Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 162 of the Constitution
  • Section 192 of the Army Act, 1950
  • Section 193-A of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 193 of the Army Act, 1950
  • Clause (a) of Sub-section (2) of Section 191 of the Army Act, 1950
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 162 of the Constitution
  • Section 192 of the Army Act, 1950
  • Section 193-A of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 193 of the Army Act, 1950
  • Clause (a) of Sub-section (2) of Section 191 of the Army Act, 1950
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a Lieutenant General in the Infantry who had joined service on 6 June 1954, was compulsorily retired with effect from 31 December 1990 upon completing 57 years of age. He challenged the retirement order in Civil Writ Petition No. 3997 of 1990 before the Delhi High Court, asserting a right to serve until 58 years under departmental instructions dated 9 May 1985. The Union of India relied on later instructions dated 9 September 1986 that introduced a two-stream concept (“Command and Staff” and “Staff only”) and prescribed a retirement age of 57 for Lieutenant Generals in the Staff-only stream. The High Court dismissed the writ petition, prompting the present appeal by special leave to the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s retirement was governed by the executive instructions of 9 May 1985 (fixing 58 years for all Lieutenant Generals) or by the subsequent instructions of 9 September 1986 (fixing 57 years for Lieutenant Generals in the “Staff only” stream).
  2. Whether the 1986 instructions possessed the same legal status as the 1985 instructions and could therefore validly modify the retirement age without amending Rule 16-A of the Army Rules, 1954.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The letter of 9 May 1985, issued with the concurrence of the Ministry of Defence, constituted binding executive instructions under Article 162 of the Constitution and guaranteed retirement at 58 years.
  • The subsequent letter of 9 September 1986 was merely a departmental communication lacking the status to supersede the 1985 instructions.
  • Notings in June 1987 placing an “addenda” in abeyance demonstrated that the two-stream concept had been suspended, reinstating the 1985 instructions.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Rule 16-A(5) of the Army Rules permits retirement between 56 and 58 years; hence retiring the appellant at 57 was within statutory bounds.
  • The 1986 instructions, approved by the Ministry of Defence and the Prime Minister, validly introduced the two-stream concept and fixed retirement at 57 for “Staff only” Lieutenant Generals.
  • The 1987 noting only deferred a draft addenda and did not suspend the operative 1986 instructions.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court examined the statutory framework—Sections 191, 192 and 193 of the Army Act, 1950 and Rule 16-A of the Army Rules, 1954—which fixes a retirement window of 56-58 years for Lieutenant Generals.
2. The 1985 letter, though envisaging amendment of Rule 16-A, never resulted in such amendment and thus remained an executive instruction, not a rule.
3. The 1986 letter, endorsed by the Ministry of Defence and approved by the Prime Minister, likewise constituted an executive instruction of equal status. It introduced the two-stream concept under which “Staff only” Lieutenant Generals retire one year earlier than those in the “Command and Staff” stream.
4. Because both documents are executive instructions of the same hierarchy, the later instruction of 1986 validly modified the earlier instruction of 1985 so far as “Staff only” officers were concerned.
5. The Court inspected departmental files and found that the 1987 noting merely placed an addenda in abeyance; it did not suspend the operative 1986 instructions.
6. Consequently, the appellant, categorised in the “Staff only” stream, was correctly retired at 57 in conformity with the 1986 instructions and within the statutory band of Rule 16-A.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed.

The Supreme Court affirmed the validity of the 9 September 1986 executive instructions and upheld the appellant’s retirement at 57 years. The decision directly affects the appellant but sets no new precedent beyond confirming that later executive instructions of equal authority can modify earlier ones when consistent with the governing statutory rule.

    Lt. Genl. R.K Anand v. Union Of India And Another

    A.M Ahmadi, J.— Special leave granted.

