AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 311(1) of the Constitution
  • Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Article 309 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 311(1) of the Constitution
  • Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Article 309 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, who joined the Tamil Nadu Cooperative Department as Deputy Registrar in 1969 and rose to Joint Registrar/Special Officer of the Park Town Cooperative Wholesale Stores Ltd. in 1984, faced allegations of irregular appointments and purchases during his tenure. The Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption investigated after obtaining materials from the Registrar of Cooperative Societies.

Meanwhile, by G.O. Ms. No. 185 dated 17 March 1988, Rule 12 of the Tamil Nadu Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules was amended to empower Heads of Departments to impose minor penalties. After the Vigilance Directorate submitted its report, the Government, through G.O. Ms. No. 371 dated 20 December 1988, directed the Registrar to initiate disciplinary action. Consequently, on 20 March 1989 the Registrar issued a charge-memo and appointed an Enquiry Officer.

Alleging bias, the respondent twice sought a change of Enquiry Officer; both requests were rejected. He then filed OA No. 1294 of 1990 before the Tamil Nadu Administrative Tribunal, which on 19 March 1991 quashed the disciplinary proceedings on the ground that the Registrar lacked authority under Rule 17(b). The State appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after the 1988 amendment to Rule 12, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies (as Head of Department) was competent to initiate disciplinary proceedings and impose minor penalties on a State Service officer.
  2. Whether the delay in commencing disciplinary proceedings rendered them invalid.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Tribunal ignored G.O. Ms. No. 185 (17 March 1988), which expressly delegated power to Heads of Departments to impose minor penalties.
  • G.O. Ms. No. 371 (20 December 1988) specifically authorised the Registrar to frame charges; thus the Registrar acted under Government direction, not on his own initiative.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Because the State Government is the Disciplinary Authority for Joint Registrars, only the Government could frame charges and initiate an enquiry; the Registrar lacked such competence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.V. Srinivasa Sastry v. Comptroller and Auditor General, (1993) 1 SCC 419 Initiation of disciplinary proceedings need not be by the appointing authority unless rules so require. The Court relied on this decision to hold that, absent a specific rule, a superior controlling authority (here, the Registrar acting under Government direction) may initiate proceedings.
State of M.P. v. Shardul Singh, (1970) 1 SCC 108 Article 311(1) does not mandate that disciplinary proceedings be initiated by the appointing authority. Cited to reinforce that initiation by a subordinate authority does not violate constitutional safeguards.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that the Tribunal’s conclusion was premised on the pre-amended Rule 12. After quoting the original provision and the 1988 amendment, the Court noted that sub-rule (2) unequivocally authorises Heads of Departments to impose minor penalties on State Service officers (excluding officers immediately below them). Consequently, the Registrar, as Head of Department, possessed the requisite authority.

Furthermore, the Registrar did not act suo motu; he proceeded pursuant to G.O. Ms. No. 371, which directed disciplinary action against the respondent for irregular appointments and purchases. The Court invoked P.V. Srinivasa Sastry and Shardul Singh to reaffirm that Article 311(1) does not restrict the initiation of proceedings to the appointing authority when rules allow delegation.

As to alleged delay, the Court attributed it to the Vigilance Directorate’s investigation and held that the appellant could not be faulted. Regarding perceived bias, although no legal infirmity was found, the Court directed appointment of a new Enquiry Officer to ensure the appearance of fairness.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Tribunal’s order, and directed that disciplinary proceedings continue from the stage at which they were interrupted, with a new Enquiry Officer appointed; no order as to costs.

Implications: The decision clarifies that, after the 1988 amendment, Heads of Departments in Tamil Nadu may validly initiate and conduct disciplinary proceedings involving minor penalties against State Service officers, even when the Government is the appointing authority. The judgment affects only the parties by reviving the inquiry and does not create a new legal precedent beyond applying existing rules and case law.

    Registrar Of Cooperative Societies, Madras And Another v. F.X Fernando .

    S. Mohan, J.— Leave granted.

    2. The facts leading to present appeal are as under:

    3. The respondent joined the Cooperative Department as Deputy Registrar in the year 1969. He was promoted as Joint Registrar in 1981. He became the Joint Registrar/Special Officer of the Park Town Cooperative Wholesale Stores Ltd. in 1984.

    4. During his tenure as the Joint Registrar/Special Officer of Park Town Cooperative Wholesale Stores Ltd. complaints were received by the Director, Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Department. The said Department approached the Registrar, Cooperative Societies to furnish the details to investigate into the alleged irregularities. Thereupon, the Registrar furnished the relevant material. The Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Department was requested to complete the inquiry on or before December 31, 1987. However, no progress was made in that direction.

