AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 32 of the Constitution
  • Article 22 (226) of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 22(5) of the Constitution
  • Section 3 of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 32 of the Constitution
  • Article 22 (226) of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 22(5) of the Constitution
  • Section 3 of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974
Smart Summary

Case Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Raverdy Marc Germain Jules, a French national and Airport Manager for Air India in Geneva, arrived at Mumbai’s Sahar International Airport on 20 September 1981. When customs officials inspected his luggage, they discovered 41 kg of watch parts valued at approximately ₹3,91,200. Treating the incident as smuggling, the Government of Maharashtra issued a preventive detention order on 16 December 1981 under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA).

Jules sought a writ of habeas corpus before the Bombay High Court, raising three grounds; a Division Bench dismissed the petition. He then filed (i) a special-leave petition and (ii) a new Article 32 writ petition before the Supreme Court, advancing additional grounds not argued in the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether failure of the detaining authority to personally consider the detenu’s representation violated Article 22(5) of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the non-consideration of the detenu’s retracted confessional statement by the detaining authority or the Advisory Board invalidated the detention.
  3. Whether continued detention should be set aside on humanitarian grounds owing to an alleged mental disorder developed in custody.

Arguments of the Parties

Detenu’s Arguments

  • The Home Secretary, who issued the detention order, did not himself consider the representation; this contravened Article 22(5).
  • The detenu retracted his confessional statement on 16/19 December 1981; the failure to consider this retraction, or to forward it to the Advisory Board, vitiated the detention.
  • A psychiatric report by Dr P. N. Vyavhare indicated mental disorder caused by continued detention, warranting release on humanitarian grounds.

State’s Responses

  • Under the Rules of Business, either the Home Secretary or the Home Minister may validly act on behalf of the State; the Home Minister had considered and rejected the representation.
  • The retraction letter was dated after the detention order and had not reached the authorities by 16 December 1981; it was therefore not material for the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority or the Advisory Board.
  • An examination by the Psychiatric Department of the Armed Forces Medical College (AFMC), Pune, certified that the detenu was not suffering from any unsoundness of mind.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kavita v. State of Maharashtra (1981) 3 SCC 558 Either the Home Secretary or the Home Minister can act for the State Government under the Rules of Business in detention matters. Relied upon to uphold the validity of the Home Minister’s rejection of the detenu’s representation.
Smt Masuma v. State of Maharashtra (1981) 3 SCC 566 Same principle regarding competence of Home Secretary and Home Minister. Cited alongside Kavita to negate the Article 22(5) violation argument.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Article 22(5) claim: The Court held that the representation was validly considered by the Home Minister who, under the Rules of Business, is as competent as the Home Secretary. Precedents in Kavita and Smt Masuma controlled the issue.

Retracted confession: The letter retracting the confession post-dated the detention order; thus it could not have been before the detaining authority, and only material existing at the time of the order is relevant. The Advisory Board need not consider documents absent from the detaining authority’s file. The detenu, being present before the Board, could have raised the matter himself.

Humanitarian grounds: Given the AFMC psychiatrist’s certification that the detenu was not of unsound mind, the Court found no basis to terminate detention on compassionate grounds.

Holding and Implications

Both the Article 32 writ petition and the special-leave petition were dismissed, thereby sustaining the preventive detention order. The judgment reaffirms the validity of decision-making by either the Home Secretary or Home Minister under Maharashtra’s Rules of Business and applies established principles without creating new precedent.

    Raverdy Marc Germain Jules v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

    D.A Desai, J.—Detenu Raverdy Marc Germain Jules, a French national, at the relevant time was employed as Airport Manager by Air India at Geneva. By an Air India night, on September 20, 1981, he arrived at Sahar International Airport, Bombay and passed through green channel indicating he had no dutiable goods to declare to the Customs authorities. When he was at Exit Gate No. 1, the Intelligence Officer questioned him about the contents of two suitcases and other packages carried by him. The reply led to the inspection of the baggages which led to the recovery of watch parts weighing 41 kgs. in eight packages. This led to a further enquiry, and evaluation of the watch parts led to the conclusion that the value was Rs 3,91,200 c.i.f Ultimately, the Government of Maharashtra, on December 16, 1981, made an order of detention with a view to preventing the detenu from smuggling goods, in exercise of the power conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974. On the same day, he was furnished grounds of detention which inter alia referred to the smuggling of the watch parts and two wrist-watches.