    2. By an order dated March 3, 1990, the appellant on attaining the age of 57 years on December 19, 1990 was retired from service at the end of the month i.e December 31, 1990. He challenged this order of retirement by filing a Civil Writ Petition No. 3997 of 1990 in the High Court of Delhi on the ground that under the department instructions contained in the letter of May 9, 1985 he could not be retired before he attained the age of 58 years. The respondents supported the order of retirement placing reliance on the subsequent letter of instructions dated September 9, 1986. The appellant also attempted to invoke certain regulations stated to have been framed under Section 192 of the Army Act, 1950 as contained in the Army Instructions Book (1987 edition). The High Court, after a critical examination of the various submissions made before it, came to the conclusion that the appellant was not entitled to continue in service till he attained the age of 58 years. The High Court took the view that the letter of May 9, 1985 did not hold the field and the subsequent letter of September 9, 1986 was the one which governed the retirement of the appellant. In that view of the matter it dismissed the writ petition and discharged the rule awarding Rs 3300 by way of counsel fee to the appellant finding fault with the Central Government for having failed to notify the relevant instructions. Since that part of the order awarding cost is not in challenge before us we need say no more on that subject.

    3. A few facts relevant for the disposal of this appeal may be noticed at this stage. The appellant joined the Infantry on June 6, 1954 and in due course rose to the rank of Lieutenant General. The terms and conditions of his service were governed by the Army Act, 1950 (hereinafter called ‘the Act’) and the Rules made thereunder. Section 191 of the Act empowers the Central Government to make rules for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of the Act. Sub-section (2) of Section 191 enumerates the various matters in respect of which rules may be framed by the Central Government. Clause (a) of that sub-section deals with the question of retirement from service. Therefore, the age of superannuation for officers governed under the provisions of the Act could be prescribed by the rules made under Section 191 of the Act. Section 192 empowers the Central Government to make regulations for all or any of the purposes of the Act other than those specified in Section 191 which would include the matter regarding determination of the age of superannuation. Section 193 next provides that all rules and regulations made under the Act shall be published in the official gazette and on such publication shall have effect as if enacted under the Act. Section 193-A was inserted in the Act by an amendment which came into force w.e.f March 15, 1984. It inter alia provides that every rule and every regulation made by the Central Government under the Act shall be laid before each House of Parliament. It is not in dispute that the regulations on which reliance is placed were not placed before each House of Parliament as required by this provision. Secondly, the regulation could not cover the area covered by Section 192(2)(a) which deals with the question of prescription of age of superannuation. Counsel for the appellant realising these difficulties could not carry his submission based on the regulations any further. But it is stated that the regulations give an insight in how the authorities understood the relevant letters of instructions dated May 9, 1985 and September 9, 1986. We will presently come to these two documents on which either side places reliance but before we do so we think it necessary to notice Rule 16-A introduced by the Army (Amendment) Rules, 1979 (hereinafter called ‘the Rules’). By the said rules the Army Rules, 1954 came to be amended. Rule 16-A deals with the question of compulsory retirement of officers of the Armed Forces. Clause (1)(a) of the said rule provides that officers shall be liable to be compulsorily retired from service by order of the Central Government or the authorities specified in sub-rule (2), with effect from the afternoon of the last date of the month in which they attain the age limits specified in sub-rule (5). Sub-rule (5) next provides that the officers of Armoured Corps, Artillery, Engineers, Signals, Infantry, Army Service Corps, Army Ordnance Corps, Electrical and Mechanical Engineers and Pioneer Corps shall retire at the ages mentioned immediately thereunder. So far as Lt. General is concerned the retirement age is mentioned to be between 56 years and 58 years. In other words the minimum age of retirement of a Lt. General is 56 years and the maximum 58 years. This rule has statutory force. It may be noticed that the appellant belongs to the Infantry and having been promoted to the post of Lt. General was liable to be retired between 56 and 58 years of age under Rule 16-A(5) of the Rules.

    4. We may now come to the letter of May 9, 1985 on which considerable reliance was placed by the appellant. That letter prescribes the ages of retirement for officers belonging to the Armoured Corps, Infantry, Artillery, Engineers and Signals Corps. The age of retirement for the Lt. General is mentioned as 58 years. Since the appellant belongs to the Infantry he was entitled to continue in service up to the age of 58 years under the instructions contained in this letter. This letter was issued with the concurrence of the Ministry of Defence (Finance) and was to come into force from the date of its issue. If this letter held the field the appellant's contention would be well founded. The letter further directs that the Army Rule 16-A should be revised in due course. But factually the Army Rule 16-A never underwent a revision as envisaged by this letter.

