AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

M/s Krishna Sales (P) Ltd., Delhi imported a machine in 1983 under the Open General Licence (O.G.L.), describing it as a “Bevel Gear Generator” worth a little over ₹7 lakhs. Customs authorities at Bombay treated the machine as a “Bevel Gear Planer,” alleged mis-declaration, confiscated the goods, and offered release on payment of a ₹70,000 redemption fine and a ₹10,000 penalty.

The importer appealed to the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (CEGAT). On 2 March 1985, the Tribunal allowed the appeal, holding—on the strength of technical material that included an expert opinion requested by Customs from Shri M. K. Ghosh—that the machine was indeed a Bevel Gear Generator.

The Collector of Customs filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court. While the appeal was pending, the importer sought a “detention certificate” (needed to lift the machine without duty or demurrage). A public notice dated 25 July 1985 issued by the Collector of Customs, Bombay required withholding such certificates if the Department intended to pursue a further appeal. On 6 October 1987 the Supreme Court passed an interim order directing that the application for a detention certificate should not be rejected merely because the appeal was pending.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal correctly concluded, on technical facts, that the imported machine was a Bevel Gear Generator rather than a Bevel Gear Planer.
  2. Whether Customs authorities could lawfully withhold a detention certificate pursuant to their public notice while an appeal was pending, despite the Tribunal’s un-stayed order in favour of the importer.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Collector of Customs)

  • Asserted that the machine was a Bevel Gear Planer and had been mis-declared, justifying confiscation and monetary penalties.

Respondent (M/s Krishna Sales (P) Ltd.)

  • Maintained that the machine was a Bevel Gear Generator, relying on the expert opinion of Shri M. K. Ghosh, obtained by Customs themselves.
  • Contended that refusal to issue a detention certificate on the basis of the public notice was arbitrary and contrary to law, because filing an appeal does not automatically stay the Tribunal’s order.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

On the classification dispute: The Supreme Court treated the nature of the machine as a “purely technical matter” involving questions of fact, not law. The Tribunal had already considered all relevant technical material—including the expert opinion sought by Customs—and contained a technical member. Finding “no ground to take a different view,” the Court deferred to the Tribunal’s factual determination and dismissed the appeal.

On the detention certificate: The Court examined paragraph 4 of the Collector’s public notice, which directed Customs officers to withhold detention certificates when the Department planned further appeals. It held this approach to be “arbitrary and contrary to law” because (i) an appeal does not by itself operate as a stay, and (ii) if Customs wished to prevent release of goods they should obtain a formal stay from the appellate forum. Continuing detention without such a stay risks unnecessary demurrage and deterioration of goods, and could expose Customs to liability. Accordingly, the Court ordered immediate issuance of the detention certificate without reference to the impugned public notice and urged the Collector to revise the notice in line with these observations.

The Court also directed the Port Trust of Bombay to “consider sympathetically” the importer’s request for waiver of demurrage, recognising that a detention certificate does not automatically absolve liability for such charges.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal of the Collector of Customs is DISMISSED. Customs is directed to issue the requested detention certificate forthwith, and the Port Trust is asked to consider waiver of demurrage. I.A. No. 2 is dismissed. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision affirms CEGAT’s technical findings, allowing the importer to clear the machine duty-free. More broadly, the Court reiterates that merely filing an appeal does not suspend an order; administrative instructions that presume otherwise are unlawful and risk exposing Customs to demurrage liability. No new legal precedent on substantive customs classification is set, but the ruling underscores procedural discipline in implementing un-stayed appellate orders.

    Collector Of Customs, Bombay v. Krishna Sales (P) Ltd. .

    Order

    1. This appeal is preferred against the judgment of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi. The respondent, M/s Krishna Sales (P) Ltd., Delhi imported an item of machinery which according to it is a ‘Bevel Gear Generator’ valued at a little above Rupees seven lacs. The import was made in 1983 under O.G.L The Customs authorities raised an objection that the machinery imported by the respondent was not ‘Bevel Gear Generator’ but ‘Bevel Gear Planer’. According to them, import of a different machinery than stated was violative of law. Adjudication proceedings were taken on the ground of misdeclaration and the machinery confiscated. The respondent was given an option to pay a redemption fine of Rs 70,000 and penalty of Rs 10,000 and clear the goods. Respondent filed an appeal before the Tribunal. The appeal was allowed on 2-3-1985. The Tribunal was of the opinion that what was imported was Bevel Gear Generator only, as contended by the respondent. The Tribunal inter alia relied upon the opinion of one Shri M.K Ghosh, dated 22-11-1983 — to whom the matter was referred by the Customs authorities themselves. Shri Ghosh supported the respondent's case. It is this order which is questioned in this appeal.

