AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 201/511, Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 147, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 148, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302/149, Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 201/511, Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 147, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 148, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302/149, Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents—Inder Dutt, Raghu Raj, Bikram and Noorie—were tried for offences under Sections 147, 148, 302/149 and 201/511 of the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution alleged that on 25 February 1975 they, along with two unidentified persons, fatally assaulted Ram Bharosey alias Bachan Shah with knives and lathis, then dragged his body to a nearby grove, dumped it in a pit and escaped, taking his bicycle. An FIR was lodged by eyewitness Iqbal Narain (PW 1) at 4:30 p.m. the same day.

The Additional Sessions Judge convicted all four respondents, imposing life sentences for murder and additional lesser sentences for the rioting and concealment charges. On appeal, the Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench) acquitted all four, primarily on the ground that the three eyewitnesses (PWs 1–3) could not have witnessed the crime and that the investigation was tainted. The State obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, challenging the acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in discarding the testimony of eyewitnesses PWs 1, 2 and 3 on grounds of alleged inconsistencies and investigative lapses.
  2. Whether the alleged investigative infirmities were sufficient to vitiate the prosecution case and justify acquittal.
  3. Consequentially, whether the acquittal of each respondent should be upheld or the convictions recorded by the trial court should be restored.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The High Court misread the evidence and advanced unsustainable reasons for rejecting the consistent testimonies of PWs 1–3.
  • Minor defects in investigation do not justify discarding otherwise reliable eyewitness accounts.
  • The High Court’s focus on speculative aspects—such as why the dog squad sniffed the bicycle—was irrelevant to the core evidence.
  • Counsel fairly conceded that the evidence against respondent Noorie was weak and her acquittal might not merit interference.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Prosecution witnesses were inimical to the respondents and their testimonies were riddled with inconsistencies.
  • The investigation was tainted, as shown by questionable use of the dog squad and failure to verify whether PW 2 had actually been repairing the tube-well.
  • Although the fact of death was not in dispute, the prosecution failed to prove that the respondents perpetrated the murder.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook its own scrutiny of the entire record, focusing on the credibility of eyewitnesses and the High Court’s methodology in evaluating their evidence.

  • Misreading of Evidence: The High Court assumed PW 2 reached the scene simultaneously with PW 1 and the deceased, whereas the record showed PW 2 arrived moments later after tightening a bolt at the tube-well. This factual error undermined the High Court’s credibility findings.
  • Peripheral vs. Core Evidence: The High Court fixated on peripheral issues—e.g., why the dog was given the bicycle to smell—rather than assessing the eyewitnesses’ accounts of the assault itself.
  • Medical Corroboration: Contrary to the High Court’s view, the Supreme Court found complete congruity between medical findings (multiple punctured, incised and lacerated wounds) and the eyewitness description of knife and lathi blows. A single lacerated wound that could not be caused by a knife was insufficient to create contradiction.
  • Principles for Assessing Eyewitnesses: The Court reaffirmed that evaluation must centre on (a) possibility of the witness being present and (b) presence of inherent improbabilities. PWs 1–3 satisfied both criteria; their accounts were consistent on the place, manner, weapons used, and post-assault dragging of the body.
  • Investigative Lapses: Even if certain lapses existed, they did not taint the prosecution case or render the eyewitness evidence unreliable.
  • Respondent Noorie: The Court agreed that evidence only showed she spoke to the deceased before the attack; no material suggested prior concert or active participation, justifying her acquittal.

Holding and Implications

PARTIAL ALLOWANCE OF APPEAL: The acquittal of Inder Dutt, Raghu Raj and Bikram is set aside; their convictions and sentences as recorded by the Additional Sessions Judge are restored. The acquittal of Noorie is affirmed.

