of the enquiry report does not automatically invalidate proceedings, and it sets no broader new precedent beyond the application of the cited authority.

    Nagar Palika, Nataur v. U.P Public Services Tribunal, Lucknow And Others

    Order

    1. The second respondent was at the material time holding the post of Tax Inspector in the notified area of Nagar Palika, Nataur. On 26-5-1973, the Chairman of the Nagar Palika found Respondent 2 sleeping during office hours. The Chairman asked the second respondent and others to submit an explanation as to why they were sleeping during duty hours. The second respondent instead of giving the explanation filed a criminal report against the Chairman at the local police station. The second respondent was suspended from service and was served with a charge-sheet containing nine serious charges. In the charge-sheet, it was stated that Respondent 2 should submit his explanation within 15 days and also that if the second respondent wanted to examine certain witnesses, names of such witnesses should also be mentioned in the explanation. Despite repeated reminders, Respondent 2 did not submit any explanation. Ultimately a letter dated 6-10-1977/11-10-1977 was sent by registered post to the second respondent directing him to submit his explanation to the charge-sheet dated 23-7-1974. Instead of submitting any explanation, Respondent 2 sent a letter in which he demanded copies of 65 documents. On 9-11-1977, the appellant again served a registered notice to Respondent 2 for submitting his explanation after inspecting the relevant record. But the second respondent did not inspect the relevant record and did not submit his explanation. Several subsequent notices were also sent to the second respondent. Ultimately since the second respondent did not submit any explanation, an order was passed dismissing the second respondent from service on 21-1-1978. In the meanwhile, the second respondent had filed two suits challenging the orders of suspension which were later transferred to the Uttar Pradesh Public Services Tribunal.

    2. The Tribunal vide its order dated 28-11-1980 dismissed both the suits of the second respondent on the ground that the second respondent had not exhausted the remedy of a departmental appeal against the order of dismissal. The High Court, however, has allowed the writ petition filed by the second respondent on the ground that looking to the fact that the second respondent was allowed to amend his suit to challenge the order of dismissal also, it was not proper on the part of the Tribunal to dismiss the suit on the ground that the alternative remedy of departmental appeal was not availed of by the second respondent.

    3. Instead of remanding the matter to the Tribunal for decision on merit, the High Court, however, has relied upon observations made by the Tribunal and has come to the conclusion that the order of dismissal is illegal. It has set aside the order of dismissal. The observations on which the High Court has relied are to the effect that no enquiry at all was held in this case and no opportunity to inspect the record was given to the second respondent. The Tribunal has also observed that no copy of the Enquiry Report was sent along with the show-cause notice and hence there was no proper enquiry. These observations of the Tribunal have failed to take into account the fact that despite repeated reminders spreading over a number of years, the second respondent failed to give any reply to the charge-sheet which was served upon him. It also failed to take into account the fact that although the second respondent was asked to inspect the record, he did not inspect the record. It was because of this failure on the part of the second respondent to reply to the charge-sheet or to appear before the Enquiry Officer that the charges were held proved by the Enquiry Officer on the basis of the material which was available before him. This cannot be considered as a negation of the principles of natural justice. The fact that the copy of the Enquiry Report was not given to the second respondent will not vitiate the proceedings, in view of the decision of this Court in Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar (1993) 4 SCC 727, (1993) 25 ATC 704.

    4. The appeal is allowed and the order of the High Court is set aside. The order of dismissal is upheld. However, pursuant to an interim order dated 23-11-1989 which was passed by this Court in the present proceedings a limited stay of the impugned order was granted, confined to the payment of back wages. The appellants were directed to reinstate the second respondent on the post which he was holding and pay him the salary due to him thereafter. The interim order now comes to an end. Since we have upheld the order of dismissal, there is no question of granting any back wages.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nagar Palika, Nataur v. U.P Public Services Tribunal, Lucknow And Others
    (Nov 4, 1997)