    2. So far as the merits of the appeal are concerned, the issue in controversy is not a question of law but one of fact — that too a technical matter. Whether the machinery imported is a Bevel Gear Generator or Bevel Gear Planer is purely a technical matter. Not only the Tribunal is composed of a technical member, it came to its conclusion on consideration of all factual and technical aspects including the opinion of Shri Ghosh, whose opinion was sought by the authorities themselves. We see no ground to take a different view. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

    3. Counsel for the respondent requested at this stage that the customs authorities may be directed to issue a detention certificate for the entire period during which the goods were detained till the date of issuance of the detention certificate — which evidently includes the period during which the proceedings were pending in this Court. For a proper appreciation of this request, a few facts need be stated.

    4. The Tribunal allowed the appeal of the respondent-company by virtue of which order the respondent was entitled to clear the said machinery without payment of any duty. But the respondent required a detention certificate to enable him to clear the said machinery. Evidently, in view of this problem, this Court made the following interim order on 6-10-1987:

    “Having heard learned counsel for the Collector of Customs, Bombay and M/s Krishna Sales (P) Ltd., we direct that the application made by the latter for a detention certificate should not be rejected on the ground that the appeal is pending in this Court against the order of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi.”

    5. The respondent says that when he applied for issuance of a detention certificate, no such certificate was issued. He says that the action of the authorities is relatable to and influenced by the public notice issued by the Collector of Customs, Bombay on 25-7-1985. The public notice says that the detention certificate for a period up to three months will be issued with the approval of and under the signature of the concerned Assistant Collector whereas a detention certificate for a period over three months will be issued with the approval of and under the signature of Deputy Collector. So far as the detention certificate for a period exceeding six months is concerned, it can issue only with the approval of and under the signature of the Collector. Para 4 of the public notice deals with issue of detention certificates to the parties succeeding in appeals. Having regard to the nature of its contents, it would be appropriate to quote the said paragraph in full:

    “Issue of detention certificates to the parties succeeding in appeals.
    Detention Certificate, as a rule, will be issued by the concerned competent Customs Authority to the appellants succeeding in appeals on receipt of the copies of such orders which the latter making formal application for issue of Detention Certificates.
    However, in cases where the Custom House decides to go in second appeal before the Tribunal or the Supreme Court, the issue of Detention Certificate will be considered only after such second appeal is finally disposed of in favour of the parties.”

    6. According to the said para 4, the goods will not be released even where the party succeeds in cases where the Customs authorities decide to go in appeal before the Tribunal or the Supreme Court. They will consider the issuance of such certificate only after the decision of the Tribunal or the Supreme Court, as the case may be. The learned counsel for the respondent characterises the said direction as arbitrary and contrary to law. We see the force in his submission. If the authorities are of the opinion that the goods ought not to be released pending the appeal, the straightforward course for them is to obtain an order of stay or other appropriate direction from the Tribunal or the Supreme Court, as the case may be. Without obtaining such an order they cannot refuse to implement the order under appeal. As is well-known, mere filing of an appeal does not operate as a stay or suspension of the order appealed against. Moreover, such detention is likely to create several complications relating to the demurrage charges besides the possible deterioration of the machinery and goods. We hope and trust that the Collector of Customs, Bombay shall appropriately revise the said public notice in the light of the observations made herein. If he does not do so, there is a likelihood of the Customs authorities being themselves made liable for demurrage charges in appropriate cases.

    7. So far as this case is concerned, we direct that the detention certificate should be issued without reference to para 4 of the said public notice or any similar public notice. Since the respondents will not be absolved of the obligation to pay the demurrage charges altogether by reason of the Detention Certificate the Trustees of the Port of Bombay, (respondent No. 2) are directed to consider sympathetically the request of the respondent No. 1 [M/s Krishna Sales (P) Ltd., Delhi] for waiver of these demurrage charges.

    8. There shall be no order as to costs.

    9. I.A No. 2 is taken on board and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Collector Of Customs, Bombay v. Krishna Sales (P) Ltd. .
    (Sep 9, 1993)