Implications: The three convicted respondents must surrender to serve the remaining portion of their life sentences; their bail bonds are cancelled. The judgment underscores that appellate interference is warranted when a lower court’s appreciation of evidence is perverse or based on conjecture. No new substantive legal principle was created, but the decision reinforces standards for evaluating eyewitness testimony and the limited impact of investigative defects.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of U.P v. Noorie (Smt) Alias Noor Jahan And Others

    G.B Pattanaik, J.— This appeal by grant of special leave is directed against the order of acquittal passed by the High Court of Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in Criminal Appeal No. 55 of 1978.

    2. The four respondents were tried for offences under Sections 147, 148, 302/149 and 201/511 IPC on the allegation that they along with some unknown persons mercilessly assaulted deceased Bachan Shah with knives and lathis and thereafter carried a cycle of the deceased and dragged the dead body of the deceased to the nearby grove and left it in a pit and escaped from the place of occurrence. The learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted the four respondents under Sections 147 and 302 read with Section 149 IPC and further convicted respondents Inder Dutt, Raghu Raj and Bikram under Sections 148, 302 and 201/511 of the Indian Penal Code. Respondent Noorie, however, was acquitted of the charge under Sections 201/511 against her. All of them were sentenced to life imprisonment under Sections 302/149 and respondent Noorie was further sentenced to undergo imprisonment for one year under Section 147 and the rest 3 respondents were sentenced under Section 148 of the Indian Penal Code and RI for one year under Sections 201/511 of the Indian Penal Code. Sentences have been directed to run concurrently. The respondents then filed an appeal and the High Court acquitted all of them of the charges levelled against them and hence this present appeal.

    3. Prosecution case in a nutshell is that deceased Ram Bharosey alias Bachan Shah had gone to his tubewell at 10.30 a.m on 25-2-1975 for getting the same repaired through the mechanic, Latta Mallah PW 2. As he did not come home to take his lunch till 2.30 p.m his nephew Iqbal Narain PW 1 went to call his uncle for food. When both of them were returning respondent Noorie stopped the deceased on the way and started talking to him. In the meantime the three other respondents along with two unknown persons came armed with knives and lathis and started assaulting the deceased. While the deceased was being assaulted, respondent Noorie was standing. PW 2 who followed the deceased and PW 1 soon reached the spot and saw the occurrence. Noorie then left the place of occurrence. Rest of the three respondents after mercilessly assaulting the deceased dragged the dead body towards the grove and threw it into a pit, and left the place. The informant Iqbal Narain PW 1 prepared a written report and lodged the same at Loni Katra Police Station at 4.30 p.m On receipt of the said report which was treated as FIR, PW 7 registered the case and started investigation. On reaching the place of occurrence, he held the inquest and then sent another officer to search for the accused persons but the accused persons were not found. A dog squad was then sent to trace out the two unknown persons and the said dog went up to the door of the accused Raghu Raj which was found locked. The dead body was sent for post-mortem examination. The investigating officer seized incriminating articles and sent them for chemical examination. Witnesses were examined under Section 161 CrPC. Finally on completion of investigation charge-sheet was filed. On being committed the respondents stood their trial. The defence plea is one of denial. The prosecution examined 9 witnesses in all of whom PWs 1, 2 and 3 are eyewitnesses to the occurrence. PW 6 is the doctor who had conducted autopsy over the dead body of the deceased. PW 4 is a witness to the inquest as well as witness to certain seizure made in the course of investigation. PW 5 is the constable who carried the dead body to the morgue for post-mortem examination. PW 7 is the police officer who had recorded the FIR and investigated into the offence. PW 8 is a constable and formal witness. PW 9 is the Head Constable who had made some entries at the police station on receipt of the written report. Prosecution also proved several documentary evidence of which Ext. 26 is the FIR, Ext. 9 is the post-mortem report of the deceased, Ext. 40 is the report of the chemical examiner and Ext. 39 is the serologist's report. The defence also examined one witness as DW 1. The learned Additional Sessions Judge on a scrutiny of the entire materials on record came to the conclusion, mostly relying upon the evidence of 3 witnesses PWs 1, 2 and 3, that the prosecution has been able to establish the charges beyond reasonable doubt and accordingly convicted and sentenced the accused persons as already stated. On appeal by the accused respondents the High Court though accepted the prosecution story that the deceased was murdered in the galiayar and his body was shifted to the pit where it was dumped but held it was not established that the said murder had been witnessed by the alleged witnesses namely PWs 1, 2 and 3 and therefore the possibility that the deceased was murdered by others and the appellants were implicated on mere suspicion or out of vengeance cannot be ruled out. With this conclusion the High Court set aside the conviction and sentence passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge and acquitted the accused respondents.

