Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 3 December 1981 at approximately 2:30 p.m., Natheshwar Mandal was fatally assaulted with a dabiya and a kulhari while returning from the field of one Ekbal Mandal in Khairpur Bahiyar, Bihar. Eyewitnesses—including Rudan Mandal (PW 11) and several villagers—testified that the assailants were Dasrath Mandal and Baleshwar Mandal, who fled after the attack. Investigating Officer Rajnandan Singh (PW 15) arrived at about 4:30 p.m., recorded the fardbayan of PW 11, prepared an inquest report and site-plan, and seized blood-stained earth and clothing. The First Information Report (FIR) was registered the next day on the basis of the fardbayan.

The appellants were tried in Sessions Trial No. 333 of 1982 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhagalpur, convicted under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, and sentenced to life imprisonment. The Patna High Court dismissed their appeals. The present judgment is the Supreme Court’s decision on their further appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether serious procedural lapses by the Investigating Officer—such as failing to send seized blood-stained articles for chemical examination and omitting to record the time of witness examinations in the case diary—vitiated the trial and caused prejudice to the appellants.
  2. Whether an alleged delay in lodging the FIR undermined the prosecution case and required acquittal.
  3. Whether the absence of the appellants’ names in the inquest report cast doubt on the authenticity of the fardbayan and the prosecution narrative.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Investigating Officer violated Section 172 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) and Rule 164 of the Bihar Police Manual by:
    • Not sending blood-stained clothes and earth for chemical analysis;
    • Not noting the time of witness examinations in the case diary; and
    • Failing to examine the appellants during investigation.
    These lapses, they contended, rendered the investigation unreliable and the conviction unsustainable.
  • A “considerable delay” in lodging the FIR showed that the appellants had been falsely implicated.
  • The inquest report did not mention the names of the accused, indicating that they were added later at the behest of prosecution witnesses.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State’s counter-arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Recognising the Investigating Officer’s non-compliance with Section 172 CrPC, the Court agreed that these were “serious lapses” diminishing the credibility of the investigation. However, it held that such non-compliance affects the conviction only if actual prejudice to the defence is demonstrated. The appellants failed to show how the omissions impaired their case. The place of occurrence and identity of the deceased were undisputed, and the consistent, trustworthy eyewitness testimony—accepted by both the trial court and the High Court—was sufficient to sustain the conviction.

On the alleged delay in lodging the FIR, the Court found the prosecution to be prompt: the fardbayan was recorded merely two hours after the incident and its contents matched the FIR exactly. Consequently, the argument of delay was rejected.

Regarding the omission of the accused’s names in the inquest report, the Court noted that no column in the prescribed form required such details and the issue had not been raised in earlier proceedings. It therefore declined to entertain the argument at the appellate stage.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the conviction and life sentences of the appellants.

Immediate Effect: The judgment upholds the findings of both the trial court and the Patna High Court, leaving the appellants’ life imprisonment intact.

Broader Implication: The decision reiterates that investigative lapses—although serious—will not overturn a conviction unless the accused can demonstrably show resulting prejudice. It also underscores that prompt filing of a fardbayan/FIR bolsters the prosecution case, and that objections first raised at the Supreme Court stage without prior foundation may be disregarded.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Baleshwar Mandal And Another v. State Of Bihar

    V.N Khare, J.— By this appeal, the appellants, who have been found guilty for the offence under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, question the correctness of the judgment rendered by the High Court of Patna, dismissing their appeals and upholding the judgment of the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhagalpur in Sessions Trial Case No. 333 of 1982.

    2. The prosecution case which has given rise to this appeal is, that on 3-12-1981 at about 2.30 p.m one Rudan Mandal (PW 11), while getting his work done in his field heard the cry of his nephew Natheshwar Mandal who was coming from the field of one Ekbal Mandal situated to the west of his field. On hearing the cry, Rudan Mandal ran towards that direction raising alarm. When Rudan Mandal arrived near the place of occurrence he witnessed the accused Dasrath Mandal and Baleshwar Mandal assaulting the deceased Natheshwar Mandal with dabiya and kulhari, respectively. On alarm being raised, the villagers from the neighbourhood arrived and thereafter both the accused managed to escape from the place of occurrence towards the north. Further case was that Kashi Mandal (PW 1), Tarni Mandal (PW 4), Kailash Mandal (PW 2), Tetar Mandal (PW 10) and Biddi Mandal (PW 3) saw the accused striking the deceased Natheshwar Mandal with dabiya and kulhari, as a result of which Natheshwar Mandal died and the accused fleeing away after they had been identified. IO Rajnandan Singh (PW 15) arrived at the place of occurrence at about 4.30 p.m when he recorded the fardbayan of PW 11 Rudan Mandal. The Investigating Officer seized the bloodstained clothes and earth of place of occurrence and prepared the inquest report and site plan and thereafter recorded the statements of witnesses. The fardbayan was sent to the police station through a special messenger and on the basis of fardbayan, the first information report was lodged next day.

    3. The Court of Session having found both the accused to have committed the murder of Natheshwar Mandal, sentenced them to imprisonment for life. The appeal preferred by the appellants was dismissed by the High Court.

