Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 420 r/w Section 34, Indian Penal Code (IPC)
  • Sections 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 420 r/w Section 34, Indian Penal Code (IPC)
  • Sections 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (complainant), Manager of Transport Corporation of India (the carrier), filed a criminal complaint under Sections 420, 467, 468, 34 and 120-B of the IPC against the respondents (accused), who were partners of M/s Badridas Jagdish Kumar (consignee), regarding a consignment of 101 bags of copra valued at Rs 22,620. The consignor was M/s Jagannath & Sons, Mysore. The bill for the consignment was negotiated through the State Bank of India, Mysore, for payment at Hathras in favour of the State Bank of India, Hathras; the consignee was expected to retire the transport receipt and related documents by paying the bank before taking delivery.

The complainant alleged that the respondents, by misrepresentation and deceit, induced the carrier to deliver the consignment without the respondents retiring the transport receipt from the bank and without paying the bank. The respondents paid freight of Rs 1,400 and later made a part payment of Rs 3,600 towards the price. At the insistence of the consignors, the carrier settled the consignors' dues by paying Rs 19,407 and odd.

The Judicial Magistrate framed a charge under Section 420 read with Section 34 IPC. The respondents' revision before the Additional Sessions Judge, Aligarh seeking quashing of the charge was dismissed. The respondents then invoked the High Court's inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC (Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 788 of 1979), and the High Court by order dated September 19, 1979 quashed the criminal case. In the present appeal, the appellant challenged the High Court's quashing order.

Separately, the respondents were earlier granted time (from October 28, 1980 onwards, with extensions) to deposit Rs 19,407.46 to the appellant to compound the matter; they did not pay or deposit the amount, and a further extension was refused.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in quashing the criminal proceedings/charge under Section 420 read with Section 34 IPC in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC on the premise that the dispute reflected only delayed payment of a monetary liability rather than dishonest intention.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court quashed the proceedings principally because it believed that the respondents had paid three sums—Rs 1,400 (freight), Rs 6,000 and Rs 19,000 and odd (towards price)—and treated the matter as “mere delay” in payment, observing that delay would not necessarily establish dishonest intention; it therefore concluded that allowing the trial to proceed would be an abuse of process.

On the facts accepted in the appellate opinion, however, the respondents had paid only Rs 1,400 towards freight and Rs 3,600 towards the price (total Rs 5,000), and no further amount was paid either to the complainant or to the consignors. Instead, the carrier paid Rs 19,400 and odd to settle the consignors’ dues. The court characterized the situation not as delayed payment but as failure to make any substantial payment even after taking delivery, allegedly by misrepresentation and deceit.

The court found that the High Court’s quashing order was founded on an error of fact—its mistaken assumption that Rs 19,000 and odd had been paid by the respondents. The court stated that, but for this mistake, the High Court would not have reversed the Sessions Court’s order refusing to quash the charge.

Holding and Implications

SET ASIDE the High Court’s order quashing the criminal case; the Judicial Magistrate, Khair, Aligarh was directed to proceed with the criminal case against the respondents and dispose of it according to law.

The direct effect is that the criminal proceedings (including the charge under Section 420 read with Section 34 IPC as framed by the Magistrate) were restored to the trial court for continuation. The opinion does not indicate any broader implications or that it set any new precedent.

    Ram Avtar Gupta v. Gopal Das Taliwal And Others

    1. In this matter as far back as October 28, 1980 the respondents (the accused) were granted four weeks' time to pay a sum of Rs 19,407.46 to the appellant (complainant) with a view to compound the matter and though further extensions of time were granted the respondents have not paid or deposited the said amount for being paid over to the appellant till this day. We therefore, reject a further request for extension to deposit the amount and proceed to deal with the matter on merits.

    2. A complaint under Sections 420, 467, 468, 34 and 120-B, IPC was filed by the appellant (Manager of Transport Corporation of India) against the respondents who are partners of M/s Badridas Jagdish Kumar, of Hathras (the consignees), in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Khair, Aligarh. It appears that a consignment of 101 bags of copra valued at Rs 22,620 was despatched by M/s Jagannath & Sons, Mysore (consignor) to M/s Badridas Jagdish Kumar of Hathras (consignee) in respect whereof Transport Corporation of India were the carriers. The bill in respect of that consignment was negotiated by the State Bank of India, Mysore of payment at Hathras in favour of State Bank of India, Hathras and the consignee was supposed to retire the transport receipt and other documents from the State Bank of India, Hathras by making payments of the price of the goods enabling them to take delivery of the consignment. The case of the complainant (the carriers) was that by misrepresentation and deceit the respondents (partners of the consignee) induced the complainant to deliver the consignment to them without retiring the T.R from the State Bank, Hathras and without making payment to the Bank. It appears that the respondents merely paid the freight (Rs 1400) and later on made a part payment of Rs 3600 towards the price of the consignment. So at the insistence of the consignors the complainant (the carriers) settled the dues of the consignors by paying to them Rs 19,407 and odd. The learned Magistrate framed a charge against the respondents under Sections 420 r/w 34, IPC. The respondents went in revision to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Aligarh for quashing the charge on the ground that no offence was disclosed, but learned Additional Sessions Judge dismissed the revision. The respondents invoked the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 482 CrPC by preferring Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 788 of 1979 challenging the order of the Additional Sessions Judge and the High Court by its order dated September 19, 1979 quashed the criminal case. The appellant (complainant) has challenged the High Court's order in this appeal.

    3. The principal reason why the High Court was inclined to quash the criminal proceedings was that it felt that after all in respect of the concerned consignment the respondents had paid three sums of Rs 1400 (towards the freight), Rs 6000 and Rs 19000 and odd (the last two towards the price) and as such it was a case of mere delay on the part of the respondents in discharging their monetary liability and the High Court has observed thus: “the mere fact that there was delay on the part of the applicants (respondents) in paying the price of the goods will not necessarily amount to the dishonest intention on their part” and it quashed the charge under Sections 420/34, IPC on the ground that it would be sheer abuse of the process of the court if the trial were allowed to proceed.

    4. On admitted facts as indicated earlier the respondents had merely paid a total sum of Rs 5000 (Rs 1400 towards freight and Rs 3600 towards the price) and no further amount whatsoever was at all paid by them either to the complainant or to the consignors. In fact it was the complainant (carriers) who settled all the dues of the consignors by paying to them Rs 19,400 and odd. In other words, the respondents even after getting delivery of the consignment from the carriers allegedly by making misrepresentation and practising deceit have failed to make good a substantial part of the price of the goods even up to this day. It is therefore, not a case of delayed payment at all but a case of no substantial payment. We are satisfied that if the High Court had not fallen into the error of thinking that the amount of Rs 19,000 and odd had been paid by the respondents, it would not have reversed the Sessions Court's order. We accordingly set aside the High Court's order and direct that the learned Judicial Magistrate, Khair, Aligarh will proceed with a criminal case against the respondents and dispose it of according to law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Avtar Gupta v. Gopal Das Taliwal And Others
    (Jan 24, 1983)