    4. Mr Pramod Swarup, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant contended that the reasonings given by the High Court in discarding the prosecution story and in disbelieving the oral testimony of PWs 1 to 3 are wholly unsustainable in law and consequently the order of acquittal is vitiated. The learned counsel also contended that the High Court wholly erred in law in discarding the prosecution case on the basis of certain infirmities in the investigation and this has resulted in gross miscarriage of justice by ordering acquittal of the respondents. The learned counsel for the appellant, however, fairly stated that so far as respondent Noorie is concerned on the basis of evidence on record it would be difficult to assail her acquittal made by the High Court. Mr Ranjit Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the respondents on the other hand submitted that in view of the proved animosities of the prosecution witnesses and in view of the gross infirmities in their evidence, the High Court was fully justified in discarding prosecution case. According to Mr Ranjit Kumar though prosecution case so far as death of Ram Bharosey is concerned is true but the prosecution case as unfolded through the witnesses PWs 1 to 3 and the manner in which the death occurred is not true and therefore the order of acquittal passed by the High Court should not be interfered with by this Court.

    5. In view of the rival stand of the parties the question which arises for consideration is whether the evidence of PWs 1 to 3 can be discarded on the grounds advanced by the High Court or not? Before scrutinising the evidence of these three witnesses it would be appropriate to examine the correctness of the reasonings advanced by the High Court in discarding the prosecution case. But before doing so we may first set out the case against respondent Noorie. The only evidence against Noorie was that while the deceased and PW 1 were coming she stopped them on the way and talked with the deceased and at that point of time other accused persons came and assaulted the deceased. There is not an iota of material on record to indicate any prior meeting of Noorie with the other accused persons nor is there any material to implicate Noorie in any way with the occurrence. Noorie has not been assigned any role in the assault of the deceased. In this view of the matter the order of acquittal of respondent Noorie by the High Court cannot be interfered with by this Court.

