Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Smt. Kusum Gupta was appointed as a clerk in the respondent-Corporation on 25 July 1974. On 7 August 1980 her services were terminated by an office order stating that they were “no longer required” and that she would be paid “one month's pay plus allowances in lieu of notice period.” It is undisputed that this payment was never made.

Kusum Gupta filed a civil suit challenging the termination on the ground that payment in lieu of notice had not been tendered simultaneously with the termination. The trial court decreed the suit in her favour. On the Corporation’s appeal, the Additional District Judge reversed that decree. Kusum Gupta then filed a second appeal to the High Court. Although the High Court accepted that one month’s pay and allowances had to be paid along with the termination order, it nevertheless upheld the reversal because the plaintiff had not obtained a “no-dues certificate” by the time she appeared in the trial court. The present judgment arises from Kusum Gupta’s further appeal to the Supreme Court, which granted special leave to appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Bye-law 3.2(ii) of the respondent-Corporation, an employee’s services can be validly terminated without the simultaneous payment of one month’s salary and allowances in lieu of notice.
  2. Whether the employer can lawfully refuse or delay such payment on the ground that the employee has not produced a “no-dues certificate.”

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court focused on the text of Bye-law 3.2(ii), which permits termination of a temporary employee either:

  • by giving one month’s notice, or
  • by paying salary and allowances for the notice period in lieu of such notice.

The Court held that the bye-law requires the payment to be made at the time of termination; otherwise the termination is non-compliant. It rejected the employer’s stance that issuance of a “no-dues certificate” by the employee was a prerequisite for the payment, observing that:

  • The employer alone is in a position to know whether any dues are outstanding and is responsible for issuing such a certificate; it cannot shift this burden to the employee.
  • Withholding the statutory payment on the ground of the employee’s failure to produce a certificate that the employer itself must provide is impermissible.

Because the payment was never made and the insistence on a “no-dues certificate” had no legal foundation under the bye-laws, the Court concluded that the termination order was invalid. Accordingly, the High Court had erred in upholding the reversal of the trial court’s decree.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgment and decree set aside; trial court decree restored with costs throughout.

Immediate Consequences: The trial court’s decree—favourable to Kusum Gupta—stands reinstated. The respondent-Corporation must comply with that decree, including payment obligations. Broader Implications: The decision reaffirms that, under the Corporation’s own bye-laws, simultaneous payment in lieu of notice is mandatory and cannot be withheld on administrative pretexts such as a “no-dues certificate.” The ruling is confined to enforcing the bye-law and does not set a new precedent beyond that interpretive clarification.

    Kusum Gupta (Smt) Alias Kusum Bansal v. Haryana State Small Industries & Export Corpn., Chandigarh .

    O. Chinnappa Reddy, J.— Special leave granted.

    2. The services of Smt Kusum Gupta, who was originally appointed as a clerk in the respondent Corporation on July 25, 1974, were terminated on August 7, 1980 by an Office Order running as follows :
    “Office Order
    The services of Mrs Kusum Gupta working as Sales Assistant in Haryana Emporium, New Delhi are no longer required by the Corporation with immediate effect. She will be paid one month's pay plus allowances in lieu of notice period.
    sd/-
    P.R Kaushik
    Managing Director
    Endst. No. HIEC/Estt./6165 Dated August 7, 1980.
    Copy forwarded for information and necessary action to :

    1. 2. 3. General Manager, Marketing Company Secretary Controller of Accounts } They are required to issue no dues certificate in favour of Mrs Kusum Gupta 4. 5. General Manager, New Delhi Emporium Mrs Kusum Gupta, Sales Assistant, New Delhi Emporium, New Delhi } Sales Asstt. immediate

    General Manager
    for Managing Director”

    It is admitted that the “one month's pay plus allowances in lieu of notice period” was never paid to the appellant. She filed a suit questioning the order terminating her services on the principal ground that she had not been paid “one month's pay plus allowances in lieu of the notice period” simultaneously with the order terminating her services. The suit was decreed by the trial court, but on appeal, the Additional District Judge reversed the judgment and decree of the trial court. The appellant filed a second appeal to the High Court. The High Court while holding that one month's pay and allowances had to be paid along with the order terminating the appellant's services, nevertheless confirmed the decree of the appellate court on the ground that the plaintiff had failed to obtain the no dues certificate even by the time she appeared in the trial court. We are of the view that the judgment of the High Court is wholly unsustainable.

    3. Bye-law 3.2(ii) which governs the situation is as follows :
    “3.2 Termination of Service.—The services of an employee of the Corporation may be terminated by the Appointing Authority—
    (ii) in the case of temporary employees by giving one month's notice on either side or, in lieu thereof pay for the period the notice falls short of one month.”

    The bye-law is clear that the services of an employee could only be terminated by giving one month's notice or, in lieu of notice, by paying the salary, etc. for the period of one month. It would not be open to the employer to insist upon the production of “no dues certificate” by the employee. In fact, we fail to see how the employer can insist upon the production of a “no dues certificate” by the employee when the certificate has to be given by the employer. The employer is the person who is in the know of things whether any amount is due from the employee or not. The employer cannot certainly take advantage of his failure to give a certificate to the employee and claim that he was entitled to withhold the one month's pay and allowances payable in lieu of the one month's notice on the ground of non-production of no dues certificate by the employee. We have no hesitation in allowing this appeal. The judgment and decree of the High Court are set aside. The judgment and decree of the trial court are restored with costs throughout.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kusum Gupta (Smt) Al... v. Haryana State Small ...
    (Jul 31, 1986)