Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1996 INSC 466
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Schedules 5 and 3 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Equal Remuneration Act, 1976
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1996 INSC 466
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Schedules 5 and 3 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Equal Remuneration Act, 1976
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise from proceedings before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Chandigarh, where the Tribunal had directed the Chandigarh Administration to pay full Dearness Allowance (DA), City Compensatory Allowance (CCA) and House Rent Allowance (HRA) to a group of daily-wage and work-charged employees. Challenging that direction, the Chandigarh Administration filed Special Leave Petitions (SLP No. 27844 of 1995 and connected matters) before the Supreme Court of India. During the pendency of the SLPs, the Court directed the Administration to frame a comprehensive scheme for regularisation and service benefits of such employees. A scheme was consequently prepared by the Superintending Engineer, Construction Circle No. 2, Chandigarh Administration, and approved by the Central Government. The present order evaluates that scheme and the competing request that the Tribunal’s monetary directions be enforced.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Chandigarh Administration should be allowed to implement the newly framed scheme for regularisation and partial monetary benefits, or whether the CAT’s earlier direction to pay full DA, CCA and HRA to daily-wage employees must continue to operate.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (Chandigarh Administration)

  • Placed the newly framed scheme—approved by the Central Government—before the Court, asserting it provides a structured path for regularisation and benefits.
  • Submitted that implementation of the CAT’s order to pay full DA, HRA and CCA would cost approximately ₹8 crore for 3,647 daily-wage/casual employees and that the Government of India has expressed unwillingness to sanction that expenditure.
  • Offered, instead, to pay 60% of the minimum pay (Punjab pattern) along with other scheme benefits pending regularisation.

Respondents (Daily-Wage Employees)

  • Relied on the Equal Remuneration Act, 1976 and Schedules III and V of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 to contend for parity in allowances and benefits with regular employees.
  • Favoured enforcement of the CAT’s earlier direction granting full DA, HRA and CCA.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that, under “recent decisions,” daily-wage employees can only be regularised in accordance with existing recruitment rules, reservations and available vacancies. Because no such recruitment rules were in force for the Chandigarh Administration, the Court found that the workforce had remained on a daily-wage basis without prospects for regularisation.

Weighing the fiscal impact of the Tribunal’s order against the structured relief offered by the new scheme, the Court concluded that approving the scheme would better reconcile the interests of the employees with administrative feasibility. Key elements of the approved approach include:

  • Regularisation of workers who have completed at least 240 days, strictly in order of seniority and against existing vacancies, applying reservation policies.
  • Entitlement of regularised employees to the full pay scale applicable to Central Government employees.
  • For employees not yet regularised, payment of the minimum of the scale for the post plus 60% of DA following the Punjab pattern.
  • Maintenance of seniority lists and adherence to the “last-come, first-go” principle when retrenchment is necessary, with future recall without requiring Employment Exchange sponsorship.
  • Back-payment of monetary entitlements calculated from one year prior to the filing of the original application before the CAT, payable within four months.

The Court regarded these measures as a fair implementation of principles under labour laws while recognising budgetary constraints.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are allowed and disposed of. The Supreme Court approves the Chandigarh Administration’s scheme and directs its immediate implementation, including the regularisation process and partial monetary benefits outlined above. The CAT’s prior directive to pay full DA, HRA and CCA is supplanted by this order.

Implications: The decision gives statutory clarity on the treatment of approximately 3,647 daily-wage/casual employees within the Chandigarh Administration. It mandates a structured path to regularisation, ensures minimum pay plus 60% DA in the interim, and establishes guidelines for future retrenchment and recall. The ruling is specific to the parties and does not announce a new legal precedent beyond underscoring existing principles on regularisation and labour benefits.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Others v. Dharma Pal And Others

    Order

    1. Leave granted.

    2. We have heard the learned counsel on both sides.

    3. Pursuant to the direction given by this Court the appellants have framed the scheme, Shri K.B Sharma, Superintending Engineer, Construction Circle No. 2, Chandigarh Administration has placed the same along with the additional affidavit. The scheme has been approved by the Central Government. The scheme reads as under:

    For work-charged employees

    “(i) All the works establishment (excluding office of Ministerial Clerical and drawing cadres below the level of Junior Engineer), engaged in the construction/execution of maintenance work, shall be called ‘Work Force’. The work force includes buildings, roads, public health activities comprising augmentation of water supply, canals, drainage, electrical and electricity etc. The ‘work division’ shall be a unit for casual or daily-wage work force and a ‘circle’ for work-charged establishment. Separate cadre and seniority list for each category shall be maintained in the Division and Circle as the case may be.
    (ii) Workers engaged on jobs, which are likely to be of a short duration, i.e, less than 240 days in a year, will be terminated on completion of work. No seniority list of such workers will be required to be maintained.
    (iii) Workers who have completed five years' service as on 31-8-1995 will be considered for regularisation against the available regular posts subject to the fulfilment of requirements as laid down in the Recruitment Rules for the post in question, if they were recruited before 6-1-1992, the date on which a ban was imposed on the recruitment of daily/casual workers.
    (iv) Since a complete ban on recruitment of work-charged casual/daily-wage employees was imposed by Chandigarh Administration, those recruited in contravention of this policy decision after this date, i.e, 6-1-1992 will be considered for their regularisation only on the assessment of justification/requirements on the basis of norms approved for the continued nature of work and attaching the specific approval of the Home Department, Chandigarh Administration.

