AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Payment of Wages Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Payment of Wages Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Anirudh Pandey was an employee of the Bihar State Road Transport Corporation (“the Corporation”). In 1970, while still in service, he was allotted House No. 327/2-2 at Adityapur Colony, Jamshedpur, a property owned by the Bihar State Housing Board (“the Board”). Upon attaining the age of superannuation, Pandey retired on 31 January 1992.

When his post-retiral benefits—provident fund, gratuity and other dues—were not released, Pandey filed Writ Petition CWJC No. 3038/92 before the Patna High Court. The Corporation opposed the petition, asserting that payment would be made only after Pandey vacated the allotted quarter. The High Court accepted that stance and, by order dated 21 April 1993, directed Pandey to vacate the house, after which the Corporation was to pay his dues within three weeks.

Pandey appealed to the Supreme Court. During the pendency of the appeal, it emerged that the Board had cancelled the original allotment because rent had not been remitted and had re-allotted the house to Pandey’s son, Shradha Kumar Pandey, on 31 July 1992. The Board confirmed that rent deductions had been made from the employee’s salary but were never transferred by the Corporation, resulting in arrears of Rs 9,231.85 and cancellation of the allotment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Corporation could lawfully withhold Pandey’s post-retiral benefits on the ground that he had not vacated the staff-allotted house when the allotment itself had been cancelled due to the Corporation’s failure to remit rent.
  2. Whether, in the circumstances, Pandey was entitled to recover both his retiral dues and the rent already deducted from his salary but not paid to the Board.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Rent for the house had been regularly deducted from Pandey’s salary from 1 July 1970 to 31 December 1990; non-payment to the Board was the Corporation’s fault.
  • The cancellation and re-allotment of the house were consequences of the Corporation’s default, not Pandey’s; therefore, withholding retiral benefits was unjustified.

Respondent Corporation’s Position (as recorded in prior proceedings)

  • Pandey must first vacate the quarter before retiral dues could be released.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found merit in Pandey’s submission. It noted that the Board cancelled the allotment because the Corporation failed to remit rent and associated charges, even though those sums had been deducted from Pandey’s wages under the Subsidised Industrial Housing Scheme. Given that the cancellation resulted from the Corporation’s default, the Court held that the Corporation could not blame Pandey for non-surrender of the house or predicate the withholding of retiral benefits on that ground. Consequently, the High Court’s acceptance of the Corporation’s stance was erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court order set aside.

The Supreme Court directed the Corporation to:

  • Pay all legally payable post-retiral benefits to Pandey.
  • Refund the amount of house rent deducted from his salary but not remitted to the Board.
  • Discharge these payments within four months, failing which interest at 15% p.a. would accrue from the expiry of that period until payment.

Pandey was also awarded costs of Rs 5,000. The decision has immediate impact on the parties but sets no broader precedent because it turns on the specific factual default of the employer in remitting rent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Anirudh Pandey v. Bihar State Road Transport Corporation And Another

    S.C Agrawal, J.— Leave granted.

    2. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

    3. Anirudh Pandey, the appellant herein, was employed with the Bihar State Road Transport Corporation, Respondent 1 (hereinafter referred to as “the Corporation”). While he was thus employed, he was allotted House No. 327/2-2 on Road No. 26 at Adityapur Colony in Jamshedpur on 7-6-1970. The said house belongs to the Bihar State Housing Board (hereinafter referred to as “the Board”). The appellant retired on attaining the age of superannuation on 31-1-1992. Since he was not paid his post-retiral benefits, viz., provident fund, gratuity, etc. by the Corporation he filed a writ petition (CWJC No. 3038/92) in the Patna High Court. The said writ petition was contested by the Corporation. The stand of the Corporation was that the appellant had not vacated the house which was allotted to him while he was in service of the Corporation and that the Corporation was ready to pay all the legal dues of the appellant after he vacates the said quarter. The writ petition was disposed of by the High Court by order dated 21-4-1993 on the view that unless the house was vacated by the appellant he was not entitled to his post-retiral benefits. The High Court directed the appellant to vacate the house and hand over the vacant possession of the same to the Corporation and that the Corporation after taking the vacant possession of the house would pay the post-retiral benefits to the appellant within a period of three weeks from the date of the vacation of the house. Feeling aggrieved by the said order of the High Court the appellant has filed this appeal.

    4. While the matter was pending before this Court, it was pointed out that the allotment of the house which was in occupation of the appellant has been cancelled by the Board and allotment of the house has been made by the Board in favour of Shradha Kumar Pandey, son of the appellant. Notice was, therefore, issued to the Board to explain the circumstances in which the said allotment was made. In response to the said notice an affidavit of Shobha Kant Mishra was filed on behalf of the Board. From the said affidavit filed on behalf of the Board it appears that House No. 327/2-2 has been constructed by the Board under the Subsidised Industrial Housing Scheme meant for industrial workers. The said scheme envisages (i) sale of houses on hire-purchase basis to workers; and (ii) letting out of the houses on rent to the workers. For letting out a house on rent the Scheme provides for allotment of the house to the worker who is required to submit an application through his employer. Although, under the Scheme, the allottee, i.e, the worker, is liable to pay the rent of the house and other rates and taxes payable to the municipality or the Government but the same are required to be paid every month by the employer after deducting the same from the monthly wages of the worker under the Payment of Wages Act. In the affidavit of Shobha Kant Mishra, it is stated that at the end of June 1992 a sum of Rs 9231.85p was due as rent for the house in question and that the Divisional Manager of the Corporation was required to pay the amount but the same having not been paid, the Executive Engineer of the Board, on 3-7-1992, cancelled the allotment of the said house and, thereafter, by letter dated 31-7-1992 the said house was allotted in favour of M/s Ambika Rubber Product, Adityapur for the residence of their employee, Shradha Kumar Pandey, on rental basis. It is further stated that the said allotment is subject to the condition that the allottee will have to pay the sum of Rs 9231.85p, the total arrear against rent till June 1992.

    5. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that rent of the house was deducted from the salary of the appellant by the Corporation from 1-7-1970 to 31-12-1990 and in spite of such deduction the Corporation failed to deposit the rent with the Board and on account of the said default on the part of the Corporation in depositing the rent the allotment of the house was cancelled by the Board and that the appellant cannot be held responsible for the same and that the Corporation cannot withhold the post-retiral benefits of the appellant on the ground that the appellant had failed to vacate and surrender the house to the Corporation.

    6. In our opinion, the said submission of the learned counsel for the appellant must be accepted. Since the allotment of the house which was in occupation of the appellant has been cancelled by the Board on account of the failure on the part of the Corporation to pay the rent and other charges for the same it is not open to the Corporation to blame the appellant for not having surrendered the house to the Corporation. In the circumstances the Corporation was not justified in withholding the post-retiral benefits of the appellant on the ground that he has failed to surrender the possession of the house to the Corporation.

    7. The appeal is, therefore, allowed, the order passed by the High Court is set aside and the writ petition filed by the appellant is allowed with the direction that the Corporation will pay the post-retiral benefits legally payable to the appellant as well as the amount of the house rent deducted from the salary of the appellant which was not paid to the Board. The said dues shall be paid by the Corporation to the appellant within a period of four months. In the event of failure on the part of the Corporation to pay the said dues within this period, the Corporation would be liable to pay interest @ 15% per annum on the same from the date of expiry of the said period of four months till the said dues are paid. The appellant will be entitled to his costs which are assessed at Rs 5000.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anirudh Pandey v. Bihar State Road Transport Corporation And Another
    (Dec 7, 1994)