    5. The Government of Tamil Nadu by its GOMs No. 185 Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department dated March 17, 1988 amended Rule 12 of the Tamil Nadu Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules. Under the said GO, the powers imposing minor penalty came to be conferred on the Heads of the Departments.

    6. Finally, the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Department submitted its detailed report. On an examination of the same, the Government issued GOMs No. 371 dated December 20, 1988 directing the Registrar to take disciplinary action against the respondent. Thereupon the Registrar issued the charge memo dated March 20, 1989. The Registrar (Marketing, Planning and Development) was appointed as Enquiry Officer to conduct the inquiry. The respondent appeared before the Enquiry Officer from January 24, 1990 to March 20, 1990. He also cross-examined one witness.

    7. On March 20, 1990, he made a representation to the appellant alleging bias against the Enquiry Officer. The complaint was rejected. Again, another representation to the same effect was made. That was also rejected on May 8, 1990 and the Registrar called upon the respondent to appear before the Enquiry Officer. At this stage, the respondent moved an application OA No. 1294 of 1990 before the Tamil Nadu Administrative Tribunal to quash the order dated May 8, 1990 calling him by the Registrar to appear before the Enquiry Officer.

    8. By the impugned order dated March 19, 1991, the Tribunal held that the proceedings under Rule 17(b) were liable to be set aside on the ground that the Registrar of Cooperative Societies was not empowered to impose even minor penalty. However, it was open to the Government as Disciplinary Authority to initiate fresh action by issuing a charge memo and conclude the proceedings within a period of six months. Aggrieved by this order, the present civil appeal has come to be preferred.

    9. The learned counsel for the appellant would urge that the Tribunal has completely ignored GOMs No. 185 dated March 17, 1988 by which the Government had delegated the power to the Heads of the Departments to impose minor penalties.

    10. Besides, by GOMs No. 371 dated December 20, 1988, the Government directed the Registrar to frame charges against the respondent and to initiate inquiry. Without regard to this GO, the Tribunal has held as though Registrar on his own under Rule 17(b) had issued a charge memo for which there was no power.

    11. The learned counsel for the respondent would submit that if the Disciplinary Authority is the Government, the Registrar is not competent to frame charges and direct inquiry proceedings.

    12. We will now proceed to consider whether the impugned order of the Tribunal is correct. The finding of the Tribunal is as follows:

    “The Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies is a State service officer and the Disciplinary Authority is the State Government. Therefore, proceedings under Rule 17(b) of the T.N.C.S (CA) Rules can be initiated only by the person empowered to impose the penalties specified in that rule. The rules also contain a provision that an authority competent to impose the penalties mentioned in Rule 17(a) may institute a disciplinary action in respect of major penalties also. However, in this case, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies is not empowered even to impose the minor penalties and therefore initiation of disciplinary proceeding by him by issue of a charge memo and proceeding further by appointment of Enquiry Officer is beyond his powers and therefore on this ground alone the proceedings have to be set aside. It is open to the Disciplinary Authority, viz., the Government to initiate action afresh by issuing the charge memo and after obtaining the written statement of defence and examination thereof order inquiry if necessary by designating the Enquiry Officer.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    13. This finding is clearly wrong since it has not taken note of the amendment made to Tamil Nadu Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules amending Rule 12 whereunder the Heads of the Departments are enabled to impose minor penalties. We will now extract both original Rule 12 and the notification issued in GOMs No. 185, Personnel and Administrative Reform (Personnel-N) Department, dated March 17, 1988 amending the said rule:

    “12. The State Government may impose any of the penalties specified in items (i) and (iii) to (viii) in Rule 8 on members of the State Service:
    Provided that if the Governor of Madras is himself the appointing authority for any service or a class or category thereof, he may himself impose any of the said penalties on members of that service, class or category, as the case may be:
    Provided further that in the case of the members of the Services specified in column (I) of Appendix IV to these rules, the authority which may impose any of the penalties mentioned in items (i), (iii) so far as it relates to withholding of increments and (v) in Rule 8 shall be the authorities specified in the corresponding entries in columns (2), (3) and (4) thereof.”
    “notification
    In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the Governor of Tamil Nadu hereby makes the following amendment to the Tamil Nadu Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, in Volume I of the Tamil Nadu Service Manual, 1977:

    Amendment

    In the said rules, Rule 12 shall be numbered as sub-rule (1) of that rule and after sub-rule (1) as so renumbered, the following sub-rule shall be added; namely:
    ‘(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules and in Appendix IV, the Heads of Departments concerned may impose any of the penalties mentioned in items (i), (iii) insofar as it relates to withholding of increments and (v) in Rule 8 on all members of the State Service other than such members who are immediately below such Heads of Departments.’ ”

    14. The punishments that are referred to above are found in Rule 8 of Madras Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules as under:

