Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1997 INSC 617
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1997 INSC 617
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant sought a writ of mandamus in the High Court of Madras directing the Chief Engineer, Madras Port Trust, to accept his Community Certificate dated 10-3-1987 issued by the Tehsildar, Mambalam, for the purpose of his appointment as a Mazdoor in the Madras Port Trust.

The respondent called the appellant for an interview by a letter dated 19-8-1995 and asked him to appear on 17-11-1995 with all testimonials and certificates. The appellant appeared and produced the documents, including the Community Certificate issued by the Tehsildar on 10-3-1987. The Port Trust declined to accept that certificate and, on 20-11-1995, required the appellant to produce the “latest original Community Certificate” from the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO), warning that failure to do so by 30-12-1995 would result in his name being excluded from consideration.

The appellant then approached the High Court. On 8-2-1996, a learned Single Judge, referring to G.O. Ms. No. 2137 dated 11-11-1989, held that the certificate had to be issued by the RDO and that a certificate issued by a Tehsildar was not valid, and dismissed the writ petition. A writ appeal was subsequently dismissed by a Division Bench on 29-2-1996. These two High Court orders were challenged in the present appeal. The Supreme Court granted leave, heard counsel, and examined the record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Community Certificate issued to a Scheduled Tribe candidate by a Tehsildar prior to 11-11-1989 is valid for purposes of public employment.
  2. Whether the Madras Port Trust could lawfully insist on production of a fresh Community Certificate from the Revenue Divisional Officer despite the appellant holding a Tehsildar-issued certificate dated 10-3-1987.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined G.O. Ms. No. 2137 dated 11-11-1989, specifically paragraph 4, which directs that Community Certificates for Scheduled Tribes, for the purpose of appointments in public services under Central and State Governments and related institutions, “shall hereafter” be issued only by Revenue Divisional Officers. The Court also considered a subsequent communication dated 3-4-1991 from the Joint Secretary to the Government of Tamil Nadu to district Collectors clarifying that “the permanent Community Certificate issued to Scheduled Tribes by Tehsildars up to 11-11-1989 is valid.”

From a combined reading of these two documents, the Court concluded that: - After 11-11-1989, Community Certificates for Scheduled Tribes must be issued by Revenue Divisional Officers. - Community Certificates issued by Tehsildars prior to 11-11-1989 remain valid.

Applying this principle to the appellant’s case, the Court held that the Port Trust’s insistence on a fresh certificate from the RDO was improper because the appellant’s certificate was issued by the Tehsildar in 1987, i.e., prior to 11-11-1989. The Court further clarified that a Community Certificate issued to a Scheduled Tribe candidate by a Tehsildar prior to 11-11-1989 is valid “for all purposes” so long as it is not cancelled. Authorities cannot refuse to consider such a certificate and demand a fresh one from the RDO in the absence of cancellation.

The Court expressly limited its determination to the legal validity of such certificates and did not adjudicate on the genuineness or correctness of the appellant’s certificate. If any doubt arises about genuineness, the respondent may conduct a proper enquiry; however, until cancellation, the certificate must be treated as valid.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed. The High Court’s orders are set aside. A mandamus is issued directing the respondent to consider the Community Certificate issued to the appellant by the Tehsildar in 1987 for the purpose of considering the appellant for appointment. No costs.

IMPLICATIONS: The immediate effect is that the Madras Port Trust must treat the appellant’s 1987 Tehsildar-issued Community Certificate as valid unless and until it is cancelled, and must consider it in relation to his appointment as Mazdoor. More broadly, the decision clarifies the legal position that Tehsildar-issued Community Certificates to Scheduled Tribe candidates prior to 11-11-1989 are valid, while post-11-11-1989 certificates must be issued by Revenue Divisional Officers. The Court did not set forth broader procedural guidelines beyond this clarification, and it did not decide on the genuineness of the appellant’s certificate.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    R. Kandasamy v. Chief Engineer, Madras Port Trust .