    4. In this appeal, it was urged on behalf of the appellants that due to the serious lapses on the part of the Investigating Officer (PW 15) in not sending the bloodstained clothes and earth seized from the place of occurrence for chemical examination, inasmuch as in not noting down the time of examination of the witnesses in the diary and further not examining the appellants, the trial of the appellants resulting in conviction of the appellants was vitiated and the appeal is to be allowed only on this ground.

    5. Under Section 172 CrPC read with Rule 164 of Bihar Police Manual dealing with the investigation, an Investigating Officer investigating a crime is under obligation to record all the day-to-day proceedings and information in his case diary, and also record the time at which the information was received and the place visited by him, besides the preparation of site plan and other documents. The Investigating Officer is also required to send bloodstained clothes and earth seized from the place of occurrence for chemical examination. Failure on the part of the Investigating Officer to comply with the provisions of Section 172 CrPC is a serious lapse on his part resulting in diminishing the value and credibility of his investigation. In this case the Investigating Officer neither entered the time of recording of the statements of the witnesses in the diary nor did he send the bloodstained clothes and earth seized from the place of occurrence for examination by a serologist. The High Court also adversely commented upon the lapses on the part of the Investigating Officer in not complying with the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure. We, therefore, take it that, in fact, there was serious lapse on the part of the Investigation Officer in not observing the mandate of Section 172 CrPC while investigating the case which has given rise to this appeal. But the question that arises for consideration is, has any prejudice been caused to the accused in the trial by non-observance of rules by the Investigating Officer? The evidence on record before the Sessions Court and the appellate court does not show that due to the lapses on the part of the Investigating Officer in not sending the bloodstained clothes and earth seized from the place of occurrence for chemical examination and further not noting down the time of recording the statement of the witnesses in the diary has resulted in any prejudice to the defence of the accused. In the present case, the place of occurrence and the identity of the deceased are not disputed. Further, the testimony of the eyewitnesses which is consistent and does not suffer from infirmity, was believed by both the courts below. Once the eyewitnesses are believed and the courts come to the conclusion that the testimony of the eyewitnesses is trustworthy, the lapse on the part of the Investigating Officer in not observing the provisions of Section 172 CrPC unless some prejudice is shown to have been caused to the accused, will not affect the finding of guilt recorded by the Court. Neither before the High Court nor before this Court, it was pointed out in what manner the accused were prejudiced by non-observance of the provisions of Section 172 CrPC and the rules framed in this regard. We are, therefore, of opinion that judgments of the courts below do not suffer on account of omission on the part of the Investigating Officer in not sending the earth seized from the place of occurrence for chemical examination or in not entering the time of recording of the statements of witnesses in the diary.

    6. It was then urged that there was a considerable delay in lodging the FIR and the same having not been explained shows that the accused persons had been falsely implicated. In the present case, the occurrence took place at 2.30 p.m on 3-12-1981 and fardbayan of PW 11, Rudan Mandal was recorded at about 4.30 p.m at the place of occurrence — just two hours after the occurrence took place. The fardbayan gave complete and full account of the occurrence and the role of the accused in committing the crime. It has come in the evidence that the Investigating Officer reached Khairpur Bahiyar along with police force at 4.30 p.m where he recorded the fardbayan of the informant Rudan Mandal (PW 11) in the presence of the two eyewitnesses (Ex. 5). The Investigating Officer thereafter prepared the inquest report and the site plan and thereafter continued to record the statements of the witnesses till 10.30 p.m and the fardbayan was sent to Naugachis Police Station for registration through a special messenger. The contents of the FIR were exactly the same as in the fardbayan. There was no discrepancy between the fardbayan and the FIR. The very fact that the occurrence took place at 2.30 p.m on 3-12-1981 and the fardbayan recorded at 4.30 p.m itself shows the promptness on the part of the prosecution in setting the criminal law in motion. Therefore, the contention of the appellants that there was a delay in lodging the FIR which makes the prosecution story unbelievable has to be rejected.

    7. Lastly, it was urged that in the inquest report, prepared by the Investigating Officer after the fardbayan was recorded, the names of the accused persons were not mentioned therein and, as such, it shows that the time when the inquest report was prepared it was not known as to who were the accused persons and the fardbayan was drawn up later on at the instance of the prosecution witnesses in which the accused were falsely implicated. This argument was neither raised during the trial nor before the High Court. The inquest report prepared by the Investigating Officer finds place in the paper-book at p. 47. This inquest report indicates the injuries found on the dead body of the deceased duly witnessed by the two witnesses. There is no column in the said inquest report against which the Investigating Officer is required to mention the names of the accused. It may be the said report is not a complete document. It is, therefore, not safe to entertain this argument in this appeal specially when no such argument was advanced during the trial or before the High Court. We accordingly refrain ourselves from going into this question raised for the first time in this appeal.

    8. For the foregoing reasons, we do not find any merit in this appeal. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Baleshwar Mandal And Another v. State Of Bihar
    (Aug 8, 1997)