    “8. (i) Censure.
    (iii) Withholding of increments or promotion, including stoppage at an efficiency bar.
    (v)(a) Recovery from pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the State Government or the Central Government or to a local body by negligence or breach of orders, or
    (b) Recovery from pay to the extent necessary of the monetary value equivalent to the amount of increments ordered to be withheld, where such an order cannot be given effect to, or
    (c) Recovery from pay to the extent necessary of the monetary value equivalent to the amount of reduction to a lower stage in a time-scale ordered where such an order cannot be given effect to.
    Explanation.— In cases of stoppage of increment with cumulative effect, the monetary value equivalent to three times the amount of increments ordered to be withheld may be recovered.”

    15. This is not a case in which a Registrar has taken disciplinary action on his own. The Government of Tamil Nadu by GOMs No. 371 dated December 20, 1988 directed the appellant to take disciplinary action against the respondent for the following irregularities:

    “He appointed candidates for the post of Salesmen to the newly opened fair price shops of Park Town Cooperative Wholesale Stores, Madras during 1984-85 directly without being sponsored by the Employment Exchange and thereby violated GOMs No. 1138, Labour and Employment Department, dated May 25, 1978, and the instructions given by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies in Lr. No. 149614/84 PDS2, dated September 26, 1984.
    He had violated departmental instructions and purchased consumer goods such as rice, tamarind and chillies directly from traders at higher rates without placing orders through joint purchase committee meetings as prescribed by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies circulars etc. and thereby conferred undue pecuniary advantages to the private traders.”

    16. It was on the basis of this GO, on March 20, 1989 the Registrar issued the charge memo. In this connection, it is worthwhile to refer to a recent decision of this Court reported in P.V Srinivasa Sastry v. Comptroller and Auditor General (1993) 1 SCC 419, (1993) 23 ATC 645, AIR 1993 SC 1321. The relevant observations at pages 1323-24 are as under:( and 6)

    “But Article 311(1) does not say that even the departmental proceeding must be initiated only by the appointing authority. However, it is open to Union of India or a State Government to make any rule prescribing that even the proceeding against any delinquent officer shall be initiated by an officer not subordinate to the appointing authority. Any such rule shall not be inconsistent with Article 311 of the Constitution because it will amount to providing an additional safeguard or protection to the holder of a civil post. But in absence of any such rule, this right or guarantee does not flow from Article 311 of the Constitution. It need not be pointed out that initiation of a departmental proceeding per se does not visit the officer concerned with any evil consequences, and the framers of the Constitution did not consider it necessary to guarantee even that to holders of civil posts under the Union of India or under the State Government. At the same time this will not give right to authorities having the same rank as that of the officer against whom proceeding is to be initiated to take a decision whether any such proceeding should be initiated. In absence of a rule, any superior authority who can be held to be the controlling authority, can initiate such proceeding.
    In the case of State of M.P v. Shardul Singh (1970) 1 SCC 108 the departmental enquiry had been initiated against the Sub-Inspector of Police by the Superintendent of Police, who sent his inquiry report to the Inspector-General, who was the appointing authority. The Inspector-General of Police dismissed the officer concerned from the service of the State Government. That order was challenged on the ground that the initiation of the departmental enquiry by the Superintendent of Police was against the mandate of Article 311(1) of the Constitution. This contention was accepted by the High Court. But this Court said:
    ‘[W]e are unable to agree with the High Court that the guarantee given under Article 311(1) includes within itself a further guarantee that the disciplinary proceedings resulting in dismissal or removal of a civil servant should also be initiated and conducted by the authorities mentioned in that Article.’
    Although Article 311 of the Constitution does not speak as to who shall initiate the disciplinary proceedings but, as already stated above, that can be provided and prescribed by the rules. But if no rules have been framed, saying as to who shall initiate the departmental proceedings, then on the basis of Article 311 of the Constitution it cannot be urged that it is only the appointing authority and no officer subordinate to such authority can initiate the departmental proceeding. In the present case, it was not brought to our notice that any rule prescribes that the Accountant General, who is the appointing authority, alone could have initiated a departmental proceeding.”

    17. Then again the finding that there is long delay in initiating of departmental proceedings cannot be supported because in this case the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption had not been prompt. Therefore, the appellant cannot be faulted. Accordingly, we set aside the order of the Tribunal and direct that the matter be proceeded with from the stage at which it was left. It is a settled principle of law that justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done. Therefore, we would direct that another Enquiry Officer be appointed in order to remove any apprehension of bias on the part of respondent. The civil appeal will stand allowed with no cost.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Registrar Of Cooperative Societies, Madras And Another v. F.X Fernando .
    (Feb 15, 1994)