    Order

    1. Leave granted.

    2. The appellant filed a writ petition in the High Court of Madras seeking a mandamus to the Chief Engineer, Madras Port Trust — the respondent herein to accept the Community Certificate of the appellant dated 10-3-1987, issued by the Tehsildar, Mambalam, for the purpose of his appointment as a Mazdoor in the Madras Port Trust. It appears that the appellant was called for an interview for appointment to the post of Mazdoor by the respondent by the letter dated 19-8-1995 and subsequently he was called to appear for an interview on 17-11-1995 together with all the testimonials and certificates. The appellant appeared before the respondent and produced the relevant documents including the Community Certificate issued by the Tehsildar, Mambalam, Madras, dated 10-3-1987. That certificate was not acceptable by the Port Trust and on 20-11-1995, the respondent-Port Trust required the appellant to produce “the latest original Community Certificate” from the Revenue Divisional Officer. The request of the appellant to accept the certificate issued by the Tehsildar in 1987 and not to insist upon the production of a fresh certificate from the Revenue Divisional Officer was turned down and the appellant was told that if he did not produce the certificate from the Revenue Divisional Officer on or before 30-12-1995, his name would be left out of consideration for appointment. The appellant at that stage approached the High Court. A learned Single Judge of the High Court on 8-2-1996, referred to GOMs No. 2137 dated 11-11-1989 to hold that the certificate required to be produced was from the Revenue Divisional Officer and that the certificate issued by the Tehsildar was not a valid certificate. The learned Single Judge accordingly dismissed the writ petition and declined to issue mandamus, as prayed for.

    3. A writ appeal was filed. That writ appeal came to be dismissed on 29-2-1996 by the Division Bench. It is these two orders which have been put in issue before us in this appeal.

    4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. Para 4 of the GOMs No. 2137 dated 11-11-1989 reads thus:

    “The Government directs that the Community Certificates in respect of all communities included in the list of Scheduled Tribes, for the purpose of appointments in public services under the Central and State Governments, Public Sector Undertakings, quasi-Government institutions, Banks etc., shall hereafter, be issued only by the Revenue Divisional Officers.”

    5. On a doubt being raised regarding the validity of certificates issued by the Tehsildar prior to 11-11-1989, the Joint Secretary to the Government of Tamil Nadu on 3-4-1991 informed the Collectors of various districts in Tamil Nadu that “the permanent Community Certificate issued to Scheduled Tribes by Tehsildars up to 11-11-1989 is valid”. This communication had been placed on record in the High Court. From a combined reading of GOMs No. 2137 dated 11-11-1989 and letter of the Joint Secretary dated 3-4-1991, (supra) it follows that whereas a Community Certificate after 11-11-1989 is required to be issued by the Revenue Divisional Officer, but the Community Certificates issued by the Tehsildar prior to 11-11-1989 are valid certificates. In view of this position, it was not proper for the respondent to have insisted upon a fresh certificate to be produced by the appellant from the Revenue Divisional Officer as admittedly the Community Certificate produced by the appellant had been issued by the Tehsildar concerned in 1987, that is, prior to 11-11-1989.

    6. In our opinion the Community Certificate issued to a Scheduled Tribe candidate by the Tehsildar prior to 11-11-1989 is a good and valid Community Certificate for all purposes so long as such a certificate is not cancelled. The authorities cannot decline to take that into consideration and insist upon a fresh Community Certificate from the Revenue Divisional Officer.

    7. The judgments of the High Court under the circumstances cannot be sustained. They are set aside and by a mandamus we direct the respondent to take into consideration the Community Certificate issued to the appellant by the Tehsildar which had already been produced before it for the purpose of consideration of the appellant to the appointment.

    8. We clarify that we have only dealt with the legal aspect of the matter and have not pronounced upon the genuineness and the correctness of the Community Certificate for which if there is any doubt (though none appear to have been raised in the High Court and none was projected before us either) the respondent shall have to hold a proper enquiry but till that certificate is not cancelled, the certificate shall be treated as a valid certificate issued by the competent authority.

    9. The appeal is allowed in the above terms.

    10. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R. Kandasamy v. Chief Engineer, Madras Port Trust .
    (Aug 22, 1997)