    5. That brings us to the letter of September 9, 1986 on which the respondents rely. By this letter it was envisaged that officers on promotion to the post of Major General and Lt. General will be bifurcated into the ‘Command and Staff’ stream and the ‘Staff only’ stream. The former were expected to serve up to the maximum age prescribed for the rank, i.e 58 years in the case of Lt. General and the latter i.e General Cadre officers belonging to ‘Staff only’ stream were expected to superannuate one year earlier than the officers of the ‘Command and Staff’ stream in the corresponding rank. To put it differently a Lt. General belonging to the ‘Staff only’ stream would retire at the age of 57 years i.e one year before the officer of that rank in the ‘Command and Staff’ stream. It will thus be seen that by this letter of September 9, 1986 the age of superannuation in regard to Lt. Generals in the Armed Forces was regulated according to two streams, namely, those belonging to the ‘Command and Staff’ stream were to retire at the age of 58 years and those belonging to the ‘Staff only’ stream were to retire one year before, that is, at the age of 57 years. This is clear on a plain reading of the relevant clauses of the letter of September 9, 1986. This is not inconsistent with Rule 16-A of the Rules.

    6. It would thus appear from the above facts that after Rule 16-A came to be incorporated with effect from June 4, 1979, the question of superannuation of officers retiring between June 4, 1979 and May 8, 1985 was regulated on a case to case basis. The cases of officers who retired with effect from May 9, 1985 and before the letter of September 9, 1986 came into force were regulated by the instructions contained in the letter of May 9, 1985 and, therefore, Lt. Generals retired at the age of 58 years. However, after the letter of September 9, 1986 came into force and the concept of two streams was introduced the age of superannuation was regulated by the terms of the said letter. As stated earlier the instructions contained in this letter do not run counter to Rule 16-A of the Rules which prescribes the age of superannuation for Lt. Generals between 56 and 58 years. The letter of May 9, 1985 was general in nature and applied to all Lt. Generals regardless of the stream to which they belonged. Of course at that point of time there was no concept of two streams but there was nothing in Rule 16-A or the said letter which debarred the authorities from introducing the same so long as it was consistent with Rule 16-A. The appellant superannuated with effect from December 31, 1990 i.e after the terms of the letter of September 9, 1986 came into force. He cannot, therefore, claim the benefit of the instructions contained in the letter of May 9, 1985.

    7. The appellant contends that notwithstanding the letter of September 9, 1986 the letter of May 9, 1985 held the field and he was, therefore, entitled to continue in service till he attained the age of 58 years and was wrongly superannuated on his completing 57 years of age. According to him the letter of May 9, 1985 was issued under the signature of Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Defence, Central Government and was, therefore, in the nature of executive instructions, even if it did not have statutory flavour, and hence the authorities were bound by the terms thereof and could not have superannuated him before he completed 58 years of age. On the other hand the respondents contend that after the two streams concept was introduced by the letter of September 9, 1986, superannuation was regulated as per the terms thereof and accordingly the appellant who was an Infantry man and belonged to ‘Staff only’ stream had to retire one year before an officer of equivalent rank belonging to the ‘Command and Staff’ stream became liable to be superannuated. If the contention of the respondents is right, there can be no doubt that the appellant was rightly superannuated on his completing the age of 57 years.