    For Casual/Daily-Wagers

    (v) Workers working as casual labourers in works which have more or less fixed period of completion will be eligible for payment of benefits as admissible to them under rules. However, they will not be considered for regularisation automatically. Their requirement has to be reassessed after commissioning the work. Thus, the workers will be liable to be retrenched on completion of works except categories in limited numbers who are required for the operation and maintenance of the completed works. In their cases specific approval of the Home Department should be taken.
    (vi) Daily-wage employees who have completed 10 years' or more service as on 31-8-1995 shall be considered for regularisation w.e.f 31-8-1995 on the availability of posts. Such employees shall be entitled for minimum of the scale w.e.f the date of their regularisation. On regularisation, these employees shall be liable for transfer anywhere within the Engineering Department, UT Chandigarh.
    (vii) In respect of all such daily-wages employees, who have not yet completed 10 years' service, a special review should be carried out at the level of Head of the Department regarding their requirement.
    (viii) In the case of those employees whose services are no longer required and have been taken after 6-1-1992 and specific approval of the Home Department, Chandigarh Administration does not exist, they may be relieved of their duties at the earliest possible.”

    4. Shri Poti, learned Senior Counsel has brought to our notice letter dated 4-1-1996 addressed by the Joint Secretary, Personnel to all the Heads of the Departments in which it was stated that they were examining the payment of the DA, CCA, HRA to all the daily-wage workers. By our order dated 18-1-1996, while quoting the above letter that Shri K. Madhava Reddy, learned Senior Counsel when was confronted with the same, had expressed his inability to respond to the same. Consequently, we have directed him to obtain instructions in that behalf. Shri Reddy has stated today that pursuant to that letter follow-up action was taken by the appellants in their letter dated 4-3-1996 wherein the appellants had examined the impact of the direction issued by the Administrative Tribunal. It is stated that 3647 daily-wage/casual employees are not on the muster rolls. If DA, HRA and CCA are allowed at full rates it would work out at the approximate rate to Rs 8 crores. Therefore, direction seeking their approval has been sought from the Government of India. He stated that the Government of India was not willing to extend the same benefit though formal order has not been communicated so far. The Government of India is willing to permit the appellant to pay 60% of the amount of the minimum pay on a par with Punjab pattern. Instead of DA, HRA and CCA, appellants, therefore, are willing to continue to pay to the daily-wage workers above 60% subject to the above scheme. Shri Sharma, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for all the respondents in appeal arising out of SLP No. 27844 of 1995 has brought to our notice the provisions of the Equal Remuneration Act, 1976 and Schedules 5 and 3 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

    5. In view of the rival contentions, the only question is: whether the appellants would be permitted to proceed in the light of the scheme framed by them or give direction to continue to pay, as directed by the Tribunal. After giving due consideration to the respective contentions, we think that the appropriate course would be to give approval to the scheme framed by the appellants. In view of the settled law by recent decisions all the daily-wage employees are required to be regularised in accordance with the rules in vogue following the principles of rules of recruitment, reservations and existence of vacancies. Admittedly, there are no rules operating in the field. As a result, all of them have been continuing on daily-wage basis. It is true that CAT at Chandigarh had on earlier occasion directed to pay to 88 daily-wage employees DA, HRA and CCA. Instead of the repetetion (sic), we think that the scheme requires enforcement.

    6. In view of the scheme now framed, the appellants are directed to regularise all those who have completed the prescribed period of days, viz., 240 days against the existing vacancies applying the rules of reservation in the order of seniority in the respective categories mentioned in the scheme. Such regularised employees would be entitled to all the regular payment at the scale of pay prescribed to the Central Government employees. Those who could not be regularised are directed to be regularised in the order of seniority as and when vacancies arise. Work would be continued to be taken from them as long as the work exists. Even those who were engaged as daily-wage/casual labour, who could not complete 240 days but were required to be retrenched, the procedure prescribed for retrenchment under the Industrial Disputes Act should be followed. A list of them in the order of seniority should be maintained. Last-come first-go principle should be followed in that behalf. As and when vacancies arise or need for the work arises, they should be called for work immediately without asking them to get their names sponsored by the Employment Exchange. The daily-wage workers/casual workers who are not regularised and work is taken from them are entitled to minimum of scale of pay prescribed for that post. In addition to that, they are also entitled to 60% of the DA at Punjab pattern which is being followed in all other cases. The payment to all the candidates whose services are regularised/continuing on daily-wage/casual labour shall be calculated from one year prior to the date of filing of the application in the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh. The appellants are directed to pay the same within a period of four months from today.

    7. The appeals are accordingly disposed of. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. Dharma Pal And Others
    (Mar 29, 1996)