    6. The High Court came to the conclusion that PW 2 could not have reached the place of occurrence simultaneously with PW 1 and the deceased since he had to screw one bolt and lock the tubewell which in the process would have taken at least five minutes. It is neither the evidence of PW 1 that PW 2 came with them to the place of occurrence nor is it the evidence of PW 2 that he was there along with the deceased and PW 1. On the other hand the evidence of PW 2 is that after the deceased and PW 1 left the tubewell, PW 2 tightened the bolt and left for home and while he was at a distance of 100 paces from the place of occurrence he heard shouting of PW 1 and then he ran and on reaching the place of occurrence he saw that the deceased had fallen down and there respondents Inder Dutt, Vikram and Raghuraj were assaulting the deceased with knives. The conclusion of the High Court, therefore, is based upon total misreading of the evidence of PWs 1 and 2. The High Court has commented upon the investigation as to why the fact whether PW 2 was at all engaged in the repair work of the tubewell had not been investigated into. In our considered opinion it is a wholly untenable approach and had no relevance with the appreciation of the evidence of PW 2. The High Court had commented upon the evidence of PW 2 on the ground that at one place he said that he was called by the investigating officer at about the time of sunset whereas at other place he said that he was called by the investigating officer at night and on this score the High Court jumped to the conclusion that PW 2 cannot be accepted to be a witness to the occurrence. We are unable to accept this reasoning of the High Court. Instead of focussing its attention on the testimony of the witness with regard to the actual occurrence the High Court has gone around the periphery and without even discussing anything so far as the occurrence is concerned has discarded the testimony and in our view erroneously. So far as PW 3 is concerned the High Court discarded his testimony by comparing his evidence with the evidence of PW 2 and on coming to a conclusion that he could not have seen Noorie clearly from the place of occurrence. As stated earlier the very approach of the High Court in appreciating the evidence has been rather faulty and no attention has been bestowed by the High Court in discussing the basic prosecution case. The conclusion of the High Court that the evidence of PW 3 does not inspire confidence is a wrong conclusion without discussing his evidence and the said conclusion is wholly unsustainable in law. On discussion of medical evidence, the High Court came to the conclusion that the ocular version of the evidence does not receive complete support and corroboration from the medical evidence. But we are unable to sustain this conclusion of the High Court also. The doctor PW 6 who conducted the post-mortem examination found as many as 9 punctured wounds, 3 incised wounds, one lacerated wound and three abrasions on different parts of the body of the deceased. The High Court accepted the prosecution case that the punctured wounds and incised wounds could be caused by a knife but since the lacerated wound which was found between the right index finger and thumb measuring 3 cms × 2 cms could not be caused by a knife, the High Court jumped to the conclusion that the medical evidence does not corroborate the ocular statement. We find it difficult to sustain this conclusion. Commenting upon the investigation the High Court observed that it is not free from taint. The aforesaid conclusion is based upon the fact as to why the dog was given a smell of the bicycle of the deceased instead of the piece of dhoti which had allegedly got stuck to a tree. The further reasoning advanced is as to what was the necessity of dragging the deceased and throwing the dead body into a pit. Then again the High Court observed that the bicycle of the deceased had been touched by Noorie alone apart from deceased then how the dog after smelling the bicycle proceeded towards the house of Raghuraj. In our considered opinion the alleged infirmities found out by the High Court can neither be held to be sufficient to hold the investigation to be tainted nor can it be taken into account to discredit the prosecution case.

    7. The High Court having acquitted the accused persons on appreciation of the evidence, we have ourselves scrutinised the evidence of PWs 1, 2 and 3. The conclusion is irresistible that their evidence on material particulars have been brushed aside by the High Court by entering in the realm of conjecture and fanciful speculation without even discussing the evidence more particularly the evidence relating to the basic prosecution case. While assessing and evaluating the evidence of eyewitnesses the court must adhere to two principles, namely, whether in the circumstances of the case it was possible for the eyewitness to be present at the scene and whether there is anything inherently improbable or unreliable. The High Court in our opinion has failed to observe the aforesaid principles and in fact has misappreciated the evidence which has caused gross miscarriage of justice. Credibility of a witness has to be decided by referring to his evidence and finding out how he has fared in cross-examination and what impression is created by his evidence taken in other context of the case and not by entering into the realm of conjecture and speculation. On scrutinising the evidence of PWs 1, 2 and 3 we find they are consistent with one another so far as the place of occurrence, the manner of assault, the weapon of assault used by the accused persons, the fact of dragging of the dead body of the deceased from the place to the grove is concerned and nothing has been brought out in their cross-examination to impeach their testimony. The aforesaid oral evidence fully corroborates the medical evidence. In that view of the matter we unhesitatingly come to the conclusion that the prosecution has been able to establish the charge against the accused persons and the High Court committed error in acquitting the three respondents, namely, Inder Dutt, Raghu Raj and Bikram. In the aforesaid premises the order of acquittal passed by the High Court so far as respondent Noorie is concerned is confirmed but the order of acquittal so far as accused Inder Dutt, Raghu Raj and Bikram is concerned is set aside and their conviction and sentences passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge are confirmed. The appeal is allowed in part. Respondents Inder Dutt, Raghu Raj and Bikram are directed to surrender to serve the balance period of sentence. Their bail bonds stand cancelled.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of U.P v. Noorie (Smt) Alias Noor Jahan And Others
    (Mar 26, 1996)