    2. Detenu filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus under Article 22 (sic 226) of the Constitution in the High Court of Judicature at Bombay. Before the High Court, three contentions were advanced on behalf of the detenu. They were:

    “(1) It was a case of solitary incident, and prosecution was pending;

    (2) The detention order was mala fide having been served to prevent the Magistrate from passing an order on the application for leaving India;

    (3) All material documents relevant for subjective satisfaction were not considered and the order has been passed mechanically.”

    3. The Division Bench of the High Court which heard the petition held on Ground (1) that even though this is the first time the detenu was found indulging in smuggling activities and a prosecution might have been launched yet taking into account all the relevant materials, satisfaction on likelihood of repetition of smuggling activities in future seem to be real. In respect of Ground (2), the Court was of the opinion that even though the detention order was made on December 16, 1981, the day fixed for pronouncing order on the application of the detenu seeking permission to leave India, yet the file shows that the screening committee had taken the decision of recommending the detention of the detenu as well as those other persons connected with the different incidents so far back as on November 19, 1981 and the actual proposal recommending detention by Customs authority was forwarded on November 25, 1981. The counter-affidavit before the High Court disclosed that the detaining authority did not know that an application for permission to leave India was filed by the detenu and the decision of the Chief Judicial Magistrate was likely to be pronounced on December 16, 1981, the day on which the detention order was made. After taking note of this fact, the High Court rejected the contention. On the third contention, the court was of the opinion that there is nothing to show that there was no consideration of material documents and rejected the same. Ultimately, the High Court rejected the petition of the detenu.

    4. The detenu filed a petition for special leave against the judgment of the High Court as also a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution for a writ of habeas corpus. It appears that the writ petition was filed with a view to urging some additional grounds which were not raised before the High Court and, frankly speaking, Mr Jethmalani, learned counsel for the detenu, did not press any of the contentions which were canvassed before the High Court, but urged three other contentions which the High Court was not invited to examine.

    5. On behalf of the detenu, the learned counsel questioned the validity and legality of the detention order on the following three grounds:

    “(A) The detaining authority viz. Secretary to the Government of Maharashtra, Bombay Home Department (Law and Order) did not consider the representation and thereby violated constitutional guarantee under Article 22(5) of the Constitution.

    (B) Even if detenu is alleged to have made a confessional statement, the same was retracted before the detention order was made and yet there is nothing to show that the detaining authority took into consideration the fact that the confession was retracted and it is quite likely that the confessional statement itself may have influenced his mind and, therefore, the detention order is vitiated. Alternatively, it was contended that in any view of the matter, the fact that as the confessional statement was retracted by the detenu, the retraction ought to have been sent to the Advisory Board.

    (C) It appears that by the continued detention, the detenu has suffered mental disorder as revealed by the report of Senior Psychiatrist, Dr P.N Vyavhare, Senior Psychiatrist of Central Mental Hospital, Yervada and in view of this report, continued detention of the detenu is likely to inflict irreparable harm and, therefore, also the detention on the ground of humanitarian consideration requires to be terminated.”