    8. The appellant contends that the letter of September 9, 1986 cannot supersede the letter of May 9, 1985 as it is a departmental letter which cannot be placed on the pedestal of executive instructions contemplated by Article 162 of the Constitution. In order to satisfy ourselves whether the communication of September 9, 1986 had received the concurrence of the concerned Ministry, we inspected the department file and found that the matter was referred to the Ministry of Defence and had received the approval of the Prime Minister. In view of the same it is not possible to accede to the submission of the appellant that the letter of September 9, 1986 is merely a departmental communication and cannot be raised to the pedestal of an executive instruction under Article 162 of the Constitution. Therefore, both the letter of May 9, 1985 and the letter of September 9, 1986 stand on the same footing. It is obvious that by the subsequent letter of September 9, 1986 two streams were contemplated and the ages of superannuation of both the streams were separately stated. So far as the Lt. General belonging to the ‘Command and Staff’ stream is concerned, under the letter of September 9, 1986 as well as the letter of May 9, 1985, his age of superannuation is fixed at 58 years but so far as the Lt. General belonging to the ‘Staff only’ stream is concerned, by the subsequent letter of September 9, 1986 his age of superannuation is fixed at one year less than the age of superannuation of an equivalent officer in the ‘Command and Staff’ stream. As stated earlier both these letters of May 9, 1985 and September 9, 1986 are in the nature of executive instructions because Rule 16-A has not been amended even though the letter of May 9, 1985 envisaged a change therein. The fact, however, remains that no change was brought about and, therefore, Rule 16-A stands unaltered. The appellant has mainly relied on the letter of May 9, 1985 because otherwise under Rule 16-A(5) it was open to retire him between the ages of 56 and 58 years and, therefore, it was permissible to superannuate him at the age of 57 years. If only the instructions contained in the letter of May 9, 1985 come to his rescue he can succeed. But as stated earlier the subsequent letter of September 9, 1986 by which two streams came to be introduced has made inroads. That letter prescribes the age of superannuation for officers belonging to the ‘Staff only’ stream as one year less than the officer of equivalent rank in ‘Command and Staff’ stream. The Lt. General in the ‘Command and Staff’ stream would superannuate at the age of 58 years and, therefore, a Lt. General in the ‘Staff only’ stream would superannuate one year earlier, that is, at the age of 57 years. It is, therefore, clear that the subsequent letter of September 9, 1986 modifies the superannuation age for officers in the ‘Staff only’ stream from that contained in the letter of May 9, 1985. That being the position the appellant was rightly superannuated on his attaining the age of 57 years.

    9. Our attention was invited to a note dated June 22, 1987 which has reference to an earlier note dated May 17, 1987 whereby the issuance of government order stipulating ages of retirement on two stream concept was placed in abeyance. On the strength of this noting the appellant contended that the two stream concept contained in the letter of September 9, 1986 was kept in abeyance and, therefore, his case was governed by the instructions contained in the letter of May 9, 1985. In order to verify the accuracy of this submission made by the appellant we perused the file and we find that in May 1987 an Addenda was sought to be introduced in the instructions contained in the letter of May 9, 1985 by adding clauses 3 and 4 and re-numbering the existing clauses 3, 4 and 5 as clauses 5, 6 and 7. By the proposed clause 3 the age of retirement of the General Cadre Officers in the rank of Major General and Lt. General in the ‘Command and Staff’ stream was proposed to be 56 and 58 years, respectively, whereas the age of superannuation for officers of the same rank in the ‘Staff only’ stream was proposed to be 55 and 57 years. By clause 4 the age of superannuation of Lt. General of non-General cadre promoted in the ‘Staff only’ stream was proposed to be prescribed as one year earlier than the Lt. General promoted in his own corps, that is, at the age of 57 years. It was this Addenda which was placed in abeyance and not the instructions contained in the letter of September 9, 1986.

    10. The appellant, however, contends that the fact that by this Addenda two new clauses were sought to be introduced in the letter of May 9, 1985, shows that the instructions contained in the said letter were very much in operation and they were not superseded by the letter of September 9, 1986. This submission is clearly misconceived. What was proposed by the Addenda was to bring the letter of May 9, 1985 in line with the instructions contained in the letter of September 9, 1986 since the earlier letter dealt with several other Army officers also and not merely Lt. Generals. We are, therefore, not impressed by this submission made by the appellant.

    11. In the result we do not see any merit in this appeal and dismiss the same but make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lt. Genl. R.K Anand v. Union Of India And Another
    (Dec 18, 1991)