    6. We shall examine these grounds seriatum.

    7. The first contention is that the representation made by the detenu was not considered by the detaining authority though it is obligatory under Article 22(5) for the detaining authority to consider the representation of detenu. Frankly speaking, this contention in the form in which it is canvassed before us has not been taken even in the writ petition filed in this Court. However, it becomes crystal clear that the order of detention was made by Secretary to the Government of Maharashtra, Home Department (Law and Order) pursuant to Standing Order No. SD.3(A) PSA 1181 dated October 13, 1981, directing that the cases under sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the COFEPOSA be disposed of by the Home Secretary. The validity of this Order is not questioned. In exercise of this power impugned order was made by the detaining authority. The representation was rejected by the Home Minister. Under the rules of business, Home Minister was competent to examine the representation and if it is rejected by him it is futile to contend that the representation was not considered by the detaining authority. This Court in Smt Kavita v. State of Maharashtra (1981) 3 SCC 558 and Smt Masuma v. State of Maharashtra (1981) 3 SCC 566 held after referring to the rules of business of the Government of Maharashtra that both the Home Secretary and the Home Minister could act on behalf of the State Government and, therefore, it is immaterial whether the detaining authority or the Home Minister disposed of the representation. The present case is governed by the same rules of business and, therefore, the contention would stand negatived by the decisions in the aforementioned two cases.

    8. It was next contended that even though the detenu retracted his confessional statement the same was not considered by the detaining authority and in any event the same was not forwarded to the Advisory Board and, therefore, the detention order is vitiated. In para 11 of the writ petition it is alleged that the detenu retracted his confessional statement by his letter dated December 16/19, 1981 forwarded through the Jail authorities addressed to the Assistant Collector of Customs, Bombay. In the counter-affidavit it is stated that the letter retracting the confessional statement was not before the detaining authority when the order of detention was issued and in the facts of the case it could not be there because the order of detention is dated December 16, 1981, and the letter appears not to have reached the Customs authorities before December 19, 1981. The detaining authority could not have received it on or before December 16, 1981, when the order of detention was issued. The Assistant Collector of Customs, Bombay to whom the letter retracting the confessional statement was forwarded has sent his reply to the detenu, which was annexed to the counter-affidavit. Therefore, it is futile to urge that the letter retracting the confessional statement was not considered by the detaining authority because it was humanly not possible to do so.

    9. The second limb of the submission was that in any event that retraction letter ought to have been forwarded to the Advisory Board. In para 12 of the petition it is alleged that the letter retracting the confessional statement was not considered by the Advisory Board. One Shri C.V Karnik, Assistant Secretary, Government of Maharashtra, Home Department (Special) in his counter-affidavit (para 6) has stated that all the documents which were before the detaining authority were also placed before the Advisory Board. It is further averred that the Advisory Board examines the question of subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority on the material the detaining authority had before it and as the retraction was not before the detaining authority it is immaterial that the Advisory Board did not take the same into consideration. This stand may not be very satisfactory and may necessitate our deeper examination but for the fact that the detenu himself was before the Advisory Board. He is a highly qualified, highly placed person and it is unthinkable that he would not have informed the Advisory Board that he had refracted his confessional statement. Therefore, nothing turns on the letter retracting the confessional statement being not placed before the Advisory Board and the contention must be negatived.

    10. The last contention is that by the continued detention the detenu has suffered mental disorder as revealed by the report of the Senior Psychiatrist Dr P.N Vyavhare of the Central Mental Hospital, Yervada, Pune. Report of Dr Vyavhare is annexed to the additional affidavit filed on behalf of the detenu. This report did give us some anxious moments. Therefore, when we heard this petition on August 20/21, 1982, an order was made by us directing the Jail authorities to produce the detenu before the Head of the Psychiatric Department, Armed Forces Medical College, Pune, for examination and report. This place was selected after discussion in the open court with Shri Ram Jethmalani, learned counsel for the detenu. A wireless message has been received by the Registry of the Supreme Court on September 14, 1982, from Yervada Central Prison, Pune, intimating that the detenu has been certified by Psychiatric Department of the Armed Forces Medical College, Pune, that he is not suffering from any unsoundness of mind. We hope to receive the original report forwarded to us by post before we pronounce the order. In fact, awaiting the report we postponed pronouncement of this order because if in fact a satisfactory report by a competent Psychiatrist of the detenu suffering mental disorder on account of continued detention was brought to our notice it would have considerably weighed with us on the question whether we may terminate continued detention of the detenu on humanitarian grounds. The report being to the contrary that aspect need not detain us anymore.

    11. These were all the contentions urged in this petition and as we find no merit in any of them, both the petition and the special leave petition are dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raverdy Marc Germain Jules v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
    (